Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s my dog, not our dog

290 replies

Bieder · 22/02/2023 15:18

My wife and I live in separate houses - I live in the countryside and she lives in the city. A couple of years into our marriage I decided to buy a puppy because I always wanted a dog and I have the space and the time now. I brought the dog up, trained him etc. and he’s with me all of the time apart from the odd week when I go on a business trip (2-3 times a year), and then my wife looks after him at her place. My wife loves the dog and indulges him which can sometimes lead to a bit of conflict as I feel she undermines his training. But I’m petty happy to trust her with him and glad they get on so well. So this isn’t the issue.
The issue we had an argument about recently is that she stated he was “our” dog, and I corrected her, insisting he was mine. She got quite upset about that and said because we’re married we share everything, and hence the dog is our dog. I love my dog very much and invested so much time in bringing him up well and looking after him. He has a great, happy life with me in the countryside. I regard him as my dog and I don’t like it that she simply assumes there is this joint responsibility and custodianship. I find it hard to see the issue from her point of view. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
VeterinaryCareAssistant · 09/07/2023 11:23

Just because people are married doesn't automatically mean everything becomes shared. My partner bought a car, a pc and a fish tank and although I use the pc, go in the car and enjoy the fish tank they belong to him. Same as I have a tortoise, a lizard and a cat. They're mine not his.

For what it's worth my partner's and my earnings are also our own. Bills are split 50/50.

ZephyrPenguin · 20/03/2023 06:44

You sound like a petulant child throwing a tantrum. "But that's mine!! Waaaa" just go cry me a river, blubber tooth tiger. You should get divorced. You don't even sound like you like your wife. Who tf marries but lives literal separate lives when freaking married?

But alright fine, if it's your dog it's your responsibility to provide EVERYTHING for YOUR dog. Especially, when you go off on a work trip or whatever. YOU are responsible for finding adequate care for YOUR dog - food, toys, water, shelter, vet visit, emergency fund, etc - and that care shouldn't be your wife; unless you pay her the current rate for dog sitters. If she has no claim over the dog she doesn't need to be your free doggie daycare anymore 🤷‍♀️

Newstartonwards · 27/02/2023 19:07

GoodChat · 25/02/2023 08:19

They didn't get the dog together. They don't both have a legal responsibility for the dog. It's entirely different.

If one of them chose to adopt a child to live with them the child would remain with the adopter. They wouldn't adopt a child together with their current living arrangement.

Actually having been through the custody of a dog - it’s a joint asset in the eyes of a court regardless of who bought it

GretnaGreenIsLovely · 27/02/2023 19:07

I'm sorry I haven't read the full thread, but I think it depends on the set up you have

My husband and I live together. We have lived together for 20 years and married for 16. We share everything! I occasionally take this too far and eat 'his' chocolate! ;) But on our wedding day we kind of agreed 'whats mine is yours' and vice versa! (though I do think he whispered in my ear 'except chocolate' when we made that agreement!) But generally, something like a dog would be shared.

However, you seem to have a different set up. You don't share the same home, so maybe that also means you don't share other things. Are you and your wife both clear on what is shared in your marriage? Do you have other things you share?

I think in many marriages a dog would be considered shared, but only you and your wife know in this case. Can you just have a good chat about it? I guess she loves the dog and thought he/she was her dog too. Maybe there wasn't enough clarity when you got the dog.

Newstartonwards · 27/02/2023 19:06

Bieder · 22/02/2023 15:22

Even though I bought him, pay his food, vet bills, insurance and spend 95% off my time with him?

Technically he is a marital asset like any houses. In marriage everything is joint.
that’s why you are married

else you live alone and everything that is yours is yours

clw5264 · 27/02/2023 18:57

YTA. I have been with my husband for 12 years. We bought each other dogs. I bought him a chocolate Labrador and he got me a Shiba-Inu. I paid for their professional training and I pay the vet appointments each year. If we split up, we know the labrador is his and the shiba is mine, but while we are together they are both of ours equally. Just because I pay for his dog and spend more time with her doesn't mean it's my dog! Do you even love your wife? You seem too concerned with "mine mine mine." Get her her own dog then, and pay her for babysitting YOUR dog each time you are out of town at pet sitter rates. Let me guess, you don't pay her to watch the dog do you? Let the dog be both of yours until you divorce.

GoodChat · 25/02/2023 08:19

Kez1357 · 23/02/2023 23:25

If you adopted a child would it be both you child if you split up or only the child of who they lived with most of the time ? Any animal that arrived when the marriage was together means the animal belongs to both like children there part of your family

They didn't get the dog together. They don't both have a legal responsibility for the dog. It's entirely different.

If one of them chose to adopt a child to live with them the child would remain with the adopter. They wouldn't adopt a child together with their current living arrangement.

Mintyt · 25/02/2023 07:59

He's your dog, but share nicely

123Sharon · 23/02/2023 23:54

You are so not being unreasonable. Never ever allow her to think your dog is jointly owned. Never allow her to pay for anything for your dog so she has no legal claim. My own parents had an expensive custody battle over the dog. Dogs are important, much more important than keeping your wife happy.

Kez1357 · 23/02/2023 23:25

If you adopted a child would it be both you child if you split up or only the child of who they lived with most of the time ? Any animal that arrived when the marriage was together means the animal belongs to both like children there part of your family

NaMac93 · 23/02/2023 22:18

PurpleButterflyWings · 23/02/2023 12:47

Not a living situation I would envy, and extremely bizarre when you are a married couple. People question it, not because they are envious but because it's ODD!

Also, many people can't afford to keep 2 separate homes going... And many people wouldn't want to. It's crazy to do that when you are a married couple and should be sharing a home...

And where the fuck do the children go? Do they stay one half of the week at one house and the other half in the other house? Utterly. Batshit. 😜 And a really bad example of a marriage, to show to any children you might have .

Do any children you have (or may have in the future) have to keep to your rules of 'what goes where' too. Confused And is your DH's chip pan and war memorabilia so offensive to you? As i said. Utterly. Batshit.

  1. Who made the rules on how a marriage should look - every single person and relationship is different. Just because you don't understand it doesn't mean it isn't a good idea for them.
  1. Not everyone wants kids, that's fine.
  1. They do exist as people outside of their relationship you know. Not everyone basis their entire identity on their relationship with another person.

They clearly want to be together for the long run otherwise they wouldn't have got married.

Why are you even getting irate and bent out of shape about it? It literally has no effect on your life. Just chill out and get on with something else.

MamaMcW · 23/02/2023 20:50

Id say ur kinda being unreasonable but kinda not in some ways I guess 🤷‍♀️. Yes it's your dog you bought it, trained it and have it most of the time but considering how you don't pay for care while away then at that times it is also her dog. So she has reason to say "our dog" also your married and most people that get married what to share everything together but considering how the not living together thing is a big bit in your post. I'd say you like to live separate lives mostly so that is probably why it makes you anxious when she says it. maybe its more you are not use to things being jointly owned. You should probably talk about it although every marriage is different and maybe you get on better in different houses.

Swiftswatch · 23/02/2023 19:12

She got quite upset about that and said because we’re married we share everything, and hence the dog is our dog.

You don’t even share a home though. Sounds very much like a dating relationship so why would the dog be shared when you don’t even live in the same house?

SBNLJ29 · 23/02/2023 19:10

Bieder · 22/02/2023 15:49

Thank you for the perspective. Yes, clearly the consensus on this thread is that it is overly pedantic of me. And that’s kind of what I was looking for - a bit of balance. Now I need to figure out why her calling him “our” dog made me feel so anxious. And I should have a chat with her about it, because I didn’t mean to upset her.

I like your reflection here, I think it's great that it seems you are actually looking for outside opinions rather than just validation of your own which can often occur on these types of things. I hope you find your peace with the situation 🙂

SBNLJ29 · 23/02/2023 19:08

I like your reflection here, I think it's great that it seems you are actually looking for outside opinions rather than just validation of your own which can often occur on these types of things. I hope you find your peace with the situation 🙂

SBNLJ29 · 23/02/2023 18:57

I mean, I've always said dogs are kind of like babies. I am also default parent to my children, birthed them, spent 9 months solely with them, work part time to look after them, feed them, cloth them, teach them, play with them, you get the jist. My husband is really only default parent when I'm very rarely not around, but they are still OUR children. I know it's not exactly the same but even with kids usually one person puts in substantially more time and energy etc but doesn't make them less the other person's?

horseyhorsey17 · 23/02/2023 18:09

I was married until quite recently, and we got two dogs while we were together and they were both very definitely both my dogs. When we split there was no question about who the dogs would live with. (I somehow ended up with both cats as well though, and those WERE 'ours' until it turned out they were also mine too, because he refused to take them). The dogs choose their owner anyway, as much as it's the other way round, and mine obviously both saw me as 'their person' and not my husband, probably because of all the emotional energy I put into them, and the fact that I did all the walking - and eventually, replaced my husband in my bed with them (although they're on it rather than in it!).

It's your dog, OP.

ThatFlightyTemptressAdventure · 23/02/2023 17:51

I haven’t read every post so apologies if this is repeating what has already been said. Please try not to be jealous of your DW’s relationship with the dog being more fun. Our dog loves DH and I equally I would say but she gets very different things from each of us. That may be different because we do live together but DH is her playmate for the games and stuff while I am the one she snuggles up to on the sofa and likes to follow around doing scent training with. I expect your dog may be the same, you each offer something wonderful.

Terraria · 23/02/2023 17:44

I thought my parents are the only couple in the world that are married but can't and don't live together in the same house. If you expect her to take care of the dog when you are away, you have to share ownership.

XelaM · 23/02/2023 17:39

Well, "we" (as in my teenage daughter and I) have a dog and I find the OP totally bizarre. He is "our" family dog even though I paid for him and do almost al the caring for him. I absolutely love it when he's snuggled up to my daughter on the sofa and that he loves her just as much as he loves me and I would hate for him to be just "my" dog. But then I love my daughter and we're a family, of which our dog is a member.

ViburnumFarreri · 23/02/2023 17:38

I didn’t assume that you were a man, @Bieder , but lots of posters will if you don’t specify, and refer to your partner as she. MN tends to be harsher on males than females, so if they assume you’re a man you’ll get more judgemental responses, especially if your setup (ie living apart whilst married) is non-traditional.

I don’t know how long you’ve been married, but from what you’ve said here I wonder whether your motivation for getting married was to demonstrate commitment to the relationship (even though you don’t want to live together), rather than to merge your lives at the fundamental “everything we have, we share” level that many people see marriage? Maybe some of your discomfort is coming from the fact that your wife calling your dog “our dog” makes you anxious that she is of the “marriage means that everything in our lives is shared and merged” attitude, and that potential loss of self/autonomy is scary?

whomoon · 23/02/2023 17:31

@Bieder the first thing that popped into my head is whether you’re an only child OP?

WisherWood · 23/02/2023 17:30

I’m howling at some of these replies and honestly wondering if these people ever owned dogs.

I'm wondering if they've met any people, beyond the ten that live in their village.

Cadburysucks · 23/02/2023 17:20

You sound more attached to the dog than your wife. I hope she gets her own pet and says it’s hers only.

Bieder · 23/02/2023 17:16

Hooverthestairs · 23/02/2023 16:29

I'm glad you sorted this with your wife OP. I've just read the full thread and I think the big take away from this is why you were so triggered by it.

You mention that you have a fear of commitment, and that you are worried a week with your wife will undo training you've done. A week of good care (with somebody your dog knows and trusts) whilst you are away from your dog is so important (and fun for your dog) and you do need to chill out a bit about the training being undone, it won't happen in a week and it is not really the priority when it comes to you going away.

I work with dogs and there are dogs that I've been working with for 12/18 months plus, and their families jokingly call me their (the dog's) step-mum. I'm not their owner and claim no ownership to them, but really care about the dogs and have good relationships with them. Having that trusting connection with other people is so important and you need to relax about things.

I think perhaps you need to self reflect about your issues with letting go of control, and commitment issues, which is what this post highlights to me.

Hope this comes across as I mean it to.

You’re absolutely right, and thanks for taking the time to respond. I am overly anxious about the dog and that something might happen to him (the first year or so of his life I even had very frequent nightmares of him getting lost or killed) - that might also play into it.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread