Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gentle parenting emotions, I don’t understand.

133 replies

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 13:34

Please can someone tell me if I’m getting this wrong, or what the hell im ‘supposed’ to be doing. I don’t get gentle parenting but am trying to see if it helps manage my toddler (2.5yrs) emotional outbursts.

I read a Janet Lansbury post about what to do when a child has a meltdown. She used an example of a child needing a physical outlet for their frustrations and so used to rip up bits of paper. The mum kept stacks of paper ready for the child to rip up to prevent her lashing out physically. The mum thought this was successful and made a comment about how she is the same and uses a baseball bat when she’s frustrated. Now this to me is not emotionally healthy.

my question is - with gentle parenting and acknowledging the emotions and allowing them to flood out, not quietening them, are we just teaching our children that they are entitled to scream and shout when they feel upset?

How do I get my toddler to calm down and quieten down, as if I say ‘calm down’ then I’m repressing her emotions. Does that make sense? What am I missing?

OP posts:
thymee · 23/02/2023 15:58

JustForThisOneTime · 23/02/2023 14:38

Yeah I should have added this to my reply above. It isn't about stopping the tantrum at that moment but about teaching them how to cope with strong emotions.

I just don't think that a toddler is not at a developmental stage where they're going to be able to do what you're asking re the paper ripping.

That's more something I would try to talk to a teenager about, maybe a 9/10 year old.

I sometimes think that 'gentle parenting' demands too much emotional maturity of little kids who are just not capable of it yet. Sometimes kids just have to be left to have a tantrum and then given a cuddle. They don't need to talk it through or understand or reflect - they're too little.

anr70 · 23/02/2023 14:38

Read 'there's no such thing as naughty' by Kate Silverton- really eye opening

JustForThisOneTime · 23/02/2023 14:38

thymee · 23/02/2023 14:10

I think people overcomplicate all of this sometimes.

Toddlers just have tantrums, and sometimes it doesn't matter if you give them a piece of paper to rip up or try to talk to them about their feelings or just let them cry it out. They are going to have that tantrum!

You are not going to get a 2 year old to stop having a tantrum by giving them another 'outlet' like ripping paper.

What's important is that they know you love them whatever, and their feelings are valid (but sometimes their behaviour isn't). That takes a long time to learn for a little kid navigating big feelings. So 'gentle parenting' or whatever, all it really needs is patience.

Yeah I should have added this to my reply above. It isn't about stopping the tantrum at that moment but about teaching them how to cope with strong emotions.

JustForThisOneTime · 23/02/2023 14:36

UWhatNow · 23/02/2023 10:36

Yes of course ripping paper is ok to a point. But if at 2 and 3 you’re validated to think that dramatic and destructive outlets for your overwhelm are ok then, I’m not a psychologist, but that can’t be the best thing.

When my DC were upset and emotional at that age I waited for the storm to be over - I didn’t suppress, but equally I didn’t give it a lot of attention either. I would feign indifference and then when they’d stopped or calmed down I say ‘ok come on now darling, shall we have a cuddle and watch tv? (Or whatever distraction was on hand)’ - I didn’t even acknowledge it or refer to it.

Being a safe adult and understanding that they need to be stroppy or tantrummy is one thing, but you must guide them to move swiftly and safely through it and beyond. Calmness and self regulation is the desired outcome and you have to model that behaviour and mindset yourself.

My point is that ripping paper isn't destructive but it gets out the nervous energy that accompanies an unpleasant feeling. If you feel that ripping paper is destructive then suggest something else like throwing a ball around or dancing or whatever. I don't remember exactly what happens physiologically but it's something like stress causes an increased blood flow to the muscles of your limbs (so that you can react to dsngert, eg by running away) so even if stress is not caused by a physical danger (as in our case it usually isn't) our body still Mobilises it's resources in the same way, which is why we feel physically antsy when we are stressed or experience other negative emotions like anger or frustration. That's why physical movement helps.

I think it also helps teaching that ripping paper (that isn't needed anymore) is not destructive but ripping a board book is. Hitting a pillow is not destructive but hitting a person, animal or damaging something is.

Is it dramatic? Possibly but at that age everything is dramatic for a toddler. I don't think we can expect our toddlers to not act in a way that seems dramatic to us.

I also sometimes ignore it when my children are having a tantrum and depending on the situation I do think sometimes that's the best but I also want them to learn what to do if they can't calm down immediately (which again physiologically is difficult even for adults) and if they do need a physical outlet to help them with that.

thymee · 23/02/2023 14:10

I think people overcomplicate all of this sometimes.

Toddlers just have tantrums, and sometimes it doesn't matter if you give them a piece of paper to rip up or try to talk to them about their feelings or just let them cry it out. They are going to have that tantrum!

You are not going to get a 2 year old to stop having a tantrum by giving them another 'outlet' like ripping paper.

What's important is that they know you love them whatever, and their feelings are valid (but sometimes their behaviour isn't). That takes a long time to learn for a little kid navigating big feelings. So 'gentle parenting' or whatever, all it really needs is patience.

Thepurplelantern · 23/02/2023 14:03

Sorry I haven’t read everything but there are 2 parts to gentle parenting acting as a mirror for your child so they get an accurate and compassionate reflection of their strengths and weaknesses and teaching emotional regulation skills.

Emotional regulation is where again you mirror your child’s emotional state back to them using soothing words, so something like I can see you are frustrated, then you validate and hold space for them to have that emotion even one’s we were brought up to think of as being unacceptable emotions like anger even rage (you dont allow them to act out the emotion in unhealthy ways through behaviour though) and then you help them over the intense phase of the emotion. That can be different for each emotional state and for each child, so one of my kids likes their own space and a conversation when they have cooled down and another prefers hugs in the moment.

It is trial and error both with naming the emotions and the regulation techniques. The idea is that over time they internalise your parental responses and become self actualised and can do these techniques for themselves to process emotions rather than suppressing them.

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 23/02/2023 13:51

UWhatNow · 23/02/2023 10:36

Yes of course ripping paper is ok to a point. But if at 2 and 3 you’re validated to think that dramatic and destructive outlets for your overwhelm are ok then, I’m not a psychologist, but that can’t be the best thing.

When my DC were upset and emotional at that age I waited for the storm to be over - I didn’t suppress, but equally I didn’t give it a lot of attention either. I would feign indifference and then when they’d stopped or calmed down I say ‘ok come on now darling, shall we have a cuddle and watch tv? (Or whatever distraction was on hand)’ - I didn’t even acknowledge it or refer to it.

Being a safe adult and understanding that they need to be stroppy or tantrummy is one thing, but you must guide them to move swiftly and safely through it and beyond. Calmness and self regulation is the desired outcome and you have to model that behaviour and mindset yourself.

Why is ignoring better than suppression? Isn't that giving the message that noone cares if you're upset and you're only worthy of attention when you're happy?

How would you feel if you were upset and frustrated and your partner didn't even try to understand why or let you explain?

And where is the solution for next time? Noone has helped the child understand what happened and why and what they can do next time to quell the overwhelm before it happens.

Everydayimhuffling · 23/02/2023 11:22

If they can tell me what the problem is and I can solve it, then I usually will. So in your example I "can't understand" whining or screaming, but if DC were able to calm down enough to ask for the red cup then I would give it if I could or explain if I couldn't and probably offer a different cup choice. That helps them to understand why screaming and shouting doesn't help. I think you need yo consider exactly what you are trying to teach them. I don't like to have the chipped Bowl DP won't throw away, and would absolutely ask for a different one. Why shouldn't they?

I don't think the paper ripping thing would help, but I'd happily take everyone outside to throw (soft) balls in a box or at the fence if emotions were getting too high. A physical outlet can be useful.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 11:16

Calmness and self regulation is the desired outcome and you have to model that behaviour and mindset yourself.

And that's the crux of it.

UWhatNow · 23/02/2023 10:36

JustForThisOneTime · 23/02/2023 10:07

Ripping paper is ok though if it's paper you don't need, right? Or if you think that paper isn't ok then find something else that is ok. I so think it's important to teach kids to find healthy outlets for their negative emotions. As someone who has spent a lifetime of using unhealthy outlets (self harm, disordered eating, substance abuse, etc) I would like to teach my kids that it's ok to feel the way they are, that emotions don't come down immediately (it takes a finite amount of time for your body to reverse the physical changes it goes through when undergoing a strong emotion) and that's ok too but that we need to learn healthy outlets for them and how to self soothe so that the emotion does not cause hurt, injury or damage to them or anyone else. A part of that journey I hope is that at some point they will learn how to suppress showing their feelings when the situations asks for it.

At this young age though I think suppression isn't the way to go. I think that will come later (earliest by school going age) and is.kaybe easier when they know that when the time and situation is right they can safely show their emotions.

Yes of course ripping paper is ok to a point. But if at 2 and 3 you’re validated to think that dramatic and destructive outlets for your overwhelm are ok then, I’m not a psychologist, but that can’t be the best thing.

When my DC were upset and emotional at that age I waited for the storm to be over - I didn’t suppress, but equally I didn’t give it a lot of attention either. I would feign indifference and then when they’d stopped or calmed down I say ‘ok come on now darling, shall we have a cuddle and watch tv? (Or whatever distraction was on hand)’ - I didn’t even acknowledge it or refer to it.

Being a safe adult and understanding that they need to be stroppy or tantrummy is one thing, but you must guide them to move swiftly and safely through it and beyond. Calmness and self regulation is the desired outcome and you have to model that behaviour and mindset yourself.

MissMaple82 · 23/02/2023 10:26

No, adults have emotions too, it's just children don't understand emotions and become overwhelmed. Thibk about it, when you're emotional, crying for example somone saying stop it is the worst thing they can do. In an emotional state you want compassion amd understanding not judgement and to be told to just basically shut up. Emotions are complex and it's our job as parents to help children manage their emotions appropriately in an understanding and nurturing way.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 10:20

Yes. At a certain point, children are simply too young to learn to regulate. Best thing, I think, is to stay calm yourself so they have the right environment for calming down themselves, and can try to learn from you.

Sometimes you just have to let a tantrum burn itself out. I know how awful it is, I remember my youngest dragging herself across the kitchen floor screaming and wanting to throw myself out of the highest window. But it's a phase. She now can talk about starting to get big feelings and has things she can do to stop them getting so big they overwhelm her (though I'm working on getting her brother to stop winding her up!).

Abouttimemum · 23/02/2023 10:13

She’s 2.5. She has absolutely no clue how to regulate her emotions and won’t until it naturally develops, together with your support.

Imagine being really sad and upset about something and someone comes along and tells you to stop crying. Or if you’re super angry and someone tells yous to calm down.

it’s the same principle. Suppressing is not helpful.

It’s not gentle parenting it’s just basic empathy really.

JustForThisOneTime · 23/02/2023 10:08

I second the recommendation for "how to talk so little kids will listen" and also "why it's ok not to share". Great for practical tips that make a lot of sense (and sometimes work...)

JustForThisOneTime · 23/02/2023 10:07

UWhatNow · 22/02/2023 21:32

This. A child is entitled to feel the way it feels, but self regulation is ultimately what all children (and adults) need to learn. We can’t go through life shouting, screaming and ripping up papers. So teach your child how to meaningfully express their feelings without getting overwrought or destructive.

Ripping paper is ok though if it's paper you don't need, right? Or if you think that paper isn't ok then find something else that is ok. I so think it's important to teach kids to find healthy outlets for their negative emotions. As someone who has spent a lifetime of using unhealthy outlets (self harm, disordered eating, substance abuse, etc) I would like to teach my kids that it's ok to feel the way they are, that emotions don't come down immediately (it takes a finite amount of time for your body to reverse the physical changes it goes through when undergoing a strong emotion) and that's ok too but that we need to learn healthy outlets for them and how to self soothe so that the emotion does not cause hurt, injury or damage to them or anyone else. A part of that journey I hope is that at some point they will learn how to suppress showing their feelings when the situations asks for it.

At this young age though I think suppression isn't the way to go. I think that will come later (earliest by school going age) and is.kaybe easier when they know that when the time and situation is right they can safely show their emotions.

BertieBotts · 23/02/2023 10:05

OK I finally found the post OP was talking about, it's not actually a Janet Lansbury post, and it doesn't refer to a baseball bat but a tennis racquet (which the author later confirms she uses to beat the shit out of a bed - OK.)

It's this (Janet Lansbury had shared it on her page which is why it might have sounded like it came from there) by Anna Banas (never heard of her before)

www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=530870989035077&id=100063365402212

So I clicked through to Anna's page and it is quite typical of some of the newer "gentle parenting influencers" - very wordy, lots of carefully-placed full stops to invoke a slow, breathy, wise kind of tone, and very little actual substance or "what to do" (or even "why I did this"), just lots of "Wow, we need to reflect. Such reflection. Many insight." It makes you FEEL like you're reading something incredibly nuanced and intelligent, but it's actually just crafted bullshit much like the perfect instamum lives, just in word form.

OP look at Dr. Becky instead. She has an annoyingly peppy tone but her advice for "Do this IN the moment, do that OUT of the moment" is gold.

Read How To Talk So Kids Will Listen (or little kids) - it's much better with simple explanations of what to do and not so much waffle about self reflection.

Try No Drama Discipline - again a lot of "what to do" and some theory behind it, but not waffling on forever, just the info that is relevant.

Listen to some of Janet's actual own podcasts - there are some wordy no-substance ones, but there are some really brilliant and helpful ones.

If you DO want some self-reflection, there is an amazing book "When Your Kds Push Your Buttons" which is actually useful and has exercises etc to fill in.

JustForThisOneTime · 23/02/2023 10:00

I think the emotions need to come out somehow and they usually will. You are just showing them a healthier outlet for them. When they can quickly let our their negative feelings hopefully it will help them calm down sooner. In theory I think that is great.

In reality, I have tried this for years and not once has my child gone for the "healthier" option". I think in particular when they are angry or frustrated often that anger is directed at you so they actually do want to do something that impacts you (hurts you or shows you their defiance). Maybe I'm doing something wrong.

As they get older though it might be something that they will find helpful.
Having said that, yesterday, I'd promised my DD an ice cream from the ice cream van but asked her to wait till her friend had left so the friend didn't feel bad (her mum had said no an ice cream). By the time the friend left the ice cream van had left too. DD was super disappointed, cried and said it's my fault (which it was). I told her yes, that was totally my fault and I was really sorry and few minutes later she calmed down and we were able discuss alternatives. I have also realised that with age she is calming down quicker and quicker. I was actually really proud of her yesterday. So maybe those years of (mostly) being understanding about her strong emotions have made a difference somehow.

Maybe kids also struggle to calm down quickly because they believe that if they do calm down too quickly then we don't get fully how upset they really are and they want to feel understood.

Feetupteashot · 23/02/2023 09:46

Part of gentle parenting is recognizing that children of different developmental ages are capable of different things. So toddlers do not have a well developed frontal lobe of their brain and there is bi point e.g. telling them to pull themselves together. They just cannot!

Not sure about ripping paper. Gentle parenting might be more like naming an emotion, maintaining clear boundaries. It is not the same as permissive parenting.

The way I understand it is helping children to do things due to their own internal motivation, rather than out of fear of being shouted at or shamed. This tends to create more fulfilled balanced adults

A better explanation here sarahockwell-smith.com/2015/08/20/what-is-gentle-parenting-and-why-should-you-try-it/

SparkyBlue · 23/02/2023 09:15

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:11

@Courtorder how would you advise getting a toddler to calm down in a ‘gentle way’. And learn that screaming/ crying going forward is not ok? I feel if I tell her to stop crying I’ll be repressing her feelings.

Honestly sometimes you just have to accept it's their age. They will be fine and all delighted with life again in ten minutes. Stick the kettle on and take a few deep breaths. No point in getting overly stressed about it. My almost 11 year old is now in the stroppy sulky phase now as well so just when you are finished one phase another one begins. I always validate their feelings and try to be empathetic to them. I also have one child with asd and I agree with you OP I wouldn't like the paper thing either unless there were additional needs and it was the child's way of regulating but otherwise it just encourages destructive behaviour.

UWhatNow · 22/02/2023 21:32

Courtorder · 22/02/2023 14:08

The message is two-fold:

  1. Your emotions are valid
  2. There are appropriate and inappropriate ways to express those emotions

Far too often, people think that “gentle parenting” means allowing your child to behave however they wish, but it’s not. Screaming and shouting is, almost always, an unacceptable outlet for an emotion - that doesn’t mean the pain/anger/sadness/fear isn’t a valid emotion, it just means you need an appropriate way to handle that emotion. What’s “acceptable” varies from parent to parent, child to child, family to family so you choose for your family. Some parents would have no issue with tearing paper as an outlet, some would.

This. A child is entitled to feel the way it feels, but self regulation is ultimately what all children (and adults) need to learn. We can’t go through life shouting, screaming and ripping up papers. So teach your child how to meaningfully express their feelings without getting overwrought or destructive.

Gloriousgardener11 · 22/02/2023 17:07

There's a book called 'The Colour Monster' by Anna Llenas that is really good to share with children.
It explores emotions using different colours and helps children identify how they feel by colour.
It's used a lot in schools.

girlfrombackthen · 22/02/2023 17:05

Also based on attachment research, the 'Circle of Security' offers a really succinct explanation of why 'being with' our children's emotions (whatever they are feeling) is important:

vimeo.com/145329119

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 22/02/2023 17:02

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:11

@Courtorder how would you advise getting a toddler to calm down in a ‘gentle way’. And learn that screaming/ crying going forward is not ok? I feel if I tell her to stop crying I’ll be repressing her feelings.

But crying IS okay going forwards. Do you never cry when upset?

Just because she's crying about something that doesn't or wouldn't bother you doesn't mean she isn't distressed.

How would you calm your child if she was hurt or upset by something you deemed worthy of being upset over? That's how you calm her.

And then once she's calm, give her the language you'd like her to use next time. "You got really sad there. You wanted the red cup. Next time, you can say "please can I have the red cup instead?"

girlfrombackthen · 22/02/2023 16:57

Hi OP

I think 'gentle parenting' is often misconstrued - I find it more helpful to think of this approach as 'respectful parenting' and the starting point is personhood: it may sound obvious, but your baby/toddler/child is a person and should be treated as such. As somebody says above, we would be unlikely to say "don't be silly" to a frustrated adult colleague, and I don't know Ny adult who would calm down after being instructed to "calm down"

A child's response to a broken banana/ a dropped biscuit/ the wrong cup being given to them is of course completely disproportionate to an adult onlooker but I would argue that the feeling is always valid. Very young children are not able to regulate their emotions themselves - they need adult support to help them with this. (Look up "The Whole Brain Child" by Dan Siegel - he offers helpful explanations for what is happening in the infant/child brain when overwhelmed by strong emotions).

With this in mind I would accept that a very young child will scream and shout and cry when they get upset - this is completely "normal" for their age and stage of brain development. My understanding of what Janet Lansbury suggests is that parents 'lean in' to the big emotion but set limits e.g. "I know you are disappointed but I won't allow you to hit me". Of course there is a social learning aspect to this - so where possible I would remove my tantruming child from a room full of people, and allow them to scream/shout in a safe space. I want my children to grow up knowing that any feeling is permitted, but to recognise their are boundaries: the world cannot stop because a child has a feeling (Janet Lansbury's idea of 'confident momentum' is brilliant here!).

Keha · 22/02/2023 16:42

@CupEmpty

Sorry if you've answered this but what are you wanting/hoping she will do? At 2.5 I don't particularly try and stop tantrums about things that aren't risky or harmful. Eg if she wants a biscuit and I say no and she gets upset, demands its, stampa feet etc I just tell her I understand she is upset about it but she can't have it or try and move on/distract a bit. I wouldn't tell her to shut up or stop crying or particularly except her to do those things. Usually she moves on after 5/10 mins. I would get down on her level, give her a hug if she seems to want one and empathise a bit. I don't know if this is "gentle parenting" or not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread