Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To use donor sperm for 3rd baby?

135 replies

axndreial · 22/02/2023 13:28

I have 2yo twins, one of each. I'm a single mum and have always wanted 3 DCs.

If I do get into another relationship, it won't be for a while yet and I don't want a big age gap as the new baby won't have anyone to play with where as with a 3/4 year gap they most likely will.

I'm thinking of using donor sperm, but I'm not sure as the child wont have contact with their father (obviously) where as their 2 siblings will and when they're older will be staying overnight with him etc.

Would you do this or should I stop at 2?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Moonicorn · 23/02/2023 20:36

@Persipan i suppose so. I mean, very few people have 100% ideal circumstances to have a baby (which would be, let’s face it, exactly 32, married for 3+ years, in owned house, combined salary of 80k, perfect physical and mental health, supportive extended family blah blah).

But, not knowing who your dad is is a really big deal. Not just for medical/social reasons. But there’s something primitive about blood and genetics, hence why we want our own genetic children to start with rather than adopting. And missing out on any opportunity to get to know them and losing half your extended family - only one set of grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins. Explaining your situation to everyone - future friends, boyfriends, in laws - would be complicated and a little embarrassing. Most people just want to fit in.

Bloopsie · 23/02/2023 20:33

I think you should invest your time in finding a new partner with same wishes as you, perhaps you could complete your family then and the new baby would be welcomed by mum and dad.

Tabitha1960 · 23/02/2023 20:29

I honestly don't mean to come across as being rude but this sounds to me a bit like, "I have always fancied having three designer handbags......" etc

ThomasinaLivesHere · 23/02/2023 20:22

I think the main issue that you shouldn’t is the child will likely feel sad at having no dad like their siblings. It could cause issues. I know you get some families like this but to purposely create it is different.

Persipan · 23/02/2023 20:21

Not odd at all. How many ‘should I have kids’ threads on here are wondering how having a baby would affect their life? As opposed to ‘do I have enough to offer a baby?’.
Okay, I get that. But do you accept that a person might reflect on the latter question and come to the conclusion that they could offer quite a bit? I definitely found that the process of donor conception was one of thinking about my future child as a person - not just a baby - considering the spectrum of their potential thoughts and feelings and situation in depth, and being willing and prepared to adapt to what their thoughts and feelings turn out to be throughout their life.

Careeradvice123 · 23/02/2023 20:13

I have 3 and a very involved DH. Stick to 2 as 3 is alot to manage alone. I wouldn't do it on purpose.

Moonicorn · 23/02/2023 20:10

I find this a slightly odd comment in that you recognise that people who have become parents through donor conception have likely spent a lot of time carefully considering all aspects of parenthood... and yet you somehow assume this won't have extended to considering what the experience of their child will be.

Not odd at all. How many ‘should I have kids’ threads on here are wondering how having a baby would affect their life? As opposed to ‘do I have enough to offer a baby?’.

Persipan · 23/02/2023 20:07

I just hope people give the kind of thought to their children that they do to themselves. Personally me feeling 'desperate' is not reason enough to pursue motherhood at any cost. I rarely see people give critical thought to how offspring might feel - it's all about what they want.

I actually think going through these challenges can give one pause for thought on the 'selfish act' of pursuing parenthood that someone who can conceive naturally might not think about.

And of COURSE a counsellor at an IVF clinic is going to affirm your views....

I find this a slightly odd comment in that you recognise that people who have become parents through donor conception have likely spent a lot of time carefully considering all aspects of parenthood... and yet you somehow assume this won't have extended to considering what the experience of their child will be.

And personally, I found implications counselling to be a process of gently challenging my thoughts and reflecting on alternatives, so I feel you're off the mark in assuming the counselling is there to essentially agree with you.

All in all the idea that parents of donor-conceived children are just cavalier and thoughtless is such an alien one to me, and I find it quite ironic that it's often proffered by people whose experiences on the road to parenthood may not have involved anything like as much thought.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/02/2023 18:16

Two is enough for anyone.

Busybutbored · 23/02/2023 18:14

Particularprick · 23/02/2023 13:51

I just hope people give the kind of thought to their children that they do to themselves. Personally me feeling 'desperate' is not reason enough to pursue motherhood at any cost. I rarely see people give critical thought to how offspring might feel - it's all about what they want.

I actually think going through these challenges can give one pause for thought on the 'selfish act' of pursuing parenthood that someone who can conceive naturally might not think about.

And of COURSE a counsellor at an IVF clinic is going to affirm your views....

Totally agree with you

Darkstar4855 · 23/02/2023 15:26

Not having similar age siblings does not mean a child will have “nobody to play with”. Children are allowed to have friends outside their own families!

Particularprick · 23/02/2023 14:32

Tinyhappypeople · 23/02/2023 14:09

What an unpleasant message. Exactly where do you get it from that I didn’t give critical thought to what my son will think and feel?! How dare you base such a personal attack on an unfounded assumption.

I was talking generally. Defensive much?

Moonicorn · 23/02/2023 14:19

I don’t think it’s a personal attack, it’s commenting on donor gametes in general. The issue is we rarely hear from donor conceived adults, just the parents of young children or toddlers who were conceived that way and at the moment are not old enough for anyone to draw conclusions about what it will do to them long term.

Tinyhappypeople · 23/02/2023 14:09

Particularprick · 23/02/2023 13:51

I just hope people give the kind of thought to their children that they do to themselves. Personally me feeling 'desperate' is not reason enough to pursue motherhood at any cost. I rarely see people give critical thought to how offspring might feel - it's all about what they want.

I actually think going through these challenges can give one pause for thought on the 'selfish act' of pursuing parenthood that someone who can conceive naturally might not think about.

And of COURSE a counsellor at an IVF clinic is going to affirm your views....

What an unpleasant message. Exactly where do you get it from that I didn’t give critical thought to what my son will think and feel?! How dare you base such a personal attack on an unfounded assumption.

Moonicorn · 23/02/2023 13:58

Particularprick · 23/02/2023 13:51

I just hope people give the kind of thought to their children that they do to themselves. Personally me feeling 'desperate' is not reason enough to pursue motherhood at any cost. I rarely see people give critical thought to how offspring might feel - it's all about what they want.

I actually think going through these challenges can give one pause for thought on the 'selfish act' of pursuing parenthood that someone who can conceive naturally might not think about.

And of COURSE a counsellor at an IVF clinic is going to affirm your views....

I agree.

Particularprick · 23/02/2023 13:51

Tinyhappypeople · 23/02/2023 10:19

@mybunniesandme

My mother shared your opinion regarding all children needing a father. When she was desperate for a child (me) she ended up with my father, who abused both of us for years in about every way you can imagine. She insisted on pushing me to continue contact with him even when he had left our home, as like you say children need a father.

I wanted children desperately for many years and ended up in multiple abusive relationships before I gave up. I eventually decided on solo parenthood after huge amounts of research, soul searching and counselling. It was the counsellor at the ivf clinic who pointed out that actually no one has children for selfless reasons- it is almost always (arguably with the exception of some adoptions) a selfish act.

I can’t change your viewpoint but would ask you, and others, to be more sensitive with how you phrase things. Your words are very hurtful. No one (rightly) would stigmatise other unusual family structures in the same way that people feel they can be openly critical of solo parent by choice families.

I just hope people give the kind of thought to their children that they do to themselves. Personally me feeling 'desperate' is not reason enough to pursue motherhood at any cost. I rarely see people give critical thought to how offspring might feel - it's all about what they want.

I actually think going through these challenges can give one pause for thought on the 'selfish act' of pursuing parenthood that someone who can conceive naturally might not think about.

And of COURSE a counsellor at an IVF clinic is going to affirm your views....

Olivia199 · 23/02/2023 10:32

There is a Facebook group - Solo mother's by choice UK - who may be able to offer some advice from the other side of things from people who've been there or are currently.

Tinyhappypeople · 23/02/2023 10:19

@mybunniesandme

My mother shared your opinion regarding all children needing a father. When she was desperate for a child (me) she ended up with my father, who abused both of us for years in about every way you can imagine. She insisted on pushing me to continue contact with him even when he had left our home, as like you say children need a father.

I wanted children desperately for many years and ended up in multiple abusive relationships before I gave up. I eventually decided on solo parenthood after huge amounts of research, soul searching and counselling. It was the counsellor at the ivf clinic who pointed out that actually no one has children for selfless reasons- it is almost always (arguably with the exception of some adoptions) a selfish act.

I can’t change your viewpoint but would ask you, and others, to be more sensitive with how you phrase things. Your words are very hurtful. No one (rightly) would stigmatise other unusual family structures in the same way that people feel they can be openly critical of solo parent by choice families.

ladykale · 23/02/2023 08:06

Can your wage as a single mum cover three babies?? or do you mean post UC etc

Don't complicate your life.

Children deserve a dad unless circumstances mean it's just not possible. Seems sad to choose that for a child.

juliettesmother · 22/02/2023 23:26

OP, you know your situation best. Don't seek validation from strangers on the internet.

Sarahcoggles · 22/02/2023 23:24

I'm horrified at the nasty smug "my way is the only way" married posters on here saying that single women should never have children. What sad bitter people you must be. And wrong too.

I had always wanted children and when, at age 36, my fiancé announced that he didn't want kids (having said he did) , I was devastated, and knew I had to act.

I now have 2 teenagers conceived by donor sperm. I also have a partner who I met when they were younger, who doesn't live with us, but who they are fond of.

My DC have many friends who are now in single parent families, as the divorces came thick and fast once kids reached teens. These kids have witnessed screaming rows, tears, misery, violence in some instances, followed by acrimonious settlements, house moves, being uprooted, moving between houses, new partners introduced etc. They have watched their beloved parents yell at each other, and a couple of dads have disappeared completely, and not seen their kids at all.

Meanwhile my kids have never heard adults raising their voices, they've never experienced the pain of the 2 people they love the most hating each other, they've never had to lie in bed pretending they can't hear the fights. They've grown up in calm surroundings with family who love them.

It sickens me that some people are so narrow minded and unaware of the many permutations and combinations that make up a happy or unhappy childhood.

I wonder how perfect you must all be, to think you can judge others so readily.

user1492757084 · 22/02/2023 23:20

I don't think it is a great idea. As one of the the older natural children of five with a much younger adopted sibling (adopted for reasons of my parents feeling the empty nest coming etc.) we found the early days with our sibling cute but later it really stretched our parents' budget and they were continually compensating the adopted one who was hugely spoilt (their favourite) and ended up creating a lot of problems once our parents died. We all feel responsible for her and still dig her out of so many financial and relationship situations. Setting up a family where there are very differing circumstances for each child is complicated. Why aren't your other children enough? If you meet another partner they might have children already or they really might want their own with you. Leave your options more flexible. Think about freezing your eggs if you are getting older. It might seem expensive but it is not compared to the expense of having another child.

IneedanewTV · 22/02/2023 23:14

Two is enough. Take joy from them and stop wishing for more. You have a boy and a girl. How fabulous. They will, at some stage go and stay with their father. How will your third child feel? You will also not get any free time. You may have a disabled child. Be grateful.

monsteramunch · 22/02/2023 23:08

axndreial · 22/02/2023 15:55

The twins don't see their father very often at the moment, and in the future they may and it might include overnights but I don't know 100%.

The risk of twins again would likely be low this time as twins run in ex’s family and he's a twin himself.

Of course, I don't just want another DC so they'll play together but it is a reason that I don't want a big age gap as if it's 10+ years it'll technically be like raising an only child.

This isn't the case re twins OP - the increased chance of multiple birth can only come from the mum.

A man's family history of twins can't increase his partner's chance of having twins. If a man has inherited the hyperovulation gene from his mother, he may pass this gene on to his daughter, but it won't impact on the chances of him conceiving multiples with his own partner.

cadink · 22/02/2023 22:55

I would stop at two for financial and environmental reasons and also so you can focus on the two you have if you're a single parent.