Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is going on?

167 replies

pleasemindyourmanners · 20/02/2023 23:10

I am a teacher and I am aware that this will no doubt lead to lots of teacher bashing as this appears to have become a national past time.
I just can't work out what is going on with children and parents and attitudes towards school.
Younger and younger children are coming through with less and less resilience. I realise that covid and lockdowns have played a part but this was happening before then too. It is just gradually getting worse.
So many parents also appear almost delusional about their children. That is increasing year on year too. They are not interested in any misdemeanours their child may have been part of. They only believe one version of events. And all want their child to be listened to and their version to be acted upon.
I was looking at my pension pot. I have about 25 years to reach the state pension. That is a terrifying prospect. If behaviour and attitudes towards teaching/schools carry on the same trajectory I dread to think what things will be like by that point.
I really wish I could put my finger on what the main problems are but the issues are so massive there are definitely no easy fixes. Lack of resources and specialist staff is one issue but i don't remember there being such a huge need as there is nowadays.
It is like we, teachers, are also becoming immune to being sworn at by parents and even primary aged kids.
It isn't just my school. Friends in other schools and teachers on teaching Facebook pages are all saying the same thing. I'd say this is one of the many reasons there is a teacher retention issue. It is draining.
I absolutely love the kids and what I do. However, I feel like I can't do my job properly a lot of the time as I've effectively become a bouncer or a referee.
Everything appears to be blamed on teachers. Even icy conditions round school was seen as our fault and we were thoughtless putting them out in the icy playground.
Kids who just get on with things, don't try to cause a drama, who are kind without having constant dramas are becoming more and more rare. This is no longer the expected behaviour and ore like a wishful dream. It is Monday night and I'm totally exhausted already.

OP posts:
TempsPerdu · 21/02/2023 23:26

I‘m a former primary teacher, current school governor and have a 5-year-old DD in Reception. I agree with many of the reasons cited by PPs above - things like excessive screen time/social media, lack of firm boundaries and Covid all play into the narrative of increasingly poor behaviour. But I think the full picture is extremely nuanced and much more complicated than straightforward ‘poor parenting’.

When I was teaching a few years ago there was always a sizeable group of challenging children who needed additional support with behaviour, communication etc. This group was largely made up of those who were socially or economically vulnerable, and whose parents themselves lacked the education or resources to parent effectively - your classic ‘deprived kids’.

What I see around me now, though, - in the school at which I’m a governor, my own child’s school year and my peer/friendship group of mums - is that this group has been joined by another group of challenging children, who are materially much better off and more ‘middle class’, but whose issues with behaviour etc seem to stem from lack of parental time/input. They often have two full-time working parents who are run ragged trying to juggle everything, have been in full-time nursery from a very young age, spend much of their time outside actual school hours in a ever-changing mish-mash of breakfast clubs, after school clubs and holiday clubs, and are given no boundaries in the time they do spend with their parents, because said parents are exhausted, suffering from parental guilt and are desperate to spend ‘quality time’ with them. It’s really noticeable that all of the most challenging children in DD’s school fall into one of these two categories.

This is by no means a criticism of working mothers/parents; most of my own friends have no choice but to work full-time, and I’m aware that many people manage to parent perfectly well while also holding down a demanding job. But something seems to be going on whereby a growing tranche of middle-class society is now so chronically stressed, exhausted and time poor that they are unable to parent effectively, and prepare their children for school and to participate in wider society.

KissMeUnderTheMistleThrush · 21/02/2023 23:07

Parents treat their kids as friends, they are scared to say no.

I know of someone who has 2 children,one aged 15, one aged 9. They have NEVER done a full week at school.

Mother says she can't get them out of bed, or they're ill, or they're too tired (from gaming all night) They are currently being seen by welfare officers, but it's too little too late. The eldest leaves this year!

Mother isn't worried atall . It means she gets a lay in if they don't want to go to school. I despair!
And I couldn't do your job for all the tea in China! And I'm a nurse which seems easy compared to teaching !

Mummyto3ginismyfriend · 21/02/2023 22:53

I've found some of the teachers are just as bad. My youngest is Autistic and struggles academically, but you wouldn't think it at parents evening. They focus on how well she is doing and what great progress she is making. They seem shocked when I ask about how far she is behind and what more we can do to support with functional skills. If I wasn't a realistic parent the only indication that DD was so far behind would be the end of year reports when she's marked as no where near meeting expectations.

Are the teachers scared of telling the truth in parents evenings. I don't want a sanitised version of how my children are doing I want the truth. I also want to know about any bad behaviour so I can also ensure that lessons are learned and appropriate apologies to anyone effected are made.

Frustrated96 · 21/02/2023 22:10

With 3 kids of different ages and school years they have all been impacted by the past few years. My 6 year old has needed speech therapy, which we're lucky to have been able to afford to pay privately, as NHS waiting lists are so long. My 11 year old has some anxiety and trouble sleeping and my 13 year old went through lockdown year 6 & 7, which led to anxiety and some school refusal. I know so many kids with MH, anxiety, school refusal and other issues on top of parents who haven't had a break for years due to the lockdowns. On top of babies born who found socialising difficult and are behind and students leaving 1st year uni and they're not emotionally ready for it. I'm sorry for teachers having to cope with children with these issues as well but please don't blame exhausted parents who have barely survived the past few years home schooling, working and trying to keep normally in the most difficult of circumstances.

Theroofisonfiyah · 21/02/2023 21:58

Lack of accountability and a feeling of entitlement I think is a massive issue. And as a parent of good kids, with no behavioural issues and no learning issues, at school they are practically invisible, and they notice it. they recognise that their consistent effort isn't noticed.

pluggee · 21/02/2023 21:42

Snowflake parents.
Parents who spend too little time with their child or too much on organised activities so the children are never bored.
Parents who try to blame their child's bad behaviour on external factors. Eg - "Did you kick off because you couldn't do your maths?"

Who raised these parents though?

Allshallbewell2021 · 21/02/2023 21:13

I think good parenting is really incredibly hard. I think I'm a pretty poor parent. I wanted to be a great parent but was too lazy and chaotic to achieve it.
If I could do it again I think I would beca really fantastic parent.

LaDamaDeElche · 21/02/2023 21:02

Also, too much screen use definitely has an effect on behaviour.

LaDamaDeElche · 21/02/2023 21:01

For normal run of the mill bad behaviour, a lot of it comes down to kids not being hit anymore. I’m not advocating hitting children at all btw, but back in the day you didn’t really have to apply any kind of parenting strategies as kids were ruled by the fear of getting hit. In some cultures, this is still the norm and the kids in those cultures are generally much more respectful as they know the consequence of behaving badly at school and in the home. Of course, you can successfully parent a well-rounded child without hitting them, but it’s harder work and you have to follow through, be consistent with consequences etc, in a way you didn’t when fear was the motivator for behaving yourself.

Allshallbewell2021 · 21/02/2023 21:01

I think technology means neither kids nor their parents have the attention span needed for learning.
So the parents don't role model behaviours you need to succeed at school.
I see kids with iPads built into their pushchairs. How can that do anything but make kids unable to manage their own minds?
Also once children have phones - it's all over - they belong to apple/google/YouTube etc They're taken like in science fiction, I'm sort of kidding and not.

cherish123 · 21/02/2023 20:53

@Guis you have no idea what teachers actually do.
I have taught, worked in private and public sector professional roles. I can assure you that teaching is much more difficult.

Justforlaffs · 21/02/2023 20:50

It's the fallout from the Snowflake Generation having children.

Behold the Era of the Child!! (Never being at fault!)

cherish123 · 21/02/2023 20:48

Yip.
Snowflake parents.
Parents who spend too little time with their child or too much on organised activities so the children are never bored.
Parents who try to blame their child's bad behaviour on external factors. Eg - "Did you kick off because you couldn't do your maths?" 🙄

Suzi888 · 21/02/2023 15:06

purpleboy · 20/02/2023 23:18

Entitlement sums it up for me.

Yes.

I like to think of myself as someone who has respect for teachers. I do see parents getting a bit of an attitude around teaching staff and think, thank god I don’t teach….. I couldn’t put up with that sense of entitlement.

Social media usage should be banned in under 16’s. Has no place in schools, mobiles should be banned and confiscated if they are used in classrooms.

calmandcaffeinated · 21/02/2023 14:10

OP, I generally agree with your sentiments as someone who’s worked in secondary education for a number of years (and now initial teacher education). It seems issues are getting worse and more extreme.

I think a lot of the issues have stemmed from people only believing what they want and not being willing to listen or change their minds when presented with new information. Anything that contrasts their belief system or way of thinking is ignored. There’s also more extremist views at the moment which I think causes division and makes people not want to listen or change their mind.

An example I’ve seen in this thread is the discussion of gentle parenting. As a mother of a toddler I only recently came across this and despite what I would call my more ‘no nonsense approach’ I found a lot of the tenants of gentle parenting to be sound and based on scientific evidence (particularly stuff around intrinsic and extrinsic motivation) and it has impacted how I parent for the better. Tbh, I would never have consider this if I wasn’t potty training and looking for a book to guide the process. I’m glad I took the time to look at a different approach and learn something.

My point is, society as a whole could learn to try to listen to one another more and to understand better rather than constantly bashing and blaming. Also, may not thinking our way is the only way or the right way.

ChangesUsername · 21/02/2023 13:48

Parents need to let their children experience failure and disappointment and allow them to learn how to deal with it
It's not healthy to big children up constantly, encourage them, support them and protect them but with firm boundaries
When people tell me I'm lucky with my children I want to scream that it was bloody hard work
Oh and school trips are definitely not 'jollies' @Guis , you need to stop watching so much television if you are believing that

crossstitchingnana · 21/02/2023 13:44

TheShellBeach · 20/02/2023 23:33

I'm going to get flamed for this, but it starts long before children get to school, when they're babies, and their parents do not seem to be able to put them down in their cots for a night's sleep.
I see threads on here every day from women, wringing their hands because their babies wake up ten times a night. God forbid the baby gets left to fall asleep by itself - mum has to stay for hours, waiting for it to drop off.
No resilience, as you say, OP.

Info-slept and fed my babies to sleep. They are both very resilient.

Fundays12 · 21/02/2023 13:34

Sheer entitlement and laziness from what I can see in a lot of younger parents. I have noticed a huge shift in parenting strategies since my oldest started. He has a lovely year group. They are all starting secondary soon. They also overall have good parents who have rules and boundaries and overall the year group are brilliant.

DC2 year is pretty iffy. The behaviour of some of the kids in P2 and P3 is appalling and the blame culture from parents something else some of the examples I have heard include

"It's the teachers fault they are behind academically because they didn't get homework". The teachers did give homework for the last 2 years but the parents didn't bother to look at it.

The child is struggling in school so it's "school staffs fault" hhmm nothing to do with the fact a young child has never had a bed time routine so is constantly exhausted in school.

Some parents laughing at their young kids bad behaviour like swearing, shouting and hitting. They really don't realise a lot of parents will not allow their kids to play with a child that behaves like this (I am not talking about additional support needs). My oldest has diagnosed additional support needs but has been taught that behaviour is unacceptable. His school has a lot of additional needs children with diagnosed nuerological conditions but its a small percentage of nuerotypical children who are behaving far worse because their parents don't address the poor behaviour.

Parents allowing uncontrolled access to utube and video games that are not appropriate is a huge issue. Games have ages for a reason and that reason is they are not suitable for younger kids because they are either too violent or younger kids executive functioning and cognitive skill development is not at a level they can cope with these games.

Parents more interested in themselves than their child. Unfortunately this happy mum happy child plays into this. Yes a happy mum is a happy child generally but a child will never be a happy child if they are suffering because of their lifestyles choices such as spending loads of money on nights out and putting their child in old clothes.

Parents spending more time on there phones than with there child (I often have found parents who constantly boost on social media how wonderful parents they are bother with their kids the least).

Parents encouraging their kids and believing their child is a diva and encouraging this. A diva is not something to aspire to be as it's basically someone who is a spoilt and demanding brat.

I feel sorry for teachers as actually in general most kids are fabulous and a lot of parents are wonderful but their is definitely a shift in parenting in the last few years.

Drivingmisspotty · 21/02/2023 13:22

Maybe I am living a massively sheltered life as a parent, not a teacher, but I just don’t see the behaviour you’re talking about in my DC’s primary or among their friends/classmates who visit us and do activities with them.

It’s just an ordinary primary (or maybe not!) in a city with a mixture of backgrounds/income among the families. From what I have seen the teachers are really fair but firm. There is not a lot of shouting but teachers talk to kids with respect and have clear boundaries. There is a mindfulness club set up by one of the TAs because her daughter had bad anxiety as a teen and she wishes she had had the tools to cope earlier.

To be honest, the massive differences I see from when I was at school are that the kids are much more likely to articulate their feelings (not just my kids, but their friends too), they are much more knowledgeable about and sympathetic to kids who have additional needs, and they are fiercely anti-racist. I’m actually really excited and positive about the adults they will become.

hekissedmybottom · 21/02/2023 13:07

@TheShellBeach I would say similar to you but the opposite. Secure attachments are best gained by nurturing and showing baby they are completely secure, and I think we have opposite views on that.

I think ultimately it's many factors but given there are more and more people year on year this problem won't go away but only get worse.

Sherrystrull · 21/02/2023 13:05

I don't understand why teachers should show show appreciation for the working conditions of others.

Are GPs showing appreciation of other working conditions?

How about the police?

It's the assumption that teachers somehow have no understanding of other jobs. This is often spouted by people who have no understanding of teaching jobs.

Oh the irony.

FuckNuggets · 21/02/2023 13:00

TheShellBeach · 20/02/2023 23:33

I'm going to get flamed for this, but it starts long before children get to school, when they're babies, and their parents do not seem to be able to put them down in their cots for a night's sleep.
I see threads on here every day from women, wringing their hands because their babies wake up ten times a night. God forbid the baby gets left to fall asleep by itself - mum has to stay for hours, waiting for it to drop off.
No resilience, as you say, OP.

Nah. I co-slept with my kids til my eldest was 5, (although TBF she's autistic). They're 20 and 16 now, and have always been polite and well behaved. No teenage dramas or any of the crap I used to give my parents.

Wellthatwasweird · 21/02/2023 12:50

I have many examples, but most of my experiences happened when I was teaching abroad years ago. Once, mybY2 class were doing a reading comprehension test. One child kept trying to speak to another and I told her quite firmly to stop. I was doing some work on the computer at the time and quickly typed something while the kids completed the test.

The next day, the child's mum had a go at me for telling her daughter off and then proceeding to 'type angrily' afterwards. This mum was constantly complaining about my 'aggressive attitude', and while I am firm, I am a very gently mannered teacher. I went straight to SMT to tell them about the accusations. They were shocked that I was being labelled in such a manner as it was just so blatantly untrue! My nickname was Miss Honey because I have a very calm tone and am also very motherly. Having boundaries with the children was seen as an act of aggression.

I also had some concerns about some aspects of another child's development and raised it with a mum who completely lost it, asking was I calling her kid disabled and that nobody else thought there was a problem and just what exactly was I trying to say. She got so mad that I eventually dropped the issue because there was no point.

Another parent had insisted that her child skip Reception because she thought he was too clever to be messing around playing (this was not in the UK, remember!). By the time he got to me in Year 2 he was struggling massively. She blamed me completely, even though he was a year too young and had missed out all of Reception. I kept trying to differentiate the work to his ability level and the mum kept coming at me telling me it was too easy and how would he ever learn if I didn't challenge him. I felt that she was projecting a huge amount of her own guilt onto me.

Another kid spat on the floor, and when I told the mum, she told me that maybe if I loved her son more, he would listen to me. OK!

The constant, furious complaints about unlabelled uniform going missing! Parents absolutely raging when their child who couldn't speak English wasn't top of the class. Parents just going nuts with me about everything basically. In this case, the aprenst thought that if they paid for their child's education, there better be miracles.

JanusTheFirst · 21/02/2023 12:47

@Guis

The OP asked for opinions as to why teachers might not be so respected these days.

I have offered mine.

Offer the OP your views to her question ? What would you say.

It's down to the ill informed ignorance of some people.

Guis · 21/02/2023 12:45

pleasemindyourmanners · 21/02/2023 12:15

Your view of what is happening in schools is certainly not the same as mine. We tend to try and avoid too many trips because of the cost, the paperwork before you go, the risk assessments and trying to get helpers to accompany us.
We might not be in front of pupils as much as you would like but there is much more to our job. I'm lucky that I don't work on a Tuesday as I'm part time. However, whilst my child naps, I'm writing reports and I will be making resources this afternoon.

The post was not designed to 'have a go' as some have incorrectly interpreted.
You asked for opinions as to why many others have a poor view of teaching at the mo.
Nobody can speak for everyone and so it is a general view gleaned from many sources.

I do think it is important to show you do relate to other employment when casting the light on teaching and issues faced.

I once watched a programme where teachers said they sometimes didn't get home till 6pm by way of explaining how very hard they worked.
Without registering that for many people they might be catching a train or bus to get home at that time. Normally.

I am not endorsing an over hours working ethics. But it showed a lack of being able to relate to other peoples world of work.
I have had friends who are teachers so do not hate people because they are !

Every job has difficulties. I think if teachers could show they can relate more and are sensitive to the demands of the world of work elsewhere it would help.

As you pointed out there is a slip in respect. Some is behaviour in society generally. Social media has been introduced and nobody quite knows how to manage it. We don't communicate with each other in the same way anymore. People are harsher, more verbally aggressive online. Children say what they like.

Many schools are excellent and academically do very well. Not all students of course are academically minded. Many parents try to move away ( literally) from schools they worry about to get their children into a good school. Some schools and children I think get left behind.