Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If your work accidentally paid you a huge bonus would you tell them?

107 replies

namechange0998776554799000 · 21/02/2023 20:33

I've been paid a big bonus in my last pay and I know my company has made mistake - I changed roles, and I don't know what they've done but it's along the lines of them paying me my full years sales commission, despite already being paid it quarterly throughout the year. It's about 2 months salary. I work for a huge company with complex bonus/sales commission rules and I'm pretty confident they would never notice or ask for the money back if I said nothing. The money would be nice, since I've already quit to be a full time carer for my disabled son and going forward things will be very tight (I'm just working out my notice). I had to take 6 months unpaid leave already this year to care for him, another reason why the money would be handy and also why I'm confident I'm not entitled to the bonus!

I'm a good honest person so I've already told HR and they are looking into it. I assume they will rectify their mistake and ask for the money back, although I suppose there's a chance the admin will be more hassle than it's worth and they'll let me keep it! It did make me wonder though, how many people would be this honest/stupid?

OP posts:
ChimneyPot · 22/02/2023 16:18

Something similar happened to me about 20 years ago. I got paid twice for 6 months of mat leave.
I told my boss, who was the managing partner and he said to keep it as he really didn’t want to reopen the previous years accounts to fix it.

ToDoListAddict · 22/02/2023 16:13

As PP have stated, this should be picked up in an audit.
However, you are leaving, so anyone analysing the cost centre/financials etc, would most likely believe it is a payout of some sort (redundancy/ accrued holiday etc) because people in finance really do not have time to check every cost in every cost centre etc.
when prepping the payroll data it might look a bit odd but then they'll see a leaving date and make a quick assumption.
And in my experience when Payroll/HR make mistakes like that, they try their best to cover it up! The HMRC corrections will be an absolute nightmare for them!
Even auditors only check a sample of payments and are allowed limited personnel data.
It's good that you've reported it, but I'd be quite surprised if they sort this before your leave date.
If it's a big company, and this isn't a really crazy amount, even if it is picked up at the next audit. The chances are, they'll write it off.

namechange0998776554799000 · 22/02/2023 15:54

It's definitely my bonus payment and not something else. I can see roughly how it's happened and I can see that it was checked by HR/finance and they've marked it as checked/correct but I can see where they've made a mistake. It's a log if money to me (5 figures) but a drop in the ocean to my company (many billions in turnover). They're looking into so I do expect them to rectify it, only question will be how I pay it back and how much it screws up my tax etc.

OP posts:
YetMoreNewBeginnings · 22/02/2023 11:55

Please make sure you do everything in writing and keep it all.

This happened to me a few years ago and it caused hassles for ages with tax, child benefit and tax credits at the time and the following year.

That said I still have a print out of the screen shot of the balance - my account has never and will never look so good as it did those few days!!

LoveBluey · 22/02/2023 11:53

This happened to a couple of colleagues, they were paid their bonuses twice. It was at least £10k each and the company never noticed. That was over 5 years ago now and they kept schtum. (One of them told me a few months ago when we both left the company)

LuluBlakey1 · 22/02/2023 11:46

I would tell my employer - otherwise it's surely dishonest and a kind of theft.

HurryShadow · 22/02/2023 11:44

They can put you back on the payroll to correct it, if it is incorrect. They are able to amend a previously submitted payroll (HMRC link), in which case the tax and NI will show on record what it was always supposed to and it shouldn't mess anything up.

I'm hoping like a PP said, they'll tell you it's right numerous times and you get to keep it OP, but you've definitely done the right thing in telling them. I would too. I'd be too stressed thinking about them coming after me!

Have you double checked the detailed payslip? Did you usually get formal commission calculations for you to check yourself?

It could be a combination of earned commissions that had been accruing but not paid, plus holiday pay for any unused leave, so here's hoping you get to keep it!

Milky4 · 22/02/2023 11:07

thirstyformore · 22/02/2023 07:38

When I left my last role (senior position in a large international company) I was overpaid in my last wages. I contacted my HR business partner to say I thought my pay was incorrect. He told me to contact the HR online portal and log it. I duly did this and was told in writing my pay was correct. I asked for confirmation again in my reply, and received it.

It was wrong. Definitely a couple of grand too much but I wasn't about ti start arguing with payroll in my last few days. I kept the money in a separate account for a while, but it's probably now been spent. I could afford to repay if it ever caught up with me (which I doubt).

I saw it as a exit bonus for being an amazing employee for many many years Grin

There can be tax corrections. Plus you will have been paid any accrued annual leave that had not been used. Also you're paid behind, i.e your pay lags - so if you left 2 weeks into the month, you'd get your months salary + the extra two weeks.

In this case you probably were paid correctly and it was just a tying up of all the bits and bobs your company owed you in your final pay.

Depending on how much you earn, 5 days annual leave can add up to alot of money .

If you've double checked it and they confirm all correct - spend and enjoy! :-)

Tdcp · 22/02/2023 11:01

I know someone that was paid a years salary in one paycheck. He notified them by email but put a , instead of a . in the address so it didn't send ( so he had proof of trying to notify them?. He then put the money in a different account and waited. They never got in touch and he gained an extra 25k for nothing.

I'm not saying I approve before anyone comes at me 😂

Figgygal · 22/02/2023 10:32

Absolutely I would
Personal Integrity is an important trait
To not when you know its an error and not something you're entitled to is just theft

winningeasy · 22/02/2023 10:29

You've already told them so obv they will want it back,

I wouldn't have said anything no, especially not as you are already leaving

Toddlerteaplease · 22/02/2023 10:04

Yes I would tell them. I told an agency that they'd paid me for a shift I'd worked for a different agency. They hadn't noticed! Have chased it several times but I still have the money.

yaboreme · 22/02/2023 09:36

While you still have it in your bank account let them know their mistake. You can then pay it back.

If you hope they don't notice, then in 6 months time when you don't have the money they come knocking you are going to struggle to pay it back.

xogossipgirlxo · 22/02/2023 09:24

Yes, I'd tell them. If they decide to correct it, it's up to them, but at least you're clear.

Mincedpies · 22/02/2023 09:23

You can be as confident as you want that they wouldn’t have noticed but they 100% would have discovered it, and probably demanded it back at the most inconvenient time financially for you. You’ve not been stupid, you’ve done the only thing you could do - if work had taken that money from you accidentally you’d have been kicking down doors to get it back, so why would you have considered even for a second keeping money that wasn’t yours?

JustKeepSlimming · 22/02/2023 09:20

Crostimosti · 21/02/2023 21:03

I never keep what isn't mine. Its stealing. I am not a thief. Its that simple.

This. And in a similar situation I was honest; a while later another situation arose where it was my word against someone else's, and the fact that I had a history of honesty very much went in my favour.

Pippa12 · 22/02/2023 09:09

This happened to somebody I know and they came for the money, they paid it back monthly.

It happened to me but not as much (circa £400) I told them and they took it back in one chunk from my wage. My conscience was clear.

Schoolchoicesucks · 22/02/2023 09:05

It would probably be picked up and you'd have to repay. If you hadn't flagged it, your honesty would be called into question. So I think you've done the right thing in telling HR. They 99% will ask for it back, so do make sure you ring-fence it.
I have heard of cases where internal comms and procedures are soo bad that they never get round to asking for it back. So there's that tiny chance, but don't bank on it.
Sorry OP but you've not earned that money and you're not entitled to it and have done the right thing flagging it up.

MichaelFabricantWig · 22/02/2023 08:42

Of course. It’s not your money to keep

Drfosters · 22/02/2023 08:41

Morph22010 · 22/02/2023 07:52

A year end statutory audit wouldnt pick up something like this, the audit is just to determine if the accounts show a true and fair view and this wouldn’t be material. It would only likely be picked up if they have a specific audit of their payroll/commission which is not a statutory requirement so they might not

Exactly this. It would be an individual department accounts who would most likely pick it up when they do their monthly variance reporting.

I should point out (sorry if someone has already!) that there are 2 sorts of errors. One, where the payroll department is at fault. It happened to me that the amount was mistyped and I got an extra 10k because of an accidental extra 0. The other is where the payroll are given the wrong information by a department so it is technically correct at their end. If the payroll is at fault no one might ever pick up on it as the department finance might never know depending on their systems. They will run off what they budgeted for. However, If the department gave the wrong number to be paid, for instance told them the wrong bonus number, this probably more likely to be picked up during variance analysis as it will be different to budget. It really does depend on size of company and their systems. It is always best to be honest about it but once a reasonable effort has been made, it is up to the company to sort it.

topcat2014 · 22/02/2023 08:20

Plenty companies might not notice. Payroll is done and signed off month to month.

Assuming that month was 'commission' month then it will look odd compared to other months anyway.

That being the case, no one is going to go back to that month again.

Auditors check a random sample of transactions.

Having said that, you should have pointed this out when you got your payslip.

Morph22010 · 22/02/2023 07:52

Utilitaparking · 21/02/2023 20:40

They will find out when their accounts are done (and audited as you say the are a big company).

A year end statutory audit wouldnt pick up something like this, the audit is just to determine if the accounts show a true and fair view and this wouldn’t be material. It would only likely be picked up if they have a specific audit of their payroll/commission which is not a statutory requirement so they might not

sorrynotathome · 22/02/2023 07:47

My previous employer outsourced payroll and I had to alert them to mistakes four times over 7 years. I can’t imagine not coming clean - that’s not how I was brought up.

thirstyformore · 22/02/2023 07:38

When I left my last role (senior position in a large international company) I was overpaid in my last wages. I contacted my HR business partner to say I thought my pay was incorrect. He told me to contact the HR online portal and log it. I duly did this and was told in writing my pay was correct. I asked for confirmation again in my reply, and received it.

It was wrong. Definitely a couple of grand too much but I wasn't about ti start arguing with payroll in my last few days. I kept the money in a separate account for a while, but it's probably now been spent. I could afford to repay if it ever caught up with me (which I doubt).

I saw it as a exit bonus for being an amazing employee for many many years Grin

Wakemeup17 · 22/02/2023 03:07

Last job, I was paid 2 weeks extra and they would have never noticed (they didn't book my holidays on then system properly), I told them and paid it back. Current job- overpaid 20% from the beginning for eight months, I didn't notice (HR did), they let me keep it.