Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s my dog, not our dog

290 replies

Bieder · 22/02/2023 15:18

My wife and I live in separate houses - I live in the countryside and she lives in the city. A couple of years into our marriage I decided to buy a puppy because I always wanted a dog and I have the space and the time now. I brought the dog up, trained him etc. and he’s with me all of the time apart from the odd week when I go on a business trip (2-3 times a year), and then my wife looks after him at her place. My wife loves the dog and indulges him which can sometimes lead to a bit of conflict as I feel she undermines his training. But I’m petty happy to trust her with him and glad they get on so well. So this isn’t the issue.
The issue we had an argument about recently is that she stated he was “our” dog, and I corrected her, insisting he was mine. She got quite upset about that and said because we’re married we share everything, and hence the dog is our dog. I love my dog very much and invested so much time in bringing him up well and looking after him. He has a great, happy life with me in the countryside. I regard him as my dog and I don’t like it that she simply assumes there is this joint responsibility and custodianship. I find it hard to see the issue from her point of view. AIBU?

OP posts:
tiutinkerbell · 23/02/2023 07:30

I paid the adoption fee for our dog, I pay the vet bills, train him and spend the most time with him but he is still 'our' dog. I think you're being a little pedantic here.

Nogreens · 23/02/2023 07:30

Weird responses. I would bet more than half of the people saying you are wrong have 'my car' , 'my jewelry ', my mug' ' my clothes' ... and so on in their homes.

Cosyblankets · 23/02/2023 07:26

Surely this isn't real

ittakes2 · 23/02/2023 07:23

I voted ybu because are you seriously fighting over this? I get it if you were getting divorced and she wants the dog but it’s just crazy a married couple would act like this

Resister · 23/02/2023 07:16

This is a solution looking for a problem. You're hard work op. I imagine you are quick to make lovely things joyless

Courtorder · 23/02/2023 07:11

follyfoot37 · 23/02/2023 06:38

yet everyone screams for 'space' and wanting to be an individual within a marriage /long-term relationship
Just because one is in a partnership doesn't mean they can't own their own stuff. Do you class all your jewelleery as 'ours', or your menstrual care products?

Does my DH use or enjoy either of those? I’ve definitely said things like “our engagement ring…”

rookiemere · 23/02/2023 07:10

Ok so if it's your dog you're lucky your DW is prepared to look after it for free. I've started making DH pay for dog care when he is away as whilst I love rookiedog, 2 hrs of walking every day is a pain.

But I suspect the reason you don't like the use of our dog, is because you don't want any "our" things, much as you don't seem to want to be married particularly.

America12 · 23/02/2023 07:09

It's a joint dog. You sound so immature.
If you dropped dead tomorrow, who do you think would have the dog ?

pissssedofff · 23/02/2023 07:07

Banchory · 23/02/2023 06:52

My dh never wanted a dog.
After the cat died I persuaded him to let me have a dog and the inevitable happened, she much prefers him to me.
However she is and always will be my dog.
Obviously dh would say our dog now but he made it clear initially that she would be my responsibility and he wanted nothing to do with her.
I let him say our dog though, but my names on the paperwork and dogs are possessions in law.

Your dog, if it could talk, would disagree with you!

If the hound prefers someone else, i'm sorry but it ain't your dog, she has chosen someone else.

@Bieder Might be wise to remember that dogs can have other human friends, if the dog is happy with your partner and she loves the dog, then be happy, he has a good "friend" in your wife.

follyfoot37 · 23/02/2023 06:56

XelaM · 22/02/2023 15:37

Why don't you live in the same place?

why is that any of your business?

ArmchairAnarchist2 · 23/02/2023 06:54

I live with DH but everyone knows the dog is mine. He is with me 99% of the time but I'm reassured that if something happens to me he'll be loved and well looked after by people he already knows and loves.

follyfoot37 · 23/02/2023 06:53

Bieder · 22/02/2023 15:37

But I guess you wouldn’t take umbrage at dh calling them “our dogs”; it probably wouldn’t bother you much?
Most of the other respondents here don’t seem to be able to get past the fact that my wife and I don’t live together, so it’s a bit difficult to take their comments on board - they seem a bit judgemental.

unless you live within the narrow confines and definitions determined my the people on this forum you will be villified
Ignore the negative people; reading the posts here over the years you'll see thatc, they are aching to get away from their 'normal' lives with their cheating DHs, their deadful in-laws, their screaming kids and all those non-parents who don't move to allow 'our family' to sit together when in public

Thepossibility · 23/02/2023 06:53

I think it was an unnecessarily hurtful thing to say unless she's trying to take him from you while seperating. And a bit immature...this is MY dog Shock. Sounds like my 3yo claiming his toys.
She's supposed to be your wife.

Banchory · 23/02/2023 06:52

My dh never wanted a dog.
After the cat died I persuaded him to let me have a dog and the inevitable happened, she much prefers him to me.
However she is and always will be my dog.
Obviously dh would say our dog now but he made it clear initially that she would be my responsibility and he wanted nothing to do with her.
I let him say our dog though, but my names on the paperwork and dogs are possessions in law.

follyfoot37 · 23/02/2023 06:48

Those having a pop atv@Bieder re their living arrangement should wind their necks in. Plentry of couples live separately quite happily; Helena Bonham-Carter and Tim Burton for example.
You and your perfectly normal (boring) arrangements, who witter on in this forum about accepting 'everything about being a mother because society will die without us", need to accept that other ways of being are just as valed.

Mojoyoyo · 23/02/2023 06:40

What was the reason for getting married ?

follyfoot37 · 23/02/2023 06:38

Courtorder · 22/02/2023 15:22

You’re being ridiculous. I refer to the Nissan as “our car” even though I’ve only driven it once. I refer to visiting “our relatives” when I see people from DH’s family. “Our shed” even though he paid for it and I almost never use it. When you live a shared life (i.e. by getting married) then some things become “ours”, even if only by phrase. What difference does it even make to you?

yet everyone screams for 'space' and wanting to be an individual within a marriage /long-term relationship
Just because one is in a partnership doesn't mean they can't own their own stuff. Do you class all your jewelleery as 'ours', or your menstrual care products?

follyfoot37 · 23/02/2023 06:34

Bieder · 22/02/2023 15:18

My wife and I live in separate houses - I live in the countryside and she lives in the city. A couple of years into our marriage I decided to buy a puppy because I always wanted a dog and I have the space and the time now. I brought the dog up, trained him etc. and he’s with me all of the time apart from the odd week when I go on a business trip (2-3 times a year), and then my wife looks after him at her place. My wife loves the dog and indulges him which can sometimes lead to a bit of conflict as I feel she undermines his training. But I’m petty happy to trust her with him and glad they get on so well. So this isn’t the issue.
The issue we had an argument about recently is that she stated he was “our” dog, and I corrected her, insisting he was mine. She got quite upset about that and said because we’re married we share everything, and hence the dog is our dog. I love my dog very much and invested so much time in bringing him up well and looking after him. He has a great, happy life with me in the countryside. I regard him as my dog and I don’t like it that she simply assumes there is this joint responsibility and custodianship. I find it hard to see the issue from her point of view. AIBU?

YANBU you bought the dog, care for it, trained it, home it. It is your dog!

kateandme · 23/02/2023 06:34

does her feeling align with yours over this seperation of lives? is that why she is so upset. what was said at this point?

follyfoot37 · 23/02/2023 06:33

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 22/02/2023 15:19

YABU. You’re married. He’s both of yours.

So you think that just because one is married, one's good and chattels automatically tranfer to joint ownership! Does that include jewellery, jock-straps, tampons, razors, fleas.....?
That is ridiculous. The dog belongs to the OP

Sleepless1096 · 23/02/2023 06:01

Maray1967 · 23/02/2023 00:45

If you had children and she was a stay at home parent bringing them up and you worked very long hours and didn’t see them much, would the children not be yours but only hers?

I was thinking the same. We have two DC. I feed them, comfort them, care for them, meet their needs, 'train' them, run around after them and they're with me the whole time apart from school and the odd hour here and there that their father takes them out (which is getting rarer and rarer). Their father works all hours and does very little for them. So if we separate, they're 'my' kids, right? I don't have to share them with their father at all?

I guess it's different with dogs because the law views them as property, unlike children - care is decided on an ownership basis, not a 'best interests of the dog basis'. So in reality, it doesn't matter who does all the care for the dog. The law views the dog as property and the only question is who owns it. Unlike children, which at least theoretically is meant to be decided on the basis of what is best for the children.

Rogdog · 23/02/2023 05:49

@Bieder

I’d let it go I think. It’s sweet that she loves the dog so much that she feels that degree of attachment. The dog is therefore loved and cared for by two people who think the dog is awesome. That’s surely in the best interests of the dog?

YukoandHiro · 23/02/2023 05:46

"Assumes ownership?"

I'm not sure you understand what the legal contract of marriage is about mate

YukoandHiro · 23/02/2023 05:44

You share everything, apart from even a house.

This is a weird set up all round. You sound like very different people who want different things out of life.

YetiTeri · 23/02/2023 05:42

DifferenceEngines · 23/02/2023 04:22

The dog knows who they belong to. Who cares what anyone else thinks?

This.

We have a dog, he belongs to all of us. But he's MY dog. I'm his person - he's very clear on that.

You're overthinking this.