Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think society is too focused on equal representation?

119 replies

Confusedabouttheworld23 · 21/02/2023 00:01

Watching the news today, I saw how there is outrage over a lack of BAME winners at the BAFTAs. As an Indian heritage person myself, I fail to see how this is a huge problem from a few key reasons.

Firstly, , statistically the UK is predominantly a White country and therefore it is not statistically significant if one year there were no BAME winners. In fact a statistician tweeted that you need to look over a period of 5/6 years to see if there is systemic racism in the BAFTAs. In fact in 2021 or 2022, half of the winners were BAME, showing that you cannot read too much into such a small sample size.
As a subpoint, BAFTA voters are predominantly going to be White if this is representative of the UK Population. If it is true that people resonate with those who predominantly look like them, it is no surprise and not a huge issue that the majority of UK award winners are White. If one were to go to India for example, most if not all award winners would be of Indian heritage, this is completely fine and reflective of a country’s demographics,

Secondly, with so many other issues in the UK, I feel that a focus on equal representation is being totally blown out of proportion. We need to focus on just working hard, trying to better ourselves and get through the tough economic times we are experiencing at the moment.
A lack of diversity in acting seems almost trivial compared to other significant issues affecting the UK population - I am much more concerned about rising inflation, housing costs than the number of people who I feel represent me in film.

Thirdly, it is argued that we need to encourage more people from diverse backgrounds to go into film and other arts in the UK, and the main way to do this is to award and recognise BAME artists/actors. However, is it really a huge issue if those from BAME backgrounds go into other sectors of the economy. For example, Indian heritage people often go into STEM, finance etc, rather than the Arts which has resulted in them being one of the most economically successful groups in the UK. This is not a huge issue therefore, and hence there is not a need to push for increased diversity in the Arts to the extent that we are doing so today.
I just feel that everyone needs to just work hard and get through life, rather than focus on issues which in the grand scheme of things are not that significant.

OP posts:
Randomactsofspanking · 21/02/2023 14:24

midgemadgemodge · 21/02/2023 14:18

And an individual can't address their unconscious bias in isolation from society

Your unconscious picks up clues from society and makes rational conclusions and humans have unconscious bias because no one has the mental resources to think everything through all the time

Good point, I, too, often find I’m far too busy and important with my life to spare any mental ressources to think about the way I make decisions and how they affect people.

latetothefisting · 21/02/2023 14:22

I agree that just looking at 1 year in isolation doesn't work as there can be an outlier at any point.

I also think we get caught up too much in what types of diversity we value. The current outrage over the race/heritage of the winners for example when there are approximately 4% of the population of black heritage yet 17% who have some form of disability, yet you never see complaints about no disabled winners.

On the other hand if 40% of nominations weren't yet 100% of winners were white that is a slightly unusual statistic. But not worth getting worked up about as a one off, if a similar pattern persisted over the next 2 years it might be an issue.

midgemadgemodge · 21/02/2023 14:18

And an individual can't address their unconscious bias in isolation from society

Your unconscious picks up clues from society and makes rational conclusions and humans have unconscious bias because no one has the mental resources to think everything through all the time

Reclaimtheoutdoors · 21/02/2023 14:17

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 21/02/2023 00:27

YABVVVVU. Representation matters. What do you as an 'Indian person' (Your words) know about the importance of representation for black Caribbean people, let alone any other ethnic group. What about how structural and systemic racism (Windrush anyone?) impacts representation for black communities. To say the everyone needs to just work hard shows ignorance and privilege. Stay in your narrow lane.

This!

This shows how many non-white people are complicit in not only their own oppression but the oppression in others. Black or brown skin fighting to maintain white supremacist status quo doesn’t make it better. Take note Priti Patel, Suella Braverman, Kwarteng et al.

midgemadgemodge · 21/02/2023 14:17

To tackle the bottom you also need to tackle the top

For example - there are not a lot of class x coming through so it doesn't matter they aren't seen in the awards

But the reasons they don't come through include the fact that they don't think they belong because they have no role models they identify with, because they aren't given a chance because they are too different to previously successful people ....

The top has to offer a leg up where it can or the bottom won't ever change.

Change across the board is needed

Randomactsofspanking · 21/02/2023 14:14

UdoU · 21/02/2023 12:59

So basically you’re saying British Indians are sorted so let’s ignore all the other minorities?

You are part of the problem, OP.

British Indians are not ‘sorted’. No group is ‘sorted’ you must see how ridiculously bigoted it is to talk about people as a random group rather than an individual!?
it’s down to an individual to decide how to change their unconscious bias and essential ‘not be a dick’ it’s not down to the system to force discrimination of a ‘special’ group cause their the flavour of the month. Work hard = get rewarded. It’s the Tory dream! It’s up to the individual to take some responsibility for not being dick. How can so many people be at a such a lazy place where they need society/the government/school/the BAFTAs to police or control them not being a dick!
overheard in Waitrose:
‘im sorry maam I’ve tried so hard but I just can’t stop being rascist’
‘don’t worry dear, we’re all rascists, if we stick at it long enough someone else will fix this for us’ *rolls eyes

Elsiebear90 · 21/02/2023 14:02

I think you need to tackle it from the bottom up, not just hand out awards to minorities to fulfil a quota, I wouldn’t want to win something just because I’m a gay woman, I want to win because I’m the best.

The only way we can have fair representation of minorities is to create equal opportunities, so we need to look at why the film and TV industry is dominated by white middle class people, and we need to look at why the music industry is dominated by men and start there. I think scrapping the female sex category at the Brits was a mistake, but having a female category was also just masking the problem.

HisRoyalWhineness · 21/02/2023 13:36

UdoU · 21/02/2023 12:59

So basically you’re saying British Indians are sorted so let’s ignore all the other minorities?

You are part of the problem, OP.

I believe OP is saying that tokenism is problematic and so is victim mentality. Not that they are 'sorted' because clearly there isn't very much British Indian representation in film awards. But I can't speak for them, of course!

JamSandle · 21/02/2023 13:32

I think we are. And as you say, in terms of representation, we fall really low when it comes to representing the working class.

HisRoyalWhineness · 21/02/2023 13:32

It seems to be largely about those one-off films that capture a moment in the psyche. This year, it was a German war film. In 2009, it was Slumdog Millionaire - lots of 'PoC' actors winning awards, and the film overall won a BAFTA. Pitting black against white actors is too oversimplistic - it's about the films that capture something about the mood of the nation in that moment. Currently, that would be war (obviously, Ukraine). Next year, who knows?

MotherOfRatios · 21/02/2023 13:20

This is why BAME is crap because south Asian struggles aren't necessarily the same as Black people, as a Black woman I disagree.

The issue is the snubbing of people in favour of white people, some white actors who win are mediocre and win over Black/racialised people who deserve the award. That is the issue not that people just aren't winning

midgemadgemodge · 21/02/2023 13:15

... and not accidentally hitting post too soon..

Then we make it more normal to see people on top roles - it helps to overcome bias elsewhere

For example if no none white person ever won an award and you were a film writer you might subconsciously think I want white actors as I want to win awards

It sounds daft but it is what goes on in your pattern matching subconscious

If all colours can win awards pretty well in line with proportions in society - then it's not a risky choice , its a none issue ( to your subconscious)

And if all colours win children know that children like them have a chance making them
Much more likely to try

Yes it's hard
Yes it feels unfair - but life isn't fair and what we want to do is make it fairer

Let's face it as a white person do you think your award has as much value now as it would ina future where you are competing fairly with all colours - today your award was won unfairly as you had so many advantages to get where you are

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 21/02/2023 13:12

I agree with you about the adverts - and TV in general. For instance, schools or extra-curricular activities will often choose an ethnic minority to represent them in publicity, even if in reality they are majority white, and I think a good case can be made for this. Where it falls down is, why would a kid whose parents come from Africa (for example) feel 'represented' by a picture of an Asian kid any more than a picture of a white kid? Or even a picture of somebody who comes from a very different part of Africa? BAME don't all look the same, you know!

I find lumping a very diverse group of people together under BAME, and using it as what is essentially a tick box very, very problematic, and I have mentioned this at work on a number of occasions - and not just for BAME, because there's always the question in work of is a representative representing themselves or a wider group or community, and how to have clarity around that.

midgemadgemodge · 21/02/2023 13:10

I think the thing to remember is that to address the structural problems at the bottom of the rungs - why there are fewer good roles for example and why some classes of people find it hard to get opportunities- we have to change every rung

By making sure that people from minorities get visibility - so making an effort to at least check we haven't been lazy in out "merit" based decisions, and where it's hard to call favouring the none white candidate-

rexythedinosaur · 21/02/2023 13:05

Confusedabouttheworld23 · 21/02/2023 00:19

@noblegiraffe I think, if I’m not mistaken, fewer top British women artists released music this year compared to men, and this was one of the big reasons as to why men won the majority/all the votes this year.

From the BBC:
Part of the reason for this year's showing is that fewer major female stars like Adele and Dua Lipa put out new music in the last 12 months.
In 2022, there was just one British female solo artist with a new album among the top 100 best-sellers - Florence and the Machine, at number 89. In comparison, there were seven men in the top 100.
And women are represented in other Brits categories - female duo Wet Leg have four nominations, the joint highest with Styles; while Taylor Swift, Beyonce and Lizzo outnumber the men on the best international artist shortlist.

Do you not question WHY there are fewer women artists releasing music/ in the top 100 though?

Maybe there is some problem in society preventing women from becoming musicians.

I do get what you're saying - of course awards should be based on merit - but I don't think you are thinking about it deeply enough.

Where do you think that 'merit' comes from? WHY would white males be winning more awards based on 'merit'? (as they inevitably do if we don't make explicit efforts to recognise diversity).

It is to do with privilege and life opportunities they have which enables them to excel.

We have got to address this at both ends of the scale to tackle it - both in providing more opportunities to less privileged groups, and also by providing more recognition/ awards to less privileged groups.

If there is no thought to diversity then white men tend to bulldoze on all fronts. Therefore I understand that it might seem tokenistic, but it's important.

UdoU · 21/02/2023 12:59

So basically you’re saying British Indians are sorted so let’s ignore all the other minorities?

You are part of the problem, OP.

WeAreBorg · 21/02/2023 12:57

OP - you have succumbed to the same fate as Priti Patel and her sort. Years and years of racism directed against you and you found a glimmer of hope when you realised if you become right wing and ingratiate yourselves with racist people that they will like you and tell you “but you’re okay, I don’t mean you” when they talk about terrible immigrants etc.

Don’t use BAME ffs

Danikm151 · 21/02/2023 12:55

BAME is a problematic term. It lumps anyone who isn’t white in a group.

It annoys a lot of people. Myself included. I’m not white but my family are. I’m mixed heritage but apparently I should be in a different group.

Dobby123456 · 21/02/2023 12:49

Catspyjamas17 · 21/02/2023 07:47

No, I think diversity is really important.

One thing the entertainment and media industry needs to focus on massively is class, though. It's hugely upper middle class.

I once met a make-up artist who'd trained to work in TV, but left because 'it was too middle class'. It was a real eye-opener to me that somebody would leave their dream job for that reason. Really nice lady too.

debbrianna · 21/02/2023 12:49

Dobby123456 · 21/02/2023 12:30

Is this discrimination against ethnic minorities, though, or just anyone who doesn't have much money? (which is most white people).

Think of the bigger picture. It's a symptom. Sports, is not just sports.

Dobby123456 · 21/02/2023 12:40

NightSprinkles · 21/02/2023 10:12

I don't care about the baftas but I do care about representation. When I was younger I used to think similar to other pp on here. Society's job is to provide equality of opportunity and not equality of outcome. However, we have tried this for years and it doesn't work because of systemic racism and unconscious bias.

There is another very important point why representation is so important and that is to normalise being different and to change people's perception that "white" (or "man", etc) is the default and is better. Most of us (of whatever race, gender or sexual orientation) are unconsciously guilty of this. I am too (and I am of Indian origin). We need to see all kinds of people in all fields so that our unconscious bias is wiped out. You can be told a million times that a doctor of colour will provide equally good care but it's only when you see many doctors of colours providing good care that you even stop (unconsciously) questioning it as it's become the norm, ie so common that you don't even think about it anymore.

Bame (for want of a better word) kids need to see people like them being successful so they know that they too can be successful. Equally or maybe even more importantly white kids need to see this too so that they don't learn that "white" is the default or that white is better. Yes, the majority of the UK is white but if a child only sees white people achieving then they will equate white with being capable and that will become their default. That is why I like the ads where people of colour are disproportionately represented. It doesn't maybe reflect society accurately but it shows that this society (with mixed couples) isn't a big deal, isn't very different and isn't any worse. It normalises it.

I'm not explaining it very well so I hope someone more eloquent can explain my point as I do think I have a good point. :-)

I have digressed from the baftas but my point is maybe we need to Make sure that we have diverse representation in all areas of life so that we get equality in the areas that perhaps matter more. People of colour should be seen as rounded, talented and achieving members of society so that our skills aren't doubted. So that we don't have to keep proving ourselves. And to show that we are individuals just like everyone else.

I agree with you about the adverts - and TV in general. For instance, schools or extra-curricular activities will often choose an ethnic minority to represent them in publicity, even if in reality they are majority white, and I think a good case can be made for this. Where it falls down is, why would a kid whose parents come from Africa (for example) feel 'represented' by a picture of an Asian kid any more than a picture of a white kid? Or even a picture of somebody who comes from a very different part of Africa? BAME don't all look the same, you know!

The other problem is, while it's fine to pick somebody as a kind of aspirational image on a website, it's not ok to pick (for instance) the Prime Minister, based on what they look like. We currently have an ethnic minority PM, and he didn't get there because somebody thought he'd look good in a photograph (Although, he's a clear improvement on Boris!)

Nimbostratus100 · 21/02/2023 12:38

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 21/02/2023 10:21

I'd say you have to tackle it from both ends because representation is important, both for the people being represented (BAME in this case) and everyone else.

o yes, I agree, but changing the results of racism are only a sticking plaster to cover up that we have failed to address the causes

Dobby123456 · 21/02/2023 12:30

debbrianna · 21/02/2023 12:04

This is not the same. If you notice, in many sports that do not require a lot of backing and hidden tallent, ethic minorities do really well. The example is running, all you need to be is good, and the rest can follow. This also applies to areas like football. Where it kicks out ethnic minorities in sports like sailing, tennis, car racing cars, and golf for example, where lots of money is required before you can even get to close to being a pro, these sports favour white men and women including advertising which always pays more. But also mostly white males.

Is this discrimination against ethnic minorities, though, or just anyone who doesn't have much money? (which is most white people).

CrinkleCutChips · 21/02/2023 12:13

I could have written your post OP. Too many people look for offence where there is none to be had.

debbrianna · 21/02/2023 12:10

I don't want to rain on Alison's parade, but I feel like the BAFTA's knew what the winning results were like and threw her in as a consolation prize with Andrea Dubios doing that idiotic create rap fest.