Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think society is too focused on equal representation?

119 replies

Confusedabouttheworld23 · 21/02/2023 00:01

Watching the news today, I saw how there is outrage over a lack of BAME winners at the BAFTAs. As an Indian heritage person myself, I fail to see how this is a huge problem from a few key reasons.

Firstly, , statistically the UK is predominantly a White country and therefore it is not statistically significant if one year there were no BAME winners. In fact a statistician tweeted that you need to look over a period of 5/6 years to see if there is systemic racism in the BAFTAs. In fact in 2021 or 2022, half of the winners were BAME, showing that you cannot read too much into such a small sample size.
As a subpoint, BAFTA voters are predominantly going to be White if this is representative of the UK Population. If it is true that people resonate with those who predominantly look like them, it is no surprise and not a huge issue that the majority of UK award winners are White. If one were to go to India for example, most if not all award winners would be of Indian heritage, this is completely fine and reflective of a country’s demographics,

Secondly, with so many other issues in the UK, I feel that a focus on equal representation is being totally blown out of proportion. We need to focus on just working hard, trying to better ourselves and get through the tough economic times we are experiencing at the moment.
A lack of diversity in acting seems almost trivial compared to other significant issues affecting the UK population - I am much more concerned about rising inflation, housing costs than the number of people who I feel represent me in film.

Thirdly, it is argued that we need to encourage more people from diverse backgrounds to go into film and other arts in the UK, and the main way to do this is to award and recognise BAME artists/actors. However, is it really a huge issue if those from BAME backgrounds go into other sectors of the economy. For example, Indian heritage people often go into STEM, finance etc, rather than the Arts which has resulted in them being one of the most economically successful groups in the UK. This is not a huge issue therefore, and hence there is not a need to push for increased diversity in the Arts to the extent that we are doing so today.
I just feel that everyone needs to just work hard and get through life, rather than focus on issues which in the grand scheme of things are not that significant.

OP posts:
DrManhattan · 21/02/2023 08:48

@BeetleyCarapace why are you thinking it is? I don't. It's an observation

BeetleyCarapace · 21/02/2023 08:47

DrManhattan · 21/02/2023 08:08

If you watched TV adverts in the UK you would think most families have a black/white Dad and black/white mum. Massive over representation.

And this is a… problem? Why?

midgemadgemodge · 21/02/2023 08:41

DrManhattan · 21/02/2023 08:08

If you watched TV adverts in the UK you would think most families have a black/white Dad and black/white mum. Massive over representation.

You may be right that adverts are showing more mixed families

Or you may notice just because it's unusual

We know racism occurs across all society and harms the chances of people - people lose out because a weaker white person is seen as better

Anyone who cares has a responsibility to try and eradicate that false perception- because it's fairer and because our society and culture would be stronger if it was based on merit

And one way to eradicate bias against is to try and promote those society is biased against , to normalise seeing underrepresented groups in all settings , to reward pointedly when they do well because they will have had to work harder to get there . So if you end up with a "merit" selection that doesn't represent our society you should be asking yourself some bloody hard questions - am I biased , did I miss opportunities to promote equality ( say a category where the judges were split )

KrisAkabusi · 21/02/2023 08:39

"Imagine if thé olympics said ‘you know what guys, I don’t care how fast you are at the 100m, we actually want each race to participate equally in this final so we’re gonna have to bump a few of you.*

You couldn't have picked a worse example. 100m is purely on merit. The fastest runner wins. The winner is measurable. It's where you have awards where "best" is subjective, like best actor, that you run into problems with bias, and where race or sex or class or any other number of factors come into play.

And even the Olympics try to overcome this as there are a number of places given to athletes from developing countries who otherwise would not qualify due to lack of opportunity. Look at Eric the Eel as a famous example.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 21/02/2023 08:15

noblegiraffe · 21/02/2023 07:40

Was the vote really biased because of racism?

Or were the films containing white artists simply better hence why the white artists won?

How can anyone seriously still be asking this faux-innocent question after so many decades of disproportionately white people winning?

This

The idea that things in life are handed out on merit, and that equal opportunity is the default in the Western world, is one of the biggest fairytales people choose to believe in

and this

DrManhattan · 21/02/2023 08:08

If you watched TV adverts in the UK you would think most families have a black/white Dad and black/white mum. Massive over representation.

midgemadgemodge · 21/02/2023 08:05

25 awards
18% none white in uk - so expedition might be 5 of the award winners would be none white if everything was equal there is 1% chance that this happens

A 1 in 100 year event

I don't think I need to see it happen 5 times to suspect there may be an element of racism in there

Yes to merit
But not when racism is dressed up as merit , not when people feel a white person has more merit be cuss they feel more comfortable with them, less challenged ,

Familyofthem · 21/02/2023 07:48

MySugarBabyLove · 21/02/2023 07:32

We’ve gone too far in the direction of making it solely about whichever diverse group you fit into though rather than ability.

There should be equal opportunity for winning, but winning should be based purely on ability and nothing else.

We can take that further. Let’s look at employment for instance, if you have three candidates, one is black, one is white and one is disabled, and there is an expectation on your company to employ more people who are black and more who are disabled, should you pick those two candidates purely because they represent those groups even though the white person may be better able to do the job? Conversely, do people who are of ethnic minorities and who are disabled really want to win based on their background rather than their ability? I have a disability and I sure as hell don’t. I want to be given the same opportunities to be in the position, i.e. if I get to interview then I want to be on a level playing field, but I certainly wouldn’t want to be given a job because I have a disability rather than that I was the best candidate for the job.

And when this happens (and it des happen), you are going to end up with the opposite in that you are going to end up with people who felt they were capable/more capable but that they have been overlooked because they’re white. And that is no more fair than being overlooked because you’re black. People should win based on merit.

If there have only been white winners then we need to ask:

Was the vote really biased because of racism?

Or were the films containing white artists simply better hence why the white artists won?

As for albums, if Adele released ten albums and George Ezra released one, I would buy his one album and wouldn’t go anywhere near any of Adele’s. That has nothing to do wth the fact that she’s a woman, and everything to do with the fact that I don’t like her music. But should I buy one because it’s not fair that as a woman she gets less sales?

Even if it was somehow true that the 'white films' were 'better', you are missing the point. Why are they better? Are non-white actors getting the same exposure and opportunity to star in the best movies (the answer is no).

The idea that things in life are handed out on merit, and that equal opportunity is the default in the Western world, is one of the biggest fairytales people choose to believe in.

Catspyjamas17 · 21/02/2023 07:47

No, I think diversity is really important.

One thing the entertainment and media industry needs to focus on massively is class, though. It's hugely upper middle class.

LaviniasBigBloomers · 21/02/2023 07:45

Ponoka7 · 21/02/2023 07:35

I used to go on the film reviews over a couple of sites, one being rotten tomatoes. We took a chance on some with low scores. I started to realise that those with female casts, who wasn't highly sexualised, got low reviews. Likewise all black cast films. I don't think that the reviewers would even watch if the cast had disabilities in. I agree that it isn't an issue if there are less winners, in line with the statistics of society, but some performances seem to get completely overlooked. I thought that this was going to be about adverts tbh, which massively over represents ethnic diversity, not that it matters.

This is so true. And filmmakers keep making films for this demo because 'women don't watch films' - dudes, if you made something worth watching...

LaviniasBigBloomers · 21/02/2023 07:43

MySugarBabyLove · 21/02/2023 07:32

We’ve gone too far in the direction of making it solely about whichever diverse group you fit into though rather than ability.

There should be equal opportunity for winning, but winning should be based purely on ability and nothing else.

We can take that further. Let’s look at employment for instance, if you have three candidates, one is black, one is white and one is disabled, and there is an expectation on your company to employ more people who are black and more who are disabled, should you pick those two candidates purely because they represent those groups even though the white person may be better able to do the job? Conversely, do people who are of ethnic minorities and who are disabled really want to win based on their background rather than their ability? I have a disability and I sure as hell don’t. I want to be given the same opportunities to be in the position, i.e. if I get to interview then I want to be on a level playing field, but I certainly wouldn’t want to be given a job because I have a disability rather than that I was the best candidate for the job.

And when this happens (and it des happen), you are going to end up with the opposite in that you are going to end up with people who felt they were capable/more capable but that they have been overlooked because they’re white. And that is no more fair than being overlooked because you’re black. People should win based on merit.

If there have only been white winners then we need to ask:

Was the vote really biased because of racism?

Or were the films containing white artists simply better hence why the white artists won?

As for albums, if Adele released ten albums and George Ezra released one, I would buy his one album and wouldn’t go anywhere near any of Adele’s. That has nothing to do wth the fact that she’s a woman, and everything to do with the fact that I don’t like her music. But should I buy one because it’s not fair that as a woman she gets less sales?

In my hoop have we gone too far. That really grinds my gears.

We'll have gone too far when we've had 60 female PMs and 50 female POTUS. We'll have gone too far when the boards of the Footsie have been 85% female for 100 years. We'll have gone too far when there have been no white male BAFTA or BRIT winners for 50 years.

That's what going too far looks like. Inconceivable.

Yet, equal.

noblegiraffe · 21/02/2023 07:40

Was the vote really biased because of racism?

Or were the films containing white artists simply better hence why the white artists won?

How can anyone seriously still be asking this faux-innocent question after so many decades of disproportionately white people winning?

Ponoka7 · 21/02/2023 07:35

I used to go on the film reviews over a couple of sites, one being rotten tomatoes. We took a chance on some with low scores. I started to realise that those with female casts, who wasn't highly sexualised, got low reviews. Likewise all black cast films. I don't think that the reviewers would even watch if the cast had disabilities in. I agree that it isn't an issue if there are less winners, in line with the statistics of society, but some performances seem to get completely overlooked. I thought that this was going to be about adverts tbh, which massively over represents ethnic diversity, not that it matters.

MySugarBabyLove · 21/02/2023 07:32

We’ve gone too far in the direction of making it solely about whichever diverse group you fit into though rather than ability.

There should be equal opportunity for winning, but winning should be based purely on ability and nothing else.

We can take that further. Let’s look at employment for instance, if you have three candidates, one is black, one is white and one is disabled, and there is an expectation on your company to employ more people who are black and more who are disabled, should you pick those two candidates purely because they represent those groups even though the white person may be better able to do the job? Conversely, do people who are of ethnic minorities and who are disabled really want to win based on their background rather than their ability? I have a disability and I sure as hell don’t. I want to be given the same opportunities to be in the position, i.e. if I get to interview then I want to be on a level playing field, but I certainly wouldn’t want to be given a job because I have a disability rather than that I was the best candidate for the job.

And when this happens (and it des happen), you are going to end up with the opposite in that you are going to end up with people who felt they were capable/more capable but that they have been overlooked because they’re white. And that is no more fair than being overlooked because you’re black. People should win based on merit.

If there have only been white winners then we need to ask:

Was the vote really biased because of racism?

Or were the films containing white artists simply better hence why the white artists won?

As for albums, if Adele released ten albums and George Ezra released one, I would buy his one album and wouldn’t go anywhere near any of Adele’s. That has nothing to do wth the fact that she’s a woman, and everything to do with the fact that I don’t like her music. But should I buy one because it’s not fair that as a woman she gets less sales?

Alltheprettyseahorses · 21/02/2023 07:29

If we don't focus on inclusion we end up with posh white men tickboxing and I can't think of a single field where that is a good thing. Let's focus on real ability instead because we're missing out.

UthredofBattenberg · 21/02/2023 07:26

Any award should be deserved because of performance alone. Not because of race, sex or any other category.

I don't agree with shoving anyone in for the sake of it, to complete a tick box exercise.

However, if some stellar performances have been over looked because of race or sex, then that's absolutely wrong and needs addressing.

If the major roles aren't going to minority groups, then that needs addressing. That's what needs to change.

cakeorwine · 21/02/2023 07:16

clpsmum · 21/02/2023 07:10

I didn't meant that to sound like I didn't agree with equality and inclusion I think it's fantastic we are moving towards a more inclusive society I just wish it were inclusive for all

It's a bit like all women shortlists. Great to promote more women into Parliament etc, but are all types of women represented. Or is it women of a certain background who are more likely to be represented.

And why just have all women shortlists? There are other under represented groups who maybe could benefit from a short list.

OTOH, if it's on merit, then there are groups who stand less chance of getting on such lists and having such opportunities because of barriers, lack of opportunity etc. Whilst some other people seem more likely to succeed.

clpsmum · 21/02/2023 07:10

I didn't meant that to sound like I didn't agree with equality and inclusion I think it's fantastic we are moving towards a more inclusive society I just wish it were inclusive for all

clpsmum · 21/02/2023 07:09

Maybe it's focused on equality inclusion for people of colour but not for everybody. Disabled people are hardly ever represented in anything and nobody seems to give a shit

cakeorwine · 21/02/2023 07:08

DelphiniumBlue123 · 21/02/2023 06:53

This.
Why is it so hard to comprehend?

Why do you think that is?

And why just stop at categories for men and women? Why not drill down more into a whole range of awards for under represented groups?

If it's an award for women, are there particular types of women who always win?

Same as for men - are there particular groups of men who usually win the male awards?

LaviniasBigBloomers · 21/02/2023 07:00

When I were a lass and it were all fields round here, drama college (like all third sector education) was free. So I went. I was estranged from my family, had been self-supporting since I was 17 and through hard work and sacrifice, I got in. Tutoring was free, I got a loan for living expenses and I worked. I'm white, Scottish and came from a family that wouldn't even qualify as working class.

Nowadays that route wouldn't be open to me and as a pp has said, arts training is almost exclusively reserved for the rich.

It was a huge issue to me that I went into that sector of the economy. It was a huge issue to me that working class voices were represented.

You cannot possibly speak from all people of colour and say that they don't care about seeing themselves on the screen, and then reaching the highest levels of that profession when they get there.

FWIW I do think that we're quick to apply an American lens to everything and yes, you do need to look over a length of time and apply some critical thinking to see if there is evidence of racism or if it's 'statistically OK' to have an all white BAFTA. But saying that a lack of diversity in the performing arts isn't important is a really ignorant thing to say. Art matters, it matters to who we are as a nation, it matters to who we are as humans, and it also contributes a huge amount to our cultural capital, which directly translates into $$$

Namenic · 21/02/2023 06:58

I kinda know where you are coming from OP - as I’m E Asian and attitudes towards careers in my culture seem pretty similar.

I think you’re right about statistics - basing things on 1 year isn’t really sensible. But I do think using statistics (over multiple years) and caring about representation matters on a deeper level. If you’re looking at the numbers as an end in itself - I can see it’s pretty pointless. But if you’re looking at the more varied output of such diversity then I think there is a point. I really enjoy watching Mindy Kaling’s Never Have I ever on Netflix or the Fresh off the boat sitcom or listening to the comedians Sindhu Vee or Ken Cheng. They capture funny stuff that is part of the immigrant experience that I guess it might be hard for others to do in the same way.

I suppose the Arts often involve quite a bit of sacrifice and hard work/poor pay to ‘make it’, and awards are not a goal in themselves but a way of encouraging people in this career and giving them publicity - so they can make entertaining shows that I enjoy. Diversity also makes it a valid career path for the Asian (and other ethnic minorities too) kids to point out to their parents - ‘I wanna be like Ken Cheng whose show you loved’. I’d still give them the speech - ‘for every Ken Cheng there are 1000s who don’t become famous…. But there are lots of accountancy jobs that… blah blah’. But who knows - they might make it as a star and make some great shows for people.

DelphiniumBlue123 · 21/02/2023 06:55

Confusedabouttheworld23 · 21/02/2023 00:40

@noblegiraffe I am not denying that there was bias in the past and that there is definitely no bias now. I am saying that we can’t judge if recent progress has been made, based on one year. We need to wait for a few years and then do analysis. Over a long period of time, there may be more diversity but it is surely unrealistic to think that we can just click our fingers and in a year or two significant diversity has been achieved. There may be regressions along the way- significant change never occurs in a linear fashion.

in addition, surely we should be celebrating the works of art themselves rather than worry about the characteristics of the artists.

Don't be daft.

DelphiniumBlue123 · 21/02/2023 06:53

noblegiraffe · 21/02/2023 00:16

When awards are given in open categories with no thought to diversity then they are predominantly won by white men.

And that’s nothing to do with merit.

That’s why there are female categories, for a start. Look what happened when they got rid of that at the BRITs.

This.
Why is it so hard to comprehend?

Bumpitybumper · 21/02/2023 06:48

I agree partly with what you are saying, in that the focus isn't really on proportional representation which I think is probably the best way to achieve equality of opportunity but instead some kind of representative tokenism.

Ideally achievement in all fields of life and representation should roughly reflect the demographics of the population. So for example, just over 50% of the British population is female so you would expect half of BRIT award winners to be women. There may be years where this is slightly skewed towards one sex because how music releases happen to have fallen over time but a strong bias towards men is alarming and non-representative. This implies there is something structurally wrong with the music industry that favours men and would require at the very least further investigation.

What I don't agree with is where people demand that all minority groups are represented in all things always otherwise it's discrimination of some kind. More than 80% of our population is white so if you were to put a production with five cast members together then statistically you could have only one person from an ethnic minority and this would be representative. I think that a lot of people would find the 1:5 ratio unacceptable and unrepresentative though. Then you would be asked why nobody is gay (3% of the population) or trans (0.5%). I think in a bid to avoid criticism, some minority groups are now overrepresented to a point where it is almost tokenism and done for effect.

Conversely, other groups are massively unrepresented and nobody seems to care. The working class are barely seen, especially if you're white and a bit of a 'chav'. I see people around like this all the time around town and yet can't recall seeing an actor or actress who genuinely seemed to represent this type of person. Most of the time it's middle class people playing those parts. Older women are not represented properly and nobody seems to care. After 35 you can be cast as a 25 year olds mother and that is considered acceptable.