Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Grandfather smacked DS bottom

667 replies

ranblungs · 21/02/2023 14:35

DS can have meltdowns/big tantrums, usually when he's very tired. More so when he's at his grandparents' house (ex's parents). They have communicated to me that they found his behaviour very difficult at one point, but it seems to have resolved now.

ExDP did live with them but moved our two weeks ago.

DS (aged 4) told me yesterday evening that grandad had smacked his bottom because he was being naughty and that it "really hurt" he got upset as he was telling me and cried. I get the impression this wasn't necessarily recent.

DS also can play up at bed time when he is there and he told me that grandad pushes him back onto the bed for being naughty at bed time.

I'm not sure what to do next?

They are huge sources of childcare, ExDP is supposed to have him two nights per week but often works away so they will have him. They also help out during the week as/when needed.

The relationship between us was once very strained when DS was tiny.

I am furious that he has hit my child. Am I overreacting as it was just a smack on the bottom?

DS can be very challenging there.

OP posts:
Emmamoo89 · 21/02/2023 21:44

Fordian · 21/02/2023 21:28

Yes, you have to give up your job.

I wouldn't leave my job over it.

Fordian · 21/02/2023 21:39

isadoradancing123 · 21/02/2023 19:48

OMG you do not need to give up your job because he got a smack on the bottom, if indeed he did. If it bothers you that much mention it to them

I think the responses on here make it clear that she does have to leave her job, and that she must never allow this 4 year old to be in the company of the grandparent, ever again.

She must find ways of supporting herself and child given this.

It's pretty cut and dried.

silverclock222 · 21/02/2023 21:36

WinterMusings · 21/02/2023 20:31

@Bigbadfish

theyre grandparents though, so not sure they get the exemption.

o was a child in the '70's. I think I was smacked (not hit) twice, but when
i was told if I carried on I'd get a smack, was the point at which I knew I was pushing my luck!

I loved my parents , I wasn't scared of them & children weren't feral little buggers or snowflakes.

OP you say 'challenging'. Try 'naughty' & do something about it. Instead of getting lots of free childcare and not listening when they say he's too much!

Ask them not to smack him again, but don't expect them to be happy being 'told off' for parenting him how they patented their children.

Totally agree

Fordian · 21/02/2023 21:28

Yes, you have to give up your job.

IneedanewTV · 21/02/2023 21:11

Is there a link to your child’s challenging behaviour and the long hours they spend in child care (full time) and at the grandparents. Could you and your ex review your hours as it does sound very tough for your child.

BlueVinca · 21/02/2023 20:56

I mean could he look for other work?

BlueVinca · 21/02/2023 20:54

Nor have I. I'm 52 and smacking was normal when I was a kid where I grew up and it was still done in my primary school, but I'm not aware of any of my friends doing it and I didn't either. I think it should be illegal. It sounds like they're struggling. Does the child's dad have to work away on his days?

flutterbyebaby · 21/02/2023 20:47

MereDintofPandiculation · 21/02/2023 20:39

And therefore 10 in about 1984. Corporal punishment in schools was still legal - banned in state schools in 1986, in independents in 1999. So although it was dying out, it was still around, and wasn’t viewed with such horror as it is nowadays.

I'm in my 50s and was leathered at home and in school by nuns, I've never thought hitting kids normal

flutterbyebaby · 21/02/2023 20:46

WinterMusings · 21/02/2023 20:37

It's not child abuse, and frankly that just minimises the actual abuse some children are subject too. It was a smacked bottom.

So it would be ok if someone slapped you if they didn't like something you did?

GoodChat · 21/02/2023 20:40

@WinterMusings if your husband slapped you he'd be an abuser.

MereDintofPandiculation · 21/02/2023 20:39

diddl · 21/02/2023 15:05

to granddad this is probably normal behaviour (and probs how he was raised)

I would say that this is doubtful as Op has now pointed out that he is only around 50.

And therefore 10 in about 1984. Corporal punishment in schools was still legal - banned in state schools in 1986, in independents in 1999. So although it was dying out, it was still around, and wasn’t viewed with such horror as it is nowadays.

Emmamoo89 · 21/02/2023 20:38

WinterMusings · 21/02/2023 20:37

It's not child abuse, and frankly that just minimises the actual abuse some children are subject too. It was a smacked bottom.

I agree with this also

WinterMusings · 21/02/2023 20:37

GoodChat · 21/02/2023 17:36

It's incredible how many people use the "it's not illegal" argument. That's only because people are cunts.

There's no excuse to hit a young child.

OP speak to your work and see if you can amend yours hours temporarily.
Speak to your ex and see what he says. If he's ok with child abuse, it might not help, but he might be willing to start pulling his weight otherwise.

Do you have a relationship with your parents? Could you speak to nursery staff and see if anyone would babysit outside of nursery hours?

It's not child abuse, and frankly that just minimises the actual abuse some children are subject too. It was a smacked bottom.

WinterMusings · 21/02/2023 20:31

Bigbadfish · 21/02/2023 15:27

It may not be illegal.

It is unlawful for a parent to smack their child in England except where this may amount to 'reasonable punishment'. This defence is included in section 58 of the the Children's Act 2004 - but the law is somewhat grey in that it doesn't define exactly what 'reasonable punishment' might consist of.

It all depends on where OP lives.

@Bigbadfish

theyre grandparents though, so not sure they get the exemption.

o was a child in the '70's. I think I was smacked (not hit) twice, but when
i was told if I carried on I'd get a smack, was the point at which I knew I was pushing my luck!

I loved my parents , I wasn't scared of them & children weren't feral little buggers or snowflakes.

OP you say 'challenging'. Try 'naughty' & do something about it. Instead of getting lots of free childcare and not listening when they say he's too much!

Ask them not to smack him again, but don't expect them to be happy being 'told off' for parenting him how they patented their children.

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream · 21/02/2023 20:24

isadoradancing123 · 21/02/2023 19:48

OMG you do not need to give up your job because he got a smack on the bottom, if indeed he did. If it bothers you that much mention it to them

I also agree

Emmamoo89 · 21/02/2023 20:17

isadoradancing123 · 21/02/2023 19:48

OMG you do not need to give up your job because he got a smack on the bottom, if indeed he did. If it bothers you that much mention it to them

I agree

isadoradancing123 · 21/02/2023 19:48

OMG you do not need to give up your job because he got a smack on the bottom, if indeed he did. If it bothers you that much mention it to them

Streamside · 21/02/2023 19:41

Wnikat · 21/02/2023 14:38

Maybe your DS is challenging at their house because they are arseholes to him? He’s confided in you. Listen to him. Don’t send him there again.

Exactly, why is he challenging when he's at their home. You need to protect your child with immediate effect.

Daisybuttercup12345 · 21/02/2023 19:35

Mamansparkles · 21/02/2023 14:51

Honestly, they are presumably post retirement age? They have told you in the past they are struggling with him, you admit he has challenging behaviour and it sounds like your ex leaves a lot to them. And they come from a generation where a smack on the bottom was a normal and acceptable method of disciplining a naughty child.
I don't think you can jump to 'they are terrible people'. You can choose to talk to them about how you prefer to discipline him and explain it isnt done these days. You can choose to not have them provide your childcare (sounds like it would be a relief for them).
So you aren't overreacting if that isn't how you want your son disciplined, but you also can't really 'blame' them when they have been very clear they are struggling with him and neither you nor your ex has come up with alternative childcare arrangements.
All this 'he wouldn't see my child again' stuff is an overreaction. If they were allowed to see him as a grandchild not as childcare then they would likely not have to deal with the challenging behaviour and you could more easily set parameters around how he is and isnt to be disciplined.

Entirely agree.

bellabasset · 21/02/2023 17:58

I'm in my 70's and was brought up to believe smacking children round the head or on the bottom was wrong. A short tap on the hand or leg was OK. But we weren't smacked at home or school although my dh was caned at public school. Believe me this did him irreparable harm and he left school at 15 and home at 17.

I'm opposed to any form of hitting and a 4 year old is still very young. I think you and your ex need to discuss and agree how your child can be managed at his gps.

2022again · 21/02/2023 17:50

diddl · 21/02/2023 15:05

to granddad this is probably normal behaviour (and probs how he was raised)

I would say that this is doubtful as Op has now pointed out that he is only around 50.

The grandad is my age and being smacked at home and being hit at school by teachers were both social norms in the 70's and early 80's!! It can be hard to move away from the behaviour that we grew up with but it is unacceptable now and its up to you OP and your ex to have the discussion as to whether they can promise not to hit. I have never purposefully hit my kids but have done it in anger ,regrettably , so its whether or not your ex-FIL a. has the awareness that he shouldn't hit your son b. has the skills to manage their own anger and choose other methods of managing your son.

GoodChat · 21/02/2023 17:36

It's incredible how many people use the "it's not illegal" argument. That's only because people are cunts.

There's no excuse to hit a young child.

OP speak to your work and see if you can amend yours hours temporarily.
Speak to your ex and see what he says. If he's ok with child abuse, it might not help, but he might be willing to start pulling his weight otherwise.

Do you have a relationship with your parents? Could you speak to nursery staff and see if anyone would babysit outside of nursery hours?

Bigbadfish · 21/02/2023 17:32

LittleRedTomato · 21/02/2023 17:22

@Bigbadfish and @Ceilingplaits , it absolutely is illegal. The 'reasonable chastisement ' defence applies only to the parents on someone with PR, which is not the same as 'in loco parentis' and doesn't include grandparents even if they are caring for the child.at the time. The parents can't delegate this right to somebody without PR. This has been clarified in law before, back in the 1990s, and it went to a high enough court that it's absolutely firmly established. There's no reasonable chastisement defence in this case, even if the child runs into the road.

The case in the late 90s involved a private Christian school in, I think , Birmingham - one of the last in the country to use corporal punishment well into the 90s. They tried to claim parents were entitled to delegate this right as they were acting in loco parentis. They lost, decisively. Without this law, not only grandparents but schools would still be entitled to hit your children.

This says otherwise.

www.madeformums.com/school-and-family/smacking-children-what-are-the-laws-across-the-uk/

Also it's extremely unlikely this would go anywhere as there is no evidence.

The bottom line is again OP doesn't hold all the cards.

So communication is the only option.

Theroad · 21/02/2023 17:30

It wouldn't even be a question. If someone assaulted my child I'd be murderous and they'd never look after him again.

if he's challenging there it's because he's being dragged from pillar to post with four adults and nursery looking after him all with different rules, personalities - and expectations. It's too much for a four year old.

A rubbish position for you to be put in since you are so dependent on them but I would be trying anything I could to find some alternative and to give DS more stability. I would make sure you tell him his grandad was wrong to hit him and that adults should never hit children. It's illegal where I live and I make sure my DDs know it so if it ever happens they'll hopefully tell me.

Greensleeves · 21/02/2023 17:26

It's not about whether the grandfather is an awful person, or whether he "deserves" to be banned from looking after the child. It's about the little boy who has a right to be cared for by people who can be trusted not to hurt him, and to feel safe.

No adult who hit my child would ever be alone with them again. Simple.