Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking him to get rid of his dog after 7 years?

483 replies

Uktousa2022 · 20/02/2023 16:00

I am moving to the USA to be with my fiance. He has a pitbull/lab who has previously bit a little yorkie, the yorkie did start the fight, however unfortunately the yorkie died because the pitbull punctured a lung after 1 bite.

I have 2 cavalier dogs. I have extreme anxiety about taking my 2 dogs over there to live with this dog that has previously bit before. My fiancé says it was a total one off, he has since been neutered and is older now, and it was the other dogs fault. I have met the dog and it does pretty much sleep all day.

I just don't know if I can live my life anxious always watching my dogs around this dog - It is a small house - I really don't know how to get over this as we are both refusing to rehome our dogs. He does have family nearby that he could probably give him too, I would be going out to the US with just my dogs.

OP posts:
niugboo · 21/02/2023 12:21

All this it’s the owner nonsense.

A dog with the potential to kill has no place as a pet. A dog who has killed. Nah. There are hundreds of breeds where there is no potential to kill. Get one of those.

NameChangePoP · 21/02/2023 12:03

I doubt the OP is going to come back now.

OP, I mean this kindly - but what on earth are you doing?? You must either be very very young or have self esteem issues. No one in their right mind would move their entire life to another country for a guy they met 6 months ago.
You might think you know him, but I promise you you don't. You don't know how he will handle an argument, how he will behave if you do something he doesn't like, how he treats his friends, how he treats strangers etc etc.

He's already made it quite clear that he's not willing to compromise or have adult discussions. Yet you're giving up your life in the UK to move to the unknown.

Nothing anyone says on here is going to make any difference, you've clearly made up your mind. But this will not end well. For anyone.

littlehayleyc · 21/02/2023 12:01

Sorry if others have suggested this, I don’t have time to read all replies. If you take your dogs then you will need to set up a ‘gated community’ in the house. Even if your partner’s dog had never bitten, you still would need to introduce them very gradually and keep them separate when they can’t be supervised.So if you want to give things a chance then start this way. If/when you do this, you will start to get a sense of how the 3 dogs interact and whether you can manage them. Get a behaviourist to help you. You will also get a clearer idea of which dog(s) may need to be rehomed if they are not coping.

WilsonMilson · 21/02/2023 11:31

SchoolTripDrama · 21/02/2023 10:27

Completely agree @WilsonMilson 100%!

OP says she didn't actually meet this guy online but regardless, yes I agree this is madness.

Re: online dating, I just meant in general. I personally wouldn't date someone in another country or even someone more than 50-75 miles away at most. Nobody should have to make a massive move for a relationship (military spouses the exception of course but they're already married).

Agree, I’m all for online dating, but not when the guy is thousands of miles away!

LaDamaDeElche · 21/02/2023 11:05

*we’d been living together

LaDamaDeElche · 21/02/2023 10:57

Fernand · 20/02/2023 17:51

So you’ve known him for 7 months and are giving up everything to move over with him and sort all these dog issues. And have a baby soon? Please just take a step back and think a bit more about all this.

This in spades!!! My DP is Spanish. I moved to Spain to be with him. Spain is much closer, so not such a massive upheaval. I had known him much longer than you have this man and we’d like bed together in the U.K. It was still a difficult transition. I’ve been here 5 years now, but I still miss the U.K. a bit and also have that niggling doubt that what would I do if we broke up, because although I’ve got friends and a job here, I have my lifelong friends in the U.K. and my family are there too. You are making a really big decision in a very short space of time. Dogs aside, this is so fast. You don’t really know him.

CaptainMyCaptain · 21/02/2023 10:56

EmilyGilmoresSass · 21/02/2023 09:12

Strangely enough my family have owned many Staffies. All of whom were gentle and all of whom were great with the grandkids in the family from the day they were born.

Same here. I have never known an aggressive staffie. Those we have had in the family gave been quite docile and I'm always meeting lovely Staffs on walk with my JRT. I don't know any pit bulls.

Sennelier1 · 21/02/2023 10:43

With your reasoning you can't walk your dogs, ever. Just because a stronger dog might bite them in the park or on the street. What you are asking of your fiance is cruel.

Arthurflecksfacepaint · 21/02/2023 10:34

The dog situation is the least of your worries.

You’ve spent 6 weeks with this man face to face?

I think you are being very naive here.

SchoolTripDrama · 21/02/2023 10:27

Completely agree @WilsonMilson 100%!

OP says she didn't actually meet this guy online but regardless, yes I agree this is madness.

Re: online dating, I just meant in general. I personally wouldn't date someone in another country or even someone more than 50-75 miles away at most. Nobody should have to make a massive move for a relationship (military spouses the exception of course but they're already married).

SchoolTripDrama · 21/02/2023 10:18

@Uktousa2022 Op, let me tell you about my friend Carolyn.

She moved to the USA to marry her fiancé and start a family together. They'd been together here, for a long time whilst he was stationed here.
Everyone was over the moon for her and was confident she'd be very happy as she's been with him for 3+ years and they were still head over heels for each other.Smile

Fast forward two years and she has a 6 month old baby in the USA with her new husband. Their marriage becomes a war zone and sadly comes to an end. Nothing she did - or him, they just weren't as compatible (after all the excitement of the move & the new baby) as they thought they were and began to get on each other's nerves, despite her also now having employment out there.
Subsequently, they had a fairly messy divorce but manage to be civil enough to co-parent. She has a green card by this point so she's legally entitled to stay in the USA....however....

Her now ex-husband is categorically refusing to allow her to leave the country with their child to do her usual visit to her family in the UK. In fact he won’t even allow her to travel out of their State to visit a friend for a weekend or to take her child on holiday to New York for Christmas!
Turns out this is perfectly acceptable and common in the US (or at least for the state they're in).

So now she's stuck. Quite literally trapped in the USA, unable to even visit the UK without having to leave her child behind, until they turn 21 (I think it's 21, it may be 18).

She's begged, pleaded, even tried coming to a legally binding agreement over it, to prove she'll bring the child back, as she just wants to visit her Mum & Dad as her Dad is very very poorly, but nope! He won’t allow it and if she ignores him and leaves anyway... Yeah, major, major shitstorm will ensue. Kidnapping charges which I believe could somehow be enforced by the US via UK police whilst she's actually in the UK and almost certainly would result in her losing her child altogether. Big trouble.

Carolyn is broken. She's not going to get chance to say goodbye to her Dad in person and her Mum is now too frail to travel long haul too, so she's highly unlikely to ever see her again either.
I'm actually really concerned about her and have been doing all the research I can to try find a way around this but there isn't one that I can tell.

Heed this warning. I realise your brother is out there and that's great but if you have any family here who you love & couldn't bear not to see again, then please realise that this could very well be you!
Even without the family aspect, if you have a child together & then unexpectedly split in the future, unless he signs away the rights to his child (that can be done in the USA, but not here), or he just doesn't care, then you're highly unlikely to be able to choose to come back to live here until your child/children are adult/s.

And please don't say "Oh he would never do that!" Or "He wouldn't ever stop me visiting my family!" as that would be naïve in the extreme! I mean, look at it from the partner's perspective, would you want to give permission to your British ex-spouse and parent of your child to travel over the ocean back to their home country for a 'visit' with your child, knowing that they could easily decide not to come back as you've given permission for them to go? I wouldn't. No matter how much I knew they missed their family! Also never, ever assume you wouldn't/couldn't split up! Even the most connected of couples can drift apart. Even marriages of 50+ years can end.
Speaking of, can you honestly see yourself with this man for the next 50/60 years? If (God forbid, of course) you became physically dependant, either temporarily or permanently, can you see him caring for you? Sponge bathing you, emptying your commode? Sitting by your bedside every chance he gets? The answer should be a resounding yes without hesitation. In sickness & in health, 'til death do us part.

I have vegetables in my freezer that have been there longer than you've known this man. Don't do it. Not yet 🙏 If he's the right man for you, he'll wait as long as it takes....

Laurentt86 · 21/02/2023 10:18

So you do all the necessary studying in introducing two new dogs to each other and you do it properly?! I don’t understand the problem other than educating yourselves, it could take months but if you do it properly there should be absolutely no issue and no need to ask anyone to give up their beloved pets. Keep them separated initially, use baby gates, crates, confine to different rooms whilst they get used to each others smells and noises, then after a week start in the same room aiming for no reaction from either set of dogs, neutral walks together etc, it will take time but it’s a massive change for them as well, they deserve the effort for what will hopefully be worth it with happy dogs all round.

Guis · 21/02/2023 10:11

HappinessDragon · 21/02/2023 10:09

YABU about the dog situation and you are potentially screwing up your partners life further by moving in with him if you consider yourself to be ‘giving up your life’.

The huge red flag you’re waving makes me wonder how many times you’ll throw the “given up my life for you” card at him every time you don’t get your own way.

In any ultimatum, the person who forces another’s hand will always lose eventually.

The dog discussion is a distraction.

She is unlikely to throw anything verbally in his face. She will be too submissive to do that from what we can see.

Guis · 21/02/2023 10:09

One last thing. From everything you have said, I suspect he will want to be 'the provider'. Any notion of you working will likely be a no.

HappinessDragon · 21/02/2023 10:09

Uktousa2022 · 20/02/2023 16:07

I already am giving up my entire life (Job, family, friends) I feel like giving up the only 2 things i have left (the dogs) would leave me depressed, for people asking me to give up mine. I totally get why he doesn't want to give up his too.

YABU about the dog situation and you are potentially screwing up your partners life further by moving in with him if you consider yourself to be ‘giving up your life’.

The huge red flag you’re waving makes me wonder how many times you’ll throw the “given up my life for you” card at him every time you don’t get your own way.

In any ultimatum, the person who forces another’s hand will always lose eventually.

Guis · 21/02/2023 10:07

The dogs OP are the least of your priorities at the moment. Talking about them is a distraction for you.

The main priority for you as I see it is whether to decide if you should move ,to a country you do not know, leave your job, to live with a man you do not know. A man who from what it sounds will expect you to conform to his ideas about how life should be lived. Not, how you think life should be lived.

Your brother lives in the USA but you aren't going to go and live with your brother. Do not rely on him to be able to support you if things went wrong. It might be news to him if that is in your mind.

Be careful not to have built up a fantasy about what life will be like. He constantly reassures you. But your thread is littered with words and descriptions which are concerning. How emotionally compatible are you ? You will not be emotionally mature as a couple. You haven't actually been a couple in 'real life'. And I am sorry to say FaceTime and so on is not real life. It is a small fraction of time. Not seeing someone in the round over a period of time. You both don't know each other.

What are your plans together ? Apart from having a baby.

And , as someone who has moved around even in this country be prepared for how isolating it can be. People will have conversations about places you have no connection with. They will have spent their childhoods there. Everything from the climate, the language, the names of places, the lack of connection to anywhere will have an impact on you. How people are. Some places are very friendly, some places aren't. Some rain a lot, some don't. In the USA some have very scary weather.

And money is something you must consider. He doesn't sound very well off. Nothing wrong with that. But a business running since August is not an established business. Not even one year in the running. Assume you will have no money.

People have posted OP. It is your choice. People cannot decide for you.

hot2trotter · 21/02/2023 09:58

Oh lord. I've read all of the updates. So you've only been with him (in person) for 2 weeks at a time, and that's only happened 4 times in total. So you've been in his company, for 8 weeks altogether, and now are upping sticks, leaving everything behind, moving to the other side of the world and wanting him to give up his dog for you because you are apparently giving up everything else for him.

I can't decide of you're deluded, naive, or just plain stupid.

Toddlerteaplease · 21/02/2023 09:58

He also as thick S mince if he thinks his dog wouldn't attack his own child. It might. He sounds terrible.

Toddlerteaplease · 21/02/2023 09:56

This relationship has disaster all over it. If he was In the UK, I bet you wouldn't be moving in so quickly.

WilsonMilson · 21/02/2023 09:53

SchoolTripDrama · 21/02/2023 09:16

What's wrong with online dating? For some of us who can’t socialise much, it's the only way Hmm I met my wonderful late husband online Biscuit

Absolutely nothing, but when you meet someone from a different CONTINENT and have known him a mere 5 months and then decide to leave your entire life to be with him and immediately want babies…..therein lies a bloody massive problem!

mezlou84 · 21/02/2023 09:51

If anyone rehomes their dog/dogs it should be you. You admit your dog can snap which is why you're so worried. His dog is an older dog and depending on breed of pitbull could only have a year or 2 left living 8-15yrs on average depending on type. Your dogs sound incompatible. His dog can kill in a fight (yours could too tbh just not as likely) and your dog is likely to start a fight if he gets in your dogs space. If he was coming to you I would say he should rehome his dog as they aren't compatible but he isn't you're going there so you should rehome yours or not go at all.

SchoolTripDrama · 21/02/2023 09:32

@EmilyGilmoresSass I'm sure they were - many are. I'm sure many Pitbulls are! I'm talking about when provoked (inadvertently or intentionally) that's the MASSIVE difference. Even my mums adorable miniature schnauzer can snap if you try take his toy or food! The gigantic difference being HOW they snap. A Pitbull, a Staffie, a Japanese Akita - it is literally written in their DNA to have a predisposition to attack when angered. This has been PROVEN. I say again PROVEN! Hence the DDA.

@AlwaysGinPlease I do NOT hate dogs! If I saw a Pitbull or a Staffie and spoke to the owner I'd ask to stroke them all the same as I would a Schnauzer or a Cockapoo!

SchoolTripDrama · 21/02/2023 09:16

WilsonMilson · 20/02/2023 17:34

Well, sorry to be the rolling eyed voice of reason here, but this seems to be the least of your issues.

If this guy has had a dog for 7 years and lives in the US, and you have dogs and live in the UK, then how the hell did you meet (don’t tell me, let me guess…..online) and how much time have you actually spent together in real life?? Again….not much I would guess.

Yet, here you are, giving up your job, your family and potentially your dogs, for a man who you likely don’t really know and fucking off to the US, desperate to procreate.

Disaster waiting to happen. Honestly, wake up and and get a grip.

What's wrong with online dating? For some of us who can’t socialise much, it's the only way Hmm I met my wonderful late husband online Biscuit

EmilyGilmoresSass · 21/02/2023 09:12

SchoolTripDrama · 21/02/2023 09:09

10000000% this! I adore dogs but bloody despise Pitbulls (& Staffies and all the other aggressive types) for this reason. It's been proven to be in their DNA to be aggressive/violent/fighters/to kill!

Strangely enough my family have owned many Staffies. All of whom were gentle and all of whom were great with the grandkids in the family from the day they were born.

AlwaysGinPlease · 21/02/2023 09:10

Ooh more frothing from dog haters. What a surprise 🙄