Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Grandfather smacked DS bottom

667 replies

ranblungs · 21/02/2023 14:35

DS can have meltdowns/big tantrums, usually when he's very tired. More so when he's at his grandparents' house (ex's parents). They have communicated to me that they found his behaviour very difficult at one point, but it seems to have resolved now.

ExDP did live with them but moved our two weeks ago.

DS (aged 4) told me yesterday evening that grandad had smacked his bottom because he was being naughty and that it "really hurt" he got upset as he was telling me and cried. I get the impression this wasn't necessarily recent.

DS also can play up at bed time when he is there and he told me that grandad pushes him back onto the bed for being naughty at bed time.

I'm not sure what to do next?

They are huge sources of childcare, ExDP is supposed to have him two nights per week but often works away so they will have him. They also help out during the week as/when needed.

The relationship between us was once very strained when DS was tiny.

I am furious that he has hit my child. Am I overreacting as it was just a smack on the bottom?

DS can be very challenging there.

OP posts:
ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 11:40

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 10:03

A child too young to reason will not be able to understand why they've been hit.

If the child is old enough to reason...why can't you reason?

That is a really illogical and ill considered statement.

Children who are too young to be reasoned with still understand very well the purpose of a slap on the hand or bottom, which is to prevent a behaviour, not to necessarily explain why that behaviour is bad (which can and should come later when they can understand.)

The second part of the statement presents a false dichotomy, which is that we can only have reasoning or punishment, not both. That's not how the world works.

Even with adults, we don't just reason with them to make them aware of why they shouldn't do something and why its wrong. We do that as well, but we also punish and/or chastise in someway so they have an additonal incentive not to do it again.

Why should it be different for children? We should always reason with a child and explain why something is wrong of course (if they have the capacity to understand), but that doesn't mean they shouldn't be chastised as well, I mean, what if they just don't agree, or agree and then do it anyway? What if the behaviour is dangerous or damaging to them or others? All the reasoning in the world doesn't change the need for a clear punishment if the behaviour is not to be repeated.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 11:37

Smacking is not legal in Scotland or Wales, but it is still moral.

This is just argument by assertion and means nothing.

And I agree with PP - I'd never let you near my children. You aren't safe or reasoned.

Calphurnia88 · 23/02/2023 11:33

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 11:26

'Hurting children' smacking does hurt soemwhat of course but by that rule lets apply it to other methods as well. Stop calling it 'giving a time out' and start calling it 'psychologically torturing' instead.

Hyperbole helps nobody. 🙄

You are conflating legal with moral.

Marital rape was never morally ok, but it was legal.

Smacking is not legal in Scotland or Wales, but it is still moral.

Smacking is not legal in Scotland or Wales, but it is still moral.

I don't even know what to say to this response (that won't be deleted).

Suffice to say if you were my mother you wouldn't be allowed anywhere near my children unsupervised. And that is not hyperbole.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 11:32

If by "unable to cope with life", you mean depression, trauma etc...Well yes. Kids who were smacked are known to exhibit those symptoms far more than those who weren't. The fact it wasnt understood and recorded as such in the past doesn't mean it wasn't there, and you can easily see examples of desensitisation and abuse - and mental illness - in human history.

Honestly, it's the daftest argument for "smacking is OK" that we've had yet.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 11:28

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 11:19

I never said that nobody in the past ever suffered from psychological issues, just that if what you and others were saying is true about physical chastisement, then literally everyone in the past would have been deeply damaged.

Please can you address my actual position, not one you imagine I hold.

Your position is already risibly reductive, as you're trying to claim that smacking isn't wrong unless every single person who was ever smacked experiences extreme mental breakdown to the point of either suicide or being unable to live independently (unless you meant something else by "unable to cope with life", in which case do share).

We don't use that as the measure of whether any other kind of assault or abuse is wrong. Once again, it's weird that the standards are so different when it comes to children.

The studies are in and have been for ages. It's no longer a matter of opinion. Outcomes for children who were smacked are overall consistently worse than for those who weren't. The fact that you have a very odd view of human history and how psychological trauma shows itself is really neither here nor there.

I suspect you're of the "if nobody outside the house sees anything wrong, nothing is wrong" school of thought. Scary

Loics · 23/02/2023 11:28

Well, I have an annoying colleague who I'm now looking forward to smacking next time he annoys me. I won't hurt him, just a small chastisement for being rude, so I won't have done anything wrong...

Ifeellikeateenageragain · 23/02/2023 11:28

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 11:19

I never said that nobody in the past ever suffered from psychological issues, just that if what you and others were saying is true about physical chastisement, then literally everyone in the past would have been deeply damaged.

Please can you address my actual position, not one you imagine I hold.

But that's the point - not EVERYONE in the past physically assaulted their children so no, not everyone was affected. But many people did, and therefore there was a significant degree of damage in previous generations.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 11:26

Calphurnia88 · 23/02/2023 11:18

Yes it does.

You keep using the fact that physical chastisement - or hurting children, to call it what it is - has gone on for thousands of years, so therefore it must be OK. Marital rape was only criminalised 20 years ago, so can we assume that it was OK for thousands of years prior?

You're on the wrong side of history here.

'Hurting children' smacking does hurt soemwhat of course but by that rule lets apply it to other methods as well. Stop calling it 'giving a time out' and start calling it 'psychologically torturing' instead.

Hyperbole helps nobody. 🙄

You are conflating legal with moral.

Marital rape was never morally ok, but it was legal.

Smacking is not legal in Scotland or Wales, but it is still moral.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 11:19

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 11:13

Ooh, a silly generalisation, was it?

I was being a bit glib. But in response to someone who seems to think psychological damage essentially didn't exist in two years of human millennia, it seemed appropriate. Since we're talking about silly generalisations.

I never said that nobody in the past ever suffered from psychological issues, just that if what you and others were saying is true about physical chastisement, then literally everyone in the past would have been deeply damaged.

Please can you address my actual position, not one you imagine I hold.

Calphurnia88 · 23/02/2023 11:18

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 09:57

What are you talking about? Nobody is suggesting 'bringing back' obviously criminal activites because they used to be acceptable.

As you said yourself, putting smacking in the same category as marital rape iis ridiculous and does nothing to prove your point, or disprove mine.

Yes it does.

You keep using the fact that physical chastisement - or hurting children, to call it what it is - has gone on for thousands of years, so therefore it must be OK. Marital rape was only criminalised 20 years ago, so can we assume that it was OK for thousands of years prior?

You're on the wrong side of history here.

SpideyCraw · 23/02/2023 11:15

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 09:51

Or maybe, a better question: ask them if they smack their own kids and if not, why not.

But I should warn you that my experience of asking this is to receive abuse, hyperbole and accusations of insanity...but not an actual answer.

You can see from my post a few pages back I think smacking is wrong and would never smack a child, so the question isn’t aimed at me, but to be fair the answer is pretty obvious.

A poster did answer above by saying that they think there are more effective discipline methods, which is consistent with holding an opinion (albeit one I disagree with) that smacking isn’t always wrong.

there is significant daylight between something being always wrong, and something being the best way. I assume those posters say that they think smacking falls in the middle. Not wrong to abuse, but not the best way either, hence they choose other better methods. I’ve genuinely been really confused why you keep asking that question.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 11:14

Two years of human millennia? Gah. You know know I mean. Two millennia of human existence. There was definitely psychological damage featuring in it.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 11:13

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 11:08

Again what a silly generalisation.

My grandparents were born in the late 19th century and i can clearly remember when I was little that they had nothing but contempt for the small minority of people they knew (literally 2 people) who were rumoured to 'knock their wives around'.

Just because unacceptable things used to happen, doesn't mean they were somehow seen as 'OK' or were encouraged.

Ooh, a silly generalisation, was it?

I was being a bit glib. But in response to someone who seems to think psychological damage essentially didn't exist in two years of human millennia, it seemed appropriate. Since we're talking about silly generalisations.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 11:09

BlueVinca · 23/02/2023 11:01

I started hitting back at 14 and it stopped then.

Good for you. It took me a bit longer but yes, the day I hit back was the day they suddenly managed to stop reaching the end of their tether etc etc.

Amazing.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 11:08

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 10:00

I would argue that our ancestors were far more physcologically robust and able to cope with life than any of us today!

You weren't there, but from what I gather, the men coped by drinking and hitting their wives and the women coped by taking drugs and gaining a reputation for being irrational.

But I might just be bitter, as a member of the generation that invented allergies and ADHD...

Again what a silly generalisation.

My grandparents were born in the late 19th century and i can clearly remember when I was little that they had nothing but contempt for the small minority of people they knew (literally 2 people) who were rumoured to 'knock their wives around'.

Just because unacceptable things used to happen, doesn't mean they were somehow seen as 'OK' or were encouraged.

BlueVinca · 23/02/2023 11:01

bigbazooka · 23/02/2023 10:08

Bingo! I remember clearly when I started "lightly" defending myself it suddenly stopped. I think I was about 15 or 16 then.

I started hitting back at 14 and it stopped then.

Calphurnia88 · 23/02/2023 10:55

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

QuizzlyBear · 23/02/2023 10:15

I'm 46 and was smacked as a child with hands and a wooden spoon. It bred fear and resentment towards the parent who did it.

Therefore with my kids I haven't once raised a hand to them in any capacity as I don't want to parent through fear.

My MIL was looking after DS1 when he was a toddler and I saw her smack his hand to tell him off (she didn't hurt him, it was was more 'performative') I have to admit that I marched right in and told her that wasn't how we raised our child, that physical punishment wasn't our chosen way to parent him and if she wanted to be a part of raising him, she'd have to do it our way.

She was pretty shocked as I'm non confrontational and she usually gets her own way in most things, but to give her her dues, she never once tried to smack or 'tap' him ever again.

Maybe try talking to your in-laws before quitting your job, going to SS or plunging yourself into poverty. You might be surprised at their willingness to adapt.

GoldDuster · 23/02/2023 10:13

Let's be fair, don't let @ColonelDax take the all the queries just because she's got the front to admit it... how about all the other posters who don't mind a good old smack of a small child?

When's a good time to stop hitting your children do you think?

Join in!

hello...?

GoldDuster · 23/02/2023 10:11

But, absolutely happy to be wrong @ColonelDax

Just out of interest, why and when did you stop hitting your children. If you're able to say.

GoldDuster · 23/02/2023 10:09

Boys in particular have a moment they can recall, especially with fathers who like to indulge in a bit of sensible hitting where it was the last time.

That wasn't because the parent made a rational assessment and realised that their work was done, all was well and the child had sustained the perfect amount of wallops to do the job and they were now very well behaved.

It was because the adult hit the now child, the child looked them in the eye and there was a moment where the adult knew they wouldn't get away with it again.

bigbazooka · 23/02/2023 10:08

GoldDuster · 23/02/2023 10:04

@ForTheLoveOfSleep

At what age do you think smacking should commence.

And just as interestingly, at what age should it stop? Oh hang on, it seems to just weirdly naturally fizzle out when they're big enough to hit you back.

Bingo! I remember clearly when I started "lightly" defending myself it suddenly stopped. I think I was about 15 or 16 then.

GoldDuster · 23/02/2023 10:04

@ForTheLoveOfSleep

At what age do you think smacking should commence.

And just as interestingly, at what age should it stop? Oh hang on, it seems to just weirdly naturally fizzle out when they're big enough to hit you back.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 10:03

A child too young to reason will not be able to understand why they've been hit.

If the child is old enough to reason...why can't you reason?