Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think low take up of heat pump grants is due to more than just poor advertising.

140 replies

overitt · 22/02/2023 07:55

There's a BBC story today about low take-up of the £5k grants available for heat pump installation: www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-64710225. The criticism focuses on poor marketingnof the scheme and difficulties in funding installers, both of which are true. But I think there's more to it than that. I managed to find a potential local installer and had a telephone conversation with him. He told me about the size of the pump, the restrictions on where it could be installed in relation to neighbouring properties, and the internal infrastructure that would be needed. The picture on the BBC article illustrates it well. I would need to rebuild my kitchen to accommodate it. He also said that for the system to work effectively I would need to install interior or exterior wall insulation on my solid brick house, plus either underfloor heating or bigger radiators in all the rooms. All of thus would cost many £££££. The installer told me that for these reasons he was mostly installing heat pumps in new build homes or complete refurbishments.

Aibu to think these factors are probably a much bigger part of the reason why the scheme has low take-up than "poor advertising"?

To think low take up of heat pump grants is due to more than just poor advertising.
OP posts:
Errolwasahero · 26/07/2023 08:13

It seems to me that many/most/all of these wonderful saviours aren’t all they’re being made up to be. I smell £s being burned in the name of greenwashing.

Kazzyhoward · 26/07/2023 07:58

Apart from them being too big and requiring too much space and changes to the house, I'd rather gouge out my eyeballs than have the thought of workmen all over my house and garden installing the damn thing.

There are already lots of jobs that need doing, but I just can't face having them in the house, the mess, the disruption, the inevitable being messed around, etc.

Yes, a few are respectful and considerate and honest, but they're the minority.

I can just about cope with them for short/limited jobs, but for something as big as a heat pump, with all it entails, it's a big fat no from me. Even if the grants covered 100% of the cost, I wouldn't do it.

They just should make it compulsory to have them installed in new builds and part of planning permission when people are doing major alterations/extensions.

Tatzelwyrm · 26/07/2023 07:56

I think they may be like the hot air heating like they did in the 1970s. Awful and too prone to flaws and not the all wonderful saviour that it's thought to be

WishIwasElsa · 26/07/2023 07:51

I know someone in council property who had one fitted they told me the radiators are barely warm and it's costing a lot in electricity so as a consequence can barely afford to heat their home. So I wouldn't want to pay out for it.

InstantGratificationDarkPlaygroundOfMN · 26/07/2023 07:44
  1. You have to pay half iirc?
  2. You need good insulation
  3. it costs more to run

so me - in an old, damp, draughty terrace on low income = no chance
I have neither the cash nor a suitable home to install it.

NamelessNancy · 26/07/2023 07:38

NB512 · 23/02/2023 21:35

Bottom line for most people is that heat will cost more to run than gas boiler. They don't tell you this. Big cover up me thinks. Had a quote, not only had to replace all our radiators will fool to ceiling ones, but huge noisy pump, and ridiculous price. Plus high service cost. Not new technology, just a new way to flog them to people. If you are going to spend that much money, get solar heating and power, not this con from the cons. Electricity still costs 4 times more than gas. Heat pumps at most give 2.5 x energy. You are going to be paying nearly DOUBLE compared to gas !!!

This in spades. We have one which works well and uses less kWh per annum than the old gas system by a long way BUT because the cost of electricity is four times that of gas our bills are much higher.

If the government want to encourage ashp installation there needs to be a change in pricing. About 40% of electricity comes from gas, yet the price is pegged to the price of gas so any increases there are four fold for electricity.

MintJulia · 26/07/2023 07:05

@maddening very pretty, but not terribly useful when I need to keep my house warm on a frosty December night, after the gas boiler ban.

maddening · 25/07/2023 23:50

MintJulia · 25/07/2023 19:33

I have room for a ground source heat pump. My house (1890) has been well insulated. I already have a log burner as backup heat. When the last gas boiler finally died, I had a quote for a GSHP.

It would cost £29k including changing all the pipework, radiators etc. With the grant, £24k. A new gas boiler & installation cost me £2k. The GSHP would have to save me £2.5k + interest per year (assuming a 10 year lifespan) , to be worth getting a loan & buying it now. That's more than my whole utilities bill.

So I've set up a savings account. It'll take me 6 or 7 years to save £25k. I'll be ready to buy it in 2030 or 2031, in time for the deadline, and when my current boiler dies.

Marketing has nothing to do with it.

If I had £29k I would want this https://smartflower.com/

The Solar Flower You Need to Experience — Smartflower

Smartflower is the innovative sculptural solar flower with advanced photovoltaic solar panels that open and close to cleaning itself for maximum efficiency.

https://smartflower.com

StillWantingADog · 25/07/2023 19:39

TodayInahurry · 25/07/2023 17:33

Neighbour has one, very noisy in the winter. Not suitable for houses close together. They are building hundreds of new houses near me, no solar on roofs and imagine no heat pumps (would put the house price up probably)

They got the wrong type then. Ours is very quiet. Certainly quieter than the boiler and you have to put your ear right up to it to hear it.

the most important thing to do with regards a heat pump is to do proper research and get a proper installer.

MintJulia · 25/07/2023 19:33

I have room for a ground source heat pump. My house (1890) has been well insulated. I already have a log burner as backup heat. When the last gas boiler finally died, I had a quote for a GSHP.

It would cost £29k including changing all the pipework, radiators etc. With the grant, £24k. A new gas boiler & installation cost me £2k. The GSHP would have to save me £2.5k + interest per year (assuming a 10 year lifespan) , to be worth getting a loan & buying it now. That's more than my whole utilities bill.

So I've set up a savings account. It'll take me 6 or 7 years to save £25k. I'll be ready to buy it in 2030 or 2031, in time for the deadline, and when my current boiler dies.

Marketing has nothing to do with it.

CreeperBoom · 25/07/2023 18:35

I was really keen to get a heat pump when my oil boiler was due to be replaced (no mains gas).

After getting quotes though, it would take 18 years before the savings to run it paid for the installation, even with the grant. We would have being paying the loan off for 10 years. I just don't believe that it won't drop in price/improve in efficiency dramatically in the next 10 years, so I reluctantly decided to go oil again, and wait.

TonTonMacoute · 25/07/2023 18:32

Our house is also totally unsuitable and we would have to spend a absolute fortune. We are having all our windows replaced with more efficient double glazing and although it will be expensive it's a fraction of the cost.

I live in a isolated village in Cornwall and we recently clubbed together to have a defibrillator fitted in the old phone box. The chap from Western Power, who came to install it said that if everyone in the village got an EV and switched from oil to electricity for heating and cooking (no mains gas), then it wouldn't be possible with the current infrastructure to get enough electricity into the village to meet the need. There are so many problems with many of the proposals to reach net zero that are not being addressed.

FeinCuroxiVooz · 25/07/2023 18:28

@GasPanic I think £80k is about right for ground-source - which is different from the air source heat pump that is being pushed more widely.

@yodaforpresident's experience sounds very similar to our friends' (you may even be them - if so hi) - a ground source heat pump works by effectively creating a "fridge" effect to cool down a nearby or underground stream of water and uses the heat generated by that to warm the house. Whereas the air source uses the fridge effect to cool down the surrounding air and uses the heat to warm the house. I think ground source technology is more efficient but obviously most properties can't use it as you need a suitable ground source. The properties that have the location and the space to use it tend to have really terrible insulation so the projects to modernise them are £££££

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 25/07/2023 18:27

StatisticallyChallenged · 25/07/2023 18:20

The cost is prohibitive for most, as are the practicalities of installing but we have one (new build) and it heats our house absolutely fine. My thermostat sits at 20/21 all the time and it maintains that no problem

Yes my parents house is actually a nice temperature, to be fair. Certainly not needing jumpers

Yuasa · 25/07/2023 18:27

TodayInahurry · 25/07/2023 17:33

Neighbour has one, very noisy in the winter. Not suitable for houses close together. They are building hundreds of new houses near me, no solar on roofs and imagine no heat pumps (would put the house price up probably)

I’m dreading neighbours getting heat pumps. Terraced and semis with postage stamp gardens - the idea of each one having one of these things going is horrendous.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 25/07/2023 18:26

My parents made use of the grant and got the heat pump Installed etc. I think they also got some kind of loan grant to repay as well as the 5k grant
But anyway on total it was more like 20-30k to Install I believe.

"Average" People (including me) just dont have that kind of money so it's never going to work.

Yuasa · 25/07/2023 18:23

Ruining Victorian house with insulation.

Ugly humming box in garden. (Maybe two from what I’ve read as the house has attic and basement!)

Losing space inside to a massive tank and other apparatus.

Huge radiators.

Less warm.

More costly to run.

Seriously - they couldn’t pay me to accept the above, let alone have me pay for the pleasure. A relatively small amount off the huge outlay is almost a joke.

I lived in the US as a child and we had big central air units that seem similar to the outdoor pump units. The difference was that houses and gardens there were far bigger so everyone had them down the side of the house where they weren’t a nuisance.

I’d consider a heat pump here if I had a similar set-up: plenty of space and modern house. I don’t and I just pray the technology moves on.

AnkleWidget · 25/07/2023 18:21

The loops installers have to jump through to get the funding are ridiculous and very little of it based around actual training in installation of the systems.

Plus I don’t think they are the way forward long term for this country.

StatisticallyChallenged · 25/07/2023 18:20

onefinemess · 25/07/2023 17:53

A heat pump is literally just an A/C unit that is put in backwards.

It produces the same amount of heat as the the mesh at the back of your fridge. The theory is that a constant supply of this "heat" inside a hermetically sealed room will gradually (over a number of days) bring the room temperature up to 1/3 of where your gas boiler would get it to. So not hot, but not really cold either, put a jumper and socks on and you might be OK, just don't sit around too much.

All this can be yours for 10k, well more like 30k by the time you pay for all the extra insulation, and new radiators, and pipes and triple glazing, and loft insulation . . .

Where do I sign up?

The cost is prohibitive for most, as are the practicalities of installing but we have one (new build) and it heats our house absolutely fine. My thermostat sits at 20/21 all the time and it maintains that no problem

Abitofalark · 25/07/2023 18:20

There was an informative article in The Sunday Times a couple of weeks ago about heat pumps, solar panels and other measures to reduce energy use, covering performance, price etc. It was in the Home section, I think. The cost of heat pumps, even with the grant, seems steep.

2bazookas · 25/07/2023 18:17

@pussycatinfluffyslippers ·
Have you noticed a big difference in performance/fuel cost with your new gs boiler? what sort did you go for? We're thinking of doing the same but the service engineers says the old one is better than many new models and we should run it till it dies.

HorseyMel · 25/07/2023 18:15

This is how I think about it:

  • How many gallons of 50-60 degree water does a house full of radiators take?
  • How much air would a fan need to suck in and extract heat from to get that kind of heat? How much now when the air is 12 degrees? What about winter when the air is near zero? Air is something like 800 times less dense than water.
  • To suck in and process that volume of air, that's surely going to take a lot of fan work and processing? Which all uses electric.

I'm not an engineer so I can't do the calculations, but I can't get it past my common sense filter. Maybe I should stop thinking and just trust the salesmen experts................?

WhatADrabCarpet · 25/07/2023 18:10

They are prohibitively expensive to install.

New builds won't install them.

Says it all really.

CrazyCatLady13 · 25/07/2023 18:10

I meant we only used one oil filled radiator before we had the heating fitted 😊

CrazyCatLady13 · 25/07/2023 18:08

I had one fitted for free last year, due to my health & the house only having storage heaters it was fully funded. They did a few in the area at the same time after going door to door to speak to people.

It replaced the old water cylinder & the rest of the internal bits are fixed to the wall in the airing cupboard so it doesn't take up much space. The outside box is no problem on the drive either, we've lost about a foot of the drive.

For the first time in years we were cozy all winter 😊 it does cost us more in electric as we only used one oil filled radiator, but for us it's worth it.