Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gentle parenting emotions, I don’t understand.

133 replies

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 13:34

Please can someone tell me if I’m getting this wrong, or what the hell im ‘supposed’ to be doing. I don’t get gentle parenting but am trying to see if it helps manage my toddler (2.5yrs) emotional outbursts.

I read a Janet Lansbury post about what to do when a child has a meltdown. She used an example of a child needing a physical outlet for their frustrations and so used to rip up bits of paper. The mum kept stacks of paper ready for the child to rip up to prevent her lashing out physically. The mum thought this was successful and made a comment about how she is the same and uses a baseball bat when she’s frustrated. Now this to me is not emotionally healthy.

my question is - with gentle parenting and acknowledging the emotions and allowing them to flood out, not quietening them, are we just teaching our children that they are entitled to scream and shout when they feel upset?

How do I get my toddler to calm down and quieten down, as if I say ‘calm down’ then I’m repressing her emotions. Does that make sense? What am I missing?

OP posts:
Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 27/02/2023 09:04

You acknowledge what they feel and you assure them it’s valid. Then with time you’ll discover outlets together. Mine is an anger-biter. It’s ridiculous sometimes 😂
But imagine, you as an adult, can you “calm down” if people are telling you? Surely not.
We learn to walk away, take a deep breath, count to ten and manage our emotions in a healthy way. This is what we teach our toddlers too. We also teach that emotions are very normal. It’s okay to feel sad/angry/disappointed.
Some parents mix up gentle parenting with letting the child do whatever they want to the child doesn’t scream. That’s not ideal.
I usually let my DD express her emotions, we will then talk about how we feel and I try and help her navigate it. It’s hard. But I think it helps my sanity too 😊

Houseofpainjumparound · 27/02/2023 09:01

I haven't read through the replies but I am with you op I have not worked out how to allow the child to have an emotion without enforcing the action as being right...

We have the "thinking step" when things get out of hand, it is the stairs but they have to sit quietly and calm down until I get back and then we talk about what happened and how the behaviour could have been better or what the problem was and how to fix it and sometimes the answer is in a round about way "that's life kiddo" (but explained better) sometimes their sibling doesn't want to play and that's OK.... sometimes they can't have the cup they want, the seat they want etc etc but that's OK too because there may be something better..

I try to reinforce the positives but I struggle with that sometimes which I am sure rubs off on my kids....

I am probably doing it wrong too and I will find out the harsh reality of my parenting when they are teenagers and adults. For now when in public they are generally good kids and let off their emotions at home where they are safe to do so so I will consider that a win

Manthide · 27/02/2023 08:16

murmuration · 22/02/2023 14:19

That’s exactly how I feel @bellac11 her level of upset over a cup or whatever is not valid.

But for a toddler, it might be valid. (I still remember the helium balloon I lost 4 years old. I was devastated... nothing my parents could do would help, but I realise now it was my first experience of grief - yeah, over a balloon - so it was something that needed to be felt before I could put actual problems into perspective)

Something I found sometimes worked is to ask "Is this a small, medium, or big upset?" Then gentle logic, as everything is 'big', to relate things - "oh, so this no worse than when you dropped your sandwhich yesterday" 'MUCH WORSE!!' "so that was a medium upset and this a big one; we'll remember that" Eventually she would actually identify some things as 'small' or 'medium' upsets, and calm herself down.

You're not my dd1 are you? She lost a helium balloon when she was 4 (now 31) and she was completely hysterical. Totally spoilt the day for everyone- and I've never bought a helium balloon since! I probably didn't handle it the best, I tended just to let her get with it or if she threw herself on the floor and wouldn't move I'd carry on a little until she realised I wasn't reacting. Never has that many tantrums with my other 3 so not sure if I got better at nipping them in the bud or what!

MeinKraft · 24/02/2023 14:32

Pressed send too soon! Yes I do think they know much more than people credit them with. Which is why when they want a second helping of cake I just say no, because they know you can't eat cake until you're ill. We have been over it all before.

MeinKraft · 24/02/2023 14:31

CarmenBizet · 24/02/2023 13:58

I think people woefully misunderstand what toddlers are capable of.

Obviously there are differences in development level/stage between children, but on the whole there’s no reason to presume a two/three year old can’t understand reasoning or understand emotions.

my kid is three and since 2.5yr has been able to name his emotions, predict them, guess what others might be feeling, reacts far better to a ‘no’ when I briefly explain the reason: ‘biscuits aren’t foods we eat all day long, we’ve had two today! We’re having an apple now’. A ‘no’ ‘why?’ ‘Just no’ would feel awful, we’d hate that as adults so why do we expect toddlers to tolerate that cheerfully?

Yeah certainly explain your reasoning simply and in ways your child can understand. But, occasionally, no is a complete sentence. Because sometimes your toddler will ask you to repeat your reasoning multiple times. Or sometimes they won't accept that you just don't want to do something. And sometimes they should just know why it's a no. I do think young children know much

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 24/02/2023 14:05

Moonicorn · 24/02/2023 14:01

Even so, they will still tell her ‘no’. And she isn’t ready to hear that.

Actually the majority of primary schools follow the same techniques so I don’t foresee it being an issue at all as it isn’t likely to come up 😊

ItsCalledAConversation · 24/02/2023 14:02

I’ve been validating my DS’s emotions since he was tiny, he’s now 7 and screams the house down for tiny tiny hurts. Not sure what to do about this without gently explaining that people think he’s being murdered when he’s barely got a scratch!

Moonicorn · 24/02/2023 14:01

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 23/02/2023 18:15

Not really. She has boundaries and follows rules, and she’ll be older then. Children are very adaptable.

Even so, they will still tell her ‘no’. And she isn’t ready to hear that.

CarmenBizet · 24/02/2023 13:58

I think people woefully misunderstand what toddlers are capable of.

Obviously there are differences in development level/stage between children, but on the whole there’s no reason to presume a two/three year old can’t understand reasoning or understand emotions.

my kid is three and since 2.5yr has been able to name his emotions, predict them, guess what others might be feeling, reacts far better to a ‘no’ when I briefly explain the reason: ‘biscuits aren’t foods we eat all day long, we’ve had two today! We’re having an apple now’. A ‘no’ ‘why?’ ‘Just no’ would feel awful, we’d hate that as adults so why do we expect toddlers to tolerate that cheerfully?

Mardyface · 23/02/2023 18:18

It always helped me to think that a tantrum is something that happens TO little kids not something they're doing. I'm not a 'gentle parenter' or any other 'kind' especially but it seems to me that if screaming and shouting is an outward expression of inner feelings those feelings must be pretty big and scary even if you think the situation doesn't warrant them.

My mum always used to say 'never mind' when I was upset but I DID mind and it was OK to mind. Screaming and shouting to get what you want is not ok but what's wrong with screaming and shouting because you're devastated about not getting what you want (or whatever is really the matter) when you're two and are just realising you're not the only human in the world? Feeling devastated is horrible!

3ormorecharacters · 23/02/2023 18:18

I think a lot of what people misunderstand about the Janet Lansbury style of parenting is that the tantrum management part is only really the tip of the iceberg. It's really about your relationship with your child, building connection with them. When you get that right, you can avoid lots of tantrums altogether - and prevention is much better than cure.

I think a lot of people get really hung up on the negative part of behaviour management - "showing them who's boss", "not letting them get away with things", "not giving in" etc. When we relax about all that see our children as people in their own rights, treating and speaking to them respectfully, then tantrums are far less frequent and when they do happen can be managed much more calmly.

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 23/02/2023 18:15

Moonicorn · 23/02/2023 18:12

I pretty much never say the word no to her because I find that word isn’t of any use.

Shes in for a shock when she starts school.

Not really. She has boundaries and follows rules, and she’ll be older then. Children are very adaptable.

Moonicorn · 23/02/2023 18:12

I pretty much never say the word no to her because I find that word isn’t of any use.

Shes in for a shock when she starts school.

thymee · 23/02/2023 17:54

@FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks I guess it depends on the child as to their understanding, but I have seen this approach used several times with children who just clearly were not able to follow the complexities of what their parent was trying to say, and it didn't work.

I think really empathy is the most important thing and having a good knowledge of child development/ what your child is actually capable of doing and understanding at any given age.

I have seen parents place demands on their children to be introspective, understand and reflect on their behaviour and emotions which was way beyond their cognitive ability, in the name of 'gentle parenting'. I think that is actually quite harmful.

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 23/02/2023 17:44

They also have to learn to hear 'no' and a neutral no at that. Not an angry shouting no, and not a 'I'm so sorry baby but mummy can't give you the banana right now because we are in the shop and we have to pay for it first, as soon as we get to the till you can have it ok?' That's just too many words for a toddler and they'll lose their shit. When you hear BANANAAAAA just offer a cheerful 'no' and continue about your business.

@MeinKraft I wholly disagree with this! This is exactly what works with my toddler and pretty much exactly what I say, though I generally don’t apologise.

So for example we were in the pram on the way to meet daddy in town. She’s not a big pram fan anyway. Half way there she starts trying to get out saying “out out mummy see daddy” and crying. I said “we have to stay in the pram right now but when we see daddy then we can get out”. She understood and sat nicely.

If we are buying a toy and she gets upset because she wants to play with it and open it straight away I’ll explain in similar words that we have to pay for it.

She’s 2. They have a lot more understanding than people give them credit for and as such we rarely have tantrums and she is impeccably well behaved.

She has consistent, healthy boundaries yet I pretty much never say the word no to her because I find that word isn’t of any use. Instead I tell her what to do, not what not to do. I don’t give unwanted behaviours any attention at all.

DidyouNO · 23/02/2023 17:09

Try reading up on Therapeutic parenting, we use this method for our foster children and our birth children. Sarah Naish had a couple of brilliant books. It started as a very specific form of parenting for children after abuse and trauma who need very clear boundaries and guidelines, they need routine and set reactions. In a 'normal' child this is also invaluable as it stops any uncertainty they may feel this leading to frustrations

BertieBotts · 23/02/2023 16:51

@Squidsink I had the same question so I went and searched on all Janet's website and then her social media pages. Found the post - see my comment at 10:05 today.

Squidsink · 23/02/2023 16:33

I’d be interested to see the Janet Lansbury post—I’ve been following her advice for years and the ripping paper thing doesn’t sound like something she’d recommend—perhaps she was responding to someone else’s suggestion. She tends to suggest recognising the child’s feelings rather than diverting them. Eg “I’m sorry I can’t let you do that. Yes, you’re feeling really upset about that.” Also I wouldn’t say she’s gentle parenting as such, so perhaps that’s where confusion is coming from—rather, she’s always recommending being firm on boundaries but in a way that’s calm, unrattled and stable for the child, while allowing and being able to deal with their feelings without losing your cool (sometimes hard to do!).

thymee · 23/02/2023 16:26

They also have to learn to hear 'no' and a neutral no at that. Not an angry shouting no, and not a 'I'm so sorry baby but mummy can't give you the banana right now because we are in the shop and we have to pay for it first, as soon as we get to the till you can have it ok?' That's just too many words for a toddler and they'll lose their shit. When you hear BANANAAAAA just offer a cheerful 'no' and continue about your business.

@MeinKraft Yes, exactly!

This is what bugs me about some of the gentle parenting approaches I have seen my friends doing.

There is way too much explaining and 2/3 year olds just do not have the comprehension skills for it. You can see them just getting more distressed as mummy is explaining in a whiney emotional voice how hard life must be for them but she understands and it's all going to be OK.

It's so bloody intense and it all becomes even more overwhelming and complicated!

Of course recognising emotions is important, but sometimes, kids just need things to be simple so that they can move on.

Moonicorn · 23/02/2023 16:23

@MeinKraft put it better than I ever could!

MeinKraft · 23/02/2023 16:21

thymee · 23/02/2023 14:10

I think people overcomplicate all of this sometimes.

Toddlers just have tantrums, and sometimes it doesn't matter if you give them a piece of paper to rip up or try to talk to them about their feelings or just let them cry it out. They are going to have that tantrum!

You are not going to get a 2 year old to stop having a tantrum by giving them another 'outlet' like ripping paper.

What's important is that they know you love them whatever, and their feelings are valid (but sometimes their behaviour isn't). That takes a long time to learn for a little kid navigating big feelings. So 'gentle parenting' or whatever, all it really needs is patience.

Yep. Stop panicking about doing things right or wrong. Let them tantrum for a bit, stay calm, give them a hug when they come round. Explain that you know they're upset because they wanted the yellow cup but they've got the blue cup and that's just the way it is. If they still don't want the blue cup then fine, they can have a drink in an hours time or whatever.

Toddlers just tantrum, it's what they do. The only way to avoid tantrums is to head them off at the pass - don't let them get too tired, hungry or overwhelmed. The reason tantrums often happen when we are out with them is it's just all too much for them.

They also have to learn to hear 'no' and a neutral no at that. Not an angry shouting no, and not a 'I'm so sorry baby but mummy can't give you the banana right now because we are in the shop and we have to pay for it first, as soon as we get to the till you can have it ok?' That's just too many words for a toddler and they'll lose their shit. When you hear BANANAAAAA just offer a cheerful 'no' and continue about your business.

Moonicorn · 23/02/2023 16:19

Say they had a tantrum because their drink is in the red cup instead of the orange cup, gently suggest that next time they can just ask me with words so that they can have their drink how they like it.

What if the orange cup is in the wash? I don’t really think parents should be dictated to on this level by toddlers if I’m honest. DD asks for a drink, I get her one. I won’t be pandering to cup
colours.

Moonicorn · 23/02/2023 16:18

I actually don’t think it’s healthy or acceptable to ‘let all your feelings out’. I think it’s quite a self centred way to live, to treat those around you as shock absorbers who just have to tolerate and absorb whatever screaming/shouting/crying you feel like doing because ‘that’s how I feel’.

Toddlers of course cannot be held to this standard but equally ‘gentle parenting’ and the like seems to treat them as small adults, expecting them to be introspective and identify more complicated secondary feelings which they don’t even really understand.

If DD is screaming and angry because she wasn’t allowed a slice of cake before dinner, I’ll firmly tell her that we can’t have pudding before dinner and that’s that. I’ll then ignore her and let her thrash around, telling her I’m there when she’s calmed down and wants a cuddle, but that she won’t get what she wants. I don’t shout at, smack or negotiate with her, I’m calm but firm and don’t let her ‘rattle’ me.

If she’s upset because of a ‘justified’ reason like another child has pushed her over, then of course it’s all cuddles and making sure she’s okay.

But she’s far too young for ‘feelings chat’ at 3.

PeekAtYou · 23/02/2023 16:08

I let them tantrum then when there's a lull in the shouting, I offer a hug. This often defused things extra quick. I think it's important to feel the full range of human feelings and if you parent in a way that constantly avoids difficult emotions then the child is going to struggle when they aren't with you. Their peers aren't usually going to adjust their actions because they want to prioritize their own feelings.

Then when they are totally calm, it's worth having a conversation about things and a suggestion about how they can deal with things next time. Say they had a tantrum because their drink is in the red cup instead of the orange cup, gently suggest that next time they can just ask me with words so that they can have their drink how they like it. It won't always work and sometimes there isn't a solution to their gripe but they will eventually understand that asking for the orange cup is a lot less hassle for them too.

thymee · 23/02/2023 15:59

Sorry double negative - should have said 'I just don't think that a toddler is at a developmental stage...'

Swipe left for the next trending thread