Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think low take up of heat pump grants is due to more than just poor advertising.

140 replies

overitt · 22/02/2023 07:55

There's a BBC story today about low take-up of the £5k grants available for heat pump installation: www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-64710225. The criticism focuses on poor marketingnof the scheme and difficulties in funding installers, both of which are true. But I think there's more to it than that. I managed to find a potential local installer and had a telephone conversation with him. He told me about the size of the pump, the restrictions on where it could be installed in relation to neighbouring properties, and the internal infrastructure that would be needed. The picture on the BBC article illustrates it well. I would need to rebuild my kitchen to accommodate it. He also said that for the system to work effectively I would need to install interior or exterior wall insulation on my solid brick house, plus either underfloor heating or bigger radiators in all the rooms. All of thus would cost many £££££. The installer told me that for these reasons he was mostly installing heat pumps in new build homes or complete refurbishments.

Aibu to think these factors are probably a much bigger part of the reason why the scheme has low take-up than "poor advertising"?

To think low take up of heat pump grants is due to more than just poor advertising.
OP posts:
Jonesthebones · 22/02/2023 09:02

CouldIBeAnymoreOuting · 22/02/2023 08:10

I’ve looked into heat pumps quite a bit recently as I’m in the middle of a whole house renovation and big extension.

On paper we are the ideal candidates to install a new system, but I’ve found the cost prohibitive in an already tight budget.

£5k off isn’t enough. For our house, total cost for heat pump parts labour, radiators etc would be around £11k (accounting for the grant). Comparatively, cost for a combi boiler install plus radiators is £7k. Building costs are so high, we don’t have that sort of money to spare in the renovation budget.

It’s a shame there isn’t better support. We’d take it up if there was a similar scheme to wales where they give you up to 25k interest free loan, payable at your own pace. That would also allow us to install solar panels and use the money saved to pay off the loan.

Do you have a link to this Welsh scheme? I'm in Wales and haven't seen anything about it, sounds good!

cocksstrideintheevening · 22/02/2023 09:00

I'd have to build an extension to house it

ChungusBoi · 22/02/2023 09:00

CalistoNoSolo · 22/02/2023 08:56

The govt would be far better giving everyone a grant of £5k for household insulation. The hear pump grant is greenwash to make it look like they are doing something.

I agree

Catspyjamas17 · 22/02/2023 08:58
  • Not sure if they work (in our type of home/whether we have enough insulation)
  • Not sure if they will save us money
  • Too expensive even with grant - new boiler would be less.
  • I will replace my gas hob over my dead body - induction hobs are shit.
DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 22/02/2023 08:58

We live in a modern, reasonably well insulated house that has wet UFH downstairs. In principle an ideal candidate for a heat pump. One of our neighbours in an identical house has gone down the solar/heat pump options. I don’t know about running costs but we visited their house during the cold snap this winter and it was freezing. They had oil filter radiators all over downstairs as the heat pump couldn’t keep the house at a decent temperature. It may have been a poor installation but it didn’t fill me with confidence!

purplespiral · 22/02/2023 08:57

Our terraced home and garden are far too small to have one. There’s already barely enough room for us. The kitchen is tiny; no room for dishwasher or tumble dryer. Our garden is so small that we’ve not extended into the back despite struggling with lack of space, because any smaller and the DC would have nowhere to play.

I think the people thinking up these schemes and saying that everyone will have one by xyz don’t live in the real world and see how many of us live.

Here they’re talking about bringing in four different types of recycling sacks instead of a general use one - where are people in tiny houses who have no garage etc supposed to keep those?! Rubbish is already only collected once every two weeks - and black bins were also changed to tiny ones - which is a struggle.

CalistoNoSolo · 22/02/2023 08:56

The govt would be far better giving everyone a grant of £5k for household insulation. The hear pump grant is greenwash to make it look like they are doing something.

AnneElliott · 22/02/2023 08:51

I agree with you. Plus the public sector bodies I look after have had a really difficult time with heat pumps. They haven't done what was promised and some of them are now having them taken out.

Maraudingmarauders · 22/02/2023 08:47

They're just far too expensive still. The £5k addition is just being swallowed up by increased prices. We had a quote and all in (with changes we needed to make etc) we are looking at over £16k. There's no way we can afford that. A gas boiler (which we can't have as no gas in our area) is more like £3-£6k. No wonder take up is low.
Not to mention the fact that we need solar panels and battery storage as with two car chargers and electric showers our house load couldn't cope with a Heat pump.

cupofdecaf · 22/02/2023 08:46

And there weren't loads of adjustments to make inside either. We already had a water tank so that was replaced with a better insulated one.

The space outside and space for a water tank I can see being an issue for some people.

cupofdecaf · 22/02/2023 08:44

We put a heat pump in last year. Haven't done under floor heating, no more insulation though the house in 1990s built. We've not replaced any radiators though theres one room we think we might. Never even considered the doing anything to the windows.

It's worked grand all winter. With the grant it was about 2k more expensive than replacing our old gas boiler would have been.

I suspect some of the companies either want the easy jobs so put people off or are trying to up sell you on radiators etc.

WhatsitWiggle · 22/02/2023 08:42

Why would householders pay out £5-£10k ON TOP of the grant, rather than £2k for a new gas boiler? Unless you're in your forever home, there's no way you'd recoup that cost.

And new build houses are still going up with gas boilers, surely that tells the government something?

It's not marketing, it's expense.

FeinCuroxiVooz · 22/02/2023 08:39

totally agree. most existing housing stock doesn't have the space for it and can't be adequately insulated to make it work. a house with rooms that are already tiny can't lose a few inches off each direction for adding insulation and bigger radiators, the rooms are already barely big enough to be livable in most cases.

it's fine to specify that all new builds should be designed and built with sufficient insulation and technology for heating that avoids burning gas, but a lot of the existing housing stock would need to be demolished and re-imagined from scratch rather than retrofitted, and that's simply not going to happen. the forthcoming deadline for no new combi boiler installations will surely be over-ruled. if it isn't, people will be installing less efficient and more old-fashioned technology like oil-filled electric radiators rather than the heat-pump technology that unsuitable for most older homes.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 22/02/2023 08:38

We installed a heatpump 5 years ago, so got the old grant. Our house is a 1960s one with no UFH.

Our (oil) boiler was ancient, and we were told that , if it went wrong, the parts wouldn't be available. If we had a new oil boiler installed then it would have to be elsewhere as the original one was in a place which would now be illegal to install.

We did have to upgrade some radiators, so the cost came to £12k. We had to pay upfront and then got a quarterly grant payment back, which will total £10kover 7 years. We actually moved 2 months ago, so the new owners get the payments for the next 2 years but that was factored into the sale price.

So the whole thing cost us £2k whereas a new oil boiler plus repositioning it would have cost us far more. Plus the heat pump was amazing and we never had to worry about running out of oil.

We probably wouldn't have done it if we were only going to get a £5k grant. We were lucky in that we could afford to pay for the new systemupfront, and that although our house was 50 years old, it was very well insulated - you only got the grant if your house met a certain thermal threshold, which ours did.

TheMousePipes · 22/02/2023 08:37

DH was meant to be training to fit them (he’s a gas engineer) but we’ve cancelled the training course. We had a proper look at the housing stock that he works on, which is mainly 1939’s interwar properties without cavity wall insulation. The retro fit costs to bring the properties up to spec so that the heat pumps are efficient are totally prohibitive to the people who live in them. And he’s never been asked about one.
So what’s point of losing a weeks income to pay to train to fit something no one can afford to put in their house?

Ginmonkeyagain · 22/02/2023 08:35

@WhereAreMyAirpods i am director of a freehild companybfornour purpose built block of flats (1930s) and we have been grappling with this issue.

Apparently we used to have a communal oil heating system and individual flats had a open fire place in the living room. Back in the seventies this was removed and the block put on mains gas. Since then most flats have upgraded to a combi gas boiler, ripped out their water tanks and boarded up living room fireplaces.

We can't work out if indivudal heat pumps would work (there is room to put one on balconies where gas meters currently are but would planning rules let us?) or one massive one for the whole block.

Whatever happens it will be massive external and internal works for everyone and there seems to be little guidance. When it comes to blocks of flats policy makers either seem to think they are social housing or very fancy luxury blocks. However there are a lot of private purpose built blocks lived in by people on ordinary incomes and managed by small companies or volunteer boards.

CouldIBeAnymoreOuting · 22/02/2023 08:34

@Calmdown14 in an ideal world, I’d go for both heat pump and solar, but you are right, at least solar is an option we can consider in future alongside a boiler.

Seeingadistance · 22/02/2023 08:32

I agree, OP. I heard the item on heat pumps on the news this morning and my first thought was that the problem isn’t awareness or lack of it, but the entire concept itself, encompassing all the drawbacks mentioned above.

SweetSakura · 22/02/2023 08:30

Yanbu. Most houses these days have tiny gardens as well, even the most eco minded is going to think twice about putting a hulking great box in their tiny patch of green.

drpet49 · 22/02/2023 08:30

Too big and bulky. Too expensive

Calmdown14 · 22/02/2023 08:29

I agree. I went through the options recently and the technology is not suited to my house. Even the energy advisor agreed this (Scotland).

@CouldIBeAnymoreOuting solar panels have come down a lot and there's currently no VAT. It's more like 5k for the panels, more if you want a battery.

Given the costs you outlined you can see why people would choose a new boiler and solar for the same cost as a heat pump.

ChungusBoi · 22/02/2023 08:28

My neighbours have one. It used the existing radiators I believe, and the house is kept at a steady, comfortable temperature. … but it’s more expensive to run than they anticipated. And they now have a unit the size of a fridge freezer in their outbuilding.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 22/02/2023 08:27

We looked into heat pumps recently as we had to replace our boiler. After doing lots of research, it was clear that the expense would be prohibitive and the grant barely even scraped the surface. So I'm afraid we went ahead and installed a new gas boiler. Not ideal, but there you go.

midgemadgemodge · 22/02/2023 08:24

I think new estates should be built with community ground source heating ( I think they do this in Europe )or sone kind of low carbon district heating but that would mean rules ( aka red tape) , the builder will say it slows down building process too much ...

Air source heat pumps are pretty ineffective especially in the colder regions , in larger homes never mind the insulation

StatisticallyChallenged · 22/02/2023 08:23

I have one, but it was installed in a new build. There's no way we could have had one in our old house:

  • no outdoor space (mews house so a wall mounted one would have been hanging over the road!)
  • conservation area, council won't even allow solar so no chance of mounting something the size of a washing machine outside
-sandstone with fuck all insulation and single glazing so it wouldn't manage to warm the house.
  • nowhere for the water tank
  • radiators were already as big as possible really.

They're great in the right property and I love it in this house - it's really efficient especially paired with solar and batteries

They're a part of the solution for houses which suit them, but by no means right for everyone.

Swipe left for the next trending thread