Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking him to get rid of his dog after 7 years?

483 replies

Uktousa2022 · 20/02/2023 16:00

I am moving to the USA to be with my fiance. He has a pitbull/lab who has previously bit a little yorkie, the yorkie did start the fight, however unfortunately the yorkie died because the pitbull punctured a lung after 1 bite.

I have 2 cavalier dogs. I have extreme anxiety about taking my 2 dogs over there to live with this dog that has previously bit before. My fiancé says it was a total one off, he has since been neutered and is older now, and it was the other dogs fault. I have met the dog and it does pretty much sleep all day.

I just don't know if I can live my life anxious always watching my dogs around this dog - It is a small house - I really don't know how to get over this as we are both refusing to rehome our dogs. He does have family nearby that he could probably give him too, I would be going out to the US with just my dogs.

OP posts:
Givezero · 22/02/2023 06:55

Is this what you really want? I truly love America but the American Dream is a huge marketing lie. I can see your pov, from giving them up to taking them and waiting for the Pitball to snap. But can also see why you can't expect someone to do what you can't do. If this depresses you then the excitement of a new adventure isn't that high. Sounds to me you have a decision to make and it's not about the dogs xx

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 22/02/2023 01:51

OP what is going to change in 3 short months? Nothing. His laziness, ignorance, cruelty and selfishness won't change in 3 months. His dog won't become less of a pitbull in 3 months. That America is a cesspit where you have no maternity leave, no annual leave (apart from 2 short weeks), no sick leave, no reproductive rights etc won't change. America won't become less of a dangerous country in 3 short months.

What do you expect to change in 3 months?

Have you not read anything we've said? Anything? He is garbage. Do you not understand that? Wake up!!

80sMum · 22/02/2023 01:26

Surely the simplest and fairest solution would be for both you and your fiancé to re-home your dogs? Perhaps you could then, in the fullness of time, get another dog that you could jointly own.

Welshmonster · 22/02/2023 00:57

My biggest concern about this post is you are giving up everything to move. Why don’t you keep your options open and leave your dogs here, visit partner and see what his dog is like.
can you even work in USA or will you be stuck in house unable to work? Will you keep your wfh job? Are you even allowed?
if you sell up in UK you may not be able to buy the same size house on your return.

how will your anxiety be improved moving to somewhere where you could be really isolated

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 21/02/2023 22:10

Please be aware that whatever happens if you have his child and give birth there you can never if you split up bring that child back to the UK without his permission. So you could be trapped there in a really shitty relationship or split up bitterly and nit even be allowed to bring tour child/ren home to visit your family. Home sickness now could be the very least of your problems.

Uktousa2022 · 21/02/2023 18:52

Butchyrestingface · 20/02/2023 16:42

The dog actually doesnt have much of a life - it is usually in a crate all day while he is at work - then at night just sleeps on the sofa with him and in bed

How old is his dog, @Uktousa2022 ?

7

OP posts:
Ameadowwalk · 21/02/2023 18:18

Uktousa2022 · 21/02/2023 16:23

Thats terrible for your friend! What a horrible situation. As means of an update, I have decided to hold off a few more months before making any big decisions. He has said he doesn't go into marriage lightly, or expecting to divorce, which I understand, but explained to him its not him who would never be able to return home, then he said no one would be forcing me to stay there. He thinks life is quite simple, make a plan and stick to it etc.

Holding off is a really sensible decision.
Nobody, but nobody, goes into marriage lightly or expecting to divorce, so he is not saying anything very meaningful there (but surely proposing after eight weeks is taking marriage lightly?). You massively increase your chances of making a good match if you take your time, get to know the other person properly and don’t be pressured or rushed into anything.
There is nothing to stop you visiting and getting to know him better and deciding if a life overseas is really what you want. It’s not a decision to make lightly. Eight weeks in, you have still got all the romance and hearts and flowers. But that is not what you base a life-changing decision on.

Cocobutt · 21/02/2023 17:50

He has said he doesn't go into marriage lightly, or expecting to divorce,

Of course he’s going to say that!

He’s literally just saying what ever you want to hear to get you over there but the reality will be much different.

What’s really concerning is how he doesn’t seem to care about the consequences for you.

It’s like he doesn’t live in the real world and he thinks nothing of moving your entire life for him.

Imagine moving in with him and he becomes abusive and violent.
You’d be completely stuck!

He’s going to seem like your perfect man now because you’ve only known him a few weeks.

I think you need to find a way to live there but live alone.

That way this relationship can go at a normal, healthy pace and you get to keep your dogs.

fivetriangulartrees · 21/02/2023 16:51

I am so relieved to hear your update, OP. Best of luck. xx

Uktousa2022 · 21/02/2023 16:23

SchoolTripDrama · 21/02/2023 10:18

@Uktousa2022 Op, let me tell you about my friend Carolyn.

She moved to the USA to marry her fiancé and start a family together. They'd been together here, for a long time whilst he was stationed here.
Everyone was over the moon for her and was confident she'd be very happy as she's been with him for 3+ years and they were still head over heels for each other.Smile

Fast forward two years and she has a 6 month old baby in the USA with her new husband. Their marriage becomes a war zone and sadly comes to an end. Nothing she did - or him, they just weren't as compatible (after all the excitement of the move & the new baby) as they thought they were and began to get on each other's nerves, despite her also now having employment out there.
Subsequently, they had a fairly messy divorce but manage to be civil enough to co-parent. She has a green card by this point so she's legally entitled to stay in the USA....however....

Her now ex-husband is categorically refusing to allow her to leave the country with their child to do her usual visit to her family in the UK. In fact he won’t even allow her to travel out of their State to visit a friend for a weekend or to take her child on holiday to New York for Christmas!
Turns out this is perfectly acceptable and common in the US (or at least for the state they're in).

So now she's stuck. Quite literally trapped in the USA, unable to even visit the UK without having to leave her child behind, until they turn 21 (I think it's 21, it may be 18).

She's begged, pleaded, even tried coming to a legally binding agreement over it, to prove she'll bring the child back, as she just wants to visit her Mum & Dad as her Dad is very very poorly, but nope! He won’t allow it and if she ignores him and leaves anyway... Yeah, major, major shitstorm will ensue. Kidnapping charges which I believe could somehow be enforced by the US via UK police whilst she's actually in the UK and almost certainly would result in her losing her child altogether. Big trouble.

Carolyn is broken. She's not going to get chance to say goodbye to her Dad in person and her Mum is now too frail to travel long haul too, so she's highly unlikely to ever see her again either.
I'm actually really concerned about her and have been doing all the research I can to try find a way around this but there isn't one that I can tell.

Heed this warning. I realise your brother is out there and that's great but if you have any family here who you love & couldn't bear not to see again, then please realise that this could very well be you!
Even without the family aspect, if you have a child together & then unexpectedly split in the future, unless he signs away the rights to his child (that can be done in the USA, but not here), or he just doesn't care, then you're highly unlikely to be able to choose to come back to live here until your child/children are adult/s.

And please don't say "Oh he would never do that!" Or "He wouldn't ever stop me visiting my family!" as that would be naïve in the extreme! I mean, look at it from the partner's perspective, would you want to give permission to your British ex-spouse and parent of your child to travel over the ocean back to their home country for a 'visit' with your child, knowing that they could easily decide not to come back as you've given permission for them to go? I wouldn't. No matter how much I knew they missed their family! Also never, ever assume you wouldn't/couldn't split up! Even the most connected of couples can drift apart. Even marriages of 50+ years can end.
Speaking of, can you honestly see yourself with this man for the next 50/60 years? If (God forbid, of course) you became physically dependant, either temporarily or permanently, can you see him caring for you? Sponge bathing you, emptying your commode? Sitting by your bedside every chance he gets? The answer should be a resounding yes without hesitation. In sickness & in health, 'til death do us part.

I have vegetables in my freezer that have been there longer than you've known this man. Don't do it. Not yet 🙏 If he's the right man for you, he'll wait as long as it takes....

Thats terrible for your friend! What a horrible situation. As means of an update, I have decided to hold off a few more months before making any big decisions. He has said he doesn't go into marriage lightly, or expecting to divorce, which I understand, but explained to him its not him who would never be able to return home, then he said no one would be forcing me to stay there. He thinks life is quite simple, make a plan and stick to it etc.

OP posts:
KettrickenSmiled · 21/02/2023 15:58

Well posted @TuesdayJulyNever - link is faulty though, here's the current -

www.jennisspace.com/the-shark-cage-metaphor-spotting-potential-abusers/

TuesdayJulyNever · 21/02/2023 15:55

How easy do you find it to put your needs first op?
I have a suspicion that you’re channelling your concern through your dogs because you have never learned to be comfortable with your own self worth.

You’re heading into a situation that is absolutely bedecked with red flags, and not registering them.

Keep your dogs safe, and give this guy a swerve. And take a look at the Freedom Programme and the Cage Metaphor because what you’re not seeing is dangerous.

Noangelbuthavingfun · 21/02/2023 15:41

Uktousa2022 · 20/02/2023 16:00

I am moving to the USA to be with my fiance. He has a pitbull/lab who has previously bit a little yorkie, the yorkie did start the fight, however unfortunately the yorkie died because the pitbull punctured a lung after 1 bite.

I have 2 cavalier dogs. I have extreme anxiety about taking my 2 dogs over there to live with this dog that has previously bit before. My fiancé says it was a total one off, he has since been neutered and is older now, and it was the other dogs fault. I have met the dog and it does pretty much sleep all day.

I just don't know if I can live my life anxious always watching my dogs around this dog - It is a small house - I really don't know how to get over this as we are both refusing to rehome our dogs. He does have family nearby that he could probably give him too, I would be going out to the US with just my dogs.

Read most of your posts here. U need to seriously rethink this. Putting your dogs on a plane is a risk in itself so many die in the hold carriage .
You've only seen him a few times...I predict you will be back in the UK within 3 months ... really think if its worth it. Good luck

Mediocrates · 21/02/2023 14:41

YABmassivelyU. Why are your dogs more important than his?

Zenyetta · 21/02/2023 14:29

You seem fixated on the idea that he must be a great guy because he rented a house and fixed the fence. All that is nice but from what you have posted he is making it very clear that he sees the world his way and you will need to fit right in with that.

I don’t mean that he won’t move but what you are seeing as issues he is dismissing as unimportant details that will just get sorted. Fine if you are happy to live like that but your posts imply that you are not.

I think you have serious doubts and this is too big a life decision to make based on a wish to avoid the embarrassment of what people might say to your brother if you change your mind and leave your DP in the house alone or how your boss will react. The fallout will come anyway, better now than when your lives are entwined and you live away from your support network.

GeneralDeborah · 21/02/2023 14:22

I haven’t RTFT but this is clearly about deeper stuff than the dogs. Huge alarm bells about the whole relationship with what you’ve said. 🔔 🔔 🔔

In my experience it often doesn’t work out well when the woman leaves her home, job, family and gives up everything and travels to be with her chap, who is giving up nothing, and that’s before you even factor in an issue like the one you’ve raised.

I wonder if your subconscious is trying to block this move to safeguard your best interests, and you may be projecting the concerns you’ve suppressed onto the problem with your respective dogs? What’s your instinct about this man and this relationship?

H007 · 21/02/2023 14:00

You are 100% BU. You cannot ask someone else to give up their dog just so you don’t have to give up yours and equally over the anxiety of something that may never happen.

i think you need to take a step back and think about what you are planning on doing. What do your friends and family think?

purplehair1 · 21/02/2023 13:51

I’m out of step with most of the comments on here but I am surprised his dog hasn’t been put down if it killed another dog.

TootsAtOwls · 21/02/2023 13:32

There's absolutely no way I'd move two digs into the territory of a dog who's previously killed another dog, regardless of breed. One second of poor judgement on your dog's part and it's all over!

Also this guy sounds like a terrible owner. Why does he even have a dog if he just leaves it all day? The fact is given up on getting walks makes me think you're right, it's depressed.

The trouble with this guy is, he's not acknowledging the danger. It's not like he's saying "yeah, pit bulls are incredibly powerful AND not entirely predictable, if we had kids we'd have to be super careful." He's so arrogant he thinks the dog wouldn't dare attack his offspring! It's all very well saying what about your reactive dog, as pp have said - but if they went for a child, god forbid, at least the kid would have a fighting chance. With a pit bull, they wouldn't.

UdoU · 21/02/2023 12:48

My brothers wedding in September is how we met. My brother lives over there. Not online..

You are moving to the US to marry a man you met 5 months ago?

Canuck48 · 21/02/2023 12:46

PS It’s not that typical here to have people just drop by whenever. Most make plans as well. It’s not unheard of but most people are busy with work and kids and life so what he is describing as normal just isn’t true. Most people I know just don’t have the time to socialize that much with people outside of their own insular family.

Canuck48 · 21/02/2023 12:43

Uktousa2022 · 20/02/2023 19:14

Hi Again, i was looking for your previous post to respond to but couldnt find it. I am not entirely sure of the contribution but i know for the USA the holiday is good and benefits are better than most usa companies. I say giving the job up, because there is a small risk I wont be rehired depending on how long the visa takes.

I am not sure if you can inbox on there but seems like you have gone through similar and was going to ask some more advice. Yes its all very hard to hear, especially when you love someone. I did have my suspicions (and he admits!) he is quite the alpha male type lol, and usually finds it hard to take critism, always right type of guy lol, but at least he recognises that. V hard. Not sure the way around it. We already notice huge cultural differences the way in the usa all his friends and family seem to want to hang out couple nights a week, and just turn up round each others houses or spend lots of time together, whereas in the UK everything is planned and thought out a bit more lol.

So, he is an “Alpha” type guy. What does this mean exactly. You explained a bit but when it comes down to it, do you really know?

I thought I knew when I married my ex. We knew each other for 2 1/2 yrs however after we got married and were living together longer he did a bait and switch. He told me he thought I would become more dependent on him after marriage. Bought me “ The Care and Feeding of Husbands” book ie basically a 1950’s version of wifely duties. I didn’t read it but for shits and giggles on night shift listened to the author. She was a put make up on and have dinner on the table with the house clean for your husband for when he gets home. I was the bread earner, I wasn’t this person before we got married, why would I suddenly change due to a piece of paper?!?

I tell you this as has this been discussed or will he expect to alpha make the household? No pink chores for him? He rule the roost as he is paying?

You really haven’t known him for that long. September was just around the corner and although you have seen in person a few weeks and talk daily, it’s still not a long time to give up your life to move.

I personally would give it more time. The dog issue is just one red flag. Why the hurry after just 5 months? If you lived in the same country would it be the same time line? If not, why the rush?!?

The alpha male thing is so worrisome to me. It’s a constant battle to have female rights, to be able to have your own voice without having a battle. To be able to “win” anything without subterfuge. It will get harder and harder.

Canuck48 · 21/02/2023 12:31

Uktousa2022 · 20/02/2023 16:31

Potentially, but even he admits in the UK people treat dogs like children, whereas in the US they just have a dog to have a dog in the home. My life does sort of revolve around my dogs, and if anything happend, knowing i put them in that stiatuion, i would feel terrible. They have a good life here. Crazy I know

Not sure if this was addressed at all… Canadian here with many friends in the US who have dogs. Mostly internet friends but many I have known for 16 +/- yrs.

I have a dog and she is my baby. Treated with endearment and absolutely loved on. Most people I know with pets are like this.

Most if not all people with pets are like this. Working farm animals are slightly different if they are meant to be livestock guardian animals as they live solely outside to guard the farm. They are still
loved on, just differently due to having a job.

Many people put their dogs in doggy day care due to working or have dog walkers if not able to go home during the day.

yes, crate training happens but it truly isn’t cruel, dogs will frequently use them as their cave and place of safety even when not placed in them. It keeps anxious dogs safe from getting into harm and homes safe from anxious dogs. Most people will place their anxious dogs in doggy day care or other plans. Ie friends, family or dog walkers.

I can not think of any one I know that treats their dog like this man. The dog needs walks, play, interaction. They need training to keep their brains active and on top of things. It’s not fair on the dog. Pit bulls especially need this. I have actively been around them and they need activity, ex revise and training to keep them from being bored and antsy. They need to be challenged.

That poor dog must be so bored it isn’t funny.

re the dog being around children. Pit bulls are not inherently bad around them but they, like any dog, need experience and training! When my kids were born we had a German shepherd/ pit bull mix. Most awesome dog. Super protective of me and our other dog which is good and bad. It can get too much as well. He was good with the kids. We also had a trainer help us set both dogs up for success when we had them. This included using a fake noisy doll to mimic a crying baby. It was a process.

A dog won’t automatically know to protect, you have to train them to know what to do. How to act, what is right/wrong. It really sounds like his poor dog has very little socialization with anybody or anything. This is very worrying.

emptythelitterbox · 21/02/2023 12:24

I think you need to see the practicalities of the situation.

Being honest about it may save your life.

Does he have any type of education or qualifications?

What is the longest job he's ever held?

Does he live in a large city or some small podunk?

Has he ever lived somewhere on his own besides living with another woman?

What is his business?

What about you? What type of work so you do and how long have you had the job? Do you have qualifications that are valid in the US?

What's your living situation?
Own, rent, live with parents?

What about him moving where you live? Has he ever visited you?

Honestly ask and answer those questions.

Grrrrdarling · 21/02/2023 12:23

Uktousa2022 · 20/02/2023 16:00

I am moving to the USA to be with my fiance. He has a pitbull/lab who has previously bit a little yorkie, the yorkie did start the fight, however unfortunately the yorkie died because the pitbull punctured a lung after 1 bite.

I have 2 cavalier dogs. I have extreme anxiety about taking my 2 dogs over there to live with this dog that has previously bit before. My fiancé says it was a total one off, he has since been neutered and is older now, and it was the other dogs fault. I have met the dog and it does pretty much sleep all day.

I just don't know if I can live my life anxious always watching my dogs around this dog - It is a small house - I really don't know how to get over this as we are both refusing to rehome our dogs. He does have family nearby that he could probably give him too, I would be going out to the US with just my dogs.

You are totally out of order to tell him to get rid of his dog when you literally start the post with ‘the Yorkie started the fight’ because his dog wasn’t at fault it was just the bigger dog & the smaller dog sadly didn’t survive the incident!
Why would you think your dogs were at risk unless they themselves are badly behaved dogs & likely to have a go at this guys dog?
You should have your dogs meet before you decided to live together just like you would if you had children or would you expect your children to just accept this person as their new adult/parent?
There is a lot you can do to make this transition work for everyone if you really want it to but I’d call the whole thing off if someone told me to get rid of my fur family just to accommodate theirs!