Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mocking Christianity

603 replies

Ihatepcos · 21/02/2023 20:45

I am so sick of people thinking it's okay to ridicule Catholicism and Christianity. This is especially apparent on Mumsnet. Every time there's a thread about religion I can't even read the replies because they're so awful.

The same doesn't seem to apply to the Muslim, Jewish, Hindu faiths etc.

If you don't believe in God that is your choice. But purposely mocking someone's faith and calling it a load of bullshit (and worse) is just not acceptable. So many people turn to faith to help them through extremely tough times in life and you are mocking the only thing that is keeping them going.

OP posts:
pointythings · 26/02/2023 20:43

PMforcodetomywevibe · 26/02/2023 20:39

Would you think it was ok to criticise an entire race? Or a gender? Or a sex?Probably not? So it shouldn’t really be ok to make a generalisation criticising an entire religion?

Nice false equivalence there. You're comparing traits you cannot change to something you absolutely can, and the criticism (as has been explained on here ad nauseam) is intended for the religious organisation and the things it is responsible for, not its adherents (though to be fair if confronted by someone who told me they genuinely supported the persecution, torture and in some cases murder of LGBT people in the name of God I would politely tell them that I did not think their morals were very good).

Criticising a religious organisation is equivalent to criticising a political party. Do you have a problem with that?

PMforcodetomywevibe · 26/02/2023 20:39

pointythings · 26/02/2023 20:08

Riiiiiight. So we shouldn't be allowed to post criticism of organised religion. Got it. Any other freedoms of speech you want to remove while you're at it?

Would you think it was ok to criticise an entire race? Or a gender? Or a sex?Probably not? So it shouldn’t really be ok to make a generalisation criticising an entire religion?

pointythings · 26/02/2023 20:08

PMforcodetomywevibe · 26/02/2023 19:34

I agree OP there is a lot of negativity to religions. mN central should really be stamping out this ‘xenophobic’ content before it gets posted!
it’s irritating that people can just have an opinion without mocking each others religions

Riiiiiight. So we shouldn't be allowed to post criticism of organised religion. Got it. Any other freedoms of speech you want to remove while you're at it?

SerendipityJane · 26/02/2023 19:38

I was intrigued at a Brian Cox show years ago that he quite happily debated the simulation discussion seriously. Which has also happened on at least one "Monkey Cage" I've heard.

Ultimately if we are in a simulation, we may never know it. But if we are in a simulation, maybe "woo" is simply parts of the program crashing or acting in an indeterminate or undefined way. Maybe "ghosts" are simply memory locations that weren't cleared properly.

An amusing thought is that some of the oddities noticed by scientists are simply parts of the simulation the designers hadn't quite gotten round to. And when we notice them, they fix them just to fuck with our minds. Maybe there really was cold fusion - until our overseers spotted their mistake and fixed it.

I know - by the rules of this simulation at least - that it's entirely possible to ask questions that can't be answered. And that can be shown mathematically. If anyone wants to propose gods existence, that's where I would start.

FatOaf · 26/02/2023 19:36

mN central should really be stamping out this ‘xenophobic’ content before it gets posted!

How can they do anything about it before it's posted?

PMforcodetomywevibe · 26/02/2023 19:34

I agree OP there is a lot of negativity to religions. mN central should really be stamping out this ‘xenophobic’ content before it gets posted!
it’s irritating that people can just have an opinion without mocking each others religions

OMG12 · 26/02/2023 19:23

Notwavingbutsignalling · 26/02/2023 19:04

@OMG12

thats given me a horrible thought.

Maybe another civilisation has taken a look at us and said what a bloody mess, how do we start to organise this?

Lets use a computer to tidy things up. Put it all on a spreadsheet and then we hand that out to the relevant departments

www.simulation-argument.com/simulation

cakeorwine · 26/02/2023 19:13

Notwavingbutsignalling · 26/02/2023 19:04

@OMG12

thats given me a horrible thought.

Maybe another civilisation has taken a look at us and said what a bloody mess, how do we start to organise this?

Lets use a computer to tidy things up. Put it all on a spreadsheet and then we hand that out to the relevant departments

Maybe we are an experiment and the Vogons have been tasked with destroying it?

Notwavingbutsignalling · 26/02/2023 19:04

@OMG12

thats given me a horrible thought.

Maybe another civilisation has taken a look at us and said what a bloody mess, how do we start to organise this?

Lets use a computer to tidy things up. Put it all on a spreadsheet and then we hand that out to the relevant departments

OMG12 · 26/02/2023 18:58

SerendipityJane · 26/02/2023 18:31

Ha, not humans but the society in which we live.

But it is humans. Without some form of society, our species is a goner. It takes a village to raise a baby to adolescence. Our biological evolution is as much down to society as it is to opposing thumbs

in Terms of change our society has changed a lot more than us (as physical beings) so what has changed most sine the Stone Age?

Maybe we’re the AI experiment of another civilisation? Maybe we need to consider the failings and successes of humanity when designing AI to make sure it doesn’t make the same mistakes and replicates the best of us.

SerendipityJane · 26/02/2023 18:31

Ha, not humans but the society in which we live.

But it is humans. Without some form of society, our species is a goner. It takes a village to raise a baby to adolescence. Our biological evolution is as much down to society as it is to opposing thumbs

OMG12 · 26/02/2023 18:21

OMG12 · 26/02/2023 18:18

Ha, not humans but the society in which we live.

And maybe the part of us that’s not a collection of molecules 😀

OMG12 · 26/02/2023 18:18

SerendipityJane · 26/02/2023 18:05

One things for sure civilisation will be fairly unrecognisable

Or not ? Not only can we totally recognise the Roman empire (for example) we still have a lot of it's precepts. Merchants were complaining about the state of the roads in Britain in the 1st century AD. Not only totally recognisable, but still unfixed. And the Pharaohs collected taxes for their vanity projects. And I have little doubt that a few hours around Stonehenge as it was being built would not be quite the shock you would imagine.

It irritates me when people try to portray our ancestors as a different species. From the Palaeolithic to today the only evolution has been in fashion sense.

Ha, not humans but the society in which we live.

SerendipityJane · 26/02/2023 18:05

One things for sure civilisation will be fairly unrecognisable

Or not ? Not only can we totally recognise the Roman empire (for example) we still have a lot of it's precepts. Merchants were complaining about the state of the roads in Britain in the 1st century AD. Not only totally recognisable, but still unfixed. And the Pharaohs collected taxes for their vanity projects. And I have little doubt that a few hours around Stonehenge as it was being built would not be quite the shock you would imagine.

It irritates me when people try to portray our ancestors as a different species. From the Palaeolithic to today the only evolution has been in fashion sense.

OMG12 · 26/02/2023 17:58

SerendipityJane · 26/02/2023 16:55

I guess the simple tasks are great to outsource to AI, maybe we should keep the complex stuff for humans.

It's only 2023. What will "we" think in 3023 ? Bearing in mind our current round of western civilisation is arguably less than two millennia old. Only yesterday, watching "Digging for Britain" the fact that people returned to Isla over several millennia was mentioned.

I wonder if AI will aid or inhibit evolution within the human species? Possibly both? One things for sure civilisation will be fairly unrecognisable

SerendipityJane · 26/02/2023 16:55

I guess the simple tasks are great to outsource to AI, maybe we should keep the complex stuff for humans.

It's only 2023. What will "we" think in 3023 ? Bearing in mind our current round of western civilisation is arguably less than two millennia old. Only yesterday, watching "Digging for Britain" the fact that people returned to Isla over several millennia was mentioned.

OMG12 · 26/02/2023 16:50

SerendipityJane · 26/02/2023 16:25

Is AI limited to black and white thinking?

If "AI" is developed by humans then surely it is itself a natural process ? After all humans are merely a collection of molecules that themselves are governed by universal laws. Maybe "AI" is simply part of a species evolution ? After all humans long ago outsourced digestion to cooking (in order to develop our brains). So the distinction between "artificial" and "natural" is already a bit murky.

That seems to be the way humans are being pushed. Whilst it has its value in survival, the increasing nuance needs, as Kevin Dutton says, a dimmer switch

Maybe the current amplified yes/not good/bad in/out us/them shift is itself part of evolution and a response to shrinking resources and expanding needs ?

It's already patently obvious that in a land of SEO, "AI" has severe limitations. And as several "AI" experts have pointedly told me, the "AI" I would like to see isn't going to happen on Googles watch. Because the very first thing I would ask for is a search result "without the crap". Only "the crap" is how Google make money.

my Perspective is that humans are more than a collection of molecules, governed by universal laws -(yes -although I suspect we would disagree on the breadth and content of some of those).

Would an ISIS member share the same ethics as a nun?

I like your analogy of outsourcing digestion , but are ethics as mechanistic as digestion?

I guess the simple tasks are great to outsource to AI, maybe we should keep the complex stuff for humans.

OMG12 · 26/02/2023 16:44

cakeorwine · 26/02/2023 16:25

@OMG12

Have you seen The Good Place on Netflix?

It's an interesting take on moral philosophy

No I’m going to take a look -thanks for the recommendation

SerendipityJane · 26/02/2023 16:25

Is AI limited to black and white thinking?

If "AI" is developed by humans then surely it is itself a natural process ? After all humans are merely a collection of molecules that themselves are governed by universal laws. Maybe "AI" is simply part of a species evolution ? After all humans long ago outsourced digestion to cooking (in order to develop our brains). So the distinction between "artificial" and "natural" is already a bit murky.

That seems to be the way humans are being pushed. Whilst it has its value in survival, the increasing nuance needs, as Kevin Dutton says, a dimmer switch

Maybe the current amplified yes/not good/bad in/out us/them shift is itself part of evolution and a response to shrinking resources and expanding needs ?

It's already patently obvious that in a land of SEO, "AI" has severe limitations. And as several "AI" experts have pointedly told me, the "AI" I would like to see isn't going to happen on Googles watch. Because the very first thing I would ask for is a search result "without the crap". Only "the crap" is how Google make money.

cakeorwine · 26/02/2023 16:25

@OMG12

Have you seen The Good Place on Netflix?

It's an interesting take on moral philosophy

OMG12 · 26/02/2023 16:19

AI not AO (who are good with washing machines not sure about paradoxes)

OMG12 · 26/02/2023 16:17

Notwavingbutsignalling · 26/02/2023 15:59

That was really clumsily expressed @OMG12 my apologies

Thank you it’s all so complex isn’t it? I guess it’s only ever going to be as good as it’s inputs, tbh I’m prob too stupid to fully understand AI beyond trying (and failing to get it to draw a picture of my imagination 😂)

@SerendipityJane i wonder if AI can deal with arbitrary values my initial thought would be no but tbh I found my VIC20 too complex😂. Are arbitrary decisions part of what makes us human and maintains diversity. I wonder if AO can deal with paradoxes which I think often underlies ethical decision making?

Is AI limited to black and white thinking? That seems to be the way humans are being pushed. Whilst it has its value in survival, the increasing nuance needs, as Kevin Dutton says, a dimmer switch

I sometimes wonder if we are becoming as much like computers as they are becoming like us.

cakeorwine · 26/02/2023 16:03

SerendipityJane · 26/02/2023 15:47

There is no right or wrong answer to the trolley question. Merely one which conforms with arbitrary set of values.

Evolution similarly has no right or wrong direction beyond species that become extinct or not.

Chidi knows that - but it's much more fun to see it played out for real.

Everyone hates moral philosophers Grin

SerendipityJane · 26/02/2023 16:02

True "AI" will be capable of lying, of course.

Notwavingbutsignalling · 26/02/2023 15:59

That was really clumsily expressed @OMG12 my apologies

Swipe left for the next trending thread