Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is going on?

167 replies

pleasemindyourmanners · 20/02/2023 23:10

I am a teacher and I am aware that this will no doubt lead to lots of teacher bashing as this appears to have become a national past time.
I just can't work out what is going on with children and parents and attitudes towards school.
Younger and younger children are coming through with less and less resilience. I realise that covid and lockdowns have played a part but this was happening before then too. It is just gradually getting worse.
So many parents also appear almost delusional about their children. That is increasing year on year too. They are not interested in any misdemeanours their child may have been part of. They only believe one version of events. And all want their child to be listened to and their version to be acted upon.
I was looking at my pension pot. I have about 25 years to reach the state pension. That is a terrifying prospect. If behaviour and attitudes towards teaching/schools carry on the same trajectory I dread to think what things will be like by that point.
I really wish I could put my finger on what the main problems are but the issues are so massive there are definitely no easy fixes. Lack of resources and specialist staff is one issue but i don't remember there being such a huge need as there is nowadays.
It is like we, teachers, are also becoming immune to being sworn at by parents and even primary aged kids.
It isn't just my school. Friends in other schools and teachers on teaching Facebook pages are all saying the same thing. I'd say this is one of the many reasons there is a teacher retention issue. It is draining.
I absolutely love the kids and what I do. However, I feel like I can't do my job properly a lot of the time as I've effectively become a bouncer or a referee.
Everything appears to be blamed on teachers. Even icy conditions round school was seen as our fault and we were thoughtless putting them out in the icy playground.
Kids who just get on with things, don't try to cause a drama, who are kind without having constant dramas are becoming more and more rare. This is no longer the expected behaviour and ore like a wishful dream. It is Monday night and I'm totally exhausted already.

OP posts:
Guis · 21/02/2023 11:08

Teachers in particular get a bad press because they are in a position of having a job but don't acknowledge the comparative incredibly generous time away from work. If teachers acknowledged they spend a lot of time away from the classroom people would be more inclined ,I suspect, to listen to other issues. When people usually have four to six weeks leave a year, to have people who have 13 and complaining, is a turn off. And hence disrespect comes in.

I also think as a profession they haven't kept standards high enough. I watched some of the 'teaching across Britain' and was dismayed by some of the teachers whose main priority seemed to be needing to be popular with the students far too much.

We are a very child orientated society. Children are revered and idolised. From TV shows, to social media, facilities provided and spend via local councils to 'attractions' who go out of their way to please and TV channels. Older people are not wanted. And children know it. So do parents. Everywhere should provide for their every need. No children's menu = outrage ! Except it shouldn't be so.
And if children are ever not number one priority it is confusing to them, so they kick off. As they expect to be.

And largely, the area you work in might make a difference. I know someone who grew up in a very tough area and fighting parents was going on decades ago. That is nothing new.

I think if teachers went on fewer jollies it might help their reputation. The number of times I have been out to somewhere in term time only to see a coach of children turn up, not the slightest bit interested in whatever it is they are visiting I cannot number. It really is just a day out for the teachers. Often just after they have returned from leave. Teachers are in the classroom for a maximum of 5 weeks stretch at any one time. Which is a bit shocking.

I think too the number of issues that happened around Covid disappointed people. A few schools took a proactive 'can do' approach rather than what seemed really a political stance and got children back in the classroom.

Ashorthistoryfan · 21/02/2023 10:58

Catspyjamas17 · 21/02/2023 10:44

Yes of course that language is disrespectful. I used it because that's how people generally thought about mental illness and those were the words that were commonly used.

Yes, I understand that, sorry that I didn't make that clearer.
My point was there's a big difference in how 'normal' anxiety /depression and clinically diagnosed anxiety or depression affect a person. And there are lots of other MH conditions that make life very difficult - ocd can be a nightmare, for example, and is widely misunderstood.
You don't have to be psychotic to be mentally unwell.

I think the pp you were reponding to was talking about MH problems, not MH equating to everyday emotions.

DysmalRadius · 21/02/2023 10:49

"The children now love luxury; they have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders and love chatter in place of exercise. Children are now tyrants, not the servants of their households. They no longer rise when elders enter the room. They contradict their parents, chatter before company, gobble up dainties at the table, cross their legs, and tyrannize their teachers."

Socrates complained about pretty much the same things as you, more than two thousand years ago. I think every generation believes that they are the last to behave 'properly' - maybe it is just how society evolves.

ShakespearesBlister · 21/02/2023 10:45

We used to have discipline. That's what was different. Children had respect for teachers and if you got told off by a teacher, your parents would give you a good telling off too. Now they want compensation.

Catspyjamas17 · 21/02/2023 10:44

Ashorthistoryfan · 21/02/2023 10:42

I think the pp was speaking about mental health issues or problems, not mental health.
And being mentally unwell doesn't necessarily mean you're psychotic! (As you know, using language like 'mad' and 'loopy' to describe MH illness is disrespectful and outdated at this stage.)
What about things like severe (clinical) depression or anxiety etc?

Different to being anxious about an exam or temporarily 'depressed' because your team was knocked out of the league, of course.

Yes of course that language is disrespectful. I used it because that's how people generally thought about mental illness and those were the words that were commonly used.

Ashorthistoryfan · 21/02/2023 10:42

Catspyjamas17 · 21/02/2023 10:20

Totally agree with this, including the comment about the increased blurring of what is a mental health issue and what just constitues life and common human emotions.

That is part of mental health though - life and common human emotions. Mentally unwell, actually not that many years ago to me meant mad, psycho, loopy etc. Yes, there is a difference between feeling sad one day and being depressed but it's all part of the same human experience.

I think the pp was speaking about mental health issues or problems, not mental health.
And being mentally unwell doesn't necessarily mean you're psychotic! (As you know, using language like 'mad' and 'loopy' to describe MH illness is disrespectful and outdated at this stage.)
What about things like severe (clinical) depression or anxiety etc?

Different to being anxious about an exam or temporarily 'depressed' because your team was knocked out of the league, of course.

Iwillbuymyselfflowers · 21/02/2023 10:41

It's living in Tory Britain for over a decade. It's almost the entirety of these DCs lives; they have been broken. Austerity, poverty, pandemic, mental health services obliterated, war.

Is it any wonder?

Parents often don't help. I have fought for years with Ex to try to make him understand that our child can and does, frequently do things that are wrong. He undermines my attempts at parenting every time. It's infuriating.

Lastly, we often hold children to unrealistic, higher standards of behaviour and conduct than we do ourselves as adults. This doesn't help, and often increases the desire to rebel.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 21/02/2023 10:39

‘we can't even buy a tomato in the shop due to Brexit’

Nothing to do with Brexit. There are no tariff or import restrictions into the UK from any country ( although the EU has erected some of its own). The vegetable shortage is due to poor harvest ( remember this summer?) , and the increased costs of energy in the EU , making it difficult to heat greenhouses. The energy situation is particularly bad due to the dependence of many states on Russian gas and power, and the imposition of ‘green’ policies which have discouraged greenhouse production of ….tomatoes and peppers, especially in Holland.

but you bang the drum. I expect knives in schools are somehow due to Brexit too.

bookworm14 · 21/02/2023 10:37

LaFemmeDamnee · 21/02/2023 09:29

The book Matilda literally starts with two pages on how parents think that the sun shines out of their horrible children, and how teachers have to hear this nonsense all the time. It was published in 1988.

Some of you have incredibly powerful rose tints on your glasses. Parenting was definitely not better in the 60s and 70s. Bullying and truanting were flat out ignored in the 80s. It probably was easier to teach when troubled children just didn't turn up, and dyslexic and autistic children could be slapped or mocked for not achieving. Sure, schools probably do need more consistent discipline policies in a lot of cases but who can implement them? There's a massive shortage of teachers and resources so everything in schools feels 100 times harder.

Excellent post.

Molto · 21/02/2023 10:37

CallMeDaddy58 · 21/02/2023 09:24

Some comments here are hilarious.

You know the “entitled” parents some of you are blaming for this behaviour were raised by YOUR generation. It’s also abundantly clear that some people have absolutely no idea what gentle parenting is.

kids these days are dealing with things your generation can’t even begin to fathom. The internet wasn’t even invented when you were young. Never mind social media.

On other threads people loooove to lament on about how dangerous the world is today and it wasn’t like that in your time. Kids could walk to the park and play until dark!

There’s thread after thread from women trapped (with their kids) in abusive relationships. So many single parent families and the struggles that brings (coparenting, poverty). Yet somehow the blame for children being less resilient is “gentle parenting, entitlement and screen time”.

FFS.

Btw there are quotes going back to literally Ancient Rome and Greece and beyond where the older generation talks about how the new generation are spoilt and entitled and pandered to and on and on and on it goes.

“YOUR generation” is a bit of a sweeping nonsense statement, since you don’t know how old many people are on here.

And as for kids “dealing with” social media - you do know it’s not oxygen, right? They don’t have to have it, whatever vocal online people might insist. There’s enough research now to show it’s an absolutely terrible idea to let children have access to it, so if children are “struggling” with social media, that’s poor parenting.

Agree with @Catspyjamas17 about some things though. The world looks pretty bleak at the moment, but the answer isn’t a race to the bottom - what would massively help is family and schools not dwelling on self-care and what tiny box we all fit in, but what we can individually do to help others (from helping around the house to volunteering for charities, environmental projects, unions etc when older).

Actually doing something active removes a sense of powerlessness that is at the route of so much (adult and child) anxiety, and benefits everyone around. Less so endless school assemblies about mental health, and parents calling in to say that asking their child to do their homework is causing MH issues in the parent so they’re not going to do it anymore (had that call before half term).

GCAcademic · 21/02/2023 10:37

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I don't think you can compare being a teacher in a state school or a nurse in A&E to the majority of private sector jobs. All the private sector jobs I've had have been pretty cushy, no unpaid and excessive overtime, or threats of violence, or having to take responsibility for other people's mental and physical health, certainly.

KimberleyClark · 21/02/2023 10:28

I saw a really good tiktok the other day that reasoned kids today are brats because their millennial/ gen x parents never had their emotional needs met ever. We were left to deal with all our problems ourselves, our MH issues were never dealt with and we felt completely unsupported.

I was born in the early 60s and this was just as true during my school years if not more so. The idea that we had any emotional needs was quite alien. We were at school to learn and that was that.

Futurethoughts · 21/02/2023 10:28

So there was no racism, bullying, fighting?

Homophobia? Section 28 went in 2003.

You were trusted to get on with the job and I am sure you did so diligently but many teachers did not.

Teenage pregnancy rates: what were they like?

Ah, the good old days.

SpanishGirly · 21/02/2023 10:27

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

JanusTheFirst · 21/02/2023 10:24

Futurethoughts · 21/02/2023 10:14

I think if a lot of the teachers lamenting how awful it is nowadays on here had to actually go back and teach in the 80s/90s/2000s (depending on ages) they might find the land of milk and honey they seek doesn’t actually exist at all.

I was teaching then and it was often very much a land of milk and honey.

Teachers were trusted to get on with the job and, crucially, it was much easier to expel violent pupils.

Mmmpizza · 21/02/2023 10:21

LaFemmeDamnee · 21/02/2023 09:29

The book Matilda literally starts with two pages on how parents think that the sun shines out of their horrible children, and how teachers have to hear this nonsense all the time. It was published in 1988.

Some of you have incredibly powerful rose tints on your glasses. Parenting was definitely not better in the 60s and 70s. Bullying and truanting were flat out ignored in the 80s. It probably was easier to teach when troubled children just didn't turn up, and dyslexic and autistic children could be slapped or mocked for not achieving. Sure, schools probably do need more consistent discipline policies in a lot of cases but who can implement them? There's a massive shortage of teachers and resources so everything in schools feels 100 times harder.

Absolutely this.

People are completely deluding themselves if they really believe that things were better in the 'good old days'.

My parents were born in the early 50s and things were absolutely not better then. They both had awful, neglectful childhoods. My dad was beaten at school because he was scruffy. Neither of them or any of their siblings learnt anything at school and they've all got alcohol and/or mental health problems 🤷‍♀️

I went to school in the 80s and 90s and there were disruptive kids then. Getting pissed and doing drugs in he park was the usual hobby for plenty of kids. Children had autism but were mostly just ignored. Bullying was absolutely rife as were massive fights between rival schools/gangs. Teenage pregnancy was rife. I can remember a parent threatening to break a teachers legs. I can remember a mother standing by watching while he kids battered another kid.

So please, come off it that things were better. Stop kidding yourselves.

Catspyjamas17 · 21/02/2023 10:20

Totally agree with this, including the comment about the increased blurring of what is a mental health issue and what just constitues life and common human emotions.

That is part of mental health though - life and common human emotions. Mentally unwell, actually not that many years ago to me meant mad, psycho, loopy etc. Yes, there is a difference between feeling sad one day and being depressed but it's all part of the same human experience.

Catspyjamas17 · 21/02/2023 10:16

Perhaps we are just lucky but among DDs' friends and the kids and teens we see out and about I mostly see a bunch of lovely children, in spite of everything. It's random older adults I have far more of an issue with at times.

Futurethoughts · 21/02/2023 10:14

I think if a lot of the teachers lamenting how awful it is nowadays on here had to actually go back and teach in the 80s/90s/2000s (depending on ages) they might find the land of milk and honey they seek doesn’t actually exist at all.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 21/02/2023 10:10

hamstersarse · 21/02/2023 07:46

I agree with the points already made and would add that people are having fewer children and that one child in particular, is now all these already entitled parents have to focus on.

all their eggs literally in one golden basket.

The obvious drift as to what constitutes a mental health problem and what is just normal life is also another layer of hell.

I find myself being ‘that old crone’ who pulls people up and makes comments about obvious spoilt and entitled behaviour.

Totally agree with this, including the comment about the increased blurring of what is a mental health issue and what just constitues life and common human emotions.

Gincan · 21/02/2023 10:07

I saw a really good tiktok the other day that reasoned kids today are brats because their millennial/ gen x parents never had their emotional needs met ever. We were left to deal with all our problems ourselves, our MH issues were never dealt with and we felt completely unsupported. As a result, our parenting styles have gone too far the other way and we are raising a generation of self absorbed snowflakes. I wish I could find it now but I didn't save it.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 21/02/2023 10:03

He has just as close a relationship with his father so I don’t think it’s that.

I get what you’re saying re doing this to the parent they’re closest to but she doesn’t want this!

KimberleyClark · 21/02/2023 10:03

Too many parents try to protect their children from disappointments or setbacks of any kind, and feel that those things must be made up for somehow. These things are valuable learning experiences. You only have to look at The Apprentice to see examples of young people who have never experienced constructive criticism and can’t take it. They have been brought up to believe they can have or be anything they want and that they are owed it.

EmmaEmerald · 21/02/2023 09:59

Ocsetldil · 20/02/2023 23:24

I complained about the behaviour, manners and appearance of some of the children acting like bully boys on the streets and the Head shook his head and muttered “What can you do? What can you do?” Well, grow a backbone, for a start and maybe ask the children to leave if they don’t abide by the school rules as this is an independent school and the Head has the authority to control who he has on site.

I admit I am guessing but do they have the authority they need?

one of our friends was a headteacher, she's 75 now. She retired early because she thought she was going to have a breakdown. This was maybe 15 years ago? I think the pressure on a Head not to expel a pupil, and the potential legal storm they unleash when they do, is a problem.

look at how people talk about Katherine Birbalsingh - as if she is a monster, when a lot of what she advocates is just..normal!

Alsonification · 21/02/2023 09:59

I'm a childminder over 22 years & in the last 7 or more years I've seen this too.
Parents I know are working all day & I can understand them not wanting to have a tantruming toddler to deal with, I really can, but what they end up doing is pandering to the children's every little thing so as to keep them happy. It's almost like they're afraid of them.
What they're actually doing is creating a rod for their own backs. It'll be way harder to reel it back when they're older & bigger.
Myself & other minder friends often talk about what the world will be like when these children are in charge. Confused