Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gentle parenting emotions, I don’t understand.

133 replies

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 13:34

Please can someone tell me if I’m getting this wrong, or what the hell im ‘supposed’ to be doing. I don’t get gentle parenting but am trying to see if it helps manage my toddler (2.5yrs) emotional outbursts.

I read a Janet Lansbury post about what to do when a child has a meltdown. She used an example of a child needing a physical outlet for their frustrations and so used to rip up bits of paper. The mum kept stacks of paper ready for the child to rip up to prevent her lashing out physically. The mum thought this was successful and made a comment about how she is the same and uses a baseball bat when she’s frustrated. Now this to me is not emotionally healthy.

my question is - with gentle parenting and acknowledging the emotions and allowing them to flood out, not quietening them, are we just teaching our children that they are entitled to scream and shout when they feel upset?

How do I get my toddler to calm down and quieten down, as if I say ‘calm down’ then I’m repressing her emotions. Does that make sense? What am I missing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AliasGrape · 27/02/2023 16:33

@ReneBumsWombats

Yes agree.

There's a sense from some posts of 'well I won't be validating such silly feelings', and maybe I sometimes felt that myself, but really it's about acknowledging the feeling/ emotion - it's there and they're feeling it whether you want to name it or not. I don't think ignoring it, or teaching them they have to ignore it is particularly helpful either.

MeinKraft · 27/02/2023 16:22

CupEmpty · 27/02/2023 12:31

I really appreciate all the replies and am re reading them again slowly to try and understand more. I’m still feeling a bit lost and stuck. I’m genuinely not being rude but I feel like a lot of posters don’t understand what it’s like to have a child like mine. I see what other children are like and some are much easier. To the PP who says she explains things and her toddler just listens and accepts them, you’re lucky. Yes I’m sure you feel it’s your excellent responsive parenting and you’ve put in the ground work but my toddler is just on a different level. She loses it, she’s beside herself and you can’t get through to her. I’ve tried distraction, preemptive measures etc. it’s not about hearing the word ‘no’, it’s like she is so over emotional she can’t cope with life. I think some children are easier than others but some parents don’t have the humility to understand that.

Yeah my first child was like that, he could have brought the roof down at times in his temper. His frustration stemmed from a speech and language delay and the how to talk so kids will listen thing just didn't work with him because he didn't have the receptive language to understand. So I read Jo Frosts confident toddler care and used the very unfashionable techniques in that. There was much less shouting from both of us after that - we needed it to establish proper boundaries.

ReneBumsWombats · 27/02/2023 16:13

AliasGrape · 27/02/2023 15:58

I have mixed feelings about the How to talk so little kids will listen book - I rolled my eyes a lot listening to it on audible and admit to muttering ‘yep sure that happened’ at all the ‘real life examples’ they shared.

But I have to say quite a few of the strategies they talk about have really worked here.

One is ‘giving in fantasy what you can’t give in reality’ - so when my 2.5 year old wanted the peppa pig fancy dress outfit in Sainsbury’s I found myself saying ‘I know, we’ll make
a list of all the things you would like, mummy will write it down’ then going around the shop talked about what else was going on ‘the list’ - sparkly hair clips, chocolate, a bottle of fabric softener (?). Weirdly it worked really well, and now I just say ‘yeah wow that looks really good shall we put it on the list’ and she’s perfectly happy
with that (there is no actual physical list at this point but maybe that will have to happen at some stage).

Also ‘I know you want the purple cup, It’s so annoying! I wish all the cups were purple, I wish the whole kitchen was purple, I wish YOU were pink and I was purple and ….’ - totally headed off a tantrum and she spent the next however long happily coming up with things that should be purple.

The other one that’s working here is framing it as ‘the problem is …’
I know you really want an ice lolly, the problem is we don’t have any.
I know you want the blue cup, the problem is it’s in the dishwasher.
I know you want to keep playing, the problem is it’s bath time.

Dont know why - she just seems to respond better when it’s put that way. It’s not foolproof but has helped.

They’re no use for the big, full on melt downs which do also happen sometimes, but they seem to divert them at least most of the time.

It's because you're validating her feelings an making her feel heard.

Validating feelings doesn't mean always giving in to them, or not learning to control them. It means acknowledging them and accepting that they are real. What better starting point for learning to manage them?

AliasGrape · 27/02/2023 15:58

I have mixed feelings about the How to talk so little kids will listen book - I rolled my eyes a lot listening to it on audible and admit to muttering ‘yep sure that happened’ at all the ‘real life examples’ they shared.

But I have to say quite a few of the strategies they talk about have really worked here.

One is ‘giving in fantasy what you can’t give in reality’ - so when my 2.5 year old wanted the peppa pig fancy dress outfit in Sainsbury’s I found myself saying ‘I know, we’ll make
a list of all the things you would like, mummy will write it down’ then going around the shop talked about what else was going on ‘the list’ - sparkly hair clips, chocolate, a bottle of fabric softener (?). Weirdly it worked really well, and now I just say ‘yeah wow that looks really good shall we put it on the list’ and she’s perfectly happy
with that (there is no actual physical list at this point but maybe that will have to happen at some stage).

Also ‘I know you want the purple cup, It’s so annoying! I wish all the cups were purple, I wish the whole kitchen was purple, I wish YOU were pink and I was purple and ….’ - totally headed off a tantrum and she spent the next however long happily coming up with things that should be purple.

The other one that’s working here is framing it as ‘the problem is …’
I know you really want an ice lolly, the problem is we don’t have any.
I know you want the blue cup, the problem is it’s in the dishwasher.
I know you want to keep playing, the problem is it’s bath time.

Dont know why - she just seems to respond better when it’s put that way. It’s not foolproof but has helped.

They’re no use for the big, full on melt downs which do also happen sometimes, but they seem to divert them at least most of the time.

CarmenBizet · 27/02/2023 14:23

LivingDeadGirlUK · 27/02/2023 13:48

So much of gentle parenting is just having realistic ideas about child development and what children are emotionally capable of as they grow. Babies cry when they need anything because its all they are able to do. A 2.5 year old is still developing speech and figuring out how to express their needs in ways other than just crying, its normal for them to have emotional outbursts.

DC (3) has been going through a rough time lately with a lot of intense emotions, tantrums, big feelings etc. we've had some of those days where it just feels impossible because everything is wrong, he's so upset, and it's so challenging.

One thing I found helps is almost letting go of the content of his words when he's in a 'can't win' mood (for example he's crying because I cut his toast and he didn't want me to but then I give him a fresh piece so I can eat the cut toast and he wants the cut toast back but wants it back in one piece which obviously can't be done etc.) and kinda visualise him as a tiny baby crying instead. Which is really what's happening, they're still so young even though they look so old! He's essentially crying to let his emotions out and convey a need so I try let go of the impossible requests and just focus on being a calming presence for him and soothing him while he moves through it. It actually really does help.

Choconut · 27/02/2023 14:09

I agree with a lot of gentle parenting but I don't agree with validating all feelings. I am not going to validate my child having a complete meltdown because he can't have ice cream for breakfast or because he wants a blue cup and we don't own one. I wouldn't be having them ripping up paper or using a baseball bat either. To me that all suggests serious emotional dysregulation - but there might be something behind that ADHD, ASD, etc

I'd handle it by saying 'we don't have a blue cup but you can have it in the red cup when you're ready.' Then carry on with jobs until they've calmed down and are ready for the red cup. Having a tantrum gets boring very quickly when it doesn't get you anywhere or any attention I always found with mine.

If we were out I'd just leave and take them home, no fuss, they're probably tired/hungry/just having a bad day, but I don't need to hug them over it once they calm down. Explaining why something can't or won't be happening helps though sometimes I've found, ie 'you can't have a blue cup because we don't have any'. Also there are lots of things that can work better than a straight no if they struggle with that - 'we can't have icecream for breakfast be we can have some after dinner tomorrow' for example.

mumonherphone · 27/02/2023 13:52

If a situation accelerates into a tantrum, my gut feeling is that my child is experiencing distress and in that moment needs my help to calm down. When he is calm we can talk about what happened and I will sometimes ask him to say sorry (not for the tantrum itself but for whatever led up to it) Not sure if that's gentle parenting, I'm just winging it mostly without following a specific parenting style.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 27/02/2023 13:48

So much of gentle parenting is just having realistic ideas about child development and what children are emotionally capable of as they grow. Babies cry when they need anything because its all they are able to do. A 2.5 year old is still developing speech and figuring out how to express their needs in ways other than just crying, its normal for them to have emotional outbursts.

dolly12345 · 27/02/2023 13:45

I have two like this. My 20 month old literally cried for an hour yesterday. I just think, "well, he must need to."

dolly12345 · 27/02/2023 13:43

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 22/02/2023 14:31

So I was having the worst time with my toddler and I totally flipped my parenting style for him. Honestly he would meet shouting with shouting, didn't give a flying fuck about any punishment... Whereas my first kid was really good at regulating their emotions, my second really had to learn the skill.

I took a parenting class that basically said, kids are small humans. Humans need empathy and understanding when they display their emotions. Small humans need to be taught the boundaries that are acceptable in order to regulate these emotions.

So, say my kid was having a tantrum about wanting chocolate cake? I'd empathise and reflect their emotions back to them....

"Yes you do want the cake". "I understand you want the cake, the cake is yummy, I want the cake too". "You feel cross because we can't eat the cake", "The cake does look good. We can eat it at specific time. We can have an apple or a cracker now if our tummies are feeling hungry". "You feel worried you're going to miss out on cake".

You're validating their feelings of anger/FOMO/wanting without breaking your boundary of "cake is for later". You're understanding them rather than telling them they're being a baby or whatever. It's so important- their big feelings are BIG.

Retaliates with a hit or throwing something? "Buddy it's not ok to hurt others or break things. If you need to work through it, on the thinking step and play with your calm jar, or go to your room and throw socks at the target. Let me know when you're ready for a hug".

It's a longer road than a bollocking or whatever, but I now have a 4 year old who is emotionally literate and really trusts that I am listening to him when he tells me something important.

Love this

dolly12345 · 27/02/2023 13:19

CupEmpty · 22/02/2023 14:01

I get it with hitting etc as it’s a clear boundary but hers are emotional meltdowns, that’s what I’m trying to deal with. She gets very very upset/ hysterical, over little things. So there’s no boundary to hold, if that makes sense .I do already follow big little feelings, it’s mentioned to death on here but to be honest I don’t get the hype.

You answered your own question. "There's no boundary to hold." So you don't need to do anything. You let the child meltdown and then they stop.

It's developmentally inappropriate to expect a small child to be able to process their feelings like an adult. Things do feel like a massive deal to small people - allowing them to feel and move through their huge feelings won't make them unable to handle feelings as adults. Maturity takes care of this problem - as we age, we handle our feelings better because our brains mature. Stopping a child from expressing their developmentally appropriate feelings just interferes with this natural process of maturity, imo, although obviously we must keep people and property safe. Try raisinghumanskind on Instagram.

I think meltdowns are brilliant - controversial opinion! If you let your child have a good long meltdown (and really fully allow it) they will be so much more regulated afterwards.

bussteward · 27/02/2023 12:55

She loses it, she’s beside herself and you can’t get through to her.
This sounds so normal. I think, at least with DD, there are two levels of tantrum: one is just common or garden “being an arsehole” where I can head it off at the pass by being silly – “Oh, no! The blue cup is in the dishwasher. Nee-nar nee-nar, emergency orange cup incoming” (yes you feel ridiculous) – but then also next-level emotional breakdown where she is just in pieces and, like you say, can’t be reasoned with or communicated with. Obviously “calm down” isn’t going to work here, and nor is silliness. All you can do is stop them hurting themselves as they hurl themselves about - which is why I like DD’s bed or mine as a safe space for big feelings, and be there when it ends to help them through feeling shaky afterwards.

I really recommend the books Barbara Throws a Wobbler, and My Big Shouting Day, for talking about tantrums: the wobbler book is more about those all-encompassing, beside herself tantrums, while the shouting one is more about the generic arsehole toddler moments.

Curiosity101 · 27/02/2023 12:52

@CupEmpty Your describing my DS there. Down to the fact that offering him acceptable choices wasn't enough, he knew what he wanted and no amount of 'little' decisions giving him power ever seemed to help. If he had huge meltdowns he'd just get angrier and angrier if I stayed with him and used any of the techniques. To the point we realised that actually leaving him somewhere safe, sometimes that would be putting him in his room, on his own was actually the right thing for him. We always remained calm, always went through the explanation of feelings, what to do next time etc. But he was a very explosive very inflexible and opinionated toddler. He takes after me. He's getting better as he gets older. As an aside I'm suspected to have ASD and ADHD (I've not requested an assessment yet) but he really is very similar to me in lots of ways.

Anyways - I thoroughly recommend "The Explosive Child"

I wouldn't say gentle parenting won't work for your daughter. Only that every child is different and there's no one rule / manual that works perfectly for all of them. You have to piece bits together and adjust as you go.

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 27/02/2023 12:42

She loses it, she’s beside herself and you can’t get through to her.

So does my toddler sometimes. They all do.

However well behaved a toddler is, when they have a tantrum, as they all do, they are incapable of listening to you or being distracted etc because their brain is too disregulated. That part of the brain has literally shut down.

So you need to coregulate. It’s not your job to fix it. You sit with her until she’s ridden it out. Try rubbing her back, breathing techniques or just leaving her to it quietly while you sit with her. It’s okay for her to cry, even in public.

Only when the tantrum has truly passed are you able to explain and talk to her.

JenniferBarkley · 27/02/2023 12:34

Mine aren't too bad on the tantrum front OP (don't get me wrong, could cheerfully string them up at times) but I feel the same about sleep. Ohhh, a bedtime routine, if only I'd thought of that. Grin

CupEmpty · 27/02/2023 12:31

I really appreciate all the replies and am re reading them again slowly to try and understand more. I’m still feeling a bit lost and stuck. I’m genuinely not being rude but I feel like a lot of posters don’t understand what it’s like to have a child like mine. I see what other children are like and some are much easier. To the PP who says she explains things and her toddler just listens and accepts them, you’re lucky. Yes I’m sure you feel it’s your excellent responsive parenting and you’ve put in the ground work but my toddler is just on a different level. She loses it, she’s beside herself and you can’t get through to her. I’ve tried distraction, preemptive measures etc. it’s not about hearing the word ‘no’, it’s like she is so over emotional she can’t cope with life. I think some children are easier than others but some parents don’t have the humility to understand that.

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 27/02/2023 12:21

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 27/02/2023 10:11

My baby hasn’t reached tantrum age yet, but I’ll be ignoring if she does have tantrums. She certainly won’t be given any paper to rip up or a cuddle when she’s done. What a load of nonsense.

That's the second time today that I've seen a glorious combination of username and post content.

ItsCalledAConversation · 27/02/2023 12:16

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 27/02/2023 10:11

My baby hasn’t reached tantrum age yet, but I’ll be ignoring if she does have tantrums. She certainly won’t be given any paper to rip up or a cuddle when she’s done. What a load of nonsense.

Oh my goodness, what a comment. Come back and tell us when you’ve actually been through it love!

JenniferBarkley · 27/02/2023 12:05

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 27/02/2023 10:11

My baby hasn’t reached tantrum age yet, but I’ll be ignoring if she does have tantrums. She certainly won’t be given any paper to rip up or a cuddle when she’s done. What a load of nonsense.

Until mine hit that age I never understood how infuriating, frustrating, embarrassing, upsetting a toddler tantrum could be for the parent - often all at once.

I'm pretty no-nonsense in my parenting and use the word wild abandon but I think you're being ridiculously naive.

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 27/02/2023 11:53

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 27/02/2023 10:11

My baby hasn’t reached tantrum age yet, but I’ll be ignoring if she does have tantrums. She certainly won’t be given any paper to rip up or a cuddle when she’s done. What a load of nonsense.

How embarrassing to be so proudly ignorant on parenting.

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 27/02/2023 11:03

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 27/02/2023 10:11

My baby hasn’t reached tantrum age yet, but I’ll be ignoring if she does have tantrums. She certainly won’t be given any paper to rip up or a cuddle when she’s done. What a load of nonsense.

  1. Didn't answer a single question I asked.

  2. Congratulations on not having a child of tantrum age but still being a better parent than me. You must feel hugely accomplished.

bussteward · 27/02/2023 10:36

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 27/02/2023 10:11

My baby hasn’t reached tantrum age yet, but I’ll be ignoring if she does have tantrums. She certainly won’t be given any paper to rip up or a cuddle when she’s done. What a load of nonsense.

Do come back and let us know how this goes once you’ve actually encountered it.

TigerTea3 · 27/02/2023 10:34

We've gone through the emotional meltdowns over every little thing and we're coming out the other side now.

Honestly, it's developmentally normal for toddlers to have big feelings and meltdowns and I don't view it as something that needs to be corrected.

When my DC had an emotional meltdown, I let them feel their feelings, offered a cuddle if needed and then distracted with a fun activity/toy/game whatever. We'd then discuss 'feelings' once the dust had settled. 'I'm sorry you were feeling so cross earlier. It's ok to feel cross sometimes. Next time, could you use your words for Mummy so I can understand and help you?'

I certainly wouldn't be ripping paper.

Acknowledge the feelings, offer support and then move on. The bigger deal you make out of it, the more it drags on I feel.

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 27/02/2023 10:11

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 23/02/2023 13:51

Why is ignoring better than suppression? Isn't that giving the message that noone cares if you're upset and you're only worthy of attention when you're happy?

How would you feel if you were upset and frustrated and your partner didn't even try to understand why or let you explain?

And where is the solution for next time? Noone has helped the child understand what happened and why and what they can do next time to quell the overwhelm before it happens.

My baby hasn’t reached tantrum age yet, but I’ll be ignoring if she does have tantrums. She certainly won’t be given any paper to rip up or a cuddle when she’s done. What a load of nonsense.

bussteward · 27/02/2023 09:05

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 22/02/2023 14:19

Agree with @murmuration , sometimes being nearby sitting calmly until the storm has passed and then saying 'are you ready for a cuddle now?' is all that's needed. Maybe add 'those were big emotions weren't they, shall we find something else to do?' once feeling better is all you need.

Yes! I don’t think saying “Calm down” has helped anyone, child or adult, to calm down in the whole history of trying to calm people down. Think of yourself as a hostage negotiator: you wouldn’t just say “Gun down”, you’d talk to the maniac. Toddlers are maniacs.

With DD what worked was introducing the idea of quiet alone time, with us nearby but not in her face (she hates being talked to or touched during a wobbler) and now when she loses it she bellows “I NEED QUIET TIME” and runs to her room, gets under the covers and sobs. I do think it’s OK to let them rage and cry and work through the feelings rather than immediately calming down: crying IS calming, it releases hormones. Then afterwards DD likes to talk through the big feelings and says she feels a bit shaky, and I’ll suggest a snack or that we start lunch (hunger is her trigger!) and she’ll agree, even if the tantrum started over the suggestion of lunch.