Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to just put her back in nappies?? It’s been over 6 months…

58 replies

TwinkleStarWhatAre · 22/02/2023 02:30

I’m really lost on what to do. My DD is almost 3. I’ve realised that we have been potty training now since August and she still has wee accidents every single day!!

I’m just exhausted. She’s an incredibly strong willed child and I feel like I’ve tried everything -

Constant reminders (it is always a ‘no’ even if she then wets herself 5 minutes later)
Sticker charts and a sticker every time she uses toilet or potty and no accident (with a super special sparkly sticker if she goes a whole day which we’ve never been able to use since I introduced it 3 weeks ago as she literally wets herself every day)
A potty alarm which she loved but that became an issue as she literally wouldn’t go for a wee when she needed it as she wanted the alarm to go off and turn it off herself
A phone app where she had a call from ‘Rachel’ when she went for a wee which was very exciting and initially helped her ‘get’ using a potty back in September.
Physically putting her on the potty or toilet every hour (this seems to work the best as I always get a wee out of her usually, but the problem is after she’s had a drink. I have a younger baby and I’m just overwhelmed in general on a daily basis caring for them both while DH is at work, and I miss timings after she’s had a drink as then I need to do it every 30 minutes and even then I could miss it)

She has been fully trained for poos pretty much the whole 6 months. No issue. It’s just wees.

She just seems to not be aware when she has the need to wee? She only realises after some has come out. Half the time she doesn’t even care her pants and trousers are wet, the other half she announces she’s had an accident or just removed her trousers and pants herself and does the rest of it.

She’s much better when we’re out and about weirdly enough. She’s only had three accidents when out, once at toddler group and twice on a walk. Although we don’t really go out much longer than an hour at a time so could just be luck.

She starts nursery next month. They said they can help with potty training if I need it. I just don’t want to have to send her in every day with 4 pairs or pants and trousers!

I’ve been reluctant to put her back in nappies as everyone’s said just keep at it, don’t go backwards you’ll confuse her, etc. but I am so stressed out about this. I’m awake at 2.30am just because of this - baby is fast asleep and hasn’t woken for a feed yet but im posting this on mumsnet as i cannot sleep because of it.

Please help. And please don’t suggest family and friends for help as I have no one.

OP posts:
Fixyourself · 22/02/2023 03:41

Stop putting her on the potty all the time . Putting her on and making her wee when her bladder isn't full yet sends mixed signals. You are not giving her a chance to listen to her own body.
Spend a few days at home and don't mention the word potty. Take the pressure off her completely. If she has an accident then just change her and don't make a big deal out of it.

Brown888 · 22/02/2023 03:33

*able

Brown888 · 22/02/2023 03:32

Another vote here for back to nappies.
When a child is not ready they are not ready. DS is 2y8m, and still happy to sit in poop and wet clothes without a word so I haven't tried potty training. We talk about it and he's aware of what a potty is etc but ill try when he's older and more are to understand.

Alex Drake · 22/02/2023 03:19

I attempted potty training at your DD age and promptly gave up as my DS was clearly not ready, straight back to pull ups!

Poos we're 90% on the toilet from around 3yrs (never a potty, he preferred the toilet).

He continued in pull up pants until about 3.5 yrs when he just started asking to use the toilet both at home and at nursery. Once he started to ask we switched him over to big boy pants and he was absolutely fine, not a single accident. When they know, they know.

jjeoreo · 22/02/2023 03:18

I think if would be a shame to put her back in nappies if she's got the poos cracked- I think that could be confusing.

For some reason failing at potty training feels like a MASSIVE deal and directly related to your ability as a parent (which it isn't, btw, but it's a classic 2.30 in the morning thought when you're already tired and fretting).

I do wonder if relaxing a bit might yield better results. I.e trusting her a bit more to go when she wants to. She will know its a big deal to you given the sticker charts, apps, etc and it may have become a bit of a power play if she's stubborn.

Have you read "Oh Crap!"? She's got a good insight into the psychology of potty training if I recall.

Madmax1992 · 22/02/2023 03:09

If she's having accidents every day then she's not ready to go nappy free...did the same thing with Ds and tried to make it Happen when he wasn't ready. In the end I put him back in Nappies and now and again would just have naply free time with the potty out in the front room and he started doing it without being asked ...he was 3 5 when we were able to go a day without an accident xx

ukholidayseeker · 22/02/2023 02:58

She's only 2 ☹️ Too young. Try again in August hen it's good weather.

Beepbopadooda · 22/02/2023 02:55

I've been where you are. My 6 year old was an absolute nightmare to train when he was nearly 3 and I had a baby at the same time too. He is also incredibly strong willed and bright and everything has to be on his terms. I would personally say no to going back to nappies as it might confuse your daughter especially when she's pooing fine and okay when out and about. Can you try scrapping all reminders and seeing what happens? What is she drinking? Blackcurrant and orange squash are diuretics but peach squash ok. My son needed a potty really close to him wherever he was playing and over time we moved it gradually away towards the downstairs loo. Another thing he responded to was buying pants with characters on and explaining they didn't want to be wet etc. Lastly have you checked she's fully emptying each time, after she goes ask her to remain on potty for 30 secs after and see if she had any more wee to come. Sorry if you've tried all of this, I feel so desperately for you. Probably not what you want to hear but I promise it's not forever. My son didn't fully "get it" until he was 3.5 and I truly believe it was because he was just too busy wanting to play to care etc. There's no concerns now, he never wets himself.