Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think low take up of heat pump grants is due to more than just poor advertising.

140 replies

overitt · 22/02/2023 07:55

There's a BBC story today about low take-up of the £5k grants available for heat pump installation: www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-64710225. The criticism focuses on poor marketingnof the scheme and difficulties in funding installers, both of which are true. But I think there's more to it than that. I managed to find a potential local installer and had a telephone conversation with him. He told me about the size of the pump, the restrictions on where it could be installed in relation to neighbouring properties, and the internal infrastructure that would be needed. The picture on the BBC article illustrates it well. I would need to rebuild my kitchen to accommodate it. He also said that for the system to work effectively I would need to install interior or exterior wall insulation on my solid brick house, plus either underfloor heating or bigger radiators in all the rooms. All of thus would cost many £££££. The installer told me that for these reasons he was mostly installing heat pumps in new build homes or complete refurbishments.

Aibu to think these factors are probably a much bigger part of the reason why the scheme has low take-up than "poor advertising"?

To think low take up of heat pump grants is due to more than just poor advertising.
OP posts:
onefinemess · 25/07/2023 17:53

A heat pump is literally just an A/C unit that is put in backwards.

It produces the same amount of heat as the the mesh at the back of your fridge. The theory is that a constant supply of this "heat" inside a hermetically sealed room will gradually (over a number of days) bring the room temperature up to 1/3 of where your gas boiler would get it to. So not hot, but not really cold either, put a jumper and socks on and you might be OK, just don't sit around too much.

All this can be yours for 10k, well more like 30k by the time you pay for all the extra insulation, and new radiators, and pipes and triple glazing, and loft insulation . . .

Where do I sign up?

Roselilly36 · 25/07/2023 17:33

We looked into this, performance reviews put us off, alongside the cumbersome size of the units. We did install solar with battery back up though, pound for pound a better investment.

TodayInahurry · 25/07/2023 17:33

Neighbour has one, very noisy in the winter. Not suitable for houses close together. They are building hundreds of new houses near me, no solar on roofs and imagine no heat pumps (would put the house price up probably)

maddening · 25/07/2023 17:32

We had one costed up and the amount of electricity to run.it would cost the same as the gas we use currently- on top of the £6k cost +£5k grant to have it fitted plus possible extra replacement of radiators etc and faff - not to mention chucking a 5 year old boiler - not.worth it - I want hydrogen power personally

GasPanic · 25/07/2023 17:29

yodaforpresident · 22/02/2023 12:04

We have a ground source heat pump that we put in about 13 years ago (before the grants). Our house is over 500 years old so is mostly not insulated (areas which have been reroofed have been insulated) with single glazing and detached, rural. Even so it does work surprisingly well and our house is kept at 20/21 degrees 24/7.

It was however extremely expensive to fit - it has its own room as it takes up the space of a fridge freezer and then two water tanks of the same size, half the ground floor had underfloor heating fitted and we had to replace the radiators in the rest of the house with larger, cast iron ones. All in all I would say it cost in the region of £80k to fit it. You also need to have access to a reasonable amount of outdoor space to run the pipes to collect the heat underground. It does mean that we use a lot more electricity but still works out cheaper and more convenient than oil.

I don't see how it is a feasible option for most houses - I think the only way that it could work is if you had it as a community type heating supply, so one GSHP supplying five houses.

Did you really mean £80k and not £8k ?

How many supertankers of oil can you buy for £80k ?

ThreeLittleDots · 25/07/2023 16:44

YANBU, they're too expensive and people are still cold.

Now if there was funding for air-to-air heat pumps (blown air) that would take off, they're a fraction of the price, but currently un-funded as they can be used in air-con mode which isn't very eco.

FeinCuroxiVooz · 25/07/2023 16:40

Yanbu at all. The majority of housing stock built more than a few years ago is totally unsuitable to be retrofitted with this technology. To have it in this house we would lose at least 10% of the usable space in the house from each room getting a bit smaller due to additional insulation and radiators, and having to remodel to create a space that the infrastructure can sit in as it takes a lot more space than a combi boiler, plus would have to totally redecorate once all that is done. It simply cannot be done as a project on an occupied house. It could be done as part of a total back-to-bare-bones renovation but that would be a massive waste of money that wouldn't ever pay itself back either in reduced running costs or in increased value.

Elphame · 25/07/2023 12:52

It would cost over £50K to install a heat pump at my home. I have solid stone walls which would all need to be dry lined.

Totally unaffordable and a £5K grant is pointless.

StillWantingADog · 25/07/2023 12:30

Yanbu

we’ve just had ours installed, it’s great but it has cost us about £8k over and above the grant. We’ve had to find £13k and will get £5k back in a few weeks.
(we did need to replace the gas boiler anyway)
dh is committed to reducing our carbon footprint, our house was suitable, he had a bonus through work that paid for it.

it also made a fair mess as most of our radiators and some pipework had to be replaced.

our (excellent) installer said he is moving towards new builds and full retrofits only as just not realistic for the vast majority of families, not to mention the fact that many houses will just not be suitable.

it won’t save us money long term unlike the solar panels which definitely will (and were infinitely less faff). You need to be properly committed and WANT to do it.

re size- yes is quite big. But no bigger than the gas boiler which has now gone.

i’m a fan but atm it’s not a realistic option for the vast majority of families regardless of advertising.

MojoMoon · 23/02/2023 22:10

Bear in mind that electricity bills are subject to much higher levies than gas - despite electricity in the UK being much less carbon intensive than gas (because renewables and nuclear make up the majority of generation). So the government plans to move some of the electricity levies gradually over the gas.

So the difference in cost will narrow over time.

I have an air source heat pump - mid 1980s compact 2 bed terrace with small back yard. I have replaced the crappy single glazing with double but would have done that anyway.

This is my first winter with it, having replaced gas, and it has done really well. You do need to engage with it and learn how to run them - it's not like a a gas boiler. But my house is a very toasty 21C right now at 10pm while it is 3C outside, and my entire energy bill today so far is £3.20 and that includes running the dishwasher and boiling something on the hob.

Water cylinder got squeezed in the loft space. You can also get options like Sunamp heat batteries which fit under a kitchen worktop.

I've also now got solar - just a few panels - but I set it to heat the water cylinder whenever the sun is out so it is done for free. You can't do that with gas!

Only downside is the heat pump is a bit ugly, like an air con unit. You can get vinyl wraps in the colour of your wall/fence and then they blend in a bit more.

No, they aren't for everyone but a well designed, correctly installed one can work really well, even during the cold spell back in Dec.

NB512 · 23/02/2023 21:35

Bottom line for most people is that heat will cost more to run than gas boiler. They don't tell you this. Big cover up me thinks. Had a quote, not only had to replace all our radiators will fool to ceiling ones, but huge noisy pump, and ridiculous price. Plus high service cost. Not new technology, just a new way to flog them to people. If you are going to spend that much money, get solar heating and power, not this con from the cons. Electricity still costs 4 times more than gas. Heat pumps at most give 2.5 x energy. You are going to be paying nearly DOUBLE compared to gas !!!

DeNeushoornHeeftEenHoorn · 22/02/2023 19:18

I had top-of-the-range air-conditioning (Daikin) installed throughout my house when I bought it last summer, as it’s one of those mad mid-century houses with lots and lots of glass (Like the Eames house, but less expensive/ stylish). It was 45 degrees upstairs in the heatwave. I’m using my air-conditioning as heating this winter and it’s both super efficient at warming the place and cheap to run. Best thing I ever bought. I do have an ugly condensing unit outside my front door, though, which does look quite like a heat pump. However it runs virtually silently and bothers nobody.

overitt · 22/02/2023 19:02

@EmmaGrundyForPM there is infrastructure inside too. If you look at the picture in the op, the heat pump is on the left, the interior infrastructure is on the right.

OP posts:
EmmaGrundyForPM · 22/02/2023 16:42

JemimaTiggywinkles · 22/02/2023 12:58

I recently had a new boiler fitted. I looked into a heat pump, but with all of the extra stuff needed it was way more expensive overall, even accounting for the grant. Plus I'd lose half of my (already small) third bedroom to accommodate a heat pump, while my new gas boiler fits nicely inside the old airing cupboard.

Why would you lose your bedroom? Surely ASHP systems are outside? When we had ours installed they said we could put it almost anywhere in the garden. It actually ended up being on the back of the garage, which worked really well

TheWayTheLightFalls · 22/02/2023 13:08

Same as others - on paper ideal candidates (detached, garden space, undergoing full renovation including ufh)… and it still seems like an expensive option, initially and ongoing.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 22/02/2023 12:58

I recently had a new boiler fitted. I looked into a heat pump, but with all of the extra stuff needed it was way more expensive overall, even accounting for the grant. Plus I'd lose half of my (already small) third bedroom to accommodate a heat pump, while my new gas boiler fits nicely inside the old airing cupboard.

gogohmm · 22/02/2023 12:54

Without also installing solar panels and a battery it simply will increase our bills too much. The 10 years to pay off is too long. An interest free loan system is definitely needed as well as the grants

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 22/02/2023 12:26

Ginmonkeyagain · 22/02/2023 09:45

I rented a flat once that had electric ceiling heating - it was foils rolled out above a false ceiling and each room could be indivually controlled for temprature and timing.

We really struggled with working it and maintaing a comfotable temperatire. Lookign back I see we never really understood we probably needed to leave it on all the time with the thermostat set to the ideal temperature in each room.

I think there probably needs to be an education programme on how electric heating systems best work as most of us are used to the instant direct heat of solid fuel systems and/or wood burners.

We stayed in a holiday flat in St Ives a few times that had ceiling heating, usually in October. Lovely flat, pretty much right on the beach, large windows - got quite cold, especially in the smaller bedroom so we'd have the heating on.

You could be sat down freezing, stand up and literally feel where the heat stopped, your head would be in the warmer layer. I don't know who came up with the idea of ceiling heating, but it is one of the worst ideas ever - perhaps ceiling fans would have helped circulate the warm air? I don't know.

cobblers123 · 22/02/2023 12:26

I know someone having it done at the moment and the stress has been really hard for them.

It's being done free as they qualify for it somehow but they are at their wit's end with how long it's taking. I think they were told the cost is actually £18,000 if they had to pay for it.

I had a new combi boiler last year so I certainly wouldn't be in the market for one any time soon thank goodness.

Pasithean · 22/02/2023 12:25

2 of our neighbours had it installed. Old solid stone buildings. Continuously breaking down and insufficient heat.

WorkingFromHomeRocks · 22/02/2023 12:20

We’ve only got an ASHP because we live in a new build. We could never have had one in our old house (1950s ex council house semi)

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 22/02/2023 12:15

My FIL is an architect and he says they're brilliant - in new builds.

We had a new boiler fitted last year, I looked briefly at this scheme, but the cost just for it to be fitted would have been too expensive even with the grant, plus to actually get anything out of it we'd have had to replace all our double glazing at the very least - which if we could afford to do it, we'd have already done (35+ yr old aluminium frames that you can feel sucking the heat out of the room plus some of the seals have gone and there is condensation in the double glazing).

Just switching to a combi was getting on for £4,000.

I did chat to the gas engineer about it, he said he'd go for solar panels over retro-fitting a heat pump.

taxguru · 22/02/2023 12:14

I think it's an environmental disaster to retrofit them when it involves lots of digging, new radiators/pipework, potentially new flooring, redecoration, new kitchens, etc. How much damage does all that unnecessary work do to the environment in terms of pollution (of mining and transport of the raw materials, the manufacturing process, recycling/disposal of items removed, etc)?

I think it's a no brainer for new homes that are built around heat pumps but it can't be good for the environment to have all that pollution and use of scarce resources to retrofit to a system that actually works as it stands.

As for grants, they just encourage the cowboys, as we've seen with solar installations, cavity wall insulation, etc., where you get firms being set up solely to benefit from the grants, and existing firms put up their prices because they know their customers are getting subsidised.

BigBunkers · 22/02/2023 12:08

I work for a company that installs them on new builds. £5K doesn’t touch the sides in terms of costs, even on a well insulated new build let alone retro fitting them

yodaforpresident · 22/02/2023 12:04

We have a ground source heat pump that we put in about 13 years ago (before the grants). Our house is over 500 years old so is mostly not insulated (areas which have been reroofed have been insulated) with single glazing and detached, rural. Even so it does work surprisingly well and our house is kept at 20/21 degrees 24/7.

It was however extremely expensive to fit - it has its own room as it takes up the space of a fridge freezer and then two water tanks of the same size, half the ground floor had underfloor heating fitted and we had to replace the radiators in the rest of the house with larger, cast iron ones. All in all I would say it cost in the region of £80k to fit it. You also need to have access to a reasonable amount of outdoor space to run the pipes to collect the heat underground. It does mean that we use a lot more electricity but still works out cheaper and more convenient than oil.

I don't see how it is a feasible option for most houses - I think the only way that it could work is if you had it as a community type heating supply, so one GSHP supplying five houses.

Swipe left for the next trending thread