Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Grandfather smacked DS bottom

667 replies

ranblungs · 21/02/2023 14:35

DS can have meltdowns/big tantrums, usually when he's very tired. More so when he's at his grandparents' house (ex's parents). They have communicated to me that they found his behaviour very difficult at one point, but it seems to have resolved now.

ExDP did live with them but moved our two weeks ago.

DS (aged 4) told me yesterday evening that grandad had smacked his bottom because he was being naughty and that it "really hurt" he got upset as he was telling me and cried. I get the impression this wasn't necessarily recent.

DS also can play up at bed time when he is there and he told me that grandad pushes him back onto the bed for being naughty at bed time.

I'm not sure what to do next?

They are huge sources of childcare, ExDP is supposed to have him two nights per week but often works away so they will have him. They also help out during the week as/when needed.

The relationship between us was once very strained when DS was tiny.

I am furious that he has hit my child. Am I overreacting as it was just a smack on the bottom?

DS can be very challenging there.

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 24/02/2023 09:38

I swear, arguing with child hitters and their cheerleaders is like being run over by a lorry going at five miles per hour.

It's like that time Boris Johnson looked directly at the news camera in that children's hospital and said there was no press present.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/02/2023 09:31

DanseAvecLesLoup · 24/02/2023 09:25

'Beating children senseless'

Again with the hyperbole! Also, why bring sexual assault in as an analogy, it is disingenuous and simply does not work.

The hyperbole is from you lot! You're the ones constantly minimising smacking by saying it's not beating, as you pretty much insinuated in the initial post.

We're making the point that there's no other form of assault in which you'd say only the most extreme forms are unacceptable. It's only this one.

The exaggerations and hyperbole are yours, because you're insisting it's not serious unless someone's pretty much taken out by it. Like the Colonel's other ridiculous argument that something isn't a problem unless it leaves you dead or catatonic.

And you lot accuse us of taking it to extremes?

DanseAvecLesLoup · 24/02/2023 09:25

ReneBumsWombats · 24/02/2023 09:16

No, but I also don't think groping a woman is the same as rape and that doesn't make groping OK or not on the same spectrum. Do you lot expect medals for not beating children senseless?

'Beating children senseless'

Again with the hyperbole! Also, why bring sexual assault in as an analogy, it is disingenuous and simply does not work.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/02/2023 09:16

DanseAvecLesLoup · 24/02/2023 09:11

Ultimately we are talking about assault on children. If hitting another adult is considered assault then why does this change when it is a child?

This equivalence has come up several times on this thread. Do you think a parent lightly smacking their child on the hand, bum or back of the legs is really the same as an adult punching with full force another adult??

No, but I also don't think groping a woman is the same as rape and that doesn't make groping OK or not on the same spectrum. Do you lot expect medals for not beating children senseless?

ReneBumsWombats · 24/02/2023 09:14

After their pages of intelligent, reasoned, well thought out responses?

THAT is truly hilarious.

The good Colonel thinks keeping a two year old away from sockets is bad parenting, but letting him get close and then hitting him for it is terrific, which might actually be one of the most jaw dropping things I've ever seen on here. The Colonel has claimed that posts about alternative methods don't exist even when they're on the same page as the denial, admitted that smacking is not intended to explain anything and argued by assertion. That is literally it.

It is really disturbing that even in 2023, there ars people who are more concerned about not having to admit they made mistakes than they are about preventing assault of children and encouraging people to seek out the much better alternatives. But that's the mindset engendered by "do as I say or else I'll hit you". It's stunting and mind narrowing.

The only good thing is that any reasonable human with more interest in child safety than adult egos can see from this exactly how risible the case for hitting children is.

DanseAvecLesLoup · 24/02/2023 09:11

Ultimately we are talking about assault on children. If hitting another adult is considered assault then why does this change when it is a child?

This equivalence has come up several times on this thread. Do you think a parent lightly smacking their child on the hand, bum or back of the legs is really the same as an adult punching with full force another adult??

Ifeellikeateenageragain · 24/02/2023 08:55

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream · 24/02/2023 07:32

Honestly whatever makes you feel better for hitting small children.

Wow. THIS is the best you can come up with in response to @ColonelDax? After their pages of intelligent, reasoned, well thought out responses? This childish nonsense? Okay

Because ultimately this is what it is. You can argue for slavery, discrimination, theft, etc etc in reasoned well thought out responses. Ultimately we are talking about assault on children. If hitting another adult is considered assault then why does this change when it is a child? If hitting a child who is not related to you would be considered assault, then why does it change when the child is related to you? Take it all back to these basic logic principles.

Ifeellikeateenageragain · 24/02/2023 08:52

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 18:45

Do they ever actually get punished or do you just 'explain' why they are wrong? 🙄

Why are you fixed on punishment? Boundaries and discipline are in place for safety in the first instance, then learning socialisation and ensuring all individuals in the shared space are equally respected and considered. Communicating with children in an age-appropriate manner meets these requirements.

I do think it's interesting that you've shifted from hitting as an "accidental" one off that happens when parents are under extreme stress and do not intend to use hitting as part of their toolbox to advocating for hitting as a parenting tool that does less damage than other emotional and communication strategies.

At any rate, you have your parenting practice and you are determined that your way is better. Whatever cycle you are part of, best of luck with your children in the future.

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream · 24/02/2023 07:32

Honestly whatever makes you feel better for hitting small children.

Wow. THIS is the best you can come up with in response to @ColonelDax? After their pages of intelligent, reasoned, well thought out responses? This childish nonsense? Okay

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 22:34

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 21:05

With my kids we talked about why they had done something wrong, why it wasn't acceptable and why they shouldn't do it again, but they also absolutely got punished for doing something they shouldn't have, just like in the real world. 🙄

I'm afraid your approach is wishful thinking in the extreme. I appreciate you are at a disadvantage as I know my parenting methods work, because they have, three times, whereas yours are still theory at this point as I get the feeling your children are still little.

I hope it works out for you, and they turn out ok, I really do but as a parting thought I'd really recommend you have a think about your definition of what actually 'hurts' a child. A small amount of discipline at an early stage from someone who loves and wants the best for them, or growing up with the absence of that and how its absence may affect the rest of their life.

Honestly whatever makes you feel better for hitting small children.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 22:32

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 21:05

With my kids we talked about why they had done something wrong, why it wasn't acceptable and why they shouldn't do it again, but they also absolutely got punished for doing something they shouldn't have, just like in the real world. 🙄

I'm afraid your approach is wishful thinking in the extreme. I appreciate you are at a disadvantage as I know my parenting methods work, because they have, three times, whereas yours are still theory at this point as I get the feeling your children are still little.

I hope it works out for you, and they turn out ok, I really do but as a parting thought I'd really recommend you have a think about your definition of what actually 'hurts' a child. A small amount of discipline at an early stage from someone who loves and wants the best for them, or growing up with the absence of that and how its absence may affect the rest of their life.

Thanks, but no, you can take your advice back to the 80s with you.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 21:05

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 20:39

What benefit do you see in punishing when talking about it is solving the problem? It's about working out what's behind the behaviour and addressing that rather than demanding compliance and punishing.

Is the point of parenting to have blind obedience in childhood or help them learn for when they are older?

With my kids we talked about why they had done something wrong, why it wasn't acceptable and why they shouldn't do it again, but they also absolutely got punished for doing something they shouldn't have, just like in the real world. 🙄

I'm afraid your approach is wishful thinking in the extreme. I appreciate you are at a disadvantage as I know my parenting methods work, because they have, three times, whereas yours are still theory at this point as I get the feeling your children are still little.

I hope it works out for you, and they turn out ok, I really do but as a parting thought I'd really recommend you have a think about your definition of what actually 'hurts' a child. A small amount of discipline at an early stage from someone who loves and wants the best for them, or growing up with the absence of that and how its absence may affect the rest of their life.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 20:41

SchoolTripDrama · 23/02/2023 19:47

@Forgooodnesssakenow Haha that won't last long!! Trust me. I was smug like you, thinking I'd solved it....nope! As soon as they get older and more hormones appear - Anger!

Anger from them or me? I'm sure new challenges will come up, as they have for other kids I've looked after inside and outside of family. As I say I'm 40, I've had a lot of experience with children from babies to teenagers. Mine are young yes.

Explain a situation you are thinking of here?

And it's not smugness, I mess up, I am constantly learning and adapting but the lady asked for examples, practical examples of what people do who don't hit and I've given examples.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 20:39

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 18:45

Do they ever actually get punished or do you just 'explain' why they are wrong? 🙄

What benefit do you see in punishing when talking about it is solving the problem? It's about working out what's behind the behaviour and addressing that rather than demanding compliance and punishing.

Is the point of parenting to have blind obedience in childhood or help them learn for when they are older?

SchoolTripDrama · 23/02/2023 19:47

@Forgooodnesssakenow Haha that won't last long!! Trust me. I was smug like you, thinking I'd solved it....nope! As soon as they get older and more hormones appear - Anger!

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 18:45

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 18:27

My child gets some scissors, they're age inappropriate, I take them for safety, child cries and gets upset, I accept she's upset, she wanted the scissors, I comfort her until she feels better, I don't give her the scissors, when calm I explain why she didn't get the scissors.

Son hits sister, I separate, explain no hitting, hitting hurts quickly, comfort toddler who was hit, have son sit in call down corner to calm down as he'll be screaming and upset as would only be aggressive if massively wound up, take deep breaths with him to get him to calm down, once calm explain why we don't hit, talk about what to do instead if angry. Repeat. This was when he was 3ish,now he's 5 he'll say he's angry and going to calm down rather than hit as he's been taught those techniques.

Do you want other specific l? Please pose specific questions I'd you wish specifics

Do they ever actually get punished or do you just 'explain' why they are wrong? 🙄

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 18:43

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 18:30

I wouldn't want to tell someone so adamant they hit me for my own good that they were wrong either. I absolutely stand by my assertion it did them no good. Do they hit their children? If not and they're so ok with you hitting them and it's so effective why don't they do it?

They don't have any but I asked my oldest if she would and she said she was indifferent, she wouldn't aim to of course but if it was useful or appropriate then it wouldn't worry her.

WarningToTheCurious · 23/02/2023 18:36

BlueVinca · 23/02/2023 18:27

Oh dear. You're not getting it so I can't be bothered to argue with you. Waste of my time

No, please go on - explain it?

How does a smacking ban affect criminal behaviour in adolescents and adults?

Especially compared with the known factors of being male, in a single parent family, growing up in poverty, early care experience, school exclusion, substance abuse, poor impulse control?

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 18:30

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 18:24

I mean I have asked two of them this afternoon when they popped round earlier, and they reiterated they were fine with it, but I expect they were just lying to me?

I wouldn't want to tell someone so adamant they hit me for my own good that they were wrong either. I absolutely stand by my assertion it did them no good. Do they hit their children? If not and they're so ok with you hitting them and it's so effective why don't they do it?

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 18:27

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 18:15

Again I have to insist, you aren't really answering what I said, you are answering what you want me to have said.

Nobody is denying that you can do all of those things, I certainly did.

But you haven't described beyond a vauge reference to 'natural consequences' is how you dealt with punishment and reward.

All those approaches are great, strategic level behaviour controls that we all do, but what you are still failing to describe is actual tactical level 'my child is doing X and it's naughty/disruptive/dangerous' type things.

I suspect we wont ever get anywhere as the truth will probably be somewhere along the grounds of either ignoring completely, or the usual wishy washy 'thats not ok sweetheart' type stuff, which passes as discipline these days.

Shame really. Also please stop imagining bad faith motives for me such as I 'vented my frustration' on my kids by hitting them or other such silliness. Its a cliche but it's true, disciplining my children (whether smacking or other consequences) always hurt me more than it ever hurt them.

My child gets some scissors, they're age inappropriate, I take them for safety, child cries and gets upset, I accept she's upset, she wanted the scissors, I comfort her until she feels better, I don't give her the scissors, when calm I explain why she didn't get the scissors.

Son hits sister, I separate, explain no hitting, hitting hurts quickly, comfort toddler who was hit, have son sit in call down corner to calm down as he'll be screaming and upset as would only be aggressive if massively wound up, take deep breaths with him to get him to calm down, once calm explain why we don't hit, talk about what to do instead if angry. Repeat. This was when he was 3ish,now he's 5 he'll say he's angry and going to calm down rather than hit as he's been taught those techniques.

Do you want other specific l? Please pose specific questions I'd you wish specifics

BlueVinca · 23/02/2023 18:27

WarningToTheCurious · 23/02/2023 18:25

<Sigh> no, I’m saying that you can’t link crime stats with the banning of corporal punishment, there are dozens of confounding factors that make that an impossible link to make.

Obviously that point went way over your head.

I’m certainly not arguing that a ban on parental corporal punishment is a bad thing.

Oh dear. You're not getting it so I can't be bothered to argue with you. Waste of my time

WarningToTheCurious · 23/02/2023 18:25

BlueVinca · 23/02/2023 18:14

The point I was making (which seems to have gone over your head) is that we have proof that not smacking children doesn't have adverse outcomes, as we have seen with Sweden having banned it decades ago. You being pernickety about Norway being earlier is just trying to distract from the fact that its perfectly possible to bring up a child without assaulting them.

<Sigh> no, I’m saying that you can’t link crime stats with the banning of corporal punishment, there are dozens of confounding factors that make that an impossible link to make.

Obviously that point went way over your head.

I’m certainly not arguing that a ban on parental corporal punishment is a bad thing.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 18:24

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 18:18

You think it hurt you more than it hurt them only because you have first hand exoerienceof your own feelings. I assure you it hurt them more, mentally, physically etc you don't want to see it which I get but still.

I mean I have asked two of them this afternoon when they popped round earlier, and they reiterated they were fine with it, but I expect they were just lying to me?

Forgooodnesssakenow · 23/02/2023 18:18

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 18:15

Again I have to insist, you aren't really answering what I said, you are answering what you want me to have said.

Nobody is denying that you can do all of those things, I certainly did.

But you haven't described beyond a vauge reference to 'natural consequences' is how you dealt with punishment and reward.

All those approaches are great, strategic level behaviour controls that we all do, but what you are still failing to describe is actual tactical level 'my child is doing X and it's naughty/disruptive/dangerous' type things.

I suspect we wont ever get anywhere as the truth will probably be somewhere along the grounds of either ignoring completely, or the usual wishy washy 'thats not ok sweetheart' type stuff, which passes as discipline these days.

Shame really. Also please stop imagining bad faith motives for me such as I 'vented my frustration' on my kids by hitting them or other such silliness. Its a cliche but it's true, disciplining my children (whether smacking or other consequences) always hurt me more than it ever hurt them.

You think it hurt you more than it hurt them only because you have first hand exoerienceof your own feelings. I assure you it hurt them more, mentally, physically etc you don't want to see it which I get but still.

ColonelDax · 23/02/2023 18:15

ReneBumsWombats · 23/02/2023 17:53

Apologies all. That was a very important phone call.

So I see we've got exactly what we all knew would happen...hitter demands alternatives, alternatives are given, hitter denies alternatives have been given. Quelle surprise.

The problem with smacking isn't just that it damages children. It also often seems to go alongside a God complex whereby people think that things become fact merely by their stating them ("smacking is moral", "nobody gave practical examples of alternatives"). Whether the smacking creates the God complex or vice versa, I don't know, but I've noticed that the two go together very often. We've established that smacking bypasses reason, after all.

It may be partly because hitters are more concerned with justifying themselves so they don't have to admit they made mistakes than they are with assaulting children. The ego is powerful.

Anywat, I'm much too tired to go into full detail, but effectively the main points I planned to make earlier are:

  • model the behaviour you want them to learn, including apologising
  • supervise and be preventative when they're too young to understand danger or reason
  • enact natural consequences where you must, eg, not playing nicely with toy, toy is removed for a while
  • positive reinforcement, ie praise for doing well. Then you often need only not to praise when things aren't going well.

Unfortunately, these methods don't give the quick satisfaction of venting your frustration by hitting, and they do require the parent to do some work on themselves. Which I suppose partly explains the vehement opposition to them, to the extent of denying they even exist.

Again I have to insist, you aren't really answering what I said, you are answering what you want me to have said.

Nobody is denying that you can do all of those things, I certainly did.

But you haven't described beyond a vauge reference to 'natural consequences' is how you dealt with punishment and reward.

All those approaches are great, strategic level behaviour controls that we all do, but what you are still failing to describe is actual tactical level 'my child is doing X and it's naughty/disruptive/dangerous' type things.

I suspect we wont ever get anywhere as the truth will probably be somewhere along the grounds of either ignoring completely, or the usual wishy washy 'thats not ok sweetheart' type stuff, which passes as discipline these days.

Shame really. Also please stop imagining bad faith motives for me such as I 'vented my frustration' on my kids by hitting them or other such silliness. Its a cliche but it's true, disciplining my children (whether smacking or other consequences) always hurt me more than it ever hurt them.