Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Grandfather smacked DS bottom

667 replies

ranblungs · 21/02/2023 14:35

DS can have meltdowns/big tantrums, usually when he's very tired. More so when he's at his grandparents' house (ex's parents). They have communicated to me that they found his behaviour very difficult at one point, but it seems to have resolved now.

ExDP did live with them but moved our two weeks ago.

DS (aged 4) told me yesterday evening that grandad had smacked his bottom because he was being naughty and that it "really hurt" he got upset as he was telling me and cried. I get the impression this wasn't necessarily recent.

DS also can play up at bed time when he is there and he told me that grandad pushes him back onto the bed for being naughty at bed time.

I'm not sure what to do next?

They are huge sources of childcare, ExDP is supposed to have him two nights per week but often works away so they will have him. They also help out during the week as/when needed.

The relationship between us was once very strained when DS was tiny.

I am furious that he has hit my child. Am I overreacting as it was just a smack on the bottom?

DS can be very challenging there.

OP posts:
ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:27

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 13:23

Why should I try you? You think keeping a one year old away from sockets is the worst form of helicopter parenting and equivalent to hovering over kids every second until adulthood.

What have you got to contribute, except to illustrate beautifully why smacking is such a bad technique?

This is your opportunity to prove me wrong.

Please tell me how you did it differently with your kids and what other parents should do.

You are adamant that I'm wrong so show all the parents reading this thread why they should ignore my advice and take yours.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 13:25

I genuinely haven't seen any studies that say anything like that, without conflating together a whole load of other factors such as socio-economic status etc

See, right here. You've seen the studies, with empirical evidence, and decided they aren't true.

Why should I try you?

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:24

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 13:17

If you think its shit, then fair enough, don't do it.

This doesn't really cut it when it comes to violence against children, and a parenting technique that is now known to have negative outcomes. People promoting it now are worse than those who did it historically because in the past, they didn't know conclusively that it's bad and nowadays we do.

What is your parenting approach, particularly around punishment/consequence then?

In terms of children who are too young to reason or understand danger, it's to supervise them properly so they don't get a chance to stick their fingers in sockets. But you think this is the worst form of helicopter parenting (the worst, I tell you!).

other than telling parents they have to hover over their children for every second of their lives until adulthood

That's what you take from "properly supervise your one or two year old"?

And you expect me to believe I could have an intelligent discussion with you about alternatives to hitting?

Ignore above, quoted myself by mistake. 😂

You keep saying that smacking has been proven to have negative outcomes, I genuinely haven't seen any studies that say anything like that, without conflating together a whole load of other factors such as socio-economic status etc, and that also treat a light smack on a bare bum and beating a child so hard they end up in hospital as the same thing. 🙄

Do you have access to any that don't do this, because I'd be genuinely willing to read them and then reconsider my position.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 13:23

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:19

So try me.

How do you discipline and control your children once they aren't toddlers?

Why should I try you? You think keeping a one year old away from sockets is the worst form of helicopter parenting and equivalent to hovering over kids every second until adulthood.

What have you got to contribute, except to illustrate beautifully why smacking is such a bad technique?

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:23

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:19

So try me.

How do you discipline and control your children once they aren't toddlers?

And also you keep saying that smacking has been proven to have negative outcomes, I genuinely haven't seen any studies that say anything like that, without conflating together a whole load of other factors such as socio-economic status etc, and that also treat a light smack on a bare bum and beating a child so hard they end up in hospital as the same thing. 🙄

Do you have access to any that don't do this, because I'd be genuinely willing to read them and then reconsider my position.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:19

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 13:17

If you think its shit, then fair enough, don't do it.

This doesn't really cut it when it comes to violence against children, and a parenting technique that is now known to have negative outcomes. People promoting it now are worse than those who did it historically because in the past, they didn't know conclusively that it's bad and nowadays we do.

What is your parenting approach, particularly around punishment/consequence then?

In terms of children who are too young to reason or understand danger, it's to supervise them properly so they don't get a chance to stick their fingers in sockets. But you think this is the worst form of helicopter parenting (the worst, I tell you!).

other than telling parents they have to hover over their children for every second of their lives until adulthood

That's what you take from "properly supervise your one or two year old"?

And you expect me to believe I could have an intelligent discussion with you about alternatives to hitting?

So try me.

How do you discipline and control your children once they aren't toddlers?

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 13:17

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:08

If you think its shit, then fair enough, don't do it.

What is your parenting approach, particularly around punishment/consequence then?

Because you are doing a very good job of telling me why I'm immoral and wrong, but other than telling parents they have to hover over their children for every second of their lives until adulthood, you haven't actually given any practical alternatives?

If you think its shit, then fair enough, don't do it.

This doesn't really cut it when it comes to violence against children, and a parenting technique that is now known to have negative outcomes. People promoting it now are worse than those who did it historically because in the past, they didn't know conclusively that it's bad and nowadays we do.

What is your parenting approach, particularly around punishment/consequence then?

In terms of children who are too young to reason or understand danger, it's to supervise them properly so they don't get a chance to stick their fingers in sockets. But you think this is the worst form of helicopter parenting (the worst, I tell you!).

other than telling parents they have to hover over their children for every second of their lives until adulthood

That's what you take from "properly supervise your one or two year old"?

And you expect me to believe I could have an intelligent discussion with you about alternatives to hitting?

Emmamoo89 · 23/02/2023 13:13

Calphurnia88 · 23/02/2023 12:57

@ColonelDax you keep mentioning time outs and I'm going to stop you there.

Time outs are considered ineffective by many child psychologists, paediatricians, etc. I wouldn't smack my child, but I wouldn't use a time out either. It isn't an either or situation.

I'd do time out.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:13

Wishfulthankin · 23/02/2023 13:02

So Out of interest....
How do people discipline their children?
My first was an absolute angel, did as told, my middle child was feral, didn't listen, was dangerously unpredictable in terms of road safety, took delight in pushing boundaries.

What would you use to discipline?

Exactly my point, a lot of people like to sit in their ivory tower and tell parents how everything they are doing is wrong, but then are less willing to give practical suggestions.

I think of myself as average intelligence, maybe a bit above, I am educated to post grad level (although I came to it late in life) and I like to think I put a lot of thought into what I do.

I am lost with a lot of modern parenting techniques, they predicate endless patience, endless time, and a significant degree of assumed knowledge about relatively difficult concepts of child psychology.

The fear is that if I struggle, then the ~50% of people in this country who have below average intelligence don't have a chance, and if you take away the only simple methods they have (smacking, time outs etc), then they won't move onto the more complex ones, they will just end up with nothing.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:08

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 13:01

Thank you for this very long exercise in defensiveness and self-justification.

But honestly, I preferred it when you were claiming that supervising a one year old is the worst form of helicopter parenting (The Worst!), arguing by assertion that smacking is moral, admitting that smacking doesn't explain anything and back and forthing over whether or not you could cover sockets.

That was at least on topic. Perfectly illustrated why smacking is always shit parenting, too.

If you think its shit, then fair enough, don't do it.

What is your parenting approach, particularly around punishment/consequence then?

Because you are doing a very good job of telling me why I'm immoral and wrong, but other than telling parents they have to hover over their children for every second of their lives until adulthood, you haven't actually given any practical alternatives?

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:05

Calphurnia88 · 23/02/2023 12:57

@ColonelDax you keep mentioning time outs and I'm going to stop you there.

Time outs are considered ineffective by many child psychologists, paediatricians, etc. I wouldn't smack my child, but I wouldn't use a time out either. It isn't an either or situation.

Genuine question, what would you use instead?

Wishfulthankin · 23/02/2023 13:02

Calphurnia88 · 23/02/2023 12:57

@ColonelDax you keep mentioning time outs and I'm going to stop you there.

Time outs are considered ineffective by many child psychologists, paediatricians, etc. I wouldn't smack my child, but I wouldn't use a time out either. It isn't an either or situation.

So Out of interest....
How do people discipline their children?
My first was an absolute angel, did as told, my middle child was feral, didn't listen, was dangerously unpredictable in terms of road safety, took delight in pushing boundaries.

What would you use to discipline?

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 13:01

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 12:53

This is going to start getting personal, and its not intended to be, but to be clear, I never had to hover over my children, I never had to put them on reigns to leave the house, when I spoke they listened and (usually) did what i asked, they were and still are polite and well behaved. As adults they could absolutely tell me they hated growing up in our house because of their treatment, to date they haven't, in fact they often tell me and others how happy their childhoods were.

There was no climate of fear, we talked openly about everything and nothing was off the table, everything was explained to them and they were constantly reasoned with and talked to in a mature way. Smacking, on the rare occasions that it happened never took place when I was angry or 'at the end of my tether', it was always a considered option.

I don't think I ever smacked any of them beyond the age of about 9.

I have a friend who didn't believe in smacking. Fair enough, their choice. But I recall often seeing them trying to enforce a time out or some kind of other punishment and having to keep a stubborn child returning again and again until eventually they mentally broke and complied, sobbing, wheezing and totally exhausted from the emotional effort of the encounter. Meanwhile they were no doubt utterly convinced that that was better for the child than a short sharp tap on the bum, 30 seconds of tears then crack on would have been. 🙄

To this day they no doubt still believe that they never hurt their children, I am still friends with them but I don't doubt they think they parented better than me.

Interesting that my kids all turned out more motivated, successful and mature than theirs did, although I'm not saying its because I used physical punishment on rare occasion, i think its far more likely down to a combination of factors, including our general approach to preparing them to stand on their own and be mature and robust, rather than molly coddle them.

Very happy for you to think that you are better than me because you have never 'hurt' your children. Good luck.

All I ask is that you are honest with yourself and think about what 'hurt' actually means and what is actually best for children in the long term.

Thank you for this very long exercise in defensiveness and self-justification.

But honestly, I preferred it when you were claiming that supervising a one year old is the worst form of helicopter parenting (The Worst!), arguing by assertion that smacking is moral, admitting that smacking doesn't explain anything and back and forthing over whether or not you could cover sockets.

That was at least on topic. Perfectly illustrated why smacking is always shit parenting, too.

Calphurnia88 · 23/02/2023 12:57

@ColonelDax you keep mentioning time outs and I'm going to stop you there.

Time outs are considered ineffective by many child psychologists, paediatricians, etc. I wouldn't smack my child, but I wouldn't use a time out either. It isn't an either or situation.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 12:53

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 12:35

What you are describing is the absolute worst form of helicopter parenting where you hover endlessly over your child, removing any possible issue or barrier so they never have to face it. When do you stop doing that?

This is actually amazing. Keeping your toddler off the road and away from sockets is "the worst form of helicopter parenting". But failing to prevent a disaster while they're too young to understand danger and then hitting them for it is brilliant parenting.

And you can't work out when you stop supervising them? How about when they're old enough to understand and so you no longer need to?

This is going to start getting personal, and its not intended to be, but to be clear, I never had to hover over my children, I never had to put them on reigns to leave the house, when I spoke they listened and (usually) did what i asked, they were and still are polite and well behaved. As adults they could absolutely tell me they hated growing up in our house because of their treatment, to date they haven't, in fact they often tell me and others how happy their childhoods were.

There was no climate of fear, we talked openly about everything and nothing was off the table, everything was explained to them and they were constantly reasoned with and talked to in a mature way. Smacking, on the rare occasions that it happened never took place when I was angry or 'at the end of my tether', it was always a considered option.

I don't think I ever smacked any of them beyond the age of about 9.

I have a friend who didn't believe in smacking. Fair enough, their choice. But I recall often seeing them trying to enforce a time out or some kind of other punishment and having to keep a stubborn child returning again and again until eventually they mentally broke and complied, sobbing, wheezing and totally exhausted from the emotional effort of the encounter. Meanwhile they were no doubt utterly convinced that that was better for the child than a short sharp tap on the bum, 30 seconds of tears then crack on would have been. 🙄

To this day they no doubt still believe that they never hurt their children, I am still friends with them but I don't doubt they think they parented better than me.

Interesting that my kids all turned out more motivated, successful and mature than theirs did, although I'm not saying its because I used physical punishment on rare occasion, i think its far more likely down to a combination of factors, including our general approach to preparing them to stand on their own and be mature and robust, rather than molly coddle them.

Very happy for you to think that you are better than me because you have never 'hurt' your children. Good luck.

All I ask is that you are honest with yourself and think about what 'hurt' actually means and what is actually best for children in the long term.

Calphurnia88 · 23/02/2023 12:50

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 12:35

As we covered earlier, if your measure of morality is linked to if something is legal or not, you will get yourself in a very dark place very quickly.

Whose countries laws are the objective standard?

Some things that are illegal in this world are completely moral - gay marriage, apostasy etc

Some things are legal but totally immoral - adultery etc.

I prefer to go with right and wrong.

Are you implying that a law designed to protect the welfare of children could have nefarious intentions?

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 12:35

Calphurnia88 · 23/02/2023 12:27

My position is very clear, smacking isn't the best solution to every situation, or even a solution at all to some things, but it is a valuable part of a parents toolbag and you sneer at it from your moral high ground at your peril.

Unless, of course, you're in Scotland and Wales where it is illegal. In which case you risk being arrested or charged with assault, and you may get a criminal record.

As we covered earlier, if your measure of morality is linked to if something is legal or not, you will get yourself in a very dark place very quickly.

Whose countries laws are the objective standard?

Some things that are illegal in this world are completely moral - gay marriage, apostasy etc

Some things are legal but totally immoral - adultery etc.

I prefer to go with right and wrong.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 12:35

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 12:30

I think you are making my point for me. What you are describing is the absolute worst form of helicopter parenting where you hover endlessly over your child, removing any possible issue or barrier so they never have to face it. When do you stop doing that? Do you ever?

How does your method help a child in any way to learn how to adapt to the world or survive in it?

I'd argue that form of parenting damages children far more than a quick smack on the bum ever could! How many young adults do we meet in everyday life who have grown up in this manner and are completely infantilised as a result.

I'd rather live in a society built by people brought with my methods than yours I'm afraid. At least it would function.

What you are describing is the absolute worst form of helicopter parenting where you hover endlessly over your child, removing any possible issue or barrier so they never have to face it. When do you stop doing that?

This is actually amazing. Keeping your toddler off the road and away from sockets is "the worst form of helicopter parenting". But failing to prevent a disaster while they're too young to understand danger and then hitting them for it is brilliant parenting.

And you can't work out when you stop supervising them? How about when they're old enough to understand and so you no longer need to?

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 12:32

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 12:26

smacking isn't the best solution to every situation

It's never the best solution to any situation. It's always a failure. So why, if you're trying your best and you know this, would you not opt for the better solution?

Because I'm afraid I disagree. It's often the best solution to some situations.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 12:30

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 12:24

He couldn't get socket covers offWait a minute. You said covering the sockets didn't work?But it did?And you had covers he couldn't get off, but you still chose to hit him when he wasn't old enough to understand?You could have covered the sockets that were free and closely supervised him around the ones that weren't, intervening when he got too close. And explained to him, once he was old enough, why it was dangerous.And you still chose to hit instead?

I think you are making my point for me. What you are describing is the absolute worst form of helicopter parenting where you hover endlessly over your child, removing any possible issue or barrier so they never have to face it. When do you stop doing that? Do you ever?

How does your method help a child in any way to learn how to adapt to the world or survive in it?

I'd argue that form of parenting damages children far more than a quick smack on the bum ever could! How many young adults do we meet in everyday life who have grown up in this manner and are completely infantilised as a result.

I'd rather live in a society built by people brought with my methods than yours I'm afraid. At least it would function.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 12:30

Socket covers are not recommended as they can be dangerous.

Not heard that, but if it's true, fine. Supervise your child properly instead and maybe block the socket with something they can't move. Either way, just don't let your child move all around the room, head towards a socket, start reaching for it, and only then decide it's time to do something about it.

Sockets are only one thing that a child might hurt themselves on while going around a room. That's the whole point of supervision and intervening.

Calphurnia88 · 23/02/2023 12:27

My position is very clear, smacking isn't the best solution to every situation, or even a solution at all to some things, but it is a valuable part of a parents toolbag and you sneer at it from your moral high ground at your peril.

Unless, of course, you're in Scotland and Wales where it is illegal. In which case you risk being arrested or charged with assault, and you may get a criminal record.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 12:26

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 12:23

And I think demonstrating that the vehement 'smacking is evil' opinion is held by people who are ideologically motivated and wilfully choose not to think about things from an position of honesty.

My position is very clear, smacking isn't the best solution to every situation, or even a solution at all to some things, but it is a valuable part of a parents toolbag and you sneer at it from your moral high ground at your peril.

I also come back again to my point that other 'approved' methods of parenting are equally hurtful, if not more damaging in some cases, but because the hurt occurs internally, that's ok then and doesn't puncture the idea of 'I don't smack, therefore I'm better than you' mentality.

smacking isn't the best solution to every situation

It's never the best solution to any situation. It's always a failure. So why, if you're trying your best and you know this, would you not opt for the better solution?

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 12:25

Wishfulthankin · 23/02/2023 12:22

Socket covers are not recommended as they can be dangerous.
Sanctimonious much....

It seems impossible to discipline kids these days without someone saying you're being cruel, whether a tap on the wrist or a time out. Sometimes you can't speak calmly at their level as they're headbutting you, pulling their baby sisters hair, running out into the road. Life isn't perfect and parents do the best they can.

As to the OP, explain your view on smacking, it's your child, let them change their ways. A smack on the bottom or tap on the hand is not abuse. It may not be ideal but it's not a strict no contact call the police scenario.

100% this.

In a perfect world, no child would ever behave badly, and all issues could be calmly explained to children who would then instantly understand and comply.

But we don't live in that world, we live in this one.

pastabakes · 23/02/2023 12:25

In my head, the response would be a swift punch in the face, followed by ‘Sorry, I thought violence solved everything??‘.

However, thats obviously not advisable!

Report him for assault, let the police show up at his door to question him. Make it very clear that being a violent pos has consequences.

Swipe left for the next trending thread