Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Grandfather smacked DS bottom

667 replies

ranblungs · 21/02/2023 14:35

DS can have meltdowns/big tantrums, usually when he's very tired. More so when he's at his grandparents' house (ex's parents). They have communicated to me that they found his behaviour very difficult at one point, but it seems to have resolved now.

ExDP did live with them but moved our two weeks ago.

DS (aged 4) told me yesterday evening that grandad had smacked his bottom because he was being naughty and that it "really hurt" he got upset as he was telling me and cried. I get the impression this wasn't necessarily recent.

DS also can play up at bed time when he is there and he told me that grandad pushes him back onto the bed for being naughty at bed time.

I'm not sure what to do next?

They are huge sources of childcare, ExDP is supposed to have him two nights per week but often works away so they will have him. They also help out during the week as/when needed.

The relationship between us was once very strained when DS was tiny.

I am furious that he has hit my child. Am I overreacting as it was just a smack on the bottom?

DS can be very challenging there.

OP posts:
ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 09:27

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 09:16

Sensible physical chastisement that leaves no marks or long term injuries has been a totally normal part of a parents toolkit for literally thousands of years and it achieves the aim of controlling/regulating behaviour in a quick and practical way.

People did lots of things for thousands of years that were shit. That's a really daft way of looking at it.

It does not control or regulate anything: it is the opposite of self-control and de-escalation and teaches no self-management skills whatsoever. It is also now known to be damaging, so anyone still insisting it's OK either has some vested interest in enabling the hitting of children or is actively resistant to criticism of it.

I've not seen that sensible physical chastisement in appropriate circumstances is proven to be harmful?

All studies I have seen do exactly what I refferred to in my original post and conflate a small smack on the bottom or hand in response to a measured stimulus, with aggressive beating/punching/whipping for reasons of loss of control in the parent rather than trying to achieve a behavioural outcome from the child. I can't really take them seriously as a result.

Besides a lot of 'approved' methods of discipline, such as time outs, reflection corners etc that many on this thread no doubt would be happy with and use themselves are obvious forms of psychological torture and isolation that are way more damaging than a tap on the back of the hand or bottom would ever be.

The hypocrisy is staggering.

Back2Back2t · 23/02/2023 09:23

Back2Back2t · 23/02/2023 09:20

Ahhh the old it's been around for years so it must be be an awesome form of punishment.

and it achieves the aim of controlling/regulating behaviour in a quick and practical way.

Has it achieved it for you? Just read that line back again and hopefully you realize how abusive that sounds!

Also, I will add - maybe try and put yourself in the child's shoes.

Your DP occasionally inflict "sensible physical chastisement towards you that leaves no marks or long term injuries in order to control/regulate your behavior.

Loics · 23/02/2023 09:22

So... If I become "frazzled", "stressed", "reach the end of my tether", it's okay if I momentarily can't control myself and smack my children?

Is it okay if I slap DP in the same situation if I'm stressed and he's getting on my nerves? Or are we just okay to do it to our kids as a one-off?

Absolutely ridiculous that any person coming on here to say their partner had slapped them for the first time is (rightly) told it's just the start and it's abusive, regardless of the situation, but slapping a child (because smacking is slapping, just not on the face) can be justified depending on the situation.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 09:21

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 09:16

Sensible physical chastisement that leaves no marks or long term injuries has been a totally normal part of a parents toolkit for literally thousands of years and it achieves the aim of controlling/regulating behaviour in a quick and practical way.

People did lots of things for thousands of years that were shit. That's a really daft way of looking at it.

It does not control or regulate anything: it is the opposite of self-control and de-escalation and teaches no self-management skills whatsoever. It is also now known to be damaging, so anyone still insisting it's OK either has some vested interest in enabling the hitting of children or is actively resistant to criticism of it.

I absolutely agree with everything you're saying. These people defending it are the people who a generation ago would have said 'youve been married a year, he lost his temper and slapped you once, come on now, he's a great provider and he's under a lot of stress, he apologised, he loves you....'

Which was normal for hundreds of years, it's still abuse though and most these days recognise that

Back2Back2t · 23/02/2023 09:20

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 09:11

The pearl clutching on MN around smacking is laughable. Sensible physical chastisement that leaves no marks or long term injuries has been a totally normal part of a parents toolkit for literally thousands of years and it achieves the aim of controlling/regulating behaviour in a quick and practical way. If individual parents aren't comfortable doing it then fair enough, that's their choice.

Conflating it with 'beating', 'abusing' etc is ridiculous.

In the case of the OP, I'd suggest they have a word with the grandfather and make it clear that they don't approve of physical punishment so they don't want him to do it again. Obviously if he goes on to ignore them then they can escalate.

Ahhh the old it's been around for years so it must be be an awesome form of punishment.

and it achieves the aim of controlling/regulating behaviour in a quick and practical way.

Has it achieved it for you? Just read that line back again and hopefully you realize how abusive that sounds!

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 09:19

GoldDuster · 23/02/2023 08:29

Can I just check, the people that were hit and claim to not hit their own children because they've found a better way, is that because you're finding it hard to admit you hit your children? Or that you genuinely have found a better way?

If it's a good method of controlling behaviour, doesn't hurt or frighten a child at all, is quick, painless with no lasting negative effects then what are we doing moving towards banning it? Should we bring it back?

Would you like to see frazzled parents freely able to hit small children at the school gates after a long day without the current stigma?

How about stressed out aunties walloping twelve year olds in Primark because they're moaning and you're out of patience?

Humans naturally move towards reward. If it's effective and you don't feel bad about it, why don't you do it?

Because they are people who were hit by people who loved them and who they loved and it takes decades of introspection to accept those people loved you but did not treat you well. It's b
etter to say it was harmless than I was harmed by someone who loved me.

I was smacked and can say it definitely is harmful and if someone smacked either of mine they would be out the fucking door. And I'm 40 so not some young parent and my in laws are in their 60s and they absolutely know we don't do that and actually my mil was apparently more of a shouty threatening parent than a hitter and she knows she's also not allowed to shout. She says constantly how kind our children and how you can discuss things with them when they misbehave. That's because that's how they're treated, with kindness and respect.

thats in context of my 5 yr old being very high energy and needing a fair bit of management yet we all manage to not hit him.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 09:16

Sensible physical chastisement that leaves no marks or long term injuries has been a totally normal part of a parents toolkit for literally thousands of years and it achieves the aim of controlling/regulating behaviour in a quick and practical way.

People did lots of things for thousands of years that were shit. That's a really daft way of looking at it.

It does not control or regulate anything: it is the opposite of self-control and de-escalation and teaches no self-management skills whatsoever. It is also now known to be damaging, so anyone still insisting it's OK either has some vested interest in enabling the hitting of children or is actively resistant to criticism of it.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 09:14

2022again · 22/02/2023 10:33

god this thread is making me feel so OLD!! I wish people would understand there is SUCH a generation gap issue here ,when you have grown up with teachers hitting naughty students (and seeing it as a necessary form of punishment, particularly for boys) and parents smacking you it is REALLY difficult to conflate this with people saying it is child abuse, that they should be reported to SS and you should never leave your child alone with his grandparent again! Smacking is an outdated and ineffective form of punishment, we now know better, it shouldn't be used but please don't make the mistake of missing the chance to educate his grandparents about what your boundaries are and why things are different now.

Assuming this guy is walking around alive now with access to education himself?

Just because abuse used to be widespread doesn't make it not abuse.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 09:11

The pearl clutching on MN around smacking is laughable. Sensible physical chastisement that leaves no marks or long term injuries has been a totally normal part of a parents toolkit for literally thousands of years and it achieves the aim of controlling/regulating behaviour in a quick and practical way. If individual parents aren't comfortable doing it then fair enough, that's their choice.

Conflating it with 'beating', 'abusing' etc is ridiculous.

In the case of the OP, I'd suggest they have a word with the grandfather and make it clear that they don't approve of physical punishment so they don't want him to do it again. Obviously if he goes on to ignore them then they can escalate.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 09:03

DanseAvecLesLoup · 23/02/2023 09:00

I never said it is 'ok', just that stressed struggling parents (people) can be fallible.

If you don't think it's OK, why are you arguing with me for saying it's not OK?

DanseAvecLesLoup · 23/02/2023 09:00

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 08:18

Because people are fallible and at times during extreme stress may not follow textbook approved childrearing techniques?

But that's not a reason to say hitting kids is OK. It's a reason to say the parents need to look at themselves, their situation and their coping strategies to stop it happening again. Nobody seems to do it at work, no matter how much the boss pisses them off.

It's used as an excuse for smacking when it should be seen as a sign that things are not right and the parent needs to make changes. What do we do when kids hit someone because they've lost their temper?

I never said it is 'ok', just that stressed struggling parents (people) can be fallible.

illtakeit · 23/02/2023 08:45

I personally don't believe anyone that say's smacking a child is fine but I don't smack my own children. It's BS.

GoldDuster · 23/02/2023 08:29

Can I just check, the people that were hit and claim to not hit their own children because they've found a better way, is that because you're finding it hard to admit you hit your children? Or that you genuinely have found a better way?

If it's a good method of controlling behaviour, doesn't hurt or frighten a child at all, is quick, painless with no lasting negative effects then what are we doing moving towards banning it? Should we bring it back?

Would you like to see frazzled parents freely able to hit small children at the school gates after a long day without the current stigma?

How about stressed out aunties walloping twelve year olds in Primark because they're moaning and you're out of patience?

Humans naturally move towards reward. If it's effective and you don't feel bad about it, why don't you do it?

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 08:18

Because people are fallible and at times during extreme stress may not follow textbook approved childrearing techniques?

But that's not a reason to say hitting kids is OK. It's a reason to say the parents need to look at themselves, their situation and their coping strategies to stop it happening again. Nobody seems to do it at work, no matter how much the boss pisses them off.

It's used as an excuse for smacking when it should be seen as a sign that things are not right and the parent needs to make changes. What do we do when kids hit someone because they've lost their temper?

DanseAvecLesLoup · 23/02/2023 08:01

ReneBumsWombats · 22/02/2023 14:36

Why are people saying it's somehow excusable if they're "at the end of their tether"? As the grown up and the parent, isn't it your job to regulate and de-escalate situations and your own emotions before you reach the end of your tether?

Because people are fallible and at times during extreme stress may not follow textbook approved childrearing techniques? I don't think too many new parents start out with the view that smacking is to be part of their toolkit. I know more then a few parents who have admitted being at the 'end of the their tether' in the early years of parenting. Sleep deprived, exhausted, trying to hold down a full time job and barely keeping their head above the water and eventually snapping when a perfect storm of multiple external pressures and very challenging behaviour converge. Well done you if you managed to navigate those waters successfully, not everyone can.

I have seen on here frazzled upset parents confessing that they have slapped their kid for the first time. They are distraught by their actions and loss of control and know it was wrong but you still get the usual mob on here calling them violent abusers, telling them they need to leave the home, get the police and social services involved rather then realise they are just normal parents who have been pushed to the limits. Nobody is perfect, but your posts are coming across as particularly goady. No, before you accuse me of being an apologist for child abuse, I don't condone the smacking of children, but I'm not going to jump on otherwise loving caring parents who 'fail' to get everything right 100% of the time.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 07:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Why are your methods better than smacking? What is it they improve upon?

Can you just answer the question without insulting other posters?

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream · 23/02/2023 07:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 06:38

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream · 23/02/2023 06:31

@ReneBumsWombats I'm not sure why you feel it's appropriate to take over OP's thread like this and keep repeating the same thing to me like a stuck record but I have already explained my position and am not doing so any further to you

Because you haven't explained.

You're angry, you're defensive, you're insulting other posters and lying about what they've said, all to be an apologist for hitting children. You claim you're not actually advocating it, though, and use better methods.

Given how many excuses you're making for hitting children, and all your anger at those who won't back down about it, it's fair to ask how you think your methods are an improvement on hitting. The offence you're taking and constant refusal to answer are their own answer, of course.

But if you can keep attacking other posters and excusing hitting, I can keep asking. You said ages ago that you were going to ignore me because I was beneath you anyway.

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream · 23/02/2023 06:31

@ReneBumsWombats I'm not sure why you feel it's appropriate to take over OP's thread like this and keep repeating the same thing to me like a stuck record but I have already explained my position and am not doing so any further to you

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 06:09

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream · 22/02/2023 22:30

Now look here @Squamata and @Emmamoo89, @ReneBumsWombats has made it extremely clear on her nine million posts that you're obviously lying deluded hysterical child abuse apologists who had terrible traumatic childhoods that you won't admit to (not that there's any possibility that she's just projecting about her own shit parents).
So get back in your boxes now, thank you.

Why are your methods better than smacking?

LizzieW1969 · 22/02/2023 23:26

My childhood was traumatic but it wasn't primarily because my parents smacked my siblings and me a lot. (My DM accepts that this was wrong now.) It was because I was also being sexually abused by my F and others, as was my DSis.

However, I think it's possible that we would have felt able to tell my DM what was going on if we hadn’t been afraid that she would smack us for telling lies. We were often afraid of getting into trouble.

She was devastated when we told her about it a few years ago. Because there’s no question that she loved us and wasn’t intentionally abusive. She thought she was doing the right thing. (We were a Christian, church going family and parents were encouraged to smack in many churches in the 70s and 80s.)

The end result, though, was that we were abused and she never found out about it.

Emmamoo89 · 22/02/2023 22:39

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream · 22/02/2023 22:30

Now look here @Squamata and @Emmamoo89, @ReneBumsWombats has made it extremely clear on her nine million posts that you're obviously lying deluded hysterical child abuse apologists who had terrible traumatic childhoods that you won't admit to (not that there's any possibility that she's just projecting about her own shit parents).
So get back in your boxes now, thank you.

My childhood was definitely not traumatic cause I got smacked a few times. I was a little shit at times and definitely learned to not be a little shit!

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream · 22/02/2023 22:30

Now look here @Squamata and @Emmamoo89, @ReneBumsWombats has made it extremely clear on her nine million posts that you're obviously lying deluded hysterical child abuse apologists who had terrible traumatic childhoods that you won't admit to (not that there's any possibility that she's just projecting about her own shit parents).
So get back in your boxes now, thank you.

Emmamoo89 · 22/02/2023 22:22

Squamata · 22/02/2023 22:12

I remember being smacked and it not hurting.

Didn't hurt me either

somethingslastforever · 22/02/2023 22:21

Saying it's discipline and implying it's fine is strange imo. If another 50 odd year old man annoyed him would he hit him? I think not.

Don't understand how or why you would hit a child.

Swipe left for the next trending thread