Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to just put her back in nappies?? It’s been over 6 months…

58 replies

TwinkleStarWhatAre · 22/02/2023 02:30

I’m really lost on what to do. My DD is almost 3. I’ve realised that we have been potty training now since August and she still has wee accidents every single day!!

I’m just exhausted. She’s an incredibly strong willed child and I feel like I’ve tried everything -

Constant reminders (it is always a ‘no’ even if she then wets herself 5 minutes later)
Sticker charts and a sticker every time she uses toilet or potty and no accident (with a super special sparkly sticker if she goes a whole day which we’ve never been able to use since I introduced it 3 weeks ago as she literally wets herself every day)
A potty alarm which she loved but that became an issue as she literally wouldn’t go for a wee when she needed it as she wanted the alarm to go off and turn it off herself
A phone app where she had a call from ‘Rachel’ when she went for a wee which was very exciting and initially helped her ‘get’ using a potty back in September.
Physically putting her on the potty or toilet every hour (this seems to work the best as I always get a wee out of her usually, but the problem is after she’s had a drink. I have a younger baby and I’m just overwhelmed in general on a daily basis caring for them both while DH is at work, and I miss timings after she’s had a drink as then I need to do it every 30 minutes and even then I could miss it)

She has been fully trained for poos pretty much the whole 6 months. No issue. It’s just wees.

She just seems to not be aware when she has the need to wee? She only realises after some has come out. Half the time she doesn’t even care her pants and trousers are wet, the other half she announces she’s had an accident or just removed her trousers and pants herself and does the rest of it.

She’s much better when we’re out and about weirdly enough. She’s only had three accidents when out, once at toddler group and twice on a walk. Although we don’t really go out much longer than an hour at a time so could just be luck.

She starts nursery next month. They said they can help with potty training if I need it. I just don’t want to have to send her in every day with 4 pairs or pants and trousers!

I’ve been reluctant to put her back in nappies as everyone’s said just keep at it, don’t go backwards you’ll confuse her, etc. but I am so stressed out about this. I’m awake at 2.30am just because of this - baby is fast asleep and hasn’t woken for a feed yet but im posting this on mumsnet as i cannot sleep because of it.

Please help. And please don’t suggest family and friends for help as I have no one.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
anomaly23 · 22/02/2023 13:37

Ds had just turned 2 when he went straight onto the toilet, dd was 2.5 and was dry and and night but her brother wasn't dry at night until he was 5. No accidents from either of them.

I would go back in nappies just now and try again in a month or 2.

musicforthesoul · 22/02/2023 12:05

I'd get her to help with the cleanup after she's had an accident, ie putting the clothes in the laundry, getting the fresh ones out and helping with wiping up anything on the floor etc (obviously with your help/supervision).

Not like a punishment, more just as the consequences of making a mess is to help tidy it up.

If she is just avoiding going to the loo so she doesn't have to interrupt play it'll stop it as it will be more hassle to wet herself than to just go to the toilet.

If no change maybe she genuinely doesn't know when she needs to go so worth going back to nappies for a bit

cadburyegg · 22/02/2023 11:56

BritInAus · 22/02/2023 07:57

She doesn't sound at all ready. Some kids are at 2. Some much later. Why go through the agro of accidents every single day? Say she'll be ready at 3.5 years old. You can either start at 2, and have 18 months of wet underwear etc, or start at 3.5, and have it done in a week.

100% agree with this.

I tried twice with DS1 before he turned 3, didn't work. Constant accidents, toilet refusal. Had a break for his sake but also ours as DS2 was born. Tried again when he was 3y 3m. He got it within a week.

With DS2 I didn't bother trying before he turned 3, I took May half term off work when he was 3y 2m and potty trained then. He got it within a few days. His key worker was shocked when he went back to preschool the week after completely dry.

Handful of accidents since for both of them and no toileting issues or problems. I have at least 3 friends who boasted about their kids being out of nappies at 2 but they had constant accidents and other issues sometimes over a year later.

TangledWebOfDeception · 22/02/2023 11:48

Thefaceofboe · 22/02/2023 03:48

She's only 2 ☹️ Too young. Try again in August hen it's good weather

2 (almost 3) is absolutely not too young

It most definitely is for some children! They don't come out as cookie cutter toddlers all with exactly the same abilities at exactly the same age. 🙄

AGoldenNarwhal · 22/02/2023 11:45

BritInAus · 22/02/2023 07:57

She doesn't sound at all ready. Some kids are at 2. Some much later. Why go through the agro of accidents every single day? Say she'll be ready at 3.5 years old. You can either start at 2, and have 18 months of wet underwear etc, or start at 3.5, and have it done in a week.

I agree with this. For lots of kids, it just gets easier as they get older. I tried with DC1 at 2.5. Three weeks of constant accidents. We tried again at 3.1. He got it easily. He only had a handful of accidents in the day after the first few weeks. Being dry at night has taken much longer though.

When DC2 is ready to start, our approach will be to go with the flow and wait until they are ready. It is really not worth the constant stress and missing days out. There are other, more worthwhile things for they and you to be concentrating on.

And I can't stress how much I disagree with any shaming/'telling-off' for accidents or toileting issues. This will just stress them and you out. Any accidents should be dealt with matter-of-factly without any comment. If you can't hide your annoyance because it's so stressful, it's definitely less harmful for your DC to go back into nappies.

Justcashnosweets · 22/02/2023 08:49

Absolutely put her back in nappies! Don't keep trying if its causing her stress, thats a surefire way to long term toilet issues. And I say that as this happened to some of my friends. Dd was out of nappies at 3, almost 4, as any attempts to do so before were awful. She became so stressed that she would become hysterical. When we did decide it was time, we didn't make a fuss, we told her the day before that there would be no more nappies, and really made as little fuss as possible. Thankfully this worked and she had cracked it within 24 hours.
I know the popular opinion is that all children should be out of nappies by the age of 2, but thats just not realistic. Every child is different, and your DD will get there when she is ready.

Fundays12 · 22/02/2023 08:23

Dc3 started going through phases of wetting himself daily after being fully trained from just after his 2nd birthday (he was 3 years 3 months). The pre school nursery recommend getting him checked for a UTI. It turned out he did have one and couldn't feel when he needed to pee so I would suggest getting her checked first before putting her back in nappies

Twizbe · 22/02/2023 08:19

My DD tried to do that. She'd do a little dribble and demand a sticker.

We set the expectation that she had to do a 'big wee' to get a sticker.

TwinkleStarWhatAre · 22/02/2023 08:17

She also cracked poos after about 2 weeks of potty training back in September! Super quick and no issues since. It’s just wees

OP posts:
TwinkleStarWhatAre · 22/02/2023 08:16

Thank you all for your responses, I cannot tell you how much I needed this!

She’s 3 in a month so I feel like it would be silly to stop trying now?

I think I’m going to try and stay in for a few days, have her in just a long top so no bottoms, and just ignore the potty, and just celebrate when she does a wee. Yes, I can see how keep putting her on the potty means she’s not going to be listening to her body so will try and avoid that now.

If by next week no improvement, I shall try the chocolate button idea. However, I know what she will do - she’s just gonna keep going and doing a tiny drop of wee just to get a chocolate button. How best to navigate this situation and not end up with her eating bags every day? 🤣

OP posts:
londonrach · 22/02/2023 08:04

Can't believe you done this so long. She's only two!!! Please please put her back in nappies. She not ready. My DD learnt just before third birthday...no accident..she told me she wanted to wear pants and I did as she asked. There's no rush to do it before. Had a friend like you who did it with her first at 2 and her dd wet herself and had severe issues with poo with holding .. her second a boy she didn't bother did he asked. Pop back in nappies and wait a few months

berksandbeyond · 22/02/2023 07:59

ItchyBillco · 22/02/2023 07:56

How is almost three ‘way too young’ according to some posters?

It’s not way too young but it clearly was 6 months ago when they started as the child was obviously not ready!

I drained DD the month before she turned 3 and it took less than 2 weeks. When they’re ready they’re ready. She has been dry through the night since 3 too. They’re all different

BritInAus · 22/02/2023 07:58

berksandbeyond · 22/02/2023 07:54

You started way too early and you’ve kept going way too long. If she wasn’t getting it after 2 weeks you should have stopped and gone back to nappies then tried again a couple of months later - you’ve probably made it more difficult by yourself and her by keeping going when she’s so clearly not been ready. Stop now. Nappy back on. Try again in 8 weeks or so. If she doesn’t get it in 2 weeks? Nappy back on

This!!

BritInAus · 22/02/2023 07:57

She doesn't sound at all ready. Some kids are at 2. Some much later. Why go through the agro of accidents every single day? Say she'll be ready at 3.5 years old. You can either start at 2, and have 18 months of wet underwear etc, or start at 3.5, and have it done in a week.

ItchyBillco · 22/02/2023 07:56

How is almost three ‘way too young’ according to some posters?

ItchyBillco · 22/02/2023 07:55

ukholidayseeker · 22/02/2023 02:58

She's only 2 ☹️ Too young. Try again in August hen it's good weather.

It’s not too young at all. And don’t put her back in nappies, that will confuse her now.

I think her starting nursery will help. Either being surrounded by other toilet trained children and staff who offer toilet trips a lot, or peer pressure.

berksandbeyond · 22/02/2023 07:54

You started way too early and you’ve kept going way too long. If she wasn’t getting it after 2 weeks you should have stopped and gone back to nappies then tried again a couple of months later - you’ve probably made it more difficult by yourself and her by keeping going when she’s so clearly not been ready. Stop now. Nappy back on. Try again in 8 weeks or so. If she doesn’t get it in 2 weeks? Nappy back on

Beseen22 · 22/02/2023 07:45

My youngest didn't seem to 'just click' like other children and his big brother did. It's definitely been a process. He hated the constant pressure and reward charts and is incredibly private so when I put too much pressure on he started hiding in cupboards to poop when he had been previously sorted for months. The only thing that worked was habitually putting him on the toilet everytime I went (around every 3h). Any more than that he became resistant to the idea and tantrummed about it. I didn't want it to become a negative thing, I disagree with people saying to give them in to trouble, if you follow any of the Eric stuff for incontinence a lot of it is taking away shame around toileting. If he is wet he has to take his own trousers off and pop them into the washing then get some paper towels to help me clean up any spills, our conversation is very neutral at that time 'oh dear, these are wet pants, what do we need to do to sort this?'

He is speech delayed and still doesn't really ask to go to the toilet much because I still just take him but is dry and in pants all the time, even at nursery where I believe they can just take themselves. Had a wee set back everytime someone else looked after him because they didn't believe me that he hated praise and attention and just wanted to quickly pee and get off.

Danneigh · 22/02/2023 07:35

I personally wouldn't go back to nappies at the age of almost 3. Do you have floor's that can ve easily cleaned or carpets? If the likes of wooden floors or tiles, spend a few days back to back at home without needing to go out and leave her in a long vest (covering her bits of course). Mine both didn't like to wet themselves when they only had a vest on because they'd actually feel the wee on them rather than it absorbing into clothes, and after about 4 days at home like this both of them took to it and stopped having accidents. DS was 2.5 and DD was almost 2.

ProbablyRomanticised · 22/02/2023 07:32

Oh, brightbots were the other brand we used! They were brilliant and still seem to be going.

ProbablyRomanticised · 22/02/2023 07:30

I was going to say, don't they do training pants any more? We used imsy vimsy back in the day.

They have an absorbent pad - not enough for a whole week but enough for a dribble. My youngest son was in them til 5 - he is probably a bit dyspraxic with poor body awareness and never realized he needed a wee until the last second.

My daughter had a two hourly ipad alarm telling her to wee - she used this for about 3 weeks and then she was fine on her own, but it sounds like you may have tried this.

I really wouldn't go back to nappies.

MotherofBingo · 22/02/2023 07:25

Look up training pants on amazon, they are slightly absorbant but not totally so she will need to keep up with the poos but might save some clothes while she's still getting the hang of wees. Don't panic - my eldest daughter was 3.5 years old before she was potty trained (we started at 18 months so it was 2 years for us!) Like you, we tried everything.

Please, please don't get cross with her for accidents it's not fair on her and it can also have the opposite effect. The only people who have ever told my youngest off for accidents, also happen to be the only people she has accidents around (and screams and cries if we are going to see them because she doesn't like them because they've told her off in the past). It won't be something she's doing on purpose to wind you up, she's just very young and just learning.

SunshineAndFizz · 22/02/2023 07:23

We also used chocolate buttons.

Eventually we also moved to a treat if they filled a whole row on their chart. We got them to pick something, a small toy, beforehand so they could visualise what they'd be getting. Worked really well.

Dacadactyl · 22/02/2023 07:21

Drinkinggreentea · 22/02/2023 03:49

I wouldn't go back to nappies with her being nearly three. I was having a similar problem with my daughter when she was two and a half but my hairdresser gave me some great advice which sounds horrible and mean but was extremely effective and sorted out the problem almost straight away.

Once they've had a few successful wees on the potty at that age (which sounds like the case) you can get a bit cross with them for weeing themselves. I know people on here will not agree with this but what you're doing obviously isn't working so you could at least try it.

Give her lots of praise about being a big girl who's going to nursery soon and explain that at nursery you have to go to the toilet/potty. Keep up the praise when she does wee or poo on the potty but if you ask her if she needs a wee, she says no and then wees her pants a few minutes later treat it as though she's being naughty because that's what babies do and big girls at nursery don't do that. If she thinks it's not acceptable it will make her think a bit more before doing it again.

Do what feels right for you but this worked so, so quickly with mine and a couple of weeks later she was dry at night too. It'll be obvious within a week or two whether this method is working or not.

Good luck anyway, you sound exhausted. This phase will pass.

I was given much the same advice from a childminder at a playgroup. She had 4 of her own kids so knew what she was on about, although I'm not sure whether she did the same with her "minded" children....but I would suspect so.

She told me to leave DD in wet clothes for a few minutes longer than I would have otherwise and also to get her to help clearing up the wee on the floor.

She was potty trained quickly once I implemented this advice.

TiredandLate · 22/02/2023 07:21

My dd had a horrendous year of illness after starting nursery at 2, so I didn't start potty training until she had turned 3. It clicked straight away (absolutely no skill on my part) I just think being that little bit older helped her understand.

I'd be tempted to go back to nappies for a month and 'reset', then start again. She's getting older and might dislike having a nappy change like the baby does?