Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think dh should not be telling family about our problems?

116 replies

OnenightinBangkok · 22/02/2023 08:06

Hope I can get some advice from some objective people as I don't know if iabu or not.
My husband and I are going through a very rough patch.
My family are aware of this but they deem it to be the case from sensing it rather than anything I say to them.
Their attitude is that they'll help if I wish to leave but don't want to know the ins and outs of the marriage.
My dgm said that she felt that things were six of one half dozen of the other in terms of mine and dh's faults as people.
We've no dcs.
Anyway, my dh has taken to having long phone calls with his mother about our issues.
I can hear him in the next room talking to her. I have begged him not to do this to no avail.
It's basically him slagging me off and her somewhat enthusiastically joining in.
I'm angry and hurt by this.
This has made me lose trust in him and I can't stand her anymore.
Aibu?
P. S. I do appreciate the fact I'm asking for advice here but I'm anonymous and I guess my issue is far from unusual!
Thanks for any replies.

OP posts:
IDontWantToBeAPie · 22/02/2023 09:33

I don't know tbh. I think everyone has a need to talk to someone about their problems and a parent is usually the safest person to do hat with.

I think I couldn't say 'don't ever talk about our problems' because that feels unfair and a little controlling.

Could you afford for him to talk to a therapist instead? That might be a good compromise?

OnenightinBangkok · 22/02/2023 09:32

Apologies for drip feeding but the opening post would be really long if I said all this in it.

I understand that some people confide in their families about their marriage problems. I don't think this is wise but it may be coming from a good place.

This is not the case here: this is a man getting drunk and making damned sure I can hear him badmouth me to his mother.

See the difference?

OP posts:
sandgrown · 22/02/2023 09:27

My ex and his sister used to have long, loud FaceTime conversations slagging me off . I kept my cool and ignored it as I was waiting to move out but on the day I left I completely let rip and told him what I thought of his sister ( I was disappointed with myself but they had been through my personal belongings and I lost it) She always told him what he wanted to hear . Probably your MIL is the same. I am a pretty private person but he was an oversharer which I found really difficult.

bloodyplanes · 22/02/2023 09:18

Nope I would leave him! If he's slagging you off when you can hear him just imagine what he says when are not there! He has no respect for you to do this and he's not genuinely trying to get to the bottom of your issues he"s just painting himself as a victim to a very willing audience! My ex partner was like this and believe me it won't get better, life is so much nicer when you know that you are not being constantly slagged off or bitched about!

Onnabugeisha · 22/02/2023 09:18

OnenightinBangkok · 22/02/2023 09:07

No. You don't get it. He is not respectfully asking for advice. He is actively and purposefully badmouthing me to his mother. Loudly so I cannot help but hear.
Sometimes actively coming into the bedroom where I've gone so to make sure I can hear. Believe me I don't want to listen.
He does this when he's been drinking heavily.
in spite of me begging him not to do this.

Because he doesn't remember a damned thing what he said to her but she does.

If asking my husband not to do this is controlling then so be it. I don't care. I think accusations of me asking him not to do this are absolutely ridiculous.

He doesn’t have to be “respectfully asking for advice” imho.

Bit of a drip feed to go from him in the next room and you coincidentally on purpose “overhearing” every word he and his mum say to him shouting down the phone and following you about whilst doing it and adding in he does it when he’s so blind drunk he doesn’t even remember it the next day.

May I suggest the primary issue with your marriage then is his alcohol abuse? And perhaps he needs to go to rehab and dry out.

OnenightinBangkok · 22/02/2023 09:16

DontLikeMenthols · 22/02/2023 09:08

This is probably the most unpopular opinion of them all but I find slagging your partner off to random strangers on the internet who don’t know either of you and can’t give informed or educated advice worse than talking to a loved one. He’s talking to someone who’s opinion he values, who knows you both, it’s kind of tough you don’t like it as you’ve clearly let on more to your family than you’re saying if they’re ‘sensing it’ and your DGM is chipping in with her 2 cents.

its not great that you can hear him doing it and maybe you can ask him to take his calls privately but you can’t and shouldn’t try to control who he speaks to and about what. If this was reversed and a woman was confiding in her mum and her husband demanded she stopped telling others about their issues you’d hear the cries of ‘abuser’ from space.

It's not abusive to ask your spouse not to badmouth you to their family.

He's not saying to me 'hey let's ask my mum to help' (I'd say no as I don't think it's appropriate) he's calling her up to badmouth me when he's drunk and she loves every minute of it.

He doesn't remember a damned thing the next day.

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 22/02/2023 09:14

How many women say they discuss problems with their mums, bff's, sisters etc. ?

Brefugee · 22/02/2023 09:14

I admit hearing him badmouthing me to his mother has made me view him as less of a man and have gone off him sexually because of it.
'She did this' 'She said that'. Ugh!!
Like a child telling tales.

you still haven't given an example of the "badmouthing". Is he saying "she hit me in the face with a frying pan" or is he saying "she's annoying"?

As for "less of a man"? DH if you're reading this: time to leave.

yodayoga1 · 22/02/2023 09:14

From your follow up messages, I really don't think the fact he chooses to talk to his mother about you is the problem. It's that he's deliberately running you down within your earshot. It's a strange passive aggressive way of going about things. Not to mention that he's sitting at home drinking to the point of memory loss the next day.

It sounds as though you've already decided you want out and I'm wondering what keeps you holding on?

Groutyonehereagain · 22/02/2023 09:10

Don’t listen then.

Snoken · 22/02/2023 09:10

OnenightinBangkok · 22/02/2023 09:07

No. You don't get it. He is not respectfully asking for advice. He is actively and purposefully badmouthing me to his mother. Loudly so I cannot help but hear.
Sometimes actively coming into the bedroom where I've gone so to make sure I can hear. Believe me I don't want to listen.
He does this when he's been drinking heavily.
in spite of me begging him not to do this.

Because he doesn't remember a damned thing what he said to her but she does.

If asking my husband not to do this is controlling then so be it. I don't care. I think accusations of me asking him not to do this are absolutely ridiculous.

Sorry, I wrote my reply before I had seen this. Now I think he's just being abusive.

Snoken · 22/02/2023 09:08

I think it's a good think he has someone to talk to regarding your issues. A lot of men don't feel like they can talk about feelings and it usually makes things a lot worse for everyone involved. I know you are calling it slagging off but he is most likely just telling things from his point of view.

I separated from my husband last year and in the months leading up to that and after the separation I spoke to my closest friends about our issues in detail. It's normal an healthy to speak about issues you are having, it helps as you get different perspectives and validation.

DontLikeMenthols · 22/02/2023 09:08

This is probably the most unpopular opinion of them all but I find slagging your partner off to random strangers on the internet who don’t know either of you and can’t give informed or educated advice worse than talking to a loved one. He’s talking to someone who’s opinion he values, who knows you both, it’s kind of tough you don’t like it as you’ve clearly let on more to your family than you’re saying if they’re ‘sensing it’ and your DGM is chipping in with her 2 cents.

its not great that you can hear him doing it and maybe you can ask him to take his calls privately but you can’t and shouldn’t try to control who he speaks to and about what. If this was reversed and a woman was confiding in her mum and her husband demanded she stopped telling others about their issues you’d hear the cries of ‘abuser’ from space.

OnenightinBangkok · 22/02/2023 09:07

Onnabugeisha · 22/02/2023 08:54

I’m sorry, but everyone needs someone they trust to confide in and vent frustration to. That person is his mum. And quite frankly, you don’t have to be hovering in the next room listening in on what he says and his mum’s responses. Does your DH know you are spying on him? I would consider that an invasion of my privacy to be listened in on while talking with my mum about any marriage issues. Does your DH hover in the next room while you talk to your family?? I hope not because that would be doubly toxic. It’s also weirdly controlling to get angry and demand he not speak to anyone outside the marriage unless a professional counsellor.

Look, when things are rough and both members of a couple are trying to patch things up both are going to need emotional support from someone who knows them well. It’s unreasonable for you to expect yourself or him to succeed without any support. And letting off steam, expressing frustrations to a third party is a healthy thing to do- the alternative is to bottle it all up and then have explosive rows.

No. You don't get it. He is not respectfully asking for advice. He is actively and purposefully badmouthing me to his mother. Loudly so I cannot help but hear.
Sometimes actively coming into the bedroom where I've gone so to make sure I can hear. Believe me I don't want to listen.
He does this when he's been drinking heavily.
in spite of me begging him not to do this.

Because he doesn't remember a damned thing what he said to her but she does.

If asking my husband not to do this is controlling then so be it. I don't care. I think accusations of me asking him not to do this are absolutely ridiculous.

OP posts:
StrawBeretMoose · 22/02/2023 09:07

I wouldn't discuss marital issues with family or mutual friends and neither would DH.
I'd be really annoyed if he spoke to his mum about any issues we had.

Putitsimply · 22/02/2023 09:06

You need to leave. Neither of you like each other. And you just called his mother a bitch! You are slagging her off- and worse than him, because you’re doing it to the whole internet.

Holly60 · 22/02/2023 09:00

OnenightinBangkok · 22/02/2023 08:46

Do you think I should leave because of our issues because before he took to doing this I thought they could possibly be worked out OR because he's taken to doing this?
I admit hearing him badmouthing me to his mother has made me view him as less of a man and have gone off him sexually because of it.
'She did this' 'She said that'. Ugh!!
Like a child telling tales.
This is not a man being neutral and asking for advice in a calm manner.
Even if it was, seek advice from a neutral third party is my view.
As for her, I just view her as an interfering bitch now.

Worse still he tends to do this when he's been drinking. He never really remembers exactly what he said the next day.

The more you say the more I think you should leave.

If anyone called my mum an interfering bitch, for any reason, I wouldn't want to be with them.

This dynamic won't change, and will only get worse if you have children.

Leave now I'm afraid. You don't like his family, he does. It's a recipe for endless heartache

TootHole · 22/02/2023 08:59

Wind up thread.

FloydPepper · 22/02/2023 08:58

OnenightinBangkok · 22/02/2023 08:46

Do you think I should leave because of our issues because before he took to doing this I thought they could possibly be worked out OR because he's taken to doing this?
I admit hearing him badmouthing me to his mother has made me view him as less of a man and have gone off him sexually because of it.
'She did this' 'She said that'. Ugh!!
Like a child telling tales.
This is not a man being neutral and asking for advice in a calm manner.
Even if it was, seek advice from a neutral third party is my view.
As for her, I just view her as an interfering bitch now.

Worse still he tends to do this when he's been drinking. He never really remembers exactly what he said the next day.

I’m sorry? What the fuck?
confiding in his mum makes him less of a man?
jesus!

OngoingCrisis · 22/02/2023 08:57

My ex was like this. Any time we'd had a disagreement he went straight to his mom and would tell her everything. But, he was a typical mamas boy so I guess this is different. He'd show her the text messages between us and she'd just sit there and read them and he would get her to message me on his behalf. I felt like you, I would have preferred him to have discussed things with one of his brothers at least, as opposed to his mom as it felt quite invasive. Especially when he'd tell her everything.

35965a · 22/02/2023 08:56

It’s awful to slag your partner off to family. As a PP said, families hold grudges. Venting to your own friends isn’t so bad but I’ve never ever criticised my husband to my family. Therapy to sort issues is great. Just talking shit about your spouse to your mum is pathetic.

Onnabugeisha · 22/02/2023 08:54

I’m sorry, but everyone needs someone they trust to confide in and vent frustration to. That person is his mum. And quite frankly, you don’t have to be hovering in the next room listening in on what he says and his mum’s responses. Does your DH know you are spying on him? I would consider that an invasion of my privacy to be listened in on while talking with my mum about any marriage issues. Does your DH hover in the next room while you talk to your family?? I hope not because that would be doubly toxic. It’s also weirdly controlling to get angry and demand he not speak to anyone outside the marriage unless a professional counsellor.

Look, when things are rough and both members of a couple are trying to patch things up both are going to need emotional support from someone who knows them well. It’s unreasonable for you to expect yourself or him to succeed without any support. And letting off steam, expressing frustrations to a third party is a healthy thing to do- the alternative is to bottle it all up and then have explosive rows.

calmandcaffeinated · 22/02/2023 08:53

@OnenightinBangkok I would be upset if my husband was slagging me off to MIL. I think it's different if he's asking for genuine advice or a different perspective. I personally don't think it's appropriate to run to mummy or daddy about issues in a marriage. I would say speaking to mates (who aren't mutual mates) is probably ok, but a third party who is not known to either is best.

I highly recommend marriage counselling where you can each speak to them individually as well as together. Hopefully it will be a way to communication to build up. Me and DH did this when we went through a rough patch in 2016 and it really really helped.

Firsttimemum120 · 22/02/2023 08:52

We all need support from somewhere. I talk to my family about my own issues but not where my partner can hear. Everyone needs someone to talk to and sometimes it’s good when it’s not your partner as someone else can give other opinions perspectives and help.

bikiniisland · 22/02/2023 08:52

I don't think there is anything wrong with talking to family members about your relationship.

That said, he is supposed to be your husband. The one who loves you the most, the one who is on your side. If he is slagging you off it sounds like he isn't that.