Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s my dog, not our dog

290 replies

Bieder · 22/02/2023 15:18

My wife and I live in separate houses - I live in the countryside and she lives in the city. A couple of years into our marriage I decided to buy a puppy because I always wanted a dog and I have the space and the time now. I brought the dog up, trained him etc. and he’s with me all of the time apart from the odd week when I go on a business trip (2-3 times a year), and then my wife looks after him at her place. My wife loves the dog and indulges him which can sometimes lead to a bit of conflict as I feel she undermines his training. But I’m petty happy to trust her with him and glad they get on so well. So this isn’t the issue.
The issue we had an argument about recently is that she stated he was “our” dog, and I corrected her, insisting he was mine. She got quite upset about that and said because we’re married we share everything, and hence the dog is our dog. I love my dog very much and invested so much time in bringing him up well and looking after him. He has a great, happy life with me in the countryside. I regard him as my dog and I don’t like it that she simply assumes there is this joint responsibility and custodianship. I find it hard to see the issue from her point of view. AIBU?

OP posts:
BarrelOfOtters · 23/02/2023 17:16

TBH I wouldn't mind having a pied a terre in the countryside near a beach where I could walk my husband's dog, she is very much his dog, when she came to stay. And I could go and visit him in his house in town and vice versa.

She's our dog when she's with us - but still very much his - and she spends most days with her grandparents, who happily introduce her to people as their dog. We are all her pack.

It sounds like this has worked out well for you OP....enjoy your dog.

BloggersBlog · 23/02/2023 17:15

Just dont go buying any new bathroom scales....

Clownfish78 · 23/02/2023 17:10

I’m howling at some of these replies and honestly wondering if these people ever owned dogs. My partner and I got together with a dog a piece, I walked, fed looked after both as did he, my dog never really became his and his was definitely never mine. A couple of times a year the wife gets the dog and he spends 95% of his time with it, it’s his dog! If she wants a dog maybe she could living somewhere dog friendly and doing the work 😱🤣

Drfosters · 23/02/2023 16:49

Because the point of marriage is 2 separate people joining together to become 1 single family unit. This may or may not involve children, pets and living together but you are a single unit. Your pet is yours together jointly as it belongs to your family unit. To me it’s bizarre you think differently. Now sure if you split, the dog would go to you I would have thought as you are the primary caregiver, but until that point he belongs to you both. Also you don’t pay for his care, you both do out of your joint matrimonial assets. Nothing belongs to you separately unless you have a prenup (and even that may not count!) Why get married if you wanted to live separate lives?

Bluekerfuffle · 23/02/2023 16:45

Bieder · 22/02/2023 15:39

I don’t pay her to look after him, no. She enjoys it, and hasn’t asked for payment. If she had a dog, I would certainly be very happy to look after him for her too. It would be quite weird to ask for payment, don’t you think?

Well, not really any more weird than the rest of your set up.

Hooverthestairs · 23/02/2023 16:29

I'm glad you sorted this with your wife OP. I've just read the full thread and I think the big take away from this is why you were so triggered by it.

You mention that you have a fear of commitment, and that you are worried a week with your wife will undo training you've done. A week of good care (with somebody your dog knows and trusts) whilst you are away from your dog is so important (and fun for your dog) and you do need to chill out a bit about the training being undone, it won't happen in a week and it is not really the priority when it comes to you going away.

I work with dogs and there are dogs that I've been working with for 12/18 months plus, and their families jokingly call me their (the dog's) step-mum. I'm not their owner and claim no ownership to them, but really care about the dogs and have good relationships with them. Having that trusting connection with other people is so important and you need to relax about things.

I think perhaps you need to self reflect about your issues with letting go of control, and commitment issues, which is what this post highlights to me.

Hope this comes across as I mean it to.

Catspyjamas17 · 23/02/2023 16:20

Our dog is our dog though they usually have someone they think of as their number one best person or surrogate parent. So it's not so much that she's my dog but that I am her mum.

LornaLynch · 23/02/2023 16:05

If its YOUR dog then why arent YOU paying to board your dog instead of expecting your wife to care for it for free while your gone?

MissWings · 23/02/2023 14:05

The dog is yours. My mum and dad live together but they have separate dogs. It is odd but it’s the way it is round there. They’re even segregated into different living spaces.

Bieder · 23/02/2023 13:55

PurpleButterflyWings · 23/02/2023 12:47

Not a living situation I would envy, and extremely bizarre when you are a married couple. People question it, not because they are envious but because it's ODD!

Also, many people can't afford to keep 2 separate homes going... And many people wouldn't want to. It's crazy to do that when you are a married couple and should be sharing a home...

And where the fuck do the children go? Do they stay one half of the week at one house and the other half in the other house? Utterly. Batshit. 😜 And a really bad example of a marriage, to show to any children you might have .

Do any children you have (or may have in the future) have to keep to your rules of 'what goes where' too. Confused And is your DH's chip pan and war memorabilia so offensive to you? As i said. Utterly. Batshit.

Unbelievably judgemental and offensive comment. Wow.

OP posts:
DeathstarDarling · 23/02/2023 13:46

PurpleButterflyWings · 23/02/2023 12:47

Not a living situation I would envy, and extremely bizarre when you are a married couple. People question it, not because they are envious but because it's ODD!

Also, many people can't afford to keep 2 separate homes going... And many people wouldn't want to. It's crazy to do that when you are a married couple and should be sharing a home...

And where the fuck do the children go? Do they stay one half of the week at one house and the other half in the other house? Utterly. Batshit. 😜 And a really bad example of a marriage, to show to any children you might have .

Do any children you have (or may have in the future) have to keep to your rules of 'what goes where' too. Confused And is your DH's chip pan and war memorabilia so offensive to you? As i said. Utterly. Batshit.

I will put you in the VERY rude category then 😄

SerafinasGoose · 23/02/2023 13:44

I'm amazed at the number of people of here who can't understand that people live different lives to them.

I'm not, unfortunately. Nor surprised at the devotees to convention telling other couples how they 'should' be living.

For me that's filed strictly under the category of 'other people's business'. Ie. precisely none of mine.

ThereIsNoSuchThingAsRoadTax · 23/02/2023 13:32

I'm amazed at the number of people of here who can't understand that people live different lives to them. Married people living apart is not unheard of, and doesn't mean that their marriage is lesser than yours. I wonder if you are all so closed minded in respect to anyone else who doesn't conform to all of society's norms.

@Bieder My wife and I live in different houses (different countries, in fact). We have two dogs, and one lives with each of us. We would both say that one is very much my dog, and the other is very much her dog. They spend 95% of their time with just one or other of us, and we separately pay for all of their costs. But they are also both 'our' dogs. I think the dog is yours, but I think it is nice that your wife thinks he's both of yours.

Chickenly · 23/02/2023 12:58

ThePixiesTookIt · 23/02/2023 12:34

One of the many checklist things I have to do leaving the house is to take "Knobs off the hob"
I swear some of our four legged friends are trying to kill us.

His dog actually did turn our hob on. Our house filled with gas and all four of us (including my, then, 8 week old DD) were taken to hospital by ambulance. The knobs aren’t removable unfortunately - but we can cut the supply so we did that until we moved house.

PurpleButterflyWings · 23/02/2023 12:47

DeathstarDarling · 23/02/2023 12:35

I have been married 20+ years and have never lived with OH. Like you we are very happy with our arrangement. We wanted to make a public commitment to each other that our families would take seriously. I don't have to live with his war memorabilia and chip pan. He doesn't have to live with my rules about what goes where. ( ;-)) and he has somewhere to go when my introverted energy needs restoring ( i loved lockdown - the peace!) Rarely people can be VERY rude about this including asking why we bothered to get married or 'are you even married really'. On the other hand many people are openly envious.

We had a couple of cats each at one point. My cats were my cats and I made all the decisions about food, where they could go, vet treatment / end of life etc. His cats were the same for him. Sometimes we made different decisions, though we consulted each other.

If OH had referred to DC ( darling cats) as our cats in a general sense I would not have minded as I know I can trust his boundaries and he knows what's what. But if I thought he really meant they were joint I would feel a bit upset. Again its hard to pin down why, but I think its about who gets the last say when your approaches differ.

I would be glad that she loves your dog and sees him as part of the family, but maybe think about why its upsetting, Do you think its because she may think she knows best? Or are you just worried that the dog won't have you as its primary person? Maybe talk it through and if necessary agree decision making processes , training approaches etc. (like parenting they don't have to be the exactly same, just not antagonistic)

Honestly this is more likely to be a 'you' problem than a 'her' problem but its worth working through and compromising. Good luck.

Not a living situation I would envy, and extremely bizarre when you are a married couple. People question it, not because they are envious but because it's ODD!

Also, many people can't afford to keep 2 separate homes going... And many people wouldn't want to. It's crazy to do that when you are a married couple and should be sharing a home...

And where the fuck do the children go? Do they stay one half of the week at one house and the other half in the other house? Utterly. Batshit. 😜 And a really bad example of a marriage, to show to any children you might have .

Do any children you have (or may have in the future) have to keep to your rules of 'what goes where' too. Confused And is your DH's chip pan and war memorabilia so offensive to you? As i said. Utterly. Batshit.

PurpleButterflyWings · 23/02/2023 12:41

bobbytorq · 23/02/2023 10:57

Why get married when you are leading such separate lives?

My sentiments exactly!

Bieder · 23/02/2023 12:40

DeathstarDarling · 23/02/2023 12:35

I have been married 20+ years and have never lived with OH. Like you we are very happy with our arrangement. We wanted to make a public commitment to each other that our families would take seriously. I don't have to live with his war memorabilia and chip pan. He doesn't have to live with my rules about what goes where. ( ;-)) and he has somewhere to go when my introverted energy needs restoring ( i loved lockdown - the peace!) Rarely people can be VERY rude about this including asking why we bothered to get married or 'are you even married really'. On the other hand many people are openly envious.

We had a couple of cats each at one point. My cats were my cats and I made all the decisions about food, where they could go, vet treatment / end of life etc. His cats were the same for him. Sometimes we made different decisions, though we consulted each other.

If OH had referred to DC ( darling cats) as our cats in a general sense I would not have minded as I know I can trust his boundaries and he knows what's what. But if I thought he really meant they were joint I would feel a bit upset. Again its hard to pin down why, but I think its about who gets the last say when your approaches differ.

I would be glad that she loves your dog and sees him as part of the family, but maybe think about why its upsetting, Do you think its because she may think she knows best? Or are you just worried that the dog won't have you as its primary person? Maybe talk it through and if necessary agree decision making processes , training approaches etc. (like parenting they don't have to be the exactly same, just not antagonistic)

Honestly this is more likely to be a 'you' problem than a 'her' problem but its worth working through and compromising. Good luck.

Wonderful response, and especially nice coming from someone who understands our living arrangement. Thank you for taking the time to write. And yes, it’s clearly a “me problem” so I’m thinking about that and have already apologised to my wife for upsetting her of course.

OP posts:
DeathstarDarling · 23/02/2023 12:35

I have been married 20+ years and have never lived with OH. Like you we are very happy with our arrangement. We wanted to make a public commitment to each other that our families would take seriously. I don't have to live with his war memorabilia and chip pan. He doesn't have to live with my rules about what goes where. ( ;-)) and he has somewhere to go when my introverted energy needs restoring ( i loved lockdown - the peace!) Rarely people can be VERY rude about this including asking why we bothered to get married or 'are you even married really'. On the other hand many people are openly envious.

We had a couple of cats each at one point. My cats were my cats and I made all the decisions about food, where they could go, vet treatment / end of life etc. His cats were the same for him. Sometimes we made different decisions, though we consulted each other.

If OH had referred to DC ( darling cats) as our cats in a general sense I would not have minded as I know I can trust his boundaries and he knows what's what. But if I thought he really meant they were joint I would feel a bit upset. Again its hard to pin down why, but I think its about who gets the last say when your approaches differ.

I would be glad that she loves your dog and sees him as part of the family, but maybe think about why its upsetting, Do you think its because she may think she knows best? Or are you just worried that the dog won't have you as its primary person? Maybe talk it through and if necessary agree decision making processes , training approaches etc. (like parenting they don't have to be the exactly same, just not antagonistic)

Honestly this is more likely to be a 'you' problem than a 'her' problem but its worth working through and compromising. Good luck.

ThePixiesTookIt · 23/02/2023 12:34

Chickenly · 22/02/2023 15:30

In our house (because we live together), she’s my dog when she’s being gorgeous, our dog most of the time and his dog when she opens the fridge and eats the whole contents or turns the hob on 😂

One of the many checklist things I have to do leaving the house is to take "Knobs off the hob"
I swear some of our four legged friends are trying to kill us.

nc1013 · 23/02/2023 12:31

Bieder · 22/02/2023 15:49

Thank you for the perspective. Yes, clearly the consensus on this thread is that it is overly pedantic of me. And that’s kind of what I was looking for - a bit of balance. Now I need to figure out why her calling him “our” dog made me feel so anxious. And I should have a chat with her about it, because I didn’t mean to upset her.

Why is it an issue if you intend to remain married?
If I was your wife I'd probably be more upset/worried about the fact you had to clarify as it would make me think you were questioning our future

Thepossibility · 23/02/2023 12:24

Naunet · 23/02/2023 07:49

She said “our” dog, how is that hurtful and immature FFS??

Huh?...he was being hurtful and immature. By saying the dog was only his.

Baw92 · 23/02/2023 12:22

YANBU. He is your dog. He’s also your wife’s dog (as she does look after him and have some responsibility) but he’s more yours. Hope that makes sense.
I agree - just because you’re married doesn’t mean you own everything ‘jointly’ in my opinion but equally the more people that love him the better!

GiraffeLaSophie · 23/02/2023 12:07

Yes, the dog is obviously your dog, but I don’t really see the point in saying that he’s your dog when you must have known it was going to cause an upset.

I see my dog in a similar way to my step children (hear me out!)- my partner loves him and helps look after him, but if we were to split up then he would come with me as he’s my dog. I love my step children and I help look after them when they’re here, buy things for them etc, but they’re not my children.

My dog predates my relationship though, which I suppose makes a difference.

Idontgiveashitanymore · 23/02/2023 12:03

Aquamarine1029 · 22/02/2023 15:29

I can see why she lives separately. You sound like a child, honestly.

This ⬆️

RosaBonheur · 23/02/2023 11:59

Not as weird as it is to not live with your wife.