Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is going on?

167 replies

pleasemindyourmanners · 20/02/2023 23:10

I am a teacher and I am aware that this will no doubt lead to lots of teacher bashing as this appears to have become a national past time.
I just can't work out what is going on with children and parents and attitudes towards school.
Younger and younger children are coming through with less and less resilience. I realise that covid and lockdowns have played a part but this was happening before then too. It is just gradually getting worse.
So many parents also appear almost delusional about their children. That is increasing year on year too. They are not interested in any misdemeanours their child may have been part of. They only believe one version of events. And all want their child to be listened to and their version to be acted upon.
I was looking at my pension pot. I have about 25 years to reach the state pension. That is a terrifying prospect. If behaviour and attitudes towards teaching/schools carry on the same trajectory I dread to think what things will be like by that point.
I really wish I could put my finger on what the main problems are but the issues are so massive there are definitely no easy fixes. Lack of resources and specialist staff is one issue but i don't remember there being such a huge need as there is nowadays.
It is like we, teachers, are also becoming immune to being sworn at by parents and even primary aged kids.
It isn't just my school. Friends in other schools and teachers on teaching Facebook pages are all saying the same thing. I'd say this is one of the many reasons there is a teacher retention issue. It is draining.
I absolutely love the kids and what I do. However, I feel like I can't do my job properly a lot of the time as I've effectively become a bouncer or a referee.
Everything appears to be blamed on teachers. Even icy conditions round school was seen as our fault and we were thoughtless putting them out in the icy playground.
Kids who just get on with things, don't try to cause a drama, who are kind without having constant dramas are becoming more and more rare. This is no longer the expected behaviour and ore like a wishful dream. It is Monday night and I'm totally exhausted already.

OP posts:
ichundich · 21/02/2023 12:26

I completely disagree. I grew up in the 80ies and 90ies when neither parents nor teachers gave a shit about mental health, bullying, choosing a viable career, etc. What it meant or me was that I had to build the resilience and retrain later in life when I should have been "settled", focusing on other things. IME it's mainly schools that pander to kids nowadays - by letting them come in later if they have "issues", by renaming nativity to "seasonal performance" in fear if offending non-Christians, not allowing kids to play tag in the playground because someone might fall over, giving stars and rewards to everyone simply for participation even if they only made a half-arsed attempt.

hekissedmybottom · 21/02/2023 12:18

Is this new? I was brought up in a working class area and the school I went to was just how you describe. I remember a parent shouting at a teacher because teacher insisted child wear the uniform and she was effing and blinding. Mind you the estate wasn't much better, one mum watched as her son threatened to beat me up.

I went to a CoE primary first in Camberwell, South East London, and I distinctly remember blood on the walls and I was attacked by another child. I then went to a middle class school and things seemed better.

Similarly I went to a middle class inner city secondary then a really crap one in Peckham, and the first one our headteacher got beaten up and I got badly bullied.

Now I live in a working class area again and our little primary seems lovely but some of the kids are practically thrown through the gates by their parents and some of the children are aggressive and shout at teachers.

Is it a class thing? Or is it maybe there's still too many children in the class, 30 seems a lot to have a handle over. In the CofE school one teacher would scream at the class and hit a ruler so hard on the table it would break and fly off.

pleasemindyourmanners · 21/02/2023 12:15

Guis · 21/02/2023 11:08

Teachers in particular get a bad press because they are in a position of having a job but don't acknowledge the comparative incredibly generous time away from work. If teachers acknowledged they spend a lot of time away from the classroom people would be more inclined ,I suspect, to listen to other issues. When people usually have four to six weeks leave a year, to have people who have 13 and complaining, is a turn off. And hence disrespect comes in.

I also think as a profession they haven't kept standards high enough. I watched some of the 'teaching across Britain' and was dismayed by some of the teachers whose main priority seemed to be needing to be popular with the students far too much.

We are a very child orientated society. Children are revered and idolised. From TV shows, to social media, facilities provided and spend via local councils to 'attractions' who go out of their way to please and TV channels. Older people are not wanted. And children know it. So do parents. Everywhere should provide for their every need. No children's menu = outrage ! Except it shouldn't be so.
And if children are ever not number one priority it is confusing to them, so they kick off. As they expect to be.

And largely, the area you work in might make a difference. I know someone who grew up in a very tough area and fighting parents was going on decades ago. That is nothing new.

I think if teachers went on fewer jollies it might help their reputation. The number of times I have been out to somewhere in term time only to see a coach of children turn up, not the slightest bit interested in whatever it is they are visiting I cannot number. It really is just a day out for the teachers. Often just after they have returned from leave. Teachers are in the classroom for a maximum of 5 weeks stretch at any one time. Which is a bit shocking.

I think too the number of issues that happened around Covid disappointed people. A few schools took a proactive 'can do' approach rather than what seemed really a political stance and got children back in the classroom.

Your view of what is happening in schools is certainly not the same as mine. We tend to try and avoid too many trips because of the cost, the paperwork before you go, the risk assessments and trying to get helpers to accompany us.
We might not be in front of pupils as much as you would like but there is much more to our job. I'm lucky that I don't work on a Tuesday as I'm part time. However, whilst my child naps, I'm writing reports and I will be making resources this afternoon.

OP posts:
Ashorthistoryfan · 21/02/2023 12:11

BasicItch · 21/02/2023 11:16

We probably disagree but..

I feel parents and society are causing a lot of these so called MH problems
Anxious parents=anxious kids. It’s very self-indulgent.

BTW She didn’t have “school refusal”

She hadn’t even expressed an opinion about attending school and in the end acted completely normal.

The dilemma was created in the parent’s head that there might be a “problem” and that the parent felt anxious because this particular parent struggles to say no and in general projects a lot of her own anxieties onto the kid. I see this happening a great deal but if you point it out there is always denial because I think some people enjoy victimhood.

Sure, it wasn't an issue for your niece. I'm glad to hear that.
That doesn't mean it isn't a serious issue for other children and that self-indulgence often doesn't come into it.
And so the one-size-fits-all non-negotiable stategy you advocate upthread won't work for everyone.
That's all I'm sayìng.

I have children. One is neurotypical. Sometimes moans about going to school but is sent in. His brother has autism, clinical anxiety, ocd. Self-harms, sucide ideation aged 10...
School refusal for him is a very different issue than it is for his sibling.
To suggest children like him are being self-indulgent or that their parents are ... to suggest that 'non-negotiable ' is even an option for some of these cases...well, it means you don't have a clue what some people are going through, do you? Lucky you.

I also think OP has a point to make. I don't dismiss what she says. I simply disagree with those who think everything is caused by poor parenting and that all kids have the same reasons for behaving as they do.

mrsbn1988 · 21/02/2023 12:07

Too many people don't understand balance.

It's perfectly possible to raise your children to be respectful and considerate towards them, whilst maintaining discipline and clear boundaries. It doesn't have to be gentle parenting OR corporal punishment.

Far too many behaving in particular ways "because they can" and because they don't give a crap about the consequences. Far too many parents pandering to their kids because they are scared of them and don't want to emotionally damage them. Oh the irony. Every other person "has anxiety" these days. Except they don't "have anxiety," they just feel worried about normal everyday situations out of their comfort zones - a normal, standard, human emotion. The sense of entitlement in this country these days is astounding. It's all "me me me" and anyone who says otherwise is wrong.

oakleaffy · 21/02/2023 12:02

Sherrystrull · 21/02/2023 11:54

The reason I booked trips to the theatre, to the library, to the park, to a residential is because I believe in giving all children as many opportunities as possible.

The risk assessment is just the start. Not to mention the stress from responsibility. Despite the huge amount of work and stress I do it for the children.

To hear you say that you think it's a jolly for me is insulting. Why would I spend 4 nights away from my own children, not having any sleep and looking after 60 children for my own sake?

School trips out are certainly not “Jollies!”
Whoever said that has never been involved in one-
I volunteered, and it is a responsibility “Shepherding” one’s group, making sure they can do the work, and are safe.
There was one parent who volunteered who thought it WAS a “Jolly”, and abandoned her group to go and sit in a dockside café!

I only knew as her group came up and said they’d lost Mrs H!

oakleaffy · 21/02/2023 11:55

LakeTiticaca · 21/02/2023 09:31

Born early sixties. Attended school with large classes of 40+ pupils. Back in the days when classes were streamed so the less able kids could work at their own pace in their own classes.
If you got into trouble at school (which was very rare as the teachers brooked no nonsense from anyone) you would be terrified of your parents finding out, the resulting punishment would be a thick ear.
Nowadays little Billy goes home and informs parents that teacher told him off.
Next day parents burst into school and threatening the teacher.
Where did it all go wrong?

This with bells on.
Mum taught at a school in Poplar , London (Working class tough area back then) and said the kids were well behaved.
Streaming worked very well- How can one teacher manage mixed abilities easily , especially if there is disruptive behaviour involved

Sherrystrull · 21/02/2023 11:54

The reason I booked trips to the theatre, to the library, to the park, to a residential is because I believe in giving all children as many opportunities as possible.

The risk assessment is just the start. Not to mention the stress from responsibility. Despite the huge amount of work and stress I do it for the children.

To hear you say that you think it's a jolly for me is insulting. Why would I spend 4 nights away from my own children, not having any sleep and looking after 60 children for my own sake?

TheShellBeach · 21/02/2023 11:54

RealBecca · 21/02/2023 11:42

As one of those mums that couldn't put my baby down at night, you have no idea what it's like unless you have lived it.

After consecutive hours of cry it out, where does softness finish and abuse begin?

Would I have been a better mum to risk her life by keeping falling asleep with her in my arms or hallucinating through exhaustion? Or letting her choke on her sick from screaming in her cot?

Unless you've lived that it's easy to say there is a solution. It doesnt mean I'm a soft parent and it's not a predictor for entitled children.

I have lived it.
I eventually had to do sleep training with my first baby.
It took two nights, then she slept through.
There was no way I was going to spend every evening waiting for a baby to fall asleep, wasting my evenings.
I followed the book's advice for my next three children, so I never had to sleep train them.

Sherrystrull · 21/02/2023 11:51

DarkShade · 21/02/2023 11:43

I hope that I'm not one of the parents with a bad attitude, I respect teachers and think they are overworked. But I think the school system is utter shit. It is designed to stifle creativity and force all children into one specific type of person. They learn very little of value, the social scene is often poor, and they are forced to spend most of their awake time doing something they don't like, and which carries little value. Many parents see this, and are not willing to go along with trampling on their own children until they conform to the system.

The government has so much to answer for. Teachers spend so long trying to make interesting and engaging lessons but are forced to teach so many things that they don't feel the children are ready for or see no value in as the curriculum is so full and uninspiring in many places.

Don't get me started on the shit show that is Year 2 and Year 6.

Guis · 21/02/2023 11:51

JanusTheFirst · 21/02/2023 11:25

@Guis

So little understanding or comprehension in your post that it's difficult to know where to start.

School trips are a day out for teachers? You have no clue what it involves. Much easier to stay in school.

Most teachers hate days out because of the responsibility, the need to ensure safeguarding, pre-visits to see what the place is like (in their own time). And, of course, a health and safety assessment to be submitted before permission is granted.

You got this so wrong, is it surprising the rest of your post also makes little sense?

If teachers dread the days out then perhaps why do them so much !
I don't mean not have any, but do fewer of them. How do they evaluate the benefits of doing them. What evidence based assessment could teachers provide to parents to show their value ?

I do realise a risk assessment would be needed etc and undertaken etc.

The OP asked for opinions as to why teachers might not be so respected these days.

I have offered mine.

Offer the OP your views to her question ? What would you say.

Eyeslikethesea · 21/02/2023 11:46

I’m 46, my childhood was awful. Narcissistic mother and enabler(but wonderful) father. We got told what to do, when to do it, and if we dared not to, we got thrashed. With my kids I’m the opposite.
And whilst my kids are well behaved (school parents evenings are an actual delight), they absolutely ARE entitled. Something I didn’t foresee when I sat next to my daughter holding her hand till she fell asleep every night (I KNOW, I KNOW!) amongst a lot of other things.
The thing is, my parenting style is one big trauma response. I couldn’t bear the thought of them thinking they weren’t safe. They know that I don’t say no, I ask them what they think I should say etc, and I’ve probably set them up with a false sense of how the world works.
I would tell all parents to be, to get counseling, To help them be better, with each generation.
I know that not everyone is going to have the same experience, but I thought I’d add this as mine.

DarkShade · 21/02/2023 11:43

I hope that I'm not one of the parents with a bad attitude, I respect teachers and think they are overworked. But I think the school system is utter shit. It is designed to stifle creativity and force all children into one specific type of person. They learn very little of value, the social scene is often poor, and they are forced to spend most of their awake time doing something they don't like, and which carries little value. Many parents see this, and are not willing to go along with trampling on their own children until they conform to the system.

pleasemindyourmanners · 21/02/2023 11:43

Catspyjamas17 · 21/02/2023 09:19

Kids who just get on with things, don't try to cause a drama, who are kind without having constant dramas are becoming more and more rare. This is no longer the expected behaviour and ore like a wishful dream. It is Monday night and I'm totally exhausted already

Look at what has happened to society in the last few years, will you?

Lots of adults feel like this all the time. For more than two years we were kept in state of perpetual anxiety, stress and fear due to Covid. Loads of people don't even leave the house any more. People are shit scared about not being able to afford stuff and their children's future. We've got a government of utter incompetents lurching from one bad policy to another who don't give a fuck. The economy is fucked, we can't even buy a tomato in the shop due to Brexit, there's potentially WW3 in Europe, for Christ's sake don't get ill, schools are underfunded, overcrowded, overstretched and generally rubbish. And kids might be behaving badly at school? I wonder why. It would be a miracle really if they could just get on with it.

I did also say that it started before the pandemic. Yes, it has got worse and Covid will have had a huge impact. However, it isn't all to do with pandemic. It had started before that just the rate of change has sped up.

OP posts:
RealBecca · 21/02/2023 11:42

TheShellBeach · 20/02/2023 23:33

I'm going to get flamed for this, but it starts long before children get to school, when they're babies, and their parents do not seem to be able to put them down in their cots for a night's sleep.
I see threads on here every day from women, wringing their hands because their babies wake up ten times a night. God forbid the baby gets left to fall asleep by itself - mum has to stay for hours, waiting for it to drop off.
No resilience, as you say, OP.

As one of those mums that couldn't put my baby down at night, you have no idea what it's like unless you have lived it.

After consecutive hours of cry it out, where does softness finish and abuse begin?

Would I have been a better mum to risk her life by keeping falling asleep with her in my arms or hallucinating through exhaustion? Or letting her choke on her sick from screaming in her cot?

Unless you've lived that it's easy to say there is a solution. It doesnt mean I'm a soft parent and it's not a predictor for entitled children.

CallMeDaddy58 · 21/02/2023 11:34

No, it isn’t a sweeping nonsense statement when the people I’m referring to have mention that they were born in the 60s 🙄 So my Mum’s generation.

Of course social media isn’t oxygen but you are being utterly wilfully obtuse if you don’t think older kids and teens NOT accessing social media at all doesn’t also have detrimental affects to them. Like it or not, social media is a thing. It’s so very easy to say “just don’t let them on it” but another thing in reality when all their friends use it to communicate constantly and your child is out the loop.

This conversation has been happening for generations. It was TV before the internet. Believe it or not it was books at one point too. Yawn. It’s getting boring.

Sherrystrull · 21/02/2023 11:27

Every job has perks. Teaching has long mostly unpaid holidays.

I don't hate my friend who stumbles to her home office at 9 every day while I run out the door at 7.

I don't hate my friend who has a leisurely run during her lunch break while I barely have time for a wee.

I don't hate my friend who gets paid overtime.

I don't hate my friend who gets paid three times what I get paid.

I find it strange that people hate teachers and disrespect them because of their holidays.

JanusTheFirst · 21/02/2023 11:25

@Guis

So little understanding or comprehension in your post that it's difficult to know where to start.

School trips are a day out for teachers? You have no clue what it involves. Much easier to stay in school.

Most teachers hate days out because of the responsibility, the need to ensure safeguarding, pre-visits to see what the place is like (in their own time). And, of course, a health and safety assessment to be submitted before permission is granted.

You got this so wrong, is it surprising the rest of your post also makes little sense?

lifeturnsonadime · 21/02/2023 11:24

I feel parents and society are causing a lot of these so called MH problems
Anxious parents=anxious kids. It’s very self-indulgent.

Top marks for your ableism and parent blaming.

School refusal mostly happens because the child has unmet needs. The closure of special schools and cuts in funding/ TAs. SATs and failure to make adjustments for children with dyslexia or neurodiversity and failure to diagnose or even recognise these conditions in some areas lead to children being so anxious and traumatised by being forced into unsuitable environment is what mostly leads to refusal.

For a parent who has to do nothing more than feed, clothe, ensure your child is transported and support with home work to get their child educated it is very easy to judge other parents who aren't so fortunate.

It has nothing to do with the child not being taught resilience or over anxious parenting or enjoying victimhood FFS.

Guis · 21/02/2023 11:23

HowcanIgetoutofthisalive · 21/02/2023 11:21

can't quite believe I just read that?!!?

Well, you did.

Let the OP know what you think the reasons might be to her questions.

HowcanIgetoutofthisalive · 21/02/2023 11:21

Guis · 21/02/2023 11:08

Teachers in particular get a bad press because they are in a position of having a job but don't acknowledge the comparative incredibly generous time away from work. If teachers acknowledged they spend a lot of time away from the classroom people would be more inclined ,I suspect, to listen to other issues. When people usually have four to six weeks leave a year, to have people who have 13 and complaining, is a turn off. And hence disrespect comes in.

I also think as a profession they haven't kept standards high enough. I watched some of the 'teaching across Britain' and was dismayed by some of the teachers whose main priority seemed to be needing to be popular with the students far too much.

We are a very child orientated society. Children are revered and idolised. From TV shows, to social media, facilities provided and spend via local councils to 'attractions' who go out of their way to please and TV channels. Older people are not wanted. And children know it. So do parents. Everywhere should provide for their every need. No children's menu = outrage ! Except it shouldn't be so.
And if children are ever not number one priority it is confusing to them, so they kick off. As they expect to be.

And largely, the area you work in might make a difference. I know someone who grew up in a very tough area and fighting parents was going on decades ago. That is nothing new.

I think if teachers went on fewer jollies it might help their reputation. The number of times I have been out to somewhere in term time only to see a coach of children turn up, not the slightest bit interested in whatever it is they are visiting I cannot number. It really is just a day out for the teachers. Often just after they have returned from leave. Teachers are in the classroom for a maximum of 5 weeks stretch at any one time. Which is a bit shocking.

I think too the number of issues that happened around Covid disappointed people. A few schools took a proactive 'can do' approach rather than what seemed really a political stance and got children back in the classroom.

can't quite believe I just read that?!!?

Guis · 21/02/2023 11:19

Sherrystrull · 21/02/2023 11:12

So much absolute rubbish in this post.

Why don't you become a teacher if it's so easy?

I didn't say teaching was easy anywhere. In some places it will not be easy at all.

The OP asked why teachers seem to have disrespect. And I have given my views as to why that might be.

What would your answer to the OP be ?

VeronicaFranklin · 21/02/2023 11:18

You have my complete sympathies OP.
One of my best friends is a primary teacher and she is at breaking point.

Kids are starting school having never been taught simple basic life skills, she regularly encounters biting, hitting, kicking, children swearing at her, subjecting her to racial abuse, they have been exposed to things primary school age children shouldn't be exposed to as no censorship at home especially when they have free rein of iPads and internet access.

When the parents get called in to discuss their child's behaviour they kick off or couldn't care less.

The UK is in a real mess, educational system is failing everyone, the teachers and the children.

But I also think in general people have no standards anymore.

BasicItch · 21/02/2023 11:16

Ashorthistoryfan · 21/02/2023 01:16

It's very clear that you have no experience of school-refusal and the mh problems some kids have. A lot of that is just down to luck so don't flatter yourself too much.
Some kids do have real issues that need to be dealt with. In the past many of these children were simply bullied and/or ignored instead, by teachers and sometimes parents.

Simply saying it's not-negotiable does not work for all children, believe me. It's really not one size fits all.

Now, to be clear, I'm not disagreeing with the OP. There is more of a sense of entitlement these days, I think. And parents are inclined to listen to their children more and are less inclined to defer to teachers - all of which is good in a way, but not if the balance is tipped too far.
However, some kids do have real problems that simply weren't acknowledged in the past, and now they are, to some extent at least.

I was born in the 60s by the way.

We probably disagree but..

I feel parents and society are causing a lot of these so called MH problems
Anxious parents=anxious kids. It’s very self-indulgent.

BTW She didn’t have “school refusal”

She hadn’t even expressed an opinion about attending school and in the end acted completely normal.

The dilemma was created in the parent’s head that there might be a “problem” and that the parent felt anxious because this particular parent struggles to say no and in general projects a lot of her own anxieties onto the kid. I see this happening a great deal but if you point it out there is always denial because I think some people enjoy victimhood.

Sherrystrull · 21/02/2023 11:12

Guis · 21/02/2023 11:08

Teachers in particular get a bad press because they are in a position of having a job but don't acknowledge the comparative incredibly generous time away from work. If teachers acknowledged they spend a lot of time away from the classroom people would be more inclined ,I suspect, to listen to other issues. When people usually have four to six weeks leave a year, to have people who have 13 and complaining, is a turn off. And hence disrespect comes in.

I also think as a profession they haven't kept standards high enough. I watched some of the 'teaching across Britain' and was dismayed by some of the teachers whose main priority seemed to be needing to be popular with the students far too much.

We are a very child orientated society. Children are revered and idolised. From TV shows, to social media, facilities provided and spend via local councils to 'attractions' who go out of their way to please and TV channels. Older people are not wanted. And children know it. So do parents. Everywhere should provide for their every need. No children's menu = outrage ! Except it shouldn't be so.
And if children are ever not number one priority it is confusing to them, so they kick off. As they expect to be.

And largely, the area you work in might make a difference. I know someone who grew up in a very tough area and fighting parents was going on decades ago. That is nothing new.

I think if teachers went on fewer jollies it might help their reputation. The number of times I have been out to somewhere in term time only to see a coach of children turn up, not the slightest bit interested in whatever it is they are visiting I cannot number. It really is just a day out for the teachers. Often just after they have returned from leave. Teachers are in the classroom for a maximum of 5 weeks stretch at any one time. Which is a bit shocking.

I think too the number of issues that happened around Covid disappointed people. A few schools took a proactive 'can do' approach rather than what seemed really a political stance and got children back in the classroom.

So much absolute rubbish in this post.

Why don't you become a teacher if it's so easy?