Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying off mortgage after cancer treatment

57 replies

Boxhike · 21/02/2023 07:03

I had cervical cancer a few years ago and claimed my critical illness insurance which means we are in the position of paying off our mortgage.
The way our mortgage works is that you can only pay 10% annually for 2 years and then pay the balance so we’ve done that over the past 2 years.
Now that we are in a position to pay the balance my husband has dropped the bombshell that he has £50k in savings! I can’t believe he has not told me this. I told him last night that I would be paying the balance of the mortgage off less £50k which I would be using for my own savings pot.
His response was ‘why would you do that if we’re in a position to pay it all off, my savings are for us both’. But after him not declaring those savings to me I’m not convinced I told him to put himself in my place I needed to look after myself and have my own pot. He’s been quiet all evening. We have 2 kids.
Any perspective appreciated!

OP posts:
Dyrne · 21/02/2023 08:45

I keep coming back to this as I’m so annoyed.

Everyone just talking about the mortgage is missing the point:

Imagine you have found out you have cancer. You go through the NHS route as you can’t afford to go private. You stress about time of work so you may make the decision to keep working or rush back before you’re ready. You struggle with trying to keep on top of the housework and not let it affect the children so you need to keep a smiley face while feeling Ill from chemo.

Now imagine, 2 years down the line, your DH offhandedly mentions they’ve got £50K. Money that could have been used to ease the burden a little bit during your treatment. Maybe an alternative therapy like acupuncture which has been proven to ease sickness from chemo. Or childcare to help keep a bit of normality for the kids. Or a cleaner so you didn’t feel you had to wipe down the kitchen while feeling Ill. Or a Bupa appointment right at the beginning to stop the 2 weeks of worry around diagnosis and confirmation. It would have meant that you could have taken more of a phased return to work. It could have meant you’d have got a few more taxis rather than struggling on public transport.

Now, I’d imagine all of the above doesn’t apply to OP, but I bet some of it does.

How can he claim it’s “family money” when it didn’t even occur to him to fess up about his savings at a time when the family could have really needed it?

Littlewhitecat · 21/02/2023 08:43

Summerfun54321 · 21/02/2023 07:51

Is it really a secret or is it just that you never had a sit down chat to talk about your savings? I have no idea how much my DH has in savings, but I wouldn't call that a secret, I just haven't asked in a while.

He's said it's for both of you so why not carve out some time to sit down and discuss investment ideas.

I agree with this. Did you know your husband had savings? If you are a high income family and are not going without on a daily basis then I can see how this has happened. My DH had no idea how much I had in my savings (it's in the same ball park as your DH) until recently when we redid our wills and I had no idea how much he had in various investments, but I did know they existed. It's not a secret it's just not something we discuss on a daily basis as our living costs are more than covered. We are married so all money is family money but we choose to keep it in separate accounts which works for us (despite MNetters opinion that this is a sign of impending doom).

silverclock222 · 21/02/2023 08:42

Danneigh · 21/02/2023 08:25

Her DH has been sat on £50k that he never mentioned, quite a big piece of information. Why should OP wipe out all of her money while he stays sat on £50k. If money is separate, surely she's entitled to a pot too. So she should just empty her bank while he stays sat on £50k that he never thought to mention before?

Still not getting it - the insurance paid not OP and now the restriction has ended the money is there to pay it. Is it that there were savings OP didn't know about? Anyway don't want to derail so will leave it there.

AllTheThingsIWantAreHere · 21/02/2023 08:40

It doesn't sound great but I think I'd need more details to Jude. It depends how you do your finances. How wealthy you are etc etc

HotDogsJumpingFrogsILoveTurkey · 21/02/2023 08:35

Pressed too soon...

I would be annoyed that he hadn't told me he said such large savings though. Even if they are "his", it's handy to have a rough idea of each other's finances.

HotDogsJumpingFrogsILoveTurkey · 21/02/2023 08:32

Why did he keep it secret? If it's meant to be for both of you/the family, why didn't you know about it?

I'm not sure about whether you should automatically get the same. If, as in our case, we each get an allowance from the joint finances and he has chosen to save his while you've spent yours then it isn't fair that you suddenly get the same without saving it.

Mangledrake · 21/02/2023 08:31

I don't know

Is the critical illness policy not there specifically for the mortgage? I thought they are often linked. So have you and your husband been paying this on top of your mortgage as an insurance on that policy? Or is it "your" lump sum, like an early retirement payment?

Did you have the kind of shared finances where you both had fairly allocated spending money each month, and he's just saved his?

He may be behaving badly, or just fine. If payout isn't explicitly linked to mortgage I don't see why you shouldn't save some, though.

Hont1986 · 21/02/2023 08:29

YABU to keep £50k back for yourself and make him use up all his £50k on the mortgage. YWNBU to keep back £25k and have him use his £25k, so you have equal savings afterwards.

You don't mention your ages but assuming he is in his 50s or 60s and working full time, it's not really a 'bombshell' that he might have five figure savings.

SleepingStandingUp · 21/02/2023 08:25

How did it done out and how did he text to your knowing?

I think it's reasonable that you keep 50k, in your name, for you "both" or he chicks in 25k and you keep 25k in savings

Danneigh · 21/02/2023 08:25

silverclock222 · 21/02/2023 08:21

I'm obviously missing something - you claimed off your insurance which is fine that's what it's there for, you're limited as to the amount you can pay which is what you've done and now you can pay in full there are savings to do so? I don't understand

Her DH has been sat on £50k that he never mentioned, quite a big piece of information. Why should OP wipe out all of her money while he stays sat on £50k. If money is separate, surely she's entitled to a pot too. So she should just empty her bank while he stays sat on £50k that he never thought to mention before?

KentishMama · 21/02/2023 08:21

Slightly off topic, but banks usually waive the early repayment charge if you have a critical illness payout that you're using to pay off the mortgage. Mine did that.

Two options: move savings into a joint account you can both access, or have £25k in savings each.

silverclock222 · 21/02/2023 08:21

I'm obviously missing something - you claimed off your insurance which is fine that's what it's there for, you're limited as to the amount you can pay which is what you've done and now you can pay in full there are savings to do so? I don't understand

Wishihadanalgorithm · 21/02/2023 08:19

What would happen if you didn’t pay off the mortgage and left the money in various savings schemes to accrue some interest?

I’d be suggesting that to him and see what he says.

Ourlittletalks · 21/02/2023 08:17

YANBU

Your kids are your priority and you should absolutely have savings too but I think it’s unfair of you to expect your DH to put all of his savings in while you’ll have 50k left for yourself. A way to split it fairly would be to pay 25k each from your 50k and each have 25k left in savings.

Blessedwithsunshine · 21/02/2023 08:11

What other secrets does he have?

I would be blindsided by this in your position and would struggle to trust him again.

It is not £50 - but £50,000!!

WTF. How did he even manage it without you knowing?

DrManhattan · 21/02/2023 07:59

What is he saving it for?

Dyrne · 21/02/2023 07:57

I cannot believe that he kept this a secret from you; no doubt when you were going through treatment you were worrying about family finances; how could he let you take on that burden while was happily sitting on £50K!

If he’s so insistent that it’s family savings then he shouldn’t have a problem paying off the mortgage with it, as that’s for the family.

Agree that you should do it as ([Insurance]+[DH savings]-[Mortgage])/2 and that’s what you each have left as savings in your own names.

I would find it difficult to trust him after this to be honest. It’s true that I don’t know all the ins and outs of DP’s accounts and he doesn’t know mine; but you can bet your arse that if one of us developed an illness we’d be sat down combing through the accounts so we could make financial decisions together as a couple. How dare he let you take on that burden alone when you’ve been through enough - it’s not as though you’ve had a nice little lottery win!!

Summerfun54321 · 21/02/2023 07:51

Is it really a secret or is it just that you never had a sit down chat to talk about your savings? I have no idea how much my DH has in savings, but I wouldn't call that a secret, I just haven't asked in a while.

He's said it's for both of you so why not carve out some time to sit down and discuss investment ideas.

SNWannabe · 21/02/2023 07:40

Maybe his “savings” take the form of an investment policy that will
nature etc rather than him siphoning off money into his own account. If he’s said about it now, he’s not hiding it or trying to profit from Critical Illness money.

Sit down and talk about it- why you’re hurt, what you can do next. Like a pp suggested, how about you each have £25k pot if that is reassuring to you. But then why are you automatically wanting to “look after yourself”? What’s going on there?

SaltnPeppaPig · 21/02/2023 07:38

Why didn't he tell you about the savings before and why has he just told you? Both aspects are bizarre.

gogohmm · 21/02/2023 07:34

I'm in two minds, it's the critical illness insurance payment essentially that's paying off the mortgage not savings, but why didn't you know there were savings? That said my exh had no idea how much we had in savings, everything was in my name for tax reasons

Binfluencer · 21/02/2023 07:23

He's profiting off you having cancer!

Has he always been this selfish?

RachelSq · 21/02/2023 07:18

Absolutely don’t do it - secret savings are a no-no (he obviously doesn’t see this as joint otherwise you’d have know about it).

Has he offered any explanation as to why he didn’t tell you?

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 21/02/2023 07:15

Can you take it from the point of view that if anything were to happen to one of you, it makes sense for the other one to have access to their own money until the other person's is released? I find death is harder to argue against than divorce.

whoknows1230 · 21/02/2023 07:13

I agree with the others. What a horrible thing to do. He’s happy to “take” your money that you received when you were so poorly but didn’t think to mention he’s got £50k sat there. I’d be wondering if he has more than £50k but he just doesn’t want to tell you about the rest.

Stick to your guns and keep £50k back for yourself.

Swipe left for the next trending thread