Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Grandfather smacked DS bottom

667 replies

ranblungs · 21/02/2023 14:35

DS can have meltdowns/big tantrums, usually when he's very tired. More so when he's at his grandparents' house (ex's parents). They have communicated to me that they found his behaviour very difficult at one point, but it seems to have resolved now.

ExDP did live with them but moved our two weeks ago.

DS (aged 4) told me yesterday evening that grandad had smacked his bottom because he was being naughty and that it "really hurt" he got upset as he was telling me and cried. I get the impression this wasn't necessarily recent.

DS also can play up at bed time when he is there and he told me that grandad pushes him back onto the bed for being naughty at bed time.

I'm not sure what to do next?

They are huge sources of childcare, ExDP is supposed to have him two nights per week but often works away so they will have him. They also help out during the week as/when needed.

The relationship between us was once very strained when DS was tiny.

I am furious that he has hit my child. Am I overreacting as it was just a smack on the bottom?

DS can be very challenging there.

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 22/02/2023 22:13

Squamata · 22/02/2023 22:12

I remember being smacked and it not hurting.

Begging the question of why they couldn't use a non pain centred method.

Squamata · 22/02/2023 22:12

ReneBumsWombats · 22/02/2023 20:02

Something else people forget is how much it hurts when a grown adult hits a small child. Yes yes, I know, just a tap, blah blah. Bullshit. You're three times their size. If you're only going to tap them and it doesn't hurt, why not use a method that doesn't involve pain and humiliation at all?

I remember being smacked and it not hurting.

ReneBumsWombats · 22/02/2023 21:49

DrPeppersPhD · 22/02/2023 21:18

So he pushed him back into bed, do you mean a shove across the room or being gently pushed back down?
Mumsnet is so quick to get fucking hysterical about a smack and some discipline, it's an insult to anyone who has actually been abused. I've experienced smacks and pushes and actual genuine abuse, there's a big fucking difference.

I've experienced smacks and pushes and other forms of genuine abuse. They're on the same spectrum of shit and there's no level of violence against children that's acceptable.

Nobody on this thread is anywhere near as hysterical as the hitting apologists.

DrPeppersPhD · 22/02/2023 21:18

So he pushed him back into bed, do you mean a shove across the room or being gently pushed back down?
Mumsnet is so quick to get fucking hysterical about a smack and some discipline, it's an insult to anyone who has actually been abused. I've experienced smacks and pushes and actual genuine abuse, there's a big fucking difference.

Calphurnia88 · 22/02/2023 21:13

SpideyCraw · 22/02/2023 20:53

Getting back to the OP, I would also be furious. I think it is always wrong to hit a child, and I think it is doubly wrong for someone to use that method of chastisement on someone else’s child.

I can’t agree with the whole “quit work and don’t send him there again” mentality. At the heart of all this is your son’s welfare. You have to weigh up the impact on him of your losing your job against the possibility that if you spoke to them, you might be able to sort this out and they might agree never to use physical chastisement again. I don’t know what your financial safety net is. I was very occasionally smacked as a child and I would never ever do it, but it had less of an impact on me than sitting in the dark, while cold and hungry and scared we would end up on the street, after my dad lost his job. Don’t impoverish yourselves unless you really have to because that WILL harm your son.

And you have to see the above in the context of the likelihood that your ex will continue to send him there on his time so your son would still be seeing him even if you did quit.

Absolutely all of this.

SpideyCraw · 22/02/2023 20:53

Getting back to the OP, I would also be furious. I think it is always wrong to hit a child, and I think it is doubly wrong for someone to use that method of chastisement on someone else’s child.

I can’t agree with the whole “quit work and don’t send him there again” mentality. At the heart of all this is your son’s welfare. You have to weigh up the impact on him of your losing your job against the possibility that if you spoke to them, you might be able to sort this out and they might agree never to use physical chastisement again. I don’t know what your financial safety net is. I was very occasionally smacked as a child and I would never ever do it, but it had less of an impact on me than sitting in the dark, while cold and hungry and scared we would end up on the street, after my dad lost his job. Don’t impoverish yourselves unless you really have to because that WILL harm your son.

And you have to see the above in the context of the likelihood that your ex will continue to send him there on his time so your son would still be seeing him even if you did quit.

Snugglemonkey · 22/02/2023 20:15

2022again · 22/02/2023 18:06

I think it’s important because conflating smacking with abuse is actually taking away something from those who are/have been abused? That may not make sense to you or anyone else who sees smacking as abuse and I can imagine if you yourself had a traumatic experience from being punished when you were a child, this thread could be like a red rag to a bull. society doesn’t suddenly become perfect, so with instances like this where something that was once considered acceptable is now not acceptable, it doesn’t always help to have a black and white attitude to it. I can compare it to working in elderly care….when I started in the 90’s you’d get a lot of attitudes around colour ,sex etc that would be considered racist, homophobic and if I spent my time reporting every single person without acknowledging that they were the products of their generation I wouldn’t have got much done. times move on , we educate people and that’s how things change in society.

I realise that it is particularly difficult for you to call it abuse, given that you have done it. I feel that it is imperative to call it abuse, so that we acknowledge it is always wrong. There is no acceptable violence against children.

Are some children hurt to a greater degree? Yes. But that still does not make it ok that a lesser amount of violence was used against some. Some women get groped, that is not rendered unimportant or acceptable because some women get gang raped. Sexual assault is wrong in all it's forms. Acknowledging groping as wrong detracts nothing from a rape victim

There are no grey areas. There is no magic point between acceptable violence and unacceptable violence. It doesn't matter who does it, whether they love their victim, whether they meant it, whether they didn't mean to hurt anyone, whether they were not thinking, whether they were out of control. How harshly we judge people may depend on some of those factors, but none of them make a wrong thing right. Violence is always wrong, and black and white thinking helps with clarity and makes it very obvious what expected standards of behaviour are.

ReneBumsWombats · 22/02/2023 20:02

Something else people forget is how much it hurts when a grown adult hits a small child. Yes yes, I know, just a tap, blah blah. Bullshit. You're three times their size. If you're only going to tap them and it doesn't hurt, why not use a method that doesn't involve pain and humiliation at all?

Snugglemonkey · 22/02/2023 20:00

WinterMusings · 22/02/2023 14:33

@EmmaDilemma5

No, try following the conversation, if you're going to jump in the middle of it. 🙄

A smacked bottom is not violence & abuse, it's a smacked bottom.

it's a simple request to ask that they don't smack him, but the parents need to accept he's too naughty challenging for the grandparents & pay for childcare. Not have histrionics over it.

He also pushed him. It is not only one incident, it is actually a pattern of abusive behaviour. Hitting is violence, to suggest otherwise is absolute nonsense.

ReneBumsWombats · 22/02/2023 19:52

2022again · 22/02/2023 19:44

@ReneBumsWombats don’t feel disheartened, i think probably most people regret or feel shame /guilt if they hit their kids ,and the study I posted has shown changes in attitudes and behaviour,it’s whether people have the ability to move forward and make bigger changes with each generation. In my own family it’s gone from domestic violence at grandparent level to smacking in my childhood home to my much more infrequent hitting behaviour for which I had the means to seek help for…hopefully the pattern is broken and my kids will have more skills and self regulation than those generations before. In your own situation, it’s a testament to yourself that you did survive abusive parenting and have been able to parent in a more loving way.

Thank you. And well done for working on yourself in that way. Those studies show how few people manage it and even on this thread you can see how many people still can't stop making excuses and getting defensive.

ReneBumsWombats · 22/02/2023 19:50

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream · 22/02/2023 19:43

@ReneBumsWombats it's a real shame not everyone is such a perfect parent as you obviously are

Why are your methods better than smacking? What's the improvement?

Snugglemonkey · 22/02/2023 19:49

2022again · 22/02/2023 10:33

god this thread is making me feel so OLD!! I wish people would understand there is SUCH a generation gap issue here ,when you have grown up with teachers hitting naughty students (and seeing it as a necessary form of punishment, particularly for boys) and parents smacking you it is REALLY difficult to conflate this with people saying it is child abuse, that they should be reported to SS and you should never leave your child alone with his grandparent again! Smacking is an outdated and ineffective form of punishment, we now know better, it shouldn't be used but please don't make the mistake of missing the chance to educate his grandparents about what your boundaries are and why things are different now.

I totally disagree. I am 42. I was smacked at home and school. It was abuse then, it is abuse now. I would definitely contact social services and the police.

2022again · 22/02/2023 19:44

@ReneBumsWombats don’t feel disheartened, i think probably most people regret or feel shame /guilt if they hit their kids ,and the study I posted has shown changes in attitudes and behaviour,it’s whether people have the ability to move forward and make bigger changes with each generation. In my own family it’s gone from domestic violence at grandparent level to smacking in my childhood home to my much more infrequent hitting behaviour for which I had the means to seek help for…hopefully the pattern is broken and my kids will have more skills and self regulation than those generations before. In your own situation, it’s a testament to yourself that you did survive abusive parenting and have been able to parent in a more loving way.

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream · 22/02/2023 19:43

@ReneBumsWombats it's a real shame not everyone is such a perfect parent as you obviously are

ReneBumsWombats · 22/02/2023 19:36

However, they say at some point we all turn into our parents

Pray to God it's not true.

These studies are confirming something I suspected but hoped wasn't true. At least part of the reason why we still have tons of apologists for this is because a lot of people still hit their children, not infrequently, and aren't interested in looking at alternatives...presumably because those would involve the parents doing some hard work on themselves.

Perhaps I'm unusually lucky, but as frustrating and infuriating as my kids can be - and they can - I've never, ever been tempted to hit them. It's just so obviously a stupid, lazy, damaging and counterproductive thing to do.

WarningToTheCurious · 22/02/2023 19:27

YouGov study from 2021:

While eight in ten Brits say they were punished, only some 62% of parents have physically punished their children, versus 34% who have never done so. However, they say at some point we all turn into our parents, and this survey shows that those who were physically punished during their upbringing are likely to repeat the behaviour.

yougov.co.uk/topics/society/articles-reports/2021/09/27/smacking-parents-who-were-physically-punished-chil

2022again · 22/02/2023 19:10

core.ac.uk/download/pdf/29197209.pdf …..interesting study from 2002 on the history of physical punishment (it’s a NZ one) but even in the 90s apparently 50% of mums and dads still hit their kids once a week or more

2022again · 22/02/2023 19:04

Ahh that may be why there’s a difference, apparently London was the first authority to ban corporal punishment in primary schools

2022again · 22/02/2023 19:00

a 50 yr old would have started school 76 and left in 91 or thereabouts.

Ceilingplaits · 22/02/2023 18:48

2022again · 22/02/2023 17:53

I’m not sure I agree ….were you a yuppy, they were the only people with mobile phones in the 80s!!!! I went to more than 1 state school in the 70’s and 80’s and teachers hitting kids (plimsolls, rulers, my sister was slapped round the face by an angry teacher once) was part of discipline….it didn’t start to change til the late 80’s. Things change….as an example husbands were exempt from prosecution for marital rape til a test case around 89/90 so I think you might be misremembering how some people viewed the world.

We're talking about 80s - 90s schools here if someone's 50 (perhaps started school in '78?).

Perhaps it was common in some schools, then. Not in any I or any friends or siblings went to (London and southeast).

It was only legal in C of E schools, perhaps military schools too, but Labour changed the law when they got in in the late 90s.

ReneBumsWombats · 22/02/2023 18:14

2022again · 22/02/2023 18:06

I think it’s important because conflating smacking with abuse is actually taking away something from those who are/have been abused? That may not make sense to you or anyone else who sees smacking as abuse and I can imagine if you yourself had a traumatic experience from being punished when you were a child, this thread could be like a red rag to a bull. society doesn’t suddenly become perfect, so with instances like this where something that was once considered acceptable is now not acceptable, it doesn’t always help to have a black and white attitude to it. I can compare it to working in elderly care….when I started in the 90’s you’d get a lot of attitudes around colour ,sex etc that would be considered racist, homophobic and if I spent my time reporting every single person without acknowledging that they were the products of their generation I wouldn’t have got much done. times move on , we educate people and that’s how things change in society.

I think it’s important because conflating smacking with abuse is actually taking away something from those who are/have been abused?

That works on the assumption that hitting children isn't abuse and I and others do not accept that.

Sure, there is a spectrum. Some forms of hitting are worse than others. But if all you've got to defend it is "never did me any harm" or "didn't kill anyone", your standards are in the toilet. Not permanently damaging or killing your children isn't a badge of honour.

I experienced worse than smacking as I got older, largely because my parents, being smackers, never learned to regulate themselves or de-escalate situations. Yes, those experiences were worse, but the smacking as a child was still abusive and traumatic for me (and it was well within what was normal at that point).

if I spent my time reporting every single person without acknowledging that they were the products of their generation

Nobody is suggesting we prosecute people for historic smacking. What we're asking is that you accept it was wrong, without caveats and excuses. Once you've accepted it's damaging and bad parenting, what more do you need to say?

Why is hitting children so much harder for people to renounce unconditionally than all the other shit historic things we now know are wrong? Why do children not matter in this regard?

2022again · 22/02/2023 18:06

ReneBumsWombats · 22/02/2023 17:46

It's very common for abuse victims not to believe they have been abused, especially when they love the abuser.

If we know better now, and we do, why can't we just renounce this shit parenting without excuse or caveat? Why is it important to downplay the effects on assaulted children by telling them that this person hasn't been affected like they were (or says they haven't).

It's shit parenting. It's wrong now and it was wrong then.

What more needs to be said?

I think it’s important because conflating smacking with abuse is actually taking away something from those who are/have been abused? That may not make sense to you or anyone else who sees smacking as abuse and I can imagine if you yourself had a traumatic experience from being punished when you were a child, this thread could be like a red rag to a bull. society doesn’t suddenly become perfect, so with instances like this where something that was once considered acceptable is now not acceptable, it doesn’t always help to have a black and white attitude to it. I can compare it to working in elderly care….when I started in the 90’s you’d get a lot of attitudes around colour ,sex etc that would be considered racist, homophobic and if I spent my time reporting every single person without acknowledging that they were the products of their generation I wouldn’t have got much done. times move on , we educate people and that’s how things change in society.

2022again · 22/02/2023 17:53

Ceilingplaits · 22/02/2023 17:24

Christ this thread is making me feel ancient. I'm close in age to the OP's parent-in-laws and I have a primary school aged child, am actually younger than many of the other parents of children in my child's class, and my career and relationship are just taking off.

This thread talks about people my age as if we're from the dark ages. We actually grew up with computers, television, travel abroad, even had mobile phones in our late teens, you know.

And yes, we all knew hitting children is very, very wrong.

The fact that church schools allowed it still didn't make us think it was ok, it just validated our mistrust of Christians.

And no, no one I know of my generation thinks it ok to hit a child. Parents' generation (in their 70s), yes it was thought ok in some circles, but not among people with any sensitivity, awareness, responsibility or compassion.

I’m not sure I agree ….were you a yuppy, they were the only people with mobile phones in the 80s!!!! I went to more than 1 state school in the 70’s and 80’s and teachers hitting kids (plimsolls, rulers, my sister was slapped round the face by an angry teacher once) was part of discipline….it didn’t start to change til the late 80’s. Things change….as an example husbands were exempt from prosecution for marital rape til a test case around 89/90 so I think you might be misremembering how some people viewed the world.

ReneBumsWombats · 22/02/2023 17:46

2022again · 22/02/2023 17:30

Of course I did,why wouldn’t I, I want to be a better parent than my parents were to me…but I’m trying to highlight that there will be many,many people who were smacked by their parents, some of those will never have smacked their kids (kudos to them) but some of those will likewise have gone on to smack their kids and castigating everyone in the way some posters have been castigating them is not helpful. I haven’t read a single post on here that agrees with smacking children , only that some people themselves were smacked and don’t see it in the same light as yourself and some other posters do.

It's very common for abuse victims not to believe they have been abused, especially when they love the abuser.

If we know better now, and we do, why can't we just renounce this shit parenting without excuse or caveat? Why is it important to downplay the effects on assaulted children by telling them that this person hasn't been affected like they were (or says they haven't).

It's shit parenting. It's wrong now and it was wrong then.

What more needs to be said?

Ceilingplaits · 22/02/2023 17:37

WinterMusings · 22/02/2023 12:18

No one died from a smacked bottom.

It does cause depression and other mental health conditions, which do lead to deaths, yes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread