Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think exit interviews are pointless

39 replies

Covidbegone · 22/02/2023 14:51

Just this really. I work on a team of 15 and in the last year 7 have moved on, and tbh the atmosphere has become quite rubbish. I know that nearly all gave mild reasons to leave the team (which privately I’ve been given different reasons) and ultimately I don’t think they’d tell the truth in the event that they annoyed the team leader and damage their reference, or make them seem bitter to their new employer if they were honest about why they wanted to move on. I’m not going to comment on what I do, but wondered if others found this too?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
honeylulu · 24/02/2023 13:49

In my experience they are pretty pointless because the employers weren't interested in listening and learning why retention rates were poor. If they got any negative feedback they'd get all huffy and try to argue that the points weren't valid.

tattygrl · 24/02/2023 13:37

No.

I used my exit interview to express my views and share my experience of a bullying colleague. I explained why I hadn't raised the issue at the time, and the ramifications I believed it was having on the team and the organisation. What my ex-employer did with that info I don't know, but I specifically waited for my exit interview to share the information, and wouldn't have felt safe doing it any other time.

They're often rather unnecessary, but they represent a unique opportunity for things to be shared on both sides if and when needed.

Geeds · 24/02/2023 13:22

The only one I ever had, I was totally furious at the time and didn’t hold back at all. The day after I left, the big guns from head office turned up with pizza (why is it always pizza??) and held a meeting with the staff to specifically discuss some things I’d written and apparently things did get better, I had lots of messages from ex colleagues about it at the time so I think in my case it helped.

secretllama · 24/02/2023 13:16

They're pointless if nothing is done from the info given. I left a job years ago because the supervisor had horrific mood swings and when she was in a bad mood, was awful to everyone. Like spoke to them disgustingly, and the atmosphere all day was so bad.

She made multiple people leave, all told the manager why they were leaving and nothing was done about it. So I imagine others didn't bother as what was the point?

namchangeanxious · 24/02/2023 13:09

In our organisation the boss/line manager is not allowed to read the specific comments on the exit form only HR.

Totally pointless. 4 people (inc me) named a specific person being a massive bully as reason for leaving in interview and she got promoted to super prestigious position.

@Scarecrowrowboat Yes, it's same in my workplace 😥

Scarecrowrowboat · 23/02/2023 14:46

Totally pointless. 4 people (inc me) named a specific person being a massive bully as reason for leaving in interview and she got promoted to super prestigious position.

WorkingFromHomeRocks · 23/02/2023 14:36

Totally pointless. At one job I was all fired up to say what I really thought but when it actually came to it, I just ended up saying ‘oh it’s been fine I guess. I just want a new opportunity’ (or words to that effect.

Really I wanted to say that I was leaving because of the toxic environment, bullying and the fact that they discriminated against disabled employees. In the end, I was so worn out I just wanted to leave and forget about it.

TitInATrance · 23/02/2023 11:49

Courtorder · 22/02/2023 14:58

Yep. Employers only bother having them with employees that they know won’t say anything bad. Employees who haven’t already made clear that they’d say something bad don’t want to damage a reference or upset people.

This. After 35 years with the same organisation and with in-depth knowledge of its problems, I left without an exit interview … both my manager and me were kept busy all morning.

On the plus side I didn’t get a chance to tidy my desk either, so someone else had the job of wading through it all.

Onwayoutsoon · 23/02/2023 10:57

My exit interview from Debenhams was the best 15 minutes of 2 years of working there.

I didn’t hold back about the way they treated their shop floor staff, feel tv like I was a spokesperson for my lovely colleagues I was leaving behind.

The no clue managers ears got pinker and pinker as the interview progressed, never regretted it and luckily never had to return to that type of job again so wasn’t held against me.

Ponoka7 · 23/02/2023 10:32

My DD worked for a high street retailer and they asked afterwards. She gave an honest account and two staff members were moved. It had become a family click of negativity. It should be asked once in the new role.

Dammitthisisshit · 23/02/2023 10:29

honest feedback is never pointless.

If employees aren’t giving honest feedback then they need to be reassured that there are no negative consequences of doing so. You’ll never get everyone to open up but if some do then it’s worth it.

Greenbeans123 · 23/02/2023 10:29

I worked in the nhs. I left because they merged teams and one of the team members was a long-term bully who'dnever been delt with. Who turned her attention to my boss, then to me. Both of us left (both taking a lower band job), management knew why but stated they'd be no exit interview as they were to busy to schedule one. However I wouldn't have told them exactly why I was leaving in a documented process because you never know when your going to end up being managed by someone from a previous time in the nhs as they're always moving managers/merging teams. It wouldn't have been good for my career.

TheCatApostropheSServant · 23/02/2023 10:16

i changed job last year. All leavers are sent a link to an online exit interview questionnaire. I didn’t complete it as the answers to the questionnaire would only have been read by my manager, who was the reason why I left. They’d have bitched about me and nothing would have changed. No point doing it.

ToDoListAddict · 23/02/2023 10:09

In my previous role, my manager had a very clear favourite. It drove the whole team insane that none of the rules applied to The Favourite.
Even HR commented that The Favourite could do no wrong!
So much so, people started leaving.
One guy left and gave an exit interview detailing all the faults of The Favourite. Absolutely nothing changed in the team.
He was unhappy in the new role and tried to come back (and he was desperately needed!) but the manager refused, all due the exit interview feedback.
So when I left, I gave as little information possible in my exit interview as I wanted the safety net of returning if the new job didn't go well.

Mangolist · 23/02/2023 10:09

Totally. In mine I gave an honest account of the horrendous and bordering on corrupt behaviour of management and staff. It was a really stressful and painful hour and I'd hoped something may change for those left behind. From what I can see it's probably even worse there now

Neededanewuserhandle · 23/02/2023 10:07

Lovethesun100 · 22/02/2023 14:53

I agree - completely pointless

Me too - I refuse to do them.

billyt · 23/02/2023 10:06

The company I left to join my present one arranged an exit interview for my last day. Made a big thing about it. My immediate Manager didn't want to travel down from the North to their London office so got the Sales Director to do it. (I wasn't in Sales).

Being the sort to not shit on anyone taking over my workload, when he approached me to do the meeting I asked for a few more minutes to finish something. Nope, he had to do it then as other appointments.

I was there over five years. My exit interview lasted seven minutes! Wasn't interested in why I was leaving, just box-ticking. Although, when we met up a few months later (still same industry) he said he had wished he'd asked as the division went to pot after Grin Not saying I was important, only I was the only one who knew the role.

Oh, and his next appointment? The pub....where we went for my leaving drink.

NeedToChangeName · 23/02/2023 10:02

Also, could be helpful if the employee is retiring and can speak freely as they're not bothered about getting a reference in future

NeedToChangeName · 23/02/2023 10:01

I think they could be useful if (1) employer learns that lots of employees are leaving for the same reason eg more money, better career progression, better shift pattern, part time hours, or the option to work from home / preferring to be in an office etc and (2) the employer might be able and willing to address those issues

Otherwise, probably a waste of time

Ilkleymoor · 23/02/2023 09:56

I do them my team when they leave and have made changes based on their feedback. The company does do them as a whole, which I think is a mistake. I have sent feedback up to my manager and to the HR team as well.

I worked in a charity once where someone didn't hold back when they left and there was a disciplinary interview for the manager named.

SouperWoman · 23/02/2023 09:54

Exit interviews only benefit the employer, not the employee - unless you think you might want to go back at some point, any changes you might provoke won’t benefit you. If you can, refuse to do one. If you can’t, say nothing useful. Companies should come up with better ways of getting honest and useful feedback to prevent good staff leaving, not wringing their hands when they leave.

Dreamstate · 23/02/2023 09:53

Most companies just pay lip service, lets face it is rare to find one that really wants to know. Its like good managers, a rare breed.

Arthurflecksfacepaint · 23/02/2023 09:44

I had an exit interview once.

I worked in a school and the exit interview was with the line manager that was such an incompetent, nasty bitch that I handed in my notice after 6 months.

I was very honest with her and told her I was leaving because of her and her inability to do her job correctly. That she had made me miserable, constantly changing my job description and duties and making me do things I couldn’t do without infringing on my actual job and then reprimanding me for it.

She tried to change the good reference she had given me a few days previously for my new job. Totally retraced it and gave a really vile, rubbish one making me out to be the devil.

Luckily, I was going back to the job I had left for the school (care work, they are always desperate for anyone so bit my hand off when I wanted my old job back 😂), my old boss called me and said, “wow, so what happened? They suddenly hate you!” She found it hilarious that she had thrown such a strop.

(I was totally justified - this school business manager started at the same time as me, since I left that job, no one has stayed in it longer than two terms.)

Radiatorvalves · 23/02/2023 09:39

I’d want to know your concerns. Work for a big company (20k employees) and the comments could shine a light on an individual or area that needed attention.

grrhh · 23/02/2023 09:35

As others have said it depends on the company/organisation and the culture. The company should be using it as an opportunity to reflect and for it to serve as a warning about possible problems and to enable them to do better.

I think it depends too on the person doing the interview - if its the immediate line manager it can feel hard to be truthful, if its someone else in the team / hr person it can be easier to outline the issues as it doesnt feel like a direct criticism of the person involced.

Best exit interview I had was with an HR person who I got on well with where I was able to outline concerns about (a rather controlling) line manager and also I was able to show her the job descriptions of the roles I had been applying for. She listened and when I saw her informally six months later she thanked me as my input had strengthened a case against the line manager who had been 'managed out' in a restructuring.

Swipe left for the next trending thread