Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Grandfather smacked DS bottom

667 replies

ranblungs · 21/02/2023 14:35

DS can have meltdowns/big tantrums, usually when he's very tired. More so when he's at his grandparents' house (ex's parents). They have communicated to me that they found his behaviour very difficult at one point, but it seems to have resolved now.

ExDP did live with them but moved our two weeks ago.

DS (aged 4) told me yesterday evening that grandad had smacked his bottom because he was being naughty and that it "really hurt" he got upset as he was telling me and cried. I get the impression this wasn't necessarily recent.

DS also can play up at bed time when he is there and he told me that grandad pushes him back onto the bed for being naughty at bed time.

I'm not sure what to do next?

They are huge sources of childcare, ExDP is supposed to have him two nights per week but often works away so they will have him. They also help out during the week as/when needed.

The relationship between us was once very strained when DS was tiny.

I am furious that he has hit my child. Am I overreacting as it was just a smack on the bottom?

DS can be very challenging there.

OP posts:
BlueVinca · 23/02/2023 18:14

WarningToTheCurious · 23/02/2023 18:04

If you want to be pernickety (given that you said Sweden banned it in the 70s), Sweden banned all corporal punishment in 1966. Norway had a ban on school corporal punishment for a while before Sweden and banned parental corporal punishment in 1972.

Anyway, it’s a moot point because the factors influencing adolescent and adult criminal behaviour include many, many more factors.

The point I was making (which seems to have gone over your head) is that we have proof that not smacking children doesn't have adverse outcomes, as we have seen with Sweden having banned it decades ago. You being pernickety about Norway being earlier is just trying to distract from the fact that its perfectly possible to bring up a child without assaulting them.

WarningToTheCurious · 23/02/2023 18:04

BlueVinca · 23/02/2023 17:53

Not correct. Sweden was the first country.
brilliantmaps.com/corporal-punishment/

If you want to be pernickety (given that you said Sweden banned it in the 70s), Sweden banned all corporal punishment in 1966. Norway had a ban on school corporal punishment for a while before Sweden and banned parental corporal punishment in 1972.

Anyway, it’s a moot point because the factors influencing adolescent and adult criminal behaviour include many, many more factors.

BlueVinca · 23/02/2023 17:53

WarningToTheCurious · 23/02/2023 17:41

Sweden has the 4th highest robbery rate in the EU and is the only country in Europe where gun crime is increasing.

You’d be better off comparing to Norway, which banned parental corporal punishment in 1972 and has significantly lower crime rates than Sweden.

Not correct. Sweden was the first country.
brilliantmaps.com/corporal-punishment/

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 17:53

Apologies all. That was a very important phone call.

So I see we've got exactly what we all knew would happen...hitter demands alternatives, alternatives are given, hitter denies alternatives have been given. Quelle surprise.

The problem with smacking isn't just that it damages children. It also often seems to go alongside a God complex whereby people think that things become fact merely by their stating them ("smacking is moral", "nobody gave practical examples of alternatives"). Whether the smacking creates the God complex or vice versa, I don't know, but I've noticed that the two go together very often. We've established that smacking bypasses reason, after all.

It may be partly because hitters are more concerned with justifying themselves so they don't have to admit they made mistakes than they are with assaulting children. The ego is powerful.

Anywat, I'm much too tired to go into full detail, but effectively the main points I planned to make earlier are:

  • model the behaviour you want them to learn, including apologising
  • supervise and be preventative when they're too young to understand danger or reason
  • enact natural consequences where you must, eg, not playing nicely with toy, toy is removed for a while
  • positive reinforcement, ie praise for doing well. Then you often need only not to praise when things aren't going well.

Unfortunately, these methods don't give the quick satisfaction of venting your frustration by hitting, and they do require the parent to do some work on themselves. Which I suppose partly explains the vehement opposition to them, to the extent of denying they even exist.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 17:52

Wishfulthankin · 23/02/2023 17:03

Distracting by reading a book? 😂😂 My kids bashing hell out his little sister... So I'll read a book to him?
One child is significantly easier, having to be places and do things with a tantruming toddler refusing to get dressed and hitting me (normal toddler behaviour before you ask me to review my parenting)...I don't have time to wait it out, I've got to get my other kid to hospital appointments. I ignore them mainly but not if I've got to be somewhere.

Distraction after hurling himself into the road? Okay..

I've yet to see alternatives stated here.
I use the naughty step but apparently that is on par with water torture so I'm at a loss as to what I'm actually supposed to do

How old is he? Toddlers I'd first comfort the sister, then tell him we need to go because we've an important appointment so I'm going to pick him up and put him in the car. I'd tell him to take deep breaths to calm down and do deep breaths with him should moving (I've done this with a 3 yr old while baby was in a sling.) Get both onto car and go. When calm (whether during or after appointment) we'd discuss why no hitting. He's extremely gentle with his sister now. (Sometimes does knock her over by accident as he's an enthusiastic 5 yr old and she's 18/12 old but never on purpose or when angry) he'll get cross and ask me to stop her taking a toy or whatever but he doesn't snatch or hit her. Also I can confiently say 'we don't hit each other in this family, we don't shout at each other in this family' and he sees it's true. So yeah, practically that's what I do.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 17:48

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 11:48

I find the whole 'I'm against any kind of smacking, its abuse crowd' quite tiresome to be honest, as its always the same hyperbole expressed, with no attempt to address an argument.

Even on this thread there seems to be a feeling that a parent who gives their child a single smack on their bottom after numerous warnings is morally equivalent to a parent who beats their child with a baseball bat.

Until people can be sensible, its impossible to have a sensible discussion.

Of course you do, because you smacked your children and you'd need to admit to being a abusive parent to acknowledge the truth.

WarningToTheCurious · 23/02/2023 17:41

BlueVinca · 23/02/2023 17:01

They've got a lower murder rate than the UK and France for a start, and far lower than the US where smacking is still legal. Smacking was only made illegal recently in France, Scotland, Wales and NI. Still legal in England but its only a matter of time. Its illegal in over 60 countries including all our neighbouring countries.

Sweden has the 4th highest robbery rate in the EU and is the only country in Europe where gun crime is increasing.

You’d be better off comparing to Norway, which banned parental corporal punishment in 1972 and has significantly lower crime rates than Sweden.

BlueVinca · 23/02/2023 17:12

Wishfulthankin · 23/02/2023 17:03

Distracting by reading a book? 😂😂 My kids bashing hell out his little sister... So I'll read a book to him?
One child is significantly easier, having to be places and do things with a tantruming toddler refusing to get dressed and hitting me (normal toddler behaviour before you ask me to review my parenting)...I don't have time to wait it out, I've got to get my other kid to hospital appointments. I ignore them mainly but not if I've got to be somewhere.

Distraction after hurling himself into the road? Okay..

I've yet to see alternatives stated here.
I use the naughty step but apparently that is on par with water torture so I'm at a loss as to what I'm actually supposed to do

These books are useful

www.amazon.co.uk/gp/aw/d/0091923859?psc=1&ref=ppx_pop_mob_b_asin_title

www.amazon.co.uk/Little-Angels-Essential-Transforming-Children/dp/056351941X/ref=mp_s_a_1_3?crid=1QJYTUYJXX9EY&keywords=little+angel+tanya&qid=1677172315&sprefix=little+angel+tanya%2Caps%2C101&sr=8-3

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 17:11

Wishfulthankin · 23/02/2023 17:03

Distracting by reading a book? 😂😂 My kids bashing hell out his little sister... So I'll read a book to him?
One child is significantly easier, having to be places and do things with a tantruming toddler refusing to get dressed and hitting me (normal toddler behaviour before you ask me to review my parenting)...I don't have time to wait it out, I've got to get my other kid to hospital appointments. I ignore them mainly but not if I've got to be somewhere.

Distraction after hurling himself into the road? Okay..

I've yet to see alternatives stated here.
I use the naughty step but apparently that is on par with water torture so I'm at a loss as to what I'm actually supposed to do

Exactly this. Still not had one single piece of practical advice on punishment/consequence from all of the perfect parents who think I'm the devil incarnate because I occasionally gave my kids a smacked bottom or hand, or sent them to their room with no supper.

BlueVinca · 23/02/2023 17:07

It tends to be when you bring up your own kids that you really reflect on how you were brought up. A friend and I were talking about the smacking that went on when we were at primary school and how strange it seems now its been illegal for a while. That's probably how kids will view having been smacked by parents in future.

Wishfulthankin · 23/02/2023 17:03

Distracting by reading a book? 😂😂 My kids bashing hell out his little sister... So I'll read a book to him?
One child is significantly easier, having to be places and do things with a tantruming toddler refusing to get dressed and hitting me (normal toddler behaviour before you ask me to review my parenting)...I don't have time to wait it out, I've got to get my other kid to hospital appointments. I ignore them mainly but not if I've got to be somewhere.

Distraction after hurling himself into the road? Okay..

I've yet to see alternatives stated here.
I use the naughty step but apparently that is on par with water torture so I'm at a loss as to what I'm actually supposed to do

BlueVinca · 23/02/2023 17:01

WarningToTheCurious · 23/02/2023 16:44

Sweden has one of the highest (and increasing) rates of gun crime in Europe.

Although I doubt that you can make a link to a smacking ban and increased gang violence, robberies and shootings.

They've got a lower murder rate than the UK and France for a start, and far lower than the US where smacking is still legal. Smacking was only made illegal recently in France, Scotland, Wales and NI. Still legal in England but its only a matter of time. Its illegal in over 60 countries including all our neighbouring countries.

WarningToTheCurious · 23/02/2023 16:44

BlueVinca · 23/02/2023 16:21

Smacking has been illegal in Sweden since the 70s and they don't appear to be a violent, crime ridden country.

Sweden has one of the highest (and increasing) rates of gun crime in Europe.

Although I doubt that you can make a link to a smacking ban and increased gang violence, robberies and shootings.

BlueVinca · 23/02/2023 16:21

Smacking has been illegal in Sweden since the 70s and they don't appear to be a violent, crime ridden country.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 16:13

flutterbyebaby · 23/02/2023 15:51

Tbh if evidence came and slapped to across the face you still wouldn't stand down from your stance, so what is the actual point of trying to prove other way. You feel violence to those smaller than you is acceptable and that's that. I'd call that being a coward.

I'm really happy to look at evidence, I've said so a few times on this thread.

The issue is that there aren't any studies that don't have huge flaws in both their methodologies and their conclusions. Read them yourself if you want instead of just taking people's word that they 'prove' your point and you'll see what I mean.

I'd argue the fact I go looking for reputable studies in order to challenge my own assumptions and ideas makes me the opposite of what you are characterising me as.

On the other hand, name calling me because you disagree with me without substantively engaging with anything I said isn't exactly indicative of someone who is open minded and willing to think about a subject unemotionally.

I think you are holding me to a higher standard than you hold yourself.

flutterbyebaby · 23/02/2023 15:51

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 14:07

Thank you for explaining your position but I think we are at slight cross purposes here.

What you have described is pretty much what I did, and what I think most other people do all the time. Its just common sense stuff. (with the exception of the distraction bit, I disagree with you there for two reasons. It doesn't address the underlying issues and do something to prevent the behaviour happening in future, secondly its impossible to 'distract' a child from unexpectedly doing something dangerous. By definition you don't know its going to happen so can't plan for it)

You haven't described how you deal with reward, consequence and punishment, which is the crux of the entire disagreement really. I believe that negative behaviour requires punishment and that all punishment causes a person to suffer in some way. I just believe that a sharp pain on the bum or hand from a measured smack is a less damaging form of suffering than other, more emotionally coercive methods.

I agree that prevention is absolutely better than cure, but when something has happened, how do you deal with it, and give your children incentives so they don't do it again?

Tbh if evidence came and slapped to across the face you still wouldn't stand down from your stance, so what is the actual point of trying to prove other way. You feel violence to those smaller than you is acceptable and that's that. I'd call that being a coward.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 14:07

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 13:57

There is no ad hominem in stating that your argument style so far gives me no reason to wish to discuss anything deeper with you, or to imagine there is anything to gain from it.

But all right. I'll give you a brief overview.

I don't hit, never have. When they were too young to reason or understand danger, I just kept them in as safe an environment as possible. If I saw them toddling towards a socket, I stopped them. If I realised I had messed up safeguarding, I made a change to what I did. I know you disapprove of that, so no need to tell me. But prevention is better than cure.

If they tantrummed because they really wanted to jump in the river or whatever, I stayed calm and tried to distract them, maybe by reading a book or playing music. Sometimes the tantrum just had to burn itself out. They're both older now and don't do it any more.

I try to model the behaviour I want from them. I don’t want shouting and hitting, so I don't do it. If I fuck up, I apologise.

To be honest, they're both lovely and well behaved, well socialised kids so I don't really have to do much correcting these days. They bicker and wind each other up a bit...it's pretty mild so it doesn't usually require intervention, to be honest. If it does, I'll talk to them and ask how they'd feel if X said Y. Sometimes one will come to tell tales a bit, but they usually just want to feel heard. Once I've listened, they're fine.

I would love to discuss this further but I just got a very important phone call and I'm afraid I have to go. Don't hit me.

Thank you for explaining your position but I think we are at slight cross purposes here.

What you have described is pretty much what I did, and what I think most other people do all the time. Its just common sense stuff. (with the exception of the distraction bit, I disagree with you there for two reasons. It doesn't address the underlying issues and do something to prevent the behaviour happening in future, secondly its impossible to 'distract' a child from unexpectedly doing something dangerous. By definition you don't know its going to happen so can't plan for it)

You haven't described how you deal with reward, consequence and punishment, which is the crux of the entire disagreement really. I believe that negative behaviour requires punishment and that all punishment causes a person to suffer in some way. I just believe that a sharp pain on the bum or hand from a measured smack is a less damaging form of suffering than other, more emotionally coercive methods.

I agree that prevention is absolutely better than cure, but when something has happened, how do you deal with it, and give your children incentives so they don't do it again?

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 13:57

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:43

This is straying into ad hominem now. I didn't need to google anything.

I am genuinely keen to read any study that supports your position that confounding factors have been excluded or otherwise accounted for.

I still don't understand why you are reluctant to tell me how you parent differently to me.

There is no ad hominem in stating that your argument style so far gives me no reason to wish to discuss anything deeper with you, or to imagine there is anything to gain from it.

But all right. I'll give you a brief overview.

I don't hit, never have. When they were too young to reason or understand danger, I just kept them in as safe an environment as possible. If I saw them toddling towards a socket, I stopped them. If I realised I had messed up safeguarding, I made a change to what I did. I know you disapprove of that, so no need to tell me. But prevention is better than cure.

If they tantrummed because they really wanted to jump in the river or whatever, I stayed calm and tried to distract them, maybe by reading a book or playing music. Sometimes the tantrum just had to burn itself out. They're both older now and don't do it any more.

I try to model the behaviour I want from them. I don’t want shouting and hitting, so I don't do it. If I fuck up, I apologise.

To be honest, they're both lovely and well behaved, well socialised kids so I don't really have to do much correcting these days. They bicker and wind each other up a bit...it's pretty mild so it doesn't usually require intervention, to be honest. If it does, I'll talk to them and ask how they'd feel if X said Y. Sometimes one will come to tell tales a bit, but they usually just want to feel heard. Once I've listened, they're fine.

I would love to discuss this further but I just got a very important phone call and I'm afraid I have to go. Don't hit me.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:43

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 13:39

There is no intelligent discussion to be had with someone who takes "keep your one year old away from sockets" to mean "hover endlessly over your children until they're 18". Even if they did hastily Google "confounding variable" to try to explain their rejection of empirical evidence. (You'll find there are enough studies to account for that, and actually, the fact that smacking tends to occur more commonly among families who don't have the tools and privileges to do better is actually a further argument against it).Your contribution here is to explain that you use smacking as an alternative to safeguarding and admit that it isn't designed to explain anything. Thank you for that, you did it well.There's a good thread about dealing with tantrums over here. I'm on it a little bit if you're interested in me, and we know you are.

This is straying into ad hominem now. I didn't need to google anything.

I am genuinely keen to read any study that supports your position that confounding factors have been excluded or otherwise accounted for.

I still don't understand why you are reluctant to tell me how you parent differently to me.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 13:39

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:36

OK cool. You have served me up like a kipper in this thread that's for sure. I've been well and truly told and my argument soundly beaten.

Meanwhile can you explain to all the parents reading this who now know not to copy me exactly how you parented and dealt with reward and punishment/consequence so they can do it to?

There is no intelligent discussion to be had with someone who takes "keep your one year old away from sockets" to mean "hover endlessly over your children until they're 18". Even if they did hastily Google "confounding variable" to try to explain their rejection of empirical evidence. (You'll find there are enough studies to account for that, and actually, the fact that smacking tends to occur more commonly among families who don't have the tools and privileges to do better is actually a further argument against it).Your contribution here is to explain that you use smacking as an alternative to safeguarding and admit that it isn't designed to explain anything. Thank you for that, you did it well.There's a good thread about dealing with tantrums over here. I'm on it a little bit if you're interested in me, and we know you are.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:36

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 13:32

This is your opportunity to prove me wrong.

I've already proved you wrong several times, as have other posters. Your reasons for smacking are literally argument by assertion, dismissing supervision as extreme helicopter parenting and then just a flat out "no it doesn't" even when you look at empirical academic studies.

Why should I engage in a deeper discussion with someone like that?

OK cool. You have served me up like a kipper in this thread that's for sure. I've been well and truly told and my argument soundly beaten.

Meanwhile can you explain to all the parents reading this who now know not to copy me exactly how you parented and dealt with reward and punishment/consequence so they can do it to?

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream · 23/02/2023 13:35

@ReneBumsWombats you haven't proved @ColonelDax wrong at all, not even once. 'Shouting louder and more often' does not equal anything I'm afraid.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 13:32

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:27

This is your opportunity to prove me wrong.

Please tell me how you did it differently with your kids and what other parents should do.

You are adamant that I'm wrong so show all the parents reading this thread why they should ignore my advice and take yours.

This is your opportunity to prove me wrong.

I've already proved you wrong several times, as have other posters. Your reasons for smacking are literally argument by assertion, dismissing supervision as extreme helicopter parenting and then just a flat out "no it doesn't" even when you look at empirical academic studies.

Why should I engage in a deeper discussion with someone like that?

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:31

You understand what a confounding variable is?

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 13:30

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 13:25

I genuinely haven't seen any studies that say anything like that, without conflating together a whole load of other factors such as socio-economic status etc

See, right here. You've seen the studies, with empirical evidence, and decided they aren't true.

Why should I try you?

Because silly old me, i read things, then I think about them and analyse them to see what conclusions can be drawn.

there are plenty of very good scientific studies on all sorts of things, there are also plenty of bad ones. Sloppy researching, biased perspectives, correlation not causation etc. All play a part.

If a studies contents don't support its conclusions im going to want more evidence before I agree with those conclusions.

Thats not unusual.