Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it is possible to separate the artist from the human being.

121 replies

SleepDreamThinkHuge · 21/02/2023 19:56

Take R Kelly and Chris Brown. Both have done very bad crimes as human beings for different reasons. I believe we should be able to separate the artist from the human being. There is no denying that both these guys had talent. A lot of people on here know their songs/heard them before e.g. I believe I can Fly, Worlds Greatest, Forever, Freaky Friday etc..

It seems though if someone says comments like R Kelly and Chris Brown made good songs/had talent you get ridiculed. "How dare you say that they are bad people so their songs can never be good"

Just because a person did terrible things can we not separate their talent from how they are as human beings. I mean recently you probably heard on the news of some Roald Dahl books being changed even though he was anti semitic no one can deny his books were good they sold more than 250 million copies worldwide. And we all know them e.g. Matilda, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory.

OP posts:
pigsinoodies · 21/02/2023 23:41

Eyerollcentral · 21/02/2023 23:30

When was the last time you heard ‘Two little boys’ broadcast or performed anywhere? And similarly yes ‘can you guess what it is yet?’ was in common parlance but absolutely has not been in any circles I move in since his conviction. If either of things are still part of you life now maybe consider the company you keep.

My DCs loved Rolf Harris. My two DGCs both loved Rolf Harris.

The proposition was whether it's unreasonable to think it's possible to separate the artist from the human being.

.

EmmaEmerald · 21/02/2023 23:39

Ashleighz88 · 21/02/2023 23:38

@JustAskingMate ah come on, that is not a reputable news source, half of them are just claims and sounds like people getting in his face and invading his privacy more than anything!

As for the rape, it is innocent until proven guilty, he hasn't been charged with anything, the amount of women that must try to sue knowing he is rich...

A five year restraining order is informative though.

Ashleighz88 · 21/02/2023 23:38

@JustAskingMate ah come on, that is not a reputable news source, half of them are just claims and sounds like people getting in his face and invading his privacy more than anything!

As for the rape, it is innocent until proven guilty, he hasn't been charged with anything, the amount of women that must try to sue knowing he is rich...

MeetPi · 21/02/2023 23:32

The innate problem is that for every creative artist, no matter the medium, their personal life influences, informs and suffuses their work. That's what makes it meaningful to them and to you, their audience. If in their personal life they have values, morals or ethics that are questionable - and this changes over time - this is unavoidably mirrored in whatever they produce. We can choose to see it, or not.

As a child, I adored Ronald Dahl. His books took me to strange worlds. I can see, though, I didn't fully comprehend what I was reading, and as an adult I didn't encourage my own children to read Dahl but steered them elsewhere. Dahl's books are spiteful and full of nasty tropes - even 'Matilda' is dark, frightening, and about child abuse. So Roald Dahl is off my bookshelves (and has been for some years) as I made the choice to keep such a person away from them.

pigsinoodies · 21/02/2023 23:32

EmmaEmerald · 21/02/2023 23:29

But that's a phrase I'll never use again, can't say I've listened to the song.

Well you're obviously younger than me then.

I'm not saying you're wrong, but there's a whole slew of people I'm their mid fifties who still get a chill through them when they hear 'Two Little Boys'.

Eyerollcentral · 21/02/2023 23:30

*your

Eyerollcentral · 21/02/2023 23:30

pigsinoodies · 21/02/2023 23:28

Rolf Harris was a part of the lives of a while generation of children, and many of their children.

He's obviously a twat but his 'Two Little Boys' etc. is part of our lives, as is the phrase "can you see what it is yet".

When was the last time you heard ‘Two little boys’ broadcast or performed anywhere? And similarly yes ‘can you guess what it is yet?’ was in common parlance but absolutely has not been in any circles I move in since his conviction. If either of things are still part of you life now maybe consider the company you keep.

EmmaEmerald · 21/02/2023 23:29

pigsinoodies · 21/02/2023 23:28

Rolf Harris was a part of the lives of a while generation of children, and many of their children.

He's obviously a twat but his 'Two Little Boys' etc. is part of our lives, as is the phrase "can you see what it is yet".

But that's a phrase I'll never use again, can't say I've listened to the song.

pigsinoodies · 21/02/2023 23:28

Rolf Harris was a part of the lives of a while generation of children, and many of their children.

He's obviously a twat but his 'Two Little Boys' etc. is part of our lives, as is the phrase "can you see what it is yet".

JustAskingMate · 21/02/2023 23:28

Valhalla17 · 21/02/2023 23:20

But why are you and others like you SO incredibly obsessed with this guy specifically. There are SO many others you should be bothered by. OK so a restraining order requested by an ex 6yrs ago, a couple that had a pretty tumultuous relationship by all accounts. Anyway, moving on as this isn't actually the point of the thread. CB has 3 young kids, if he was THAT dangerous to humans I reckon SS would have been stepping in by now...ffs

The minimising is appalling.

No that’s not how it works. Convicted abusers against women still are regularly allowed access to their kids.

It’s just not CB, it’s also R Kelly, Gary Glitter, Harvey Weinstein and an unfortunate amount more.

Or would you rather no one be held accountable? So long as they can visit their kids, they can abuse who they like as according to you, it mustn’t be that bad.

Horrible attitude but not surprising.

EmmaEmerald · 21/02/2023 23:27

doublechocolatedigestives · 21/02/2023 23:20

I was an R Kelly fan. Had most of his albums and I knew all the words to the In The Closet saga. However I cannot listen to him now. Some of his songs refer to having sex with the underage girls (Seems Like You're Ready, Age Ain't Nothing...) and it makes me sick to hear them. I don't even think I'd date a man that still stood up for R Kelly. Nasty man

Chris Brown on the other hand has apologised and rectified his behaviour since Rhianna so I'm still a fan of his.

Looking this up now...doesn't look rectified to me...I had no idea (but I don't follow his music).

Eyerollcentral · 21/02/2023 23:26

SleepDreamThinkHuge · 21/02/2023 19:56

Take R Kelly and Chris Brown. Both have done very bad crimes as human beings for different reasons. I believe we should be able to separate the artist from the human being. There is no denying that both these guys had talent. A lot of people on here know their songs/heard them before e.g. I believe I can Fly, Worlds Greatest, Forever, Freaky Friday etc..

It seems though if someone says comments like R Kelly and Chris Brown made good songs/had talent you get ridiculed. "How dare you say that they are bad people so their songs can never be good"

Just because a person did terrible things can we not separate their talent from how they are as human beings. I mean recently you probably heard on the news of some Roald Dahl books being changed even though he was anti semitic no one can deny his books were good they sold more than 250 million copies worldwide. And we all know them e.g. Matilda, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory.

Because R Kelly and Chris Brown are both alive and as far as I know unrepentant about their crimes. Both put their victims through a trial. It’s not difficult to understand why people don’t want to listen to the songs of an unrepentant sexual abuser of children and women and a serial domestic abuser, is it?

doublechocolatedigestives · 21/02/2023 23:24

@JustAskingMate blimey I didn't know all that about Karreuche 🤦🏽‍♀️😢

danceyourselfdizzy1 · 21/02/2023 23:24

I’m curious because I love painting and don’t like Hitler

Glad you cleared that up.

EmmaEmerald · 21/02/2023 23:21

EnglishGirlsApproximately I used to have "Starting to hurt" as my "omg I have to get out of bed and go to work now" song!

Valhalla17 · 21/02/2023 23:20

JustAskingMate · 21/02/2023 23:11

He’s still doing it now!! Just look at poor Karrueche! He was 27 when he kicked he beat her up, kicked her in the stomach and threw her down the stairs!

He videoed himself following her saying he’ll never stop stalking her! She’s had a 5 year restraining order granted because he wouldn’t stop and he told her he wouldn’t!!

Why do so many people making excuses for this guy!!

But why are you and others like you SO incredibly obsessed with this guy specifically. There are SO many others you should be bothered by. OK so a restraining order requested by an ex 6yrs ago, a couple that had a pretty tumultuous relationship by all accounts. Anyway, moving on as this isn't actually the point of the thread. CB has 3 young kids, if he was THAT dangerous to humans I reckon SS would have been stepping in by now...ffs

doublechocolatedigestives · 21/02/2023 23:20

I was an R Kelly fan. Had most of his albums and I knew all the words to the In The Closet saga. However I cannot listen to him now. Some of his songs refer to having sex with the underage girls (Seems Like You're Ready, Age Ain't Nothing...) and it makes me sick to hear them. I don't even think I'd date a man that still stood up for R Kelly. Nasty man

Chris Brown on the other hand has apologised and rectified his behaviour since Rhianna so I'm still a fan of his.

JustAskingMate · 21/02/2023 23:18

Sorry to derail but the apologist for Chris Brown on this thread and ‘he was just 17’ has really annoyed me!

thebrag.com/chris-browns-timeline-of-violence-towards-women/amp/

Chris Brown on average assaults 1 women per year that we know about.
He’s also been accused of drugging and rape.

Yet this is conveniently skimmed over by everyone who instead try to deflect with ‘Rihanna was when he was a teenager!’ Ignoring every other incident since then. People don’t give CB grief because of Rihanna, it’s because of the continuous stream of violence against women since then.

Hawkins003 · 21/02/2023 23:12

Reading with intrigue

EmmaEmerald · 21/02/2023 23:12

Valhalla17 · 21/02/2023 23:08

No he was 17 when the incident happened. To be honest I'm sick to death of it being brought up so many years later, the man is now 33! It's lazy to bring him up...particularly when there are so many other more deserving arseholes who remain booked and busy in Hollywood...

That's all I'm saying.

I just looked it up, it says 2009? Amyway, to me that's adult, but I only liked one of his songs and I can't recall which one it was!

JustAskingMate · 21/02/2023 23:11

Valhalla17 · 21/02/2023 23:08

No he was 17 when the incident happened. To be honest I'm sick to death of it being brought up so many years later, the man is now 33! It's lazy to bring him up...particularly when there are so many other more deserving arseholes who remain booked and busy in Hollywood...

That's all I'm saying.

He’s still doing it now!! Just look at poor Karrueche! He was 27 when he kicked he beat her up, kicked her in the stomach and threw her down the stairs!

He videoed himself following her saying he’ll never stop stalking her! She’s had a 5 year restraining order granted because he wouldn’t stop and he told her he wouldn’t!!

Why do so many people making excuses for this guy!!

EmmaEmerald · 21/02/2023 23:11

EnglishGirlApproximately · 21/02/2023 23:04

@EmmaEmerald I'm also very conflicted about Ryan Adams. His music has helped me through the most difficult, and also happiest times in my life. My adult life has been soundtracked by his music for over twenty years and nothing can take those moments away.
DP has bought us tickets for his upcoming tour and I really don't know how I'll react to seeing him live this time, I just don't have the same excitement any more.

Yes...I'm not letting go of the soundtrack of my life but I didn't want to listen to the new stuff.

that said, I've just looked it up and the FBI couldn't find any reason to bring charges, so it was all dropped in January 2021 (I was in a bad state then so I didn't know). I might actually listen to some new stuff then.

🎤 just so you know, you will always be the hardest thing I will let go🎤

I want to think he didn't do anything, I realise that. I'm sure he's superb in concert.

JustAskingMate · 21/02/2023 23:09

Chris Brown didn’t just beat up Rihanna though ffs!! He’s attacked multiple partners since then including stalking and a recent ex requiring a restraining order against him!

why are people minimising it to him being just 17?!

He’s still out here as a grown ass man harassing and physically attacking women with current active restraining orders!

The guy is dangerous!

Valhalla17 · 21/02/2023 23:08

EmmaEmerald · 21/02/2023 23:02

Chris Brown was 20 I thought? Not that it matters to me. And OP wasn't comparing them. Nor can you mention every problematic person in one post.

No he was 17 when the incident happened. To be honest I'm sick to death of it being brought up so many years later, the man is now 33! It's lazy to bring him up...particularly when there are so many other more deserving arseholes who remain booked and busy in Hollywood...

That's all I'm saying.

EnglishGirlApproximately · 21/02/2023 23:04

@EmmaEmerald I'm also very conflicted about Ryan Adams. His music has helped me through the most difficult, and also happiest times in my life. My adult life has been soundtracked by his music for over twenty years and nothing can take those moments away.
DP has bought us tickets for his upcoming tour and I really don't know how I'll react to seeing him live this time, I just don't have the same excitement any more.