Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think low take up of heat pump grants is due to more than just poor advertising.

140 replies

overitt · 22/02/2023 07:55

There's a BBC story today about low take-up of the £5k grants available for heat pump installation: www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-64710225. The criticism focuses on poor marketingnof the scheme and difficulties in funding installers, both of which are true. But I think there's more to it than that. I managed to find a potential local installer and had a telephone conversation with him. He told me about the size of the pump, the restrictions on where it could be installed in relation to neighbouring properties, and the internal infrastructure that would be needed. The picture on the BBC article illustrates it well. I would need to rebuild my kitchen to accommodate it. He also said that for the system to work effectively I would need to install interior or exterior wall insulation on my solid brick house, plus either underfloor heating or bigger radiators in all the rooms. All of thus would cost many £££££. The installer told me that for these reasons he was mostly installing heat pumps in new build homes or complete refurbishments.

Aibu to think these factors are probably a much bigger part of the reason why the scheme has low take-up than "poor advertising"?

To think low take up of heat pump grants is due to more than just poor advertising.
OP posts:
megletthesecond · 22/02/2023 11:48

There's a good BBC Sliced Bread podcast on heat pumps. They were split on them.

I have an eco conscious friend who has just renovated their house and they decided against a heat pump as the costs were huge and it didn't look quite effective enough.

StatisticallyChallenged · 22/02/2023 11:07

Neededanewuserhandle · 22/02/2023 10:56

House builders give millions to the Tory party to avoid pesky regulations.

There's already requirements around this for new builds in Scotland with more next year. Can't remember the exact phasing, but almost all new builds (I'm surrounded by them) already have solar and by 2024 they're meant to have low carbon heating.

We were phase 1 of our development - site started 2018ish - and we got heat pumps but not solar. Some of the smaller houses (different developer) got solar but not heat pumps

Phase 2 with our developer have pumps and solar, although I think they aren't great solar setups - no batteries and in the case of one I can see, a beautifully fitted but due north facing panel array...

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 22/02/2023 11:00

My neighbours have one and it is very difficult to set, expensive to run amd service and have great difficulty getting anyone to come out when there is a problem . Also the grant does not go far so there is still a very large expense to the home owner. Money most people do not have freely available and are not in a position to borrow and invest in another government scheme which will likely be ineffective and poor value in the long run. Its not is the consumer benefitting from this scheme.

Neededanewuserhandle · 22/02/2023 10:56

Teatime55 · 22/02/2023 08:20

We had a look and they weren’t suitable and expensive.
Why aren’t all new houses built with them as standard (and car charging ports)?

House builders give millions to the Tory party to avoid pesky regulations.

Bloopsie · 22/02/2023 10:53

British goverment lives in another land, Uk has the oldest housing stock in Europe. My brother in Europe bought a newbuild in Estonia- came with solar panels,heat pump,underfloor heating in the whole house etc- you get none of that in the newbuilds in the UK. Installing this in the old houses.. might as well tear the whole house down and start all over again.

StatisticallyChallenged · 22/02/2023 10:52

Solar panels appear to be breeding around here. The Scottish Govt offers interest free loans for panels and batteries. It didn't cover our full system because we have larger batteries (15kw) and 6kw of panels over two roof faces, but it would cover a more typical install. In our case the loan payment is about half of the reduction in our utility cost so it makes a lot of sense.

GasPanic · 22/02/2023 10:47

LastNightWasEpic · 22/02/2023 09:48

I don't know about heat pumps but surely the grant for this would be better going towards solar panels which can be much more easily fitted. That would have covered just under half the cost of ours recently fitted. It's brought the bills down by half on sunny days.

Is it because too many people could actually make use of that kind of grant and so cost money?!

There used to be better subsidies for solar. We were adding solar at a terrific rate around 2015 until they withdrew the subsidies.

Basically if we had continued to add solar at the same rate as we were adding in 2015, then by now we would have added enough solar capacity to be equivalent to another Hinkley Point C (30GW of added solar at 10% capacity factor).

Heat pumps are not really that good in existing houses. I would get a gas boiler and solar. Gas boiler is lower cost and lower risk that it will actually provide the heating you require. Plus it has less unknowns in terms of things like reliability and service costs. I would want an SCOP on a heat pump of at least 4 to offset the price cost of gas (about 3x less). Very few heat pumps achieve this.

The only time I would consider a heat pump is a) in a new build, where the whole house is wired up for them, so they work better and b) if I had no access to mains gas. In b) generally you have a choice of oil, LPG,heat pump or normal electric. The problem is in a house that doesn't have access to mains gas it will be more often than not old build and therefore need substantial insulation upgrading in order to good for a heat pumps.

I think the government should insist on heat pumps in new builds (where they can be made to work well), stop subsidising them in non new builds and put the money towards subsidising solar instead.

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 22/02/2023 10:28

@EmmaGrundyForPM I know - it's generally the same for all underfloor heating, leave it on at a low level all the time because it takes longer to heat up. Even running flat out, the heat pump couldn't keep the house comfortable.

@OddBoots AIr conditioners are heat pumps, they just run in one direction. They sometimes have electric heating elements built in so they can heat, or can act as true heat pumps, so heating and cooling.

LastNightWasEpic · 22/02/2023 09:48

I don't know about heat pumps but surely the grant for this would be better going towards solar panels which can be much more easily fitted. That would have covered just under half the cost of ours recently fitted. It's brought the bills down by half on sunny days.

Is it because too many people could actually make use of that kind of grant and so cost money?!

Ginmonkeyagain · 22/02/2023 09:45

I rented a flat once that had electric ceiling heating - it was foils rolled out above a false ceiling and each room could be indivually controlled for temprature and timing.

We really struggled with working it and maintaing a comfotable temperatire. Lookign back I see we never really understood we probably needed to leave it on all the time with the thermostat set to the ideal temperature in each room.

I think there probably needs to be an education programme on how electric heating systems best work as most of us are used to the instant direct heat of solid fuel systems and/or wood burners.

Choconut · 22/02/2023 09:39

I've read far too many stories of people saying they are expensive and rubbish unfortunately.

MrsCarson · 22/02/2023 09:35

Most houses don't have enough room for a utility room let alone all that pipe work and stuff needed for the air pump.
Our house insulation has been updated massively in the last 6 years. Still not good enough probably.

lieselotte · 22/02/2023 09:35

I will replace my gas hob over my dead body - induction hobs are shit

To be fair your hob is separate to your heating. You could have a heat pump or electric heating and still have a gas hob if you wanted.

lieselotte · 22/02/2023 09:33

We replaced a gas boiler in late 2021. We did consider a heat pump but were concerned by the cost, the noise, and the fact that it is relatively new technology and how easy (and expensive) is it to repair. So lots of reasons. But the main one was not wanting to be lumbered with something that didn't work and was hard to repair.

OddBoots · 22/02/2023 09:32

We looked at it and decided it wouldn't work for us as we have that terrible wall travelling microbore piping to our radiators so we have gone for the most efficient replacement gas boiler we could get.

In a (good) few years we will be looking again at electric heating but looking at air conditioning units rather than ASHPs. They can currently run at an efficiency of 3 kilowatts of heat for each and every kilowatt of electricity and are improving all the time. We hadn't realised this option until after we had already had the boiler replaced.

StatisticallyChallenged · 22/02/2023 09:31

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 22/02/2023 08:58

We live in a modern, reasonably well insulated house that has wet UFH downstairs. In principle an ideal candidate for a heat pump. One of our neighbours in an identical house has gone down the solar/heat pump options. I don’t know about running costs but we visited their house during the cold snap this winter and it was freezing. They had oil filter radiators all over downstairs as the heat pump couldn’t keep the house at a decent temperature. It may have been a poor installation but it didn’t fill me with confidence!

Ours is warm, but I've had to help out a couple of neighbours who were finding it cold and expensive because they were running it like an old boiler, just a couple of hours at a time. It's far more effective set to a constant temperature, and in these houses costs less that way. It's not running constantly but it kicks on and off throughout the day to just maintain temperature.

Tiredalwaystired · 22/02/2023 09:31

We looked too. Too expensive even with a grant. That’s the sum total of the reason. It needs to compete with a Regular boiler cost wise, especially with all other prices going up for building works.

CouldIBeAnymoreOuting · 22/02/2023 09:30

Jonesthebones · 22/02/2023 09:02

Do you have a link to this Welsh scheme? I'm in Wales and haven't seen anything about it, sounds good!

I found out about it via the DIY property forum here but I just googled and looks like that scheme has now retired and the new scheme is just the same as the crap England £5k one.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 22/02/2023 09:26

When I lived in France , there was a major subsidy for installing ground or air source heat pumps ( this would be 2006 Onwards). In our area there were a lot of new houses being built, all with decent size gardens ( 250m 2 at least). Virtually no one was installing them , you could tell because they always had a little sign in the garden during building.

I asked our boiler service guy about them, as his firm was an installer. He had one in his house. He said they were fine as background heating, but you still needed your woodburner. ( everyone had one) and electric radiators for boosting. So effectively two systems….okay if you are the installer.

Wheretheskyisblue · 22/02/2023 09:17

Installing a heat pump would be a complete waste of money in our house. Although it is relatively new (90s) it is timber framed with a brick outer with poor insulation between the two. We have been quoted over £40k to either internally or externally clad the house in order to improve it's efficiency which is just not worth it.

CliffsofMohair · 22/02/2023 09:14

I’ve been on MN a long time and ten years ago there was a long running thread by NZ bound or NZ located MNers. Everyone complained about the cold cold housing heated by heat pumps and it stuck in my brain…. Didn’t go down the pump/retrofit route despite all the pushing for it here in Ireland. To insulate, floor, retrofit , install , move out for 3 months whilst they do it etc etc etc was coming out in excess of 70k.

Toddlerteaplease · 22/02/2023 09:10

Not an option for me either. My house is just too small.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 22/02/2023 09:08

@DazzlePaintedBattlePants we put an ASHP into our 1960s house and it was toasty warm. You do have to treat it differently to a traditional boiler by having it constantly switched on in cold weather, so it kicks in if the temperature in the house falls below a certain level. Rather than the traditional twice a day option.

RosaGallica · 22/02/2023 09:05

Yes, I think the extortionate cost on top of any grant may have something to do with it. The extortionate cost of housing may also be a factor. Once we’ve finished paying 20 years worth of rent to idle landlords and then paid 4x more for housing than people just a few years older on the same wages did, there isn’t much lifetime left to scrape up this kind of money.

The majority of people in Britain have all been impoverished, and that means none of us have any money spare. I do not understand what the useless government of rich elites don’t understand about thus - they understand how to take wealth away from people well enough.

Fizbosshoes · 22/02/2023 09:04

We looked into it. Our boiler is 17 years old so likely will need replacing in the next few years...but a 5k grant was just the start of it, and the level of disruption to the house compared to a standard boiler replacement.

Swipe left for the next trending thread