Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gentle parenting emotions, I don’t understand.

133 replies

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 13:34

Please can someone tell me if I’m getting this wrong, or what the hell im ‘supposed’ to be doing. I don’t get gentle parenting but am trying to see if it helps manage my toddler (2.5yrs) emotional outbursts.

I read a Janet Lansbury post about what to do when a child has a meltdown. She used an example of a child needing a physical outlet for their frustrations and so used to rip up bits of paper. The mum kept stacks of paper ready for the child to rip up to prevent her lashing out physically. The mum thought this was successful and made a comment about how she is the same and uses a baseball bat when she’s frustrated. Now this to me is not emotionally healthy.

my question is - with gentle parenting and acknowledging the emotions and allowing them to flood out, not quietening them, are we just teaching our children that they are entitled to scream and shout when they feel upset?

How do I get my toddler to calm down and quieten down, as if I say ‘calm down’ then I’m repressing her emotions. Does that make sense? What am I missing?

OP posts:
RoseGoldEagle · 22/02/2023 14:40

I know what you mean and it’s something I struggle with too.

My 3 year old DS hits his siblings sometimes when he’s angry or frustrated. I’ve read ‘gentle’ advice on redirecting this and letting him hit a cushion as an outlet for his anger, but I’m never clear how this helps, really.

Surely he needs to learn that it’s ok to feel angry, everyone feels that way sometimes, but it’s my job to teach him that it is just NOT ok to hit in response to that. Otherwise what happens in other situations when there’s no pillow around- he’s still used to ‘hitting’ as his way to deal with his anger, and may take it out on someone else in that moment.

Tearing paper may not be the quite same, but the principal is the same to me. I want to teach my kids healthier ways to manage their anger- going for a walk or having a run around or taking deep deep breaths, or whatever helps them calm down, and then we can talk it through when they’re calmer. My 6 year old DD (who was also a hitter when younger), is (mostly!) great at this now, she will say fiercely ‘I am SO angry with you!! I need to be on my own!’ and she retreats to her room for a bit!

It’s completely normal for little ones not to be able to regulate their emotions, of course, but I want to get him out of what essentially becomes a habit or automatic response- to hit/tear stuff up/generally be destructive when he feels anger.

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 22/02/2023 14:35

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:22

@SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox im not being goady, honestly. But isn’t removing the ‘stressor’ just giving in to the tantrum? For example she has a meltdown because I have her the wrong cup. I remove the cup. She’s learnt if she screams she gets her way?

A tantrum isnt a deliberate manipulation at toddler age. Children can learn to switch it on when they're older if they find it means they get their own way. Which is what you're wanting to avoid I think.

So if wrong cup causes upset it is likely genuine, caused by lack of choice or inability to communicate wants in advance... let the upset pass through, then say do you want to choose a different cup (assuming which cup it is doesn't matter to you).

What you want to avoid is a tantrum turning your stated no into a yes. That's where tantrums become problematic.

So if you have said no to a glass but you can choose yellow or green breaker, all the tantrums in the world don't mean they get the glass. For good reason.

If the cup she's got is the only one you're prepared to offer, I would calmly sit while tantrum passed through and then either distract and carry on with the cup or say oh dear that's a shame. But make no change. So patience and empathy but no change.

That's how not to 'give in' you accommodate where that's kind and empathise, you don't have in and be dictated to to make the big emotions go away. And your calm is their anchor back to happy.
But not every tantrum is a battle you're trying to 'win'.

Curiosity101 · 22/02/2023 14:33

You're only validating the screaming if you replace the wrong cup with the "right" one.

"Oops, sorry I didn't realise you wanted that cup. Next time can you let me know if you want a particular cup and if I can I'll give you that one. Right now I've already put the drink you wanted in this cup, you don't have to drink it but I don't want to dirty another cup right now."

If they were old enough I'd be tempted to say "I could always transfer this drink to the other cup for you if you want, but you'd need to clean this one out before you could have the new one".

And older still... "Feel free to transfer it over, but clean the dirty cup please"

Or whatever your reasoning is for her not getting the "right" cup.

"Oops, sorry I didn't realise you wanted that cup. Next time can you let me know if you want a particular cup and if I can I'll give you that one. Right now I've already put the drink you wanted in this cup, you don't have to drink it but you were rude when you shouted. Next time you should ask politely if you've got a problem and want something changing" (depends on the age of the child of course)

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 22/02/2023 14:31

So I was having the worst time with my toddler and I totally flipped my parenting style for him. Honestly he would meet shouting with shouting, didn't give a flying fuck about any punishment... Whereas my first kid was really good at regulating their emotions, my second really had to learn the skill.

I took a parenting class that basically said, kids are small humans. Humans need empathy and understanding when they display their emotions. Small humans need to be taught the boundaries that are acceptable in order to regulate these emotions.

So, say my kid was having a tantrum about wanting chocolate cake? I'd empathise and reflect their emotions back to them....

"Yes you do want the cake". "I understand you want the cake, the cake is yummy, I want the cake too". "You feel cross because we can't eat the cake", "The cake does look good. We can eat it at specific time. We can have an apple or a cracker now if our tummies are feeling hungry". "You feel worried you're going to miss out on cake".

You're validating their feelings of anger/FOMO/wanting without breaking your boundary of "cake is for later". You're understanding them rather than telling them they're being a baby or whatever. It's so important- their big feelings are BIG.

Retaliates with a hit or throwing something? "Buddy it's not ok to hurt others or break things. If you need to work through it, on the thinking step and play with your calm jar, or go to your room and throw socks at the target. Let me know when you're ready for a hug".

It's a longer road than a bollocking or whatever, but I now have a 4 year old who is emotionally literate and really trusts that I am listening to him when he tells me something important.

murmuration · 22/02/2023 14:30

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:22

@SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox im not being goady, honestly. But isn’t removing the ‘stressor’ just giving in to the tantrum? For example she has a meltdown because I have her the wrong cup. I remove the cup. She’s learnt if she screams she gets her way?

Honestly, I think in a tantrum they don't learn much no matter what you do. So I wouldn't worry too much about it. One trick is to do something like "I see you don't like this cup, and I wish I could give you the other cup. It can't happen right now (or if there is a reason - not clean, etc.)" Just the acknowledgement that they're heard is sometimes enough.

My daughter used to have tantrums when I did give her what she asked for and I was always mystified - she asked for a biscuit and I was getting a biscuit and then she's tantrumming because she didn't have a biscuit (yet) - should I give it to her or not? I generally did, and it didn't seem to train her into tantrumming...

Rollonspring23 · 22/02/2023 14:29

The key to gentle parenting is validating and empathising with your child’s emotions (so recognising that they are upset that they can’t have the red cup) rather than dismissing their emotions. Often this acknowledgement and the offer of a cuddle once they are ready helps to regulate their emotions. They feel seen and then are able to calm down using you as a safe base. Once they are calm you can then discuss better ways of dealing with it than lashing out etc if they are old enough to understand. This may sound like ‘I can see that you really wanted the red cup and you’re upset that it’s in the dishwasher. We’ll have to use the blue one today but it’s ok to be upset / have big feelings, do you need a cuddle to help you to feel better / I’m here when you’re ready for a cuddle’. You may need to sit and wait for them to be ready for a cuddle. It’s all about holding your boundary but acknowledging and naming their emotions and then supporting them to calm down. I found it worked really well and still does with my eight year old when she’s really upset. We’ll then have a chat about better ways of handling her emotions once she’s calm.

slamfightbrightlight · 22/02/2023 14:29

Also, the question about “when would they stop ripping up paper”, the answer would be when they’ve developed sufficient emotional regulation to do so. Then they might need different methods to self-regulate.

slamfightbrightlight · 22/02/2023 14:27

It’s not usually about the cup. It is, as mentioned above, usually something else 1 overtired, hungry, needing to exert control. What most “gentle” parenting people would recommend is going “upstream” to work out what the real issue is - new sibling? Change of routine? Not enough time outside? Not enough sleep? Just being two? There’s a fine line between gentle and permissive, good advocates of gentle parenting will also be clear that it is authoritative, not permissive. There’s a group called Visible Child on Facebook, run by Robin Einzig, which I think you might find helpful OP.

winningeasy · 22/02/2023 14:25

It's simply that you are not afraid of their emotions and you don't suppress them or invalidate them eg 'you're ok', 'shhhhhh'... you recognise them, name them and allow them to flow, then explain what you think just happened and offer comfort and soothing.

It's healthy to get emotions out rather than bury them (my parents generation are some of the most emotionally people I've met), it's much more likely a child will learn to self regulate as they mature. I doubt very much you'll be seeing adults in their 20s and 30s having a massive tantrum in shopping centre in a couple of decades time.

Curiosity101 · 22/02/2023 14:25

@CupEmpty Ask yourself what she's aiming to get out of screaming/crying. Normally they're either attempting to elicit a reaction (hoping you'll give in to the demand) or they're just genuinely heartbroken as everything is the best thing in the world or the end of your world at that age.

I'd summarise what I do as offering comfort/commiserations to the negative feelings without giving in on what was presumably an unreasonable demand and without pandering/focusing on the trigger. Focusing on the trigger just extended the tantrum in my experience, in business speak it'd be referred to as focusing on solutions not problems. Over time the upset to elicit a reaction will naturally go away cause it just doesn't work. And they get better at managing disappointment with practice. They also get better at understanding that their request might not be met now but that you understand their point of view and if suitable you will offer the best alternative you can at a later date/time. So if you say "You can't have this cup now because of x,y,z but you can have it later", then build trust by making sure you give it to them later. That way next time you say that they will remember and trust you.

Just out of interest, what do you gain by her stopping crying sooner?

Courtorder · 22/02/2023 14:23

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:12

That’s exactly how I feel @bellac11 her level of upset over a cup or whatever is not valid.

It is valid. Have you never gone to the cupboard wanting a cup of tea in your favourite mug and seen that it’s dirty in the dishwasher and you have to use a different mug? You’d get upset in an adult way, a split second of sorrow and moving on. That’s because you’ve learnt how to regulate how to express your emotions but also because you know that your mug will be there tomorrow and that tea tastes the same either way. Children haven’t learnt that skill or learnt perspective yet. Children don’t know the cup will be there tomorrow or that the drink is the same from a different cup. So they express that same, valid feeling in an inappropriate way.

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 22/02/2023 14:23

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:12

That’s exactly how I feel @bellac11 her level of upset over a cup or whatever is not valid.

It's not usually about the cup though. It's usually about control or communication or choice or tiredness or hangry etc ... The scale of emotion comes from that not the cup.

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:22

@SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox im not being goady, honestly. But isn’t removing the ‘stressor’ just giving in to the tantrum? For example she has a meltdown because I have her the wrong cup. I remove the cup. She’s learnt if she screams she gets her way?

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 22/02/2023 14:21

This didn't work every time, but it worked often enough to be worth trying. I would go and read a book aloud in the corner, or put on some beautiful music and listen. My kids never wanted to tantrum alone; they always wanted me there, so I figured I was the solution somehow. They would see me doing something calming, and about half the time they would decide they were more interested in the book or music than in trying to get a reaction out of me.

Sometimes you do just have to let it run its course. They're too small to have learned to regulate strong feelings and you cant teach them how if you can't do it yourself. I never reacted, if they were doing an activity I'd remove them.

Courtorder · 22/02/2023 14:19

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:11

@Courtorder how would you advise getting a toddler to calm down in a ‘gentle way’. And learn that screaming/ crying going forward is not ok? I feel if I tell her to stop crying I’ll be repressing her feelings.

With me, I say “use your words” or “wear does it hurt?” or specific yes/no questions to make it easier (“are you sad about the cup?” etc). If DS continues to scream or shout, I’ll say “DS, if you continue to shout at me then I’ll put you on reflection rainbow” then I’ll ask another yes/no question. If he continues then I’ll say “DS, you are on reflection rainbow. Can you please think about why I don’t like it when you shout and scream? And why it makes if harder for me for help you? If you continue to scream and shout then I’ll have to move you to the stormy rain cloud”. If he continues from there, then he goes on the stormy rain cloud where I’ll say “DS, I’ve put you on the stormy rain cloud because you’ve already been on the reflection rainbow and you’re still screaming and shouting. It’s hurtful to me for you to scream and shout because X and it prevents me helping you because Y. I’d like you to stop screaming and shouting”. Then I simply ignore until he calms down and we’ll have a calm discussion about what was upsetting him before, about why it’s not a good outlet for his feelings and I’ll ask for an apology for his screaming and shouting.

murmuration · 22/02/2023 14:19

That’s exactly how I feel @bellac11 her level of upset over a cup or whatever is not valid.

But for a toddler, it might be valid. (I still remember the helium balloon I lost 4 years old. I was devastated... nothing my parents could do would help, but I realise now it was my first experience of grief - yeah, over a balloon - so it was something that needed to be felt before I could put actual problems into perspective)

Something I found sometimes worked is to ask "Is this a small, medium, or big upset?" Then gentle logic, as everything is 'big', to relate things - "oh, so this no worse than when you dropped your sandwhich yesterday" 'MUCH WORSE!!' "so that was a medium upset and this a big one; we'll remember that" Eventually she would actually identify some things as 'small' or 'medium' upsets, and calm herself down.

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 22/02/2023 14:19

Agree with @murmuration , sometimes being nearby sitting calmly until the storm has passed and then saying 'are you ready for a cuddle now?' is all that's needed. Maybe add 'those were big emotions weren't they, shall we find something else to do?' once feeling better is all you need.

murmuration · 22/02/2023 14:15

Do you actually need her to stop crying? I just used to wait for my toddler to calm down on her own. Any intervention just prolonged the whole thing.

I agree the ripping up is weird. If they were already being distructive, providing something 'safe' to get anger out on makes senses, but not encouraging destruction.

I used to give my daughter crayons and ask her to draw her upset. This generally generated either big scribbles or a crayon tossed across the room and more crying. I kept doing it for the big scribbles times.

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 22/02/2023 14:14

Can't comment on gentle parenting as a thing.

But the way you help her calm down is to address what has upset her rather than her emotional outburst. So sooth/solve/remove the cause and bring your own calm to the situation returns things to a happy state quicker and better than anything imo.

My DH used to always tackle the behaviour, try to get the child to calm down, reached to the child upset with his own emotional response. Never helped and often made it worse.

I think giving the child something harmless to lash out at instead is still just a response to the emotional overspill rather than helpful.

Dh got a lot better as he sees my response working. I don't let their emotions become mine, stay calm, remove the stressors and help de-escalate.
Then when it's calm again I say stuff like, such and such was upsetting wasn't it. It all got a bit too much didn't it.
So reflect and validate and give them the emotional language to process what happened, it all helps them build self awareness and gradually improve the responses to one of managing themselves before they are overcome with strong emotion.

Hostofgoldendaffodils · 22/02/2023 14:12

following

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:12

That’s exactly how I feel @bellac11 her level of upset over a cup or whatever is not valid.

OP posts:
CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:11

@Courtorder how would you advise getting a toddler to calm down in a ‘gentle way’. And learn that screaming/ crying going forward is not ok? I feel if I tell her to stop crying I’ll be repressing her feelings.

OP posts:
bellac11 · 22/02/2023 14:10

I think the hardest thing some of these theories dont address very well is that not all feelings are valid. Feelings are unreliable, they dont have to dictate someones behaviour and children need to learn that.

Courtorder · 22/02/2023 14:08

The message is two-fold:

  1. Your emotions are valid
  2. There are appropriate and inappropriate ways to express those emotions

Far too often, people think that “gentle parenting” means allowing your child to behave however they wish, but it’s not. Screaming and shouting is, almost always, an unacceptable outlet for an emotion - that doesn’t mean the pain/anger/sadness/fear isn’t a valid emotion, it just means you need an appropriate way to handle that emotion. What’s “acceptable” varies from parent to parent, child to child, family to family so you choose for your family. Some parents would have no issue with tearing paper as an outlet, some would.

Alexandernevermind · 22/02/2023 14:06

Toddler tantrums with mine were usually because the child was over tired, over stimulated, bored or hungry. No amount of tearing up paper was going to fix those issues. Running up and down the garden with the dog whilst I prepared a quick snack, followed by a cuddle nap solved pretty much every problem - at least with the boy child!