Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boyfriend and money

62 replies

SleepySlumber · 21/02/2023 09:03

My boyfriend recently moved in with me as we are expecting a baby together. I have two children from a previous relationship that also live with me mainly.

I told my bf that I want to split costs down the middle when he moved in and the other day sent him the amount he needs to pay for this month. What he is paying is minuscule in comparison to what he’d pay if he was to go rent somewhere on his own or even if we were to find a rental together.

He lived at home before moving in with me after a relationship breakdown, so didn’t pay any rent at home. I know he’s always dated rich girls with money before me (he’s private educated and always been around people with money) so I doubt he’s had to pay his way when living with them and it shows!

This morning he came to me and said as he knows I get some help with benefits currently (I’ve had to stop working due to illness in late pregnancy), why should he pay me his half of the rent as I don’t even pay it all at the moment so I’m just taking his money.

Yes I do get some help benefits wise currently, but I don’t feel like what I get is anything to do with him. I have two disabled children so the money I get is actually mainly to help with their care - but again I don’t feel I even need to explain to him what I get.

I also have two children to support and I’m pregnant with his child and unable to work!

He runs his own business and gets by but isn’t ambitious and has probably had the same customers the last decade without trying to get more business. He also has just himself to pay for so hasn’t had the responsibility of a child before.

AIBU to ask him to pay half still? He knew what costs were before moving in so I don’t think I am, but always good to get other opinions.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Xrays · 22/02/2023 17:00

ImAvingOops · 22/02/2023 10:31

He is joining a family though and if he starts quibbling over spending a bit more money because his partner has children (who will be the siblings of his own baby), that's not in the spirit of joining a family.
There's no point to him living with you if he's seeing himself as a separate individual rather than part of a family unit.
It's not very attractive to split every bill to working out what percentage the two kids cost in food and electricity use!

I agree.

I was a single parent when I met now dh (been married 15 years) and if he hadn’t wanted to go all in in terms of sharing everything etc alarm bells would be ringing for me.

ImAvingOops · 22/02/2023 10:31

He is joining a family though and if he starts quibbling over spending a bit more money because his partner has children (who will be the siblings of his own baby), that's not in the spirit of joining a family.
There's no point to him living with you if he's seeing himself as a separate individual rather than part of a family unit.
It's not very attractive to split every bill to working out what percentage the two kids cost in food and electricity use!

jimmyjammy001 · 21/02/2023 14:50

If he agreed 50% before moving in then he's being unreasonable now, but he shouldn't of agreed to 50% when there are 2 kids living there that arnt his which is presumably paying 50% of, is there any child maintenance from the ex for the 2 kids? In which case your be receiving even more for them if current partner paying for them as well. Will your benefits be affected when you inform DWP of your new partner moving in and his wage? Usually people receive less money in benefits when partners move in so you can ask him to subsidize what you would lose in benefit money

KettrickenSmiled · 21/02/2023 14:44

Yes the man I am having a baby with clearly needs a few lessons in life and will soon have that with a shock of a baby with me. But if he turns out to be a waste of space I won’t hesitate to get rid.

He's a spoiled rich boy who has an income he's not bothered to increase for a decade because his current clients provide HIM enough to live on.

He saw you coming, reckons you are his meal ticket & free roof, thinks he has you trapped because of the baby, & has already proved to you that he's a waste of space.

Stop prolonging the inevitable by making excuses for him.
Stop hesitating, & don't wait around for him to learn lessons - why would he, when he can manipulate you instead of pulling his finger out?

KettrickenSmiled · 21/02/2023 14:40

This morning he came to me and said as he knows I get some help with benefits currently (I’ve had to stop working due to illness in late pregnancy), why should he pay me his half of the rent as I don’t even pay it all at the moment so I’m just taking his money.
"You are an adult who is reposnsible for half the costs, which you knew when you moved in. You agreed, & now you are reneging because you are a spoiled baby who thinks his pregnany g/f ought to support him. Why don't you fuck off, & I'll let the CMS tell you what you owe me when the baby arrives?"

AIBU to ask him to pay half still? He knew what costs were before moving in so I don’t think I am, but always good to get other opinions.
YABU
He's decided not to pay, & he probably won't, so why debase yourself with begging?
Even if you make him pay this month, you'll have to go through it all over again next. Is that a life you want to lead?
He's a cocklodging waste of space - get rid of him & rely on the only person you can depend on 100% - yourself.

Danneigh · 21/02/2023 14:34

I know you've said you're not answering anymore, so pointless me commenting really. But if you are also getting help from the other children's father then potentially 50/50 to your new BF is unfair. You need to think about what support you already get, what you both earn, what you're asking him to pay for, for example to feed your other kids when their Dad already covers that (just an example). Just because you think 50/50 is fair doesn't mean it is. And just because he thinks it's not doesn't mean its not. You'd be better both doing the maths instead of hitting with a figure.

Murdoch1949 · 21/02/2023 14:03

I don't think 50:50 is fair to your bf. There's you & your 2 children on one side, and just him on the other. You need to support your children, with their dads' help plus DLA. It would be fairer for him to pay one third of the household's costs. He may have discussed this with family/friends and been told he's being taken for a ride - "she just wants you to pay half the bills" etc.

Fidgety31 · 21/02/2023 14:03

He shouldn’t have to pay half the bills as you have two kids yourself that are not his financial responsibility.
I think it’s unfair of you to expect him to pay your kids share of the household bills .

GoAgainstNicki · 21/02/2023 13:42

arethereanyleftatall · 21/02/2023 09:59

I'm sure this thread is harrowing to read op, and you're probably very upset by the responses, but please remember everyone is responding with your best interests at heart, we're very pro women on this site, so please listen very carefully.

Well this is just a lie

Xrays · 21/02/2023 12:22

I was one of the initial posters who mentioned the two disabled children. I wasn’t suggesting someone with disabled children shouldn’t have another child 😳🙄 - I have a child with severe autism and complex needs myself, he attends complex needs school and is on the highest rate of dla long term - I was making the point that this isn’t the ideal situation to have a new baby in - useless cocklodger partner and already having the strain of being a carer for someone with disabilities. That isn’t eugenics, that’s real life. Op would manage better without the useless boyfriend if she’s going to become a mum of 3 in this situation.

StarsSand · 21/02/2023 11:45

arethereanyleftatall · 21/02/2023 09:59

I'm sure this thread is harrowing to read op, and you're probably very upset by the responses, but please remember everyone is responding with your best interests at heart, we're very pro women on this site, so please listen very carefully.

I don't think these answers have been pro-women.

Some people have literally called her stupid.

She's off work due to LATE pregnancy and yet people have suggested she abort her baby.

The comment shaming her for having a third child when her first two have disabilities is ableist and basically eugenics.

OP, I'm sorry you've had to read some of this. You have a lot on your plate and I wish you all the best.

To answer your question- it is completely reasonable to expect him to pay half, and how you come about your half is none of his concern.

lazycats · 21/02/2023 11:31

Oh dear, you picked a dud to have a baby with. I hope whatever happens it goes ok.

Ceryneianhind · 21/02/2023 11:29

You deserve better

You deserve a man who will support you and his family

ItchyBillco · 21/02/2023 11:06

I’m very sad to see this has only just come up after he’s already moved in with your disabled children and you’re already pregnant.

He is a lazy, tight cocklodging taker and I fear you will be alone raising that third child. I wouldn’t anticipate much in the way of CMS as he’ll see it as you ‘taking’ his money.

SleepySlumber · 21/02/2023 10:20

arethereanyleftatall · 21/02/2023 09:59

I'm sure this thread is harrowing to read op, and you're probably very upset by the responses, but please remember everyone is responding with your best interests at heart, we're very pro women on this site, so please listen very carefully.

Ive just been called stupid so don’t see how everyone is pro women. I have also had someone ask me why I’d have another child when I have two disabled children! I think that’s absolutely disgusting to say to someone. Or the comments that I should abort my child - hardly helpful or my best interest.

Yes the man I am having a baby with clearly needs a few lessons in life and will soon have that with a shock of a baby with me. But if he turns out to be a waste of space I won’t hesitate to get rid. I dated someone for a decade and then we had children and it all fell apart so for those saying why would I have a child with this man I’ve found even a very planned situation doesn’t always work out either. But we have been together a couple of years so he’s not a total stranger, it just seems since the moving in has happened that I’m aware more of the way he is financially.

Yes Dwp are aware he has moved in and as of such my bills are more eg council tax not single any more which I have factored in.

But I still get a small amount of help with my rent even with his combined income, so I think that’s why he thought I was being unfair to ask him to still pay his half when I’m getting help.

He doesn’t know I get DLA so he doesn’t realise that was the benefit I meant - he’s not trying to take my children’s disability money.

Anyway thanks for (some) of the comments I will discuss with him later but won’t be replying further.

OP posts:
Pippa12 · 21/02/2023 10:19

Gosh OP I think this is over before it’s started! I’d end it now before it gets too messy, you’ll be doing this alone and be better off!

PicaK · 21/02/2023 10:16

You need to claim benefits as a couple or he needs to leave. You're not a couple atm he's just a lodger with benefits. And one that's not paying

NotStayingIn · 21/02/2023 10:02

Threads like this make me really irritated about how flipping stupid some women are.

There were really clear signs that he wouldn't pay his way that you knew about. So why on earth - especially if you already have kids - would you move him into your home or have a child with him?

I think you may be best off telling him to go back home and say you prefer to go it alone as he isn't capable of stepping up. You will in the end be doing this mainly alone anyway, this at least will give you some control.

qwertykeyboards · 21/02/2023 10:01

What an absolute bum trying to live off your disabled child’s benefits.

arethereanyleftatall · 21/02/2023 09:59

I'm sure this thread is harrowing to read op, and you're probably very upset by the responses, but please remember everyone is responding with your best interests at heart, we're very pro women on this site, so please listen very carefully.

Biscuits1011 · 21/02/2023 09:57

You should be claiming jointly with benefits. If on universal credit or receiving tax credits and housing benefits this needs to be a joint claim and his income would affect this. The dla is separate and as you say is for those children. I would say maybe not half of everything.. but definitely a good contribution based on his earnings. But it sounds like he could possibly earn more so that’s another chat to have..

StarsSand · 21/02/2023 09:56

Running his own business is a great way for him to fudge his income and pay you then minimum in child support if you do split.

I think 50/50 is fair. It's not just him but his baby as well, and OP has a reduced ability to work due to his baby.

He chose to get a woman with children pregnant, or at least acted in a way that made that outcome a possibility. He can't pretend they don't exist.

iamjustwinginglife · 21/02/2023 09:55

He needs to pay something and that "something" needs to be fair, but until you've had your benefits adjusted for the fact there's another adult in the home who is contributing financially then who knows what that "something" is. Not taking his presence and income into account would be benefit fraud and I'm sure you want to do everything legally and above board

BarbaraofSeville · 21/02/2023 09:53

You're likely to lose some of the income related benefits due to him moving in, so he at least needs to cover the amount you've lost.
Plus the extra council tax.
Plus the cost of his food, toiletries, extra hot water, mobile, transport, basically anything extra over and above your own costs.
Plus half the cost of you not being able to work and being on maternity leave when the baby is born.

Given the system expects him to cover the costs that were previously being paid for by benefits, I'd be surprised if half the bills etc was actually enough for you not to be worse off due to him moving in.

He's going to be a father so he needs to step up and pay his way. His days of being a perpetual teenager are over.

StarsSand · 21/02/2023 09:52

Won't you lose benefits when he moves in?

Some man he is, eyeing up a disabled child's benefits for himself.

Disgusting.

To PPs shaking their finger at OP for having a baby with him- some babies just aren't planned and people do their best. I don't think OP needs the criticism right now.

And it's all very well to tell people to 'get rid' of a man that they are already pregnant to, when it's not you having to do that.

The sensible thing is to have a grown up discussion about finances and try to make this family work so the baby grows up with a father.

Swipe left for the next trending thread