Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gentle parenting emotions, I don’t understand.

133 replies

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 13:34

Please can someone tell me if I’m getting this wrong, or what the hell im ‘supposed’ to be doing. I don’t get gentle parenting but am trying to see if it helps manage my toddler (2.5yrs) emotional outbursts.

I read a Janet Lansbury post about what to do when a child has a meltdown. She used an example of a child needing a physical outlet for their frustrations and so used to rip up bits of paper. The mum kept stacks of paper ready for the child to rip up to prevent her lashing out physically. The mum thought this was successful and made a comment about how she is the same and uses a baseball bat when she’s frustrated. Now this to me is not emotionally healthy.

my question is - with gentle parenting and acknowledging the emotions and allowing them to flood out, not quietening them, are we just teaching our children that they are entitled to scream and shout when they feel upset?

How do I get my toddler to calm down and quieten down, as if I say ‘calm down’ then I’m repressing her emotions. Does that make sense? What am I missing?

OP posts:
Teapotkitten · 22/02/2023 16:41

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:01

I get it with hitting etc as it’s a clear boundary but hers are emotional meltdowns, that’s what I’m trying to deal with. She gets very very upset/ hysterical, over little things. So there’s no boundary to hold, if that makes sense .I do already follow big little feelings, it’s mentioned to death on here but to be honest I don’t get the hype.

My DD has always felt things very, very deeply and has always had really bad emotional meltdowns from time to time where she won't even talk to me, she'll carry on for ages working herself up more and more into a frenzy until I help her recover. She'll scream "go away!!" and then cry even harder if I do! The one technique I've found that works well when she's that far gone is to sit near her and not talk to her, but get one of her teddies or toys and talk to it about what's happened instead. I tell the toy why she's upset and how what she's doing about it isn't very helpful, and that maybe she needs a cuddle, or something else we could do to make things better (without giving in to whatever it was that set her off in the first place!). She's gradually getting better at regulating her emotions herself as she gets older.

Twizbe · 22/02/2023 16:36

My son had huge frustration tantrums when he was younger.

My main approach was to name the emotion and talk about ways to express the emotion.

We'd say, it's ok to be frustrated. It's not ok to throw things. We can breath and sigh like this to deal with the emotion. You can tell me 'I'm frustrated' and we can calm down together.

BertieBotts · 22/02/2023 16:26

I try not to use the term gentle parenting any more because I have found that the whole concept of it is much too wide ranging to be useful. Gentle parenting just means not-authoritarian parenting, so what you are "supposed to do" for emotions is basically anything other than shutting them down, ignoring them or punishing them. This is why you have - I lost count - at least 8 different suggestions so far, from posters who have either confidently stated this is what gentle parenting is or at least didn't say explicitly that they don't follow gentle parenting - encompassing every approach from renaming traditional consequences (traffic light system) into fluffy names, through distraction and redirection, separating feeling from action, naming the feeling, and all the way up to go upstream and figure out what caused the feeling, because the behaviour is only a signal something is wrong. There's nothing wrong with the variety in these responses BTW but they are not all describing a singular parenting style.

Janet Lansbury teaches RIE, or her own slant on it - her thing for emotions is basically about fully accepting them, because she explains that a lot of parents have absorbed the message that they should not shut down/punish emotions (stop crying, you're not a baby etc) but we still tend to feel uncomfortable with them and make them want to go away. So we'll do things like find a creative way around a boundary so that we still feel like we've held the boundary but the child feels like they have got what they want too, or we endlessly reassure or we offer some kind of distraction because we can't bear our children being upset or sometimes people even back down on boundaries because they can't cope with children being upset. These things, she argues, are unhelpful because they leave children feeling like they have too much power, perhaps that they don't know where the boundary actually is, and they can unsettle the adult with their emotions. So one of her main things that she teaches is to be a calm kind of base for children's emotions to wash over (this is part of the name of her blog "unruffled"). BTW, I find her content is so much better/easier to understand in audio, because she does a lot with tone, and I do usually find her advice on the subject of children's emotions to be very helpful - I think I probably do fall into her camp of feeling unsettled/alarmed by my children's emotions, and wanting to fix it, almost over-empathetic because I can FEEL how real that distress is to them and it feels overwhelming to me. She says: Yes, do acknowledge how real that distress is, but let them come through it and process it.

I don't know the article you're referring to - do you have a link to it? The adult using a baseball bat to relieve their own difficult feelings does sound a bit unhealthy to me, but also surprises me for JL but maybe it came across differently in the article.

mackthepony · 22/02/2023 16:24

She's too little yet for all this

Wait a couple of years

Zippidydoda · 22/02/2023 16:18

I always think we treat children likes they’re completely different to adults and give them a lot less grace than adults. Obviously children are less developed but their basic needs are similar to us as adults.

if you as an adult are hugely upset and struggling to manage your emotions what would help you? Someone screaming at you? Someone telling you to calm down? Someone giving you a hug? Someone giving you space and then chatting to you later?

I’ve often thought the best way in managing my children’s big outbursts is to think what sort of thing might help me if I was feeling the same way. Then adapt it slightly to be child appropriate.

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 22/02/2023 16:15

Really good advice @Rinkydinkydoodle 👌 distraction and humour are super useful.

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 22/02/2023 16:12

Just because something is illogical doesn't mean it's not valid either.
My toddler would be really upset if you gave a treat with a wrapper on because they couldn't get the wrapper off. If you took the wrapper off for them they'd be really upset because they wanted to take the wrapper off.
The answer is to remember they are really really little so I'd discreetly snip the wrapper to make it easy to get off then give it until they could treat it off easily.
Or give it to them with wrapper and say would you like me to show you how to take it off. Then slowly show them exactly how to do the tear. It all puts them in the driving seat a bit more because no one likes to feel done to we all like to feel done with.
Nothing is 100% but respect for their point of view is a good starting point for all interactions because they are real people with genuine feelings (no one is more genuine than a toddler!). Then it's our job to guide them along the way to a better perspective, little by little, while accepting they're not going to react like an adult overnight.

CarmenBizet · 22/02/2023 16:05

Rebel2 · 22/02/2023 16:02

I don't have DC so take this with a pinch of salt but for me I would think

The cup is like the last straw for some reason, like when you've had a bad day and drop something, any other day it would be minor but that day makes you cry/angry/go FFS

Also they can't compare. So the wrong cup is a tiny thing to use because we've experienced much bigger/worse things but to them it's the biggest thing in their whole day/week, so their reaction is proportionate to how I dunno, crashing our car would be to us?

Again, no DC so I might be way out!

You're 100% right.

Toddlers are humans, and all humans like a degree of control over their environment and life. It's not fair for us to expect toddlers to be super chill having zero say over things. That's why giving a couple of choices often works well!

If it's a hard boundary for example no, we're not buying sweets today, no you can't hit the cat, you can't bite me, then you hold the boundary and validate the emotion and they learn to deal with frustration and disappointment. But wanting a certain colour cup isn't a negative behaviour to eradicate. If they're rejecting every cup and messing around saying I want yellow then rejecting it then obviously you'd get to a point where it's this cup or no cup cos you can't win and it's become a battle of wills where the cup isn't really the issue.

Rebel2 · 22/02/2023 16:02

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:22

@SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox im not being goady, honestly. But isn’t removing the ‘stressor’ just giving in to the tantrum? For example she has a meltdown because I have her the wrong cup. I remove the cup. She’s learnt if she screams she gets her way?

I don't have DC so take this with a pinch of salt but for me I would think

The cup is like the last straw for some reason, like when you've had a bad day and drop something, any other day it would be minor but that day makes you cry/angry/go FFS

Also they can't compare. So the wrong cup is a tiny thing to use because we've experienced much bigger/worse things but to them it's the biggest thing in their whole day/week, so their reaction is proportionate to how I dunno, crashing our car would be to us?

Again, no DC so I might be way out!

AliasGrape · 22/02/2023 15:42

I totally understand the struggle, and the worry if you’re doing right/ wrong - are you repressing feelings? Giving the wrong message? Reinforcing the behaviour? Etc etc

Id honestly ask yourself 1) why can’t she have the cup? If it’s unavailable/ in the dishwasher or she’s already changed her mind four times then ok she can’t. But if you know she has a particular favourite, or it’s simply a case of pouring a bit of water from one cup to the other then why not let her have the one she wants? It’s unlikely to turn her into some kind of delinquent, and easier to just pick your battles.

Try to set the environment up for her to be able to make choices in the first place - put some plastic cups in a low cupboard or basket and ask her to go choose one before you make her drink.

  1. Why do you need her to calm down so quickly? Whether it’s a big deal to you or not, it feels like a big deal to her in the moment. So let her have her moment. You don’t need to teach her anything mid tantrum - and it won’t work anyway. A two year old loudly sobbing about a cup may well be a pain in the arse, but it’s developmentally appropriate and she’s unlikely to still be doing it (regularly anyway) in a couple of years.

I have found as well if I’m just really calm and monotone saying ‘oh you’re upset about the cup’ it makes bugger all difference, but If I try to match the emotion a bit and put some emphasis in, ‘wow you feel SO sad, you REALLY wanted that cup’ it works better. Then as everyone else has said, ‘we don’t have that one right now, I will make sure it’s here at dinner time, right now you can have milk or water in this cup, do you want to help me pour ….’ Or if really not ready for that then either sit nearby/ get on with jobs but reiterate I’m there and she can have a hug when she needs one

HotPenguin · 22/02/2023 15:30

I think punching cushions and ripping paper is generally seen as a bad idea these days, as it's encouraging the child to express their emotions by destroying things. If you have a twelve year old punching people then yes, getting them to punch a cushion is better, but for a toddler I wouldn't encourage it as a way of handling feelings.

I think the idea is to show empathy for their feelings eg "oh no your biscuit snapped in two, that's a pain!" Rather than "don't be ridiculous just eat the biscuit". You are putting it into perspective for them, by acknowledging that it isn't great but also showing it's not a total disaster and can be solved.

WinterDeWinter · 22/02/2023 15:21

I'm so interested in this. I definitely was not allowed to be upset or angry and I now really struggle to sit with any strong negative feelings - I feel almost a propulsion to express them in a very uncontrolled way which is often not good for me or the other person. I was thinking just today that I need to try and reparent myself by asking myself similar questions to 'what are you feeling?', ''how big is it?' etc.

Mariposista · 22/02/2023 15:18

Totally agree

Rycbar · 22/02/2023 15:13

There are other ways to teach your child coping strategies. Breathing techniques work brilliantly with my class as well as fiddly tools to re centre themselves. Saying ‘I know it’s hard when you can’t have things you want’ (or something relevant to the situation). You’re validating their feelings and then you can move onto feeling better. I do a thing where the children breath in as you trace up your fingers and then breathe out as you go down. You have to teach the children this when they’re regulated for them to be able to do this when they need it. Follow good morning ms foster or courageous cubs on Instagram. They’re educators but a lot is relevant!

N4ish · 22/02/2023 15:10

It's not really about the cup! Sometimes little children have emotions building up and they need to let them out, a minor trigger like the wrong cup or a broken biscuit just provides the catalyst for a release.

KaliforniaDreamz · 22/02/2023 15:04

Take a look at Dr Becky and her videos on parenting - she uses real lif examples

CarmenBizet · 22/02/2023 15:04

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:12

That’s exactly how I feel @bellac11 her level of upset over a cup or whatever is not valid.

That's not really on you to judge. It's valid to her, it's upsetting to her. Remember she's pretty new to the world and learning to deal with emotions and disappointment, a thing that seems tiny to you (wrong cup) might feel like the end of the world to her and that's okay.

ow would you advise getting a toddler to calm down in a ‘gentle way’. And learn that screaming/ crying going forward is not ok? I feel if I tell her to stop crying I’ll be repressing her feelings

Why would you want to teach her that crying is not okay? And screaming? She's expressing her emotions. Crying is okay. Screaming (in upset) is okay. Emotions: valid, certain behaviours: not okay. Okay the emotion. Don't allow the behaviour that is genuinely not okay, for example hitting. I think the problem is you are trying to 'calm her down' and have the perception that you can do that, when the best thing to do is let her feel her emotions, allow them to run their course, and be there for her. You don't have to stop her feelings and nor should you and it's not your job to stop them. I see parents run into problems a lot when trying to 'calm down' a toddler. The more you try and get them to stop being upset or angry (which is what you're doing when you try to calm them down) the more unheard or invalidated they feel. Imagine if you're legitimately upset about something that happened to you and someone came over and was like 'calm down, it's not that big a deal, shhhh', how would that make you feel? Enraged probably, misunderstood, and hurt.

I don't even consider myself necessarily a 'gentle parent' but I do parent with compassion, validate his emotions, hold boundaries I've set and let him feel the way he feels. So if he wants a certain cup I'll give him it, why wouldn't I? Even adults have a favourite cup. If he's having a tantrum because of something he wants that isn't reasonable or doable (for example last night a tantrum over wanting to flip the pancakes in the boiling hot pan) I just comfort and validate. 'I know honey, I know you feel so sad, you really want to flip those pancakes don't you? It's tough when you can't do something you really want to do! I understand. I'm here for you. I love you' while holding and stroking him as he moves through the emotions. Once you let go of the idea that emotions are something to be controlled and suppressed parenting a toddler gets much easier!

Her feelings about the cup are valid. And remember it's not even always about the 'thing' it seems to be about. Maybe she had something happen that day at nursery that upset her she can't verbalise and now her emotions are all coming out over the cup. Respect them, get on their level, and try understand that their feelings are just as valid as ours.

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 22/02/2023 15:03

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:12

That’s exactly how I feel @bellac11 her level of upset over a cup or whatever is not valid.

Of course it’s valid.

It’s trivial to you, sure, but it’s not trivial to her and you need to respect that.

ReneBumsWombats · 22/02/2023 15:02

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 22/02/2023 14:58

Agree @takealettermsjones the more choice they get to exert that's no skin off your nose, the more willing they are to let you exert your will over theirs when it's something that matters.
Or to put it another way if choice is a normal feature in their life they are less likely to rebel when you really need them not to, like wanting them to wear a seat belt for instance.

Definitely agree with this. My experience of giving my kids choice where possible (green or red bowl etc) has led to them being more accepting of the times I can't give them a choice, not less. They know I give choices where I can, so they realise I've got good reasons when I don't, and it's not because I don't care about what they want.

I don't do "gentle parenting" as a technique, but anything's better than "because I said so".

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 22/02/2023 15:01

Why would you tell her to stop crying? It’s okay to cry.

You don’t have to fix every problem, and trying to will just make it worse. When she has these emotional meltdowns she is too emotionally disregulated to really follow anything you’re saying. So you just want to say as little as possible.

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 22/02/2023 14:58

Agree @takealettermsjones the more choice they get to exert that's no skin off your nose, the more willing they are to let you exert your will over theirs when it's something that matters.
Or to put it another way if choice is a normal feature in their life they are less likely to rebel when you really need them not to, like wanting them to wear a seat belt for instance.

Rinkydinkydoodle · 22/02/2023 14:57

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:11

@Courtorder how would you advise getting a toddler to calm down in a ‘gentle way’. And learn that screaming/ crying going forward is not ok? I feel if I tell her to stop crying I’ll be repressing her feelings.

Depends on the commitment of the toddler to the tantrum but can you make them laugh or otherwise distract them? I do think distraction is an under-employed technique in parenting. DS’s wee rubber dinosaurs used to start fighting and trash-talking when he got into a hairy in the house. Outdoors I’d go for ‘oooh look at that big dog, let’s go and see if he can talk yet’ or whatever. Just some random daft stuff. Change the mood. If it’s a tantrum over nothing (as they tend to be) it’s not invalidating so much as not centring a flip-out too much. Attention goes both ways, so if you present a more appealing alternative they’ll often cut their losses and go for that instead (not offering treats, I don’t mean bribery, which could obviously backfire). I would say this doesn’t always work, I’ve got six kids in my immediate family and it worked with four, two of them were made of sterner stuff😜

QforCucumber · 22/02/2023 14:56

The screaming and tantrumming isn't a conscious choice, we're coming out of the other side with DS2 who will be 3 in a couple of months - the wrong cup example, we would still swap to the right one, and explain that mummy hadn't realised which one you wanted, next time you can choose ok?

He now knows to ask for his water in the green cup or the pokemon cup please, and if i show him it needs washing responds well - instead of me taking the decision out of his hands completely

takealettermsjones · 22/02/2023 14:54

I agree with most PPs, I also give choices all the time. My husband gets a bit annoyed at me because things take longer (e.g. "do you want the yellow cup or the blue cup? Ok. Do you want to sit in the white chair or your red chair?" Etc) but he's also constantly telling me that DD 'behaves' better for me than him. She's the same kid, I just give her control in the little things so she doesn't mind too much when I have to take control over other things. Why make it a battle? If she wants the blue cup, give her the blue cup. In her two years of life she's probably never experienced anything worse than mummy giving her the wrong cup, and it's devastating 😂

Re. managing emotions, I also try to teach coping mechanisms in calm moments. It took a while but I sometimes see her getting upset and then independently putting her hand on her stomach and watching the breaths etc. Afterwards I praise her really specifically, e.g. "I saw that you were upset, and you remembered how to do big breaths to help yourself feel better. I'm really proud of you! Shall we..." etc.

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 22/02/2023 14:53

Sticking with the cup example:

Allowing a child to experience their emotions doesn't mean walking away and letting them crack on with no support. It means holding them and comforting them gently explaining what's happening and how they're feeling.

The goal is that by being present with them they will absorb what you're doing and saying for them and be able to do it for themselves. E.g coming to find you and say "I want to make a drink, Mummy, but I can only find the green cup and I'm sad. Please can you help me look for the red one?"

Changing your mind when a child gets upset doesn't have to mean teaching them that "screaming gets them what they want" either. It could be that when they're calm you say "Hey, I see that it made you really upset when I tried to give you the green cup. Next time, you can just say "Mummy, please could I have the red one?"
Generally, children scream when they haven't actually got the words they need. Give the language to them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread