Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Grandfather smacked DS bottom

667 replies

ranblungs · 21/02/2023 14:35

DS can have meltdowns/big tantrums, usually when he's very tired. More so when he's at his grandparents' house (ex's parents). They have communicated to me that they found his behaviour very difficult at one point, but it seems to have resolved now.

ExDP did live with them but moved our two weeks ago.

DS (aged 4) told me yesterday evening that grandad had smacked his bottom because he was being naughty and that it "really hurt" he got upset as he was telling me and cried. I get the impression this wasn't necessarily recent.

DS also can play up at bed time when he is there and he told me that grandad pushes him back onto the bed for being naughty at bed time.

I'm not sure what to do next?

They are huge sources of childcare, ExDP is supposed to have him two nights per week but often works away so they will have him. They also help out during the week as/when needed.

The relationship between us was once very strained when DS was tiny.

I am furious that he has hit my child. Am I overreacting as it was just a smack on the bottom?

DS can be very challenging there.

OP posts:
Lambchop1 · 21/02/2023 17:24

Oh god. Don’t send him again ! Why would you even contemplate this?! They smacked your child. I would be furious.

LittleRedTomato · 21/02/2023 17:22

@Bigbadfish and @Ceilingplaits , it absolutely is illegal. The 'reasonable chastisement ' defence applies only to the parents on someone with PR, which is not the same as 'in loco parentis' and doesn't include grandparents even if they are caring for the child.at the time. The parents can't delegate this right to somebody without PR. This has been clarified in law before, back in the 1990s, and it went to a high enough court that it's absolutely firmly established. There's no reasonable chastisement defence in this case, even if the child runs into the road.

The case in the late 90s involved a private Christian school in, I think , Birmingham - one of the last in the country to use corporal punishment well into the 90s. They tried to claim parents were entitled to delegate this right as they were acting in loco parentis. They lost, decisively. Without this law, not only grandparents but schools would still be entitled to hit your children.

hattie43 · 21/02/2023 17:15

Make your own arrangements . It's not worth everyone being upset

FictionalCharacter · 21/02/2023 17:15

Bigbadfish · 21/02/2023 15:27

It may not be illegal.

It is unlawful for a parent to smack their child in England except where this may amount to 'reasonable punishment'. This defence is included in section 58 of the the Children's Act 2004 - but the law is somewhat grey in that it doesn't define exactly what 'reasonable punishment' might consist of.

It all depends on where OP lives.

For a parent. He is not the child’s parent.
@LittleRedTomato explained the legal situation upthread.

RunningFromInsanity · 21/02/2023 17:14

maddy68 · 21/02/2023 16:39

Speak to them

Far too sensible.

flutterbyebaby · 21/02/2023 17:12

OoooohMatron · 21/02/2023 17:08

I totally agree it's not acceptable, but I think a conversation is reasonable before a total ban on then looking after the child.

Could you trust them though?

OoooohMatron · 21/02/2023 17:08

GoldDuster · 21/02/2023 16:50

It is not "normal" for adults to hit (we can call it smacking, but it's hitting) and push little children. It doesn't matter who hit this 50 year old when he was a child, it was also acceptable to drink five pints and drive home from the pub pissed as fart, not use seatbelts, and lots of other things we do not do now because we know better. His age is not an excuse. It is not acceptable to hit a child in your care.

Again, if this was a very very cheap and convenient childminder, would we turn a blind eye to hitting and pushing of a four year old, no matter how challenging their behaviour? We would not, there would be uproar, it would be unacceptable.

You do not have the right to hit a child because you feel they "belong to you" in some way.

I totally agree it's not acceptable, but I think a conversation is reasonable before a total ban on then looking after the child.

PennyFarthings · 21/02/2023 16:56

You need to talk to them OP. Make it clear they are not allowed to hit the child, then you can decide, based on their response, if you still want to use them as childcare.
It could be the catalyst though, he's too much for them anyway and if they can't cope with his behaviour, then that issue will move on to finding alternatives in childcare.

GoldDuster · 21/02/2023 16:50

It is not "normal" for adults to hit (we can call it smacking, but it's hitting) and push little children. It doesn't matter who hit this 50 year old when he was a child, it was also acceptable to drink five pints and drive home from the pub pissed as fart, not use seatbelts, and lots of other things we do not do now because we know better. His age is not an excuse. It is not acceptable to hit a child in your care.

Again, if this was a very very cheap and convenient childminder, would we turn a blind eye to hitting and pushing of a four year old, no matter how challenging their behaviour? We would not, there would be uproar, it would be unacceptable.

You do not have the right to hit a child because you feel they "belong to you" in some way.

JMSA · 21/02/2023 16:47

Just tell him not to do it again, and discuss other strategies you use at home. Smacking was a generational thing. If it doesn't happen again then there is no need to catastrophise by ceasing contact.

OoooohMatron · 21/02/2023 16:46

I'm a bit undecided on this OP. If they are good grandparents in every other way I think you should speak to them and let them know that smacking is a definite no and he is never to do it again. Remember these people grew up when a smack on the bum was a standard form of discipline and not considered abusive. Perhaps they just need educating that this is no longer acceptable?

flutterbyebaby · 21/02/2023 16:46

DisneyChops · 21/02/2023 16:42

I think you're overreacting a bit.
Seems I'm in the minority a bit though.
Then again this is Mumsnet.

Would you hit a child and not tell their parent?

flutterbyebaby · 21/02/2023 16:45

If the grandad thought it was ok why were you not told about the smacking, he knew it was wrong so hid it from you!

DisneyChops · 21/02/2023 16:42

I think you're overreacting a bit.
Seems I'm in the minority a bit though.
Then again this is Mumsnet.

Ceilingplaits · 21/02/2023 16:41

Bigbadfish · 21/02/2023 15:27

It may not be illegal.

It is unlawful for a parent to smack their child in England except where this may amount to 'reasonable punishment'. This defence is included in section 58 of the the Children's Act 2004 - but the law is somewhat grey in that it doesn't define exactly what 'reasonable punishment' might consist of.

It all depends on where OP lives.

In my work it would be a safeguarding concern. "Reasonable" would amount to where done to prevent danger to the child, e.g. running into a road, and parenting classes or support in finding strategies to prevent it would be mandatory.

maddy68 · 21/02/2023 16:39

Speak to them

Ceilingplaits · 21/02/2023 16:38

I know people are saying it's normal for that generation...but I'm that generation and none of my friends were ever smacked apart from in one family where the dad had a mental illness and was violent. It's possibly cultural rather than generational. Anyhow, the point is that they're an age where they're not senile and are presumably literate, grew up at a time when education and access to information were increasingly widespread, so are presumably not terribly disadvantaged by lack of education or resources and ought to have basic awareness.

Yayyayitsaholiholiday · 21/02/2023 16:34

@diddl I'm just 40 and was snacked regularly (more than once a week) with hands, shoes and wooden sticks kept for the purpose, so I wouldn’t agree that he’s too young to have done this in his parenting days……..

Sapphire387 · 21/02/2023 16:28

He smacked him on the bottom, he didn't give him a beating. You don't agree with smacking, just make it clear to them that you don't want them to use that as a method of chastisement. No need for all this banning them from looking after him at this stage, in my opinion. Surely you can have a conversation with them.

Flamingogirl08 · 21/02/2023 16:24

Mamansparkles · 21/02/2023 14:51

Honestly, they are presumably post retirement age? They have told you in the past they are struggling with him, you admit he has challenging behaviour and it sounds like your ex leaves a lot to them. And they come from a generation where a smack on the bottom was a normal and acceptable method of disciplining a naughty child.
I don't think you can jump to 'they are terrible people'. You can choose to talk to them about how you prefer to discipline him and explain it isnt done these days. You can choose to not have them provide your childcare (sounds like it would be a relief for them).
So you aren't overreacting if that isn't how you want your son disciplined, but you also can't really 'blame' them when they have been very clear they are struggling with him and neither you nor your ex has come up with alternative childcare arrangements.
All this 'he wouldn't see my child again' stuff is an overreaction. If they were allowed to see him as a grandchild not as childcare then they would likely not have to deal with the challenging behaviour and you could more easily set parameters around how he is and isnt to be disciplined.

This

Ilovelurchers · 21/02/2023 16:22

Depending on your financial situation, quitting your job with nothing to go to may put you, and therefore your son, in financial hardship. And it will not even necessarily prevent them from looking after your child, as your ex may still decide to use them as childcare.

I think you need to speak to your ex in the first instance. Does he share your views on smacking? If so, he may well be the best person to speak to his parents - make it clear to them that you are a united front on this and go from there.

I think there are many people who, while they are not personally opposed to smacking, would avoid it if asked to by the child's own parents. Hopefully this applies
to these grandparents, but your ex us in the best position to know this.

I do understand your extreme distress of course. Any form of smacking of children appalls me personally, and I'd be horrified if someone had smacked my child at that age. But I think you need to think calmly and logically now if you can. Good luck.

SpinningFloppa · 21/02/2023 16:02

Happened with my own mum she smacked my son once I didn’t talk to her for a long time and she didn’t look after him again for a long time we spoke about it and she has never done it again

Bigbadfish · 21/02/2023 15:54

How would you finically support you and your son if you quit?
Pretty sure UC doesn't kick in if you quit without reason.

This isn't something you can make a snap decision over.
Especially if it's your Exa parents and they are going to have easy access to him anyway.

Communication is definitely the way to go. Especially if you don't hold all the cards.

icefishing · 21/02/2023 15:52

I would talk to them first before making any decisions.
I'm younger than them and was smacked on bum growing up and so were most of my friends.
I didn't do this to my dc but I know some parents who did.
I would get them to talk through what happened and when it happened. Then be really clear that you aren't okay with it happening again and see what their responses are.
You can then make a final decision on what to do based on that.

ranblungs · 21/02/2023 15:45

His behaviour was challenging at theirs, but it's resolved. We did find out that it was because he was missing me. I also had some health problems and had a fit in front of him, which unsettled him for a while.

He attends nursery full time but I work 12.5 hour shifts so I need the childcare around nursery hours.

If I had the funds I would get a nanny, but I don't.

Thank you for all your points, I have a lot to think about.

OP posts: