Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking him to get rid of his dog after 7 years?

483 replies

Uktousa2022 · 20/02/2023 16:00

I am moving to the USA to be with my fiance. He has a pitbull/lab who has previously bit a little yorkie, the yorkie did start the fight, however unfortunately the yorkie died because the pitbull punctured a lung after 1 bite.

I have 2 cavalier dogs. I have extreme anxiety about taking my 2 dogs over there to live with this dog that has previously bit before. My fiancé says it was a total one off, he has since been neutered and is older now, and it was the other dogs fault. I have met the dog and it does pretty much sleep all day.

I just don't know if I can live my life anxious always watching my dogs around this dog - It is a small house - I really don't know how to get over this as we are both refusing to rehome our dogs. He does have family nearby that he could probably give him too, I would be going out to the US with just my dogs.

OP posts:
Lavender14 · 20/02/2023 16:55

I think you're both being a bit unreasonable. You should be intending to do some meet and greets on neutral territory etc before moving 3 dogs in together. Are you moving into your boyfriends home (and into his dogs space) or buying a new space together? You can't make a decision on how the dogs will react until you see how they interact together in a variety of contexts. Pitbulls can be wonderful pets but are highly impulsive so your boyfriend should be doing consistent training focused on impulsivity with his dog and making sure they get enough exercise and mental stimulation. I wouldn't be expecting a dog with those energy levels to be sleeping all day if it's only 7? I agree that all dogs have their limits and if any dog is attacked or threatened it will defend itself eventually. Could you invest in a behaviourist to oversee and help you integrate the dogs right from the get go and then you might be able to find a way to keep them all together? To be honest I agree with pps that your dogs are going to be the most put out by this in terms of quarantine/transport/ change in home/ change in weather etc. They're going to have a highly stressful time. So it makes more sense for you to rehome your dogs than him rehome his. It's also less likely his dog would be rehomed successfully due to bully breeds being over represented in shelters, his age and that there is a bite history regardless of circumstances.

category12 · 20/02/2023 16:52

Crikey you're giving up loads to be with this man. Are you sure it's a good idea?

How much time have you spent together in real?

Do you really want to be living with a man who treats his dog the way he does? He doesn't seem very kind to it - and the way someone is kind or not to animals translates to people too. Kindness is a really important trait in a partner.

Do you really want to have kids in a household with a pitbull?

MrsPutnamNaomiDarling · 20/02/2023 16:52

Higgeldypiggeldy35 · 20/02/2023 16:40

If you're wanting to start a family with this man whilst he has a pit bull in your house then your dogs are the least of your worries. It would be hugely irresponsible to have a baby in a house where there are aggressive dogs, I include your snappy dog in that.

This.

TomatoSandwiches · 20/02/2023 16:52

Doesn't sound like there is much over there for you OP, how did this relationship start?

Cherryblossoms85 · 20/02/2023 16:51

I would never, ever consider any pitbull to be harmless. so you're not being unreasonable in not wanting to take your dogs to be with that dog, but tbh I think your only option is rehome your dogs or bin the man. If you do go there, without your dogs, hopefully you can both get a few joint dogs in a few years once the pitbull has died and hopefully hasn't killed anything else.

Runningonjammiedodgers · 20/02/2023 16:51

If neither you can compromise over a dog/dogs it doesn't sound promising for the future. I would give up a pet for someone I loved. What state are you moving to? Depending on the climate it may be kindest to leave your dogs in the Uk.

On a separate note if you have children together in the US they will be US citizens. Which means if he turns out to be truly awful and you split you will have one hell of a battle trying to return to the UK with your children.

Make sure you are 100% about the move and give it a few years before starting a family. And re-home the pitbull before you have kids.

RiktheButler · 20/02/2023 16:51

There's a lot of people criticising this poor guy - and I'm not seeing the OP leaping to defend him. Not sure the dogs are the problem here....

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 20/02/2023 16:51

If you can't sort a dog dispute with him - don't have children with him!

(Do you want to bring a baby up with a dog you think is dangerous?)

OttersMayHaveShiftedInTransit · 20/02/2023 16:48

Off topic but have you considered the implication of having a child/children in an international relationship if that relationship breaks down? You may find you are then 'trapped' in the US as you aren't allowed to take the child/ren out of the country.
A relative of mine was in that situation and had a few really awful years when she longed to move back to the UK to be with friends and family but would have had to leave her children behind. She has now built herself a new life with a new friends, a great job and recently a new relationship and an OK co-parenting relationship but she had a miserable few years. I know no-one wants to think of a marriage ending or a relationship breaking down but when you are from different countries you have to think through the consequences.

Saltywalruss · 20/02/2023 16:47

You 're giving up your life here and moving to a different place. At least you should be able to bring your dogs!

GoodVibesHere · 20/02/2023 16:46

Blueuggboots · 20/02/2023 16:03

Why do your dogs take priority over his dogs?

Becauseit was his dog tgat killed another dog?!

GrasstrackGirl · 20/02/2023 16:45

I think that this relationship is doomed, I'd be reconsidering the move OP.

CrinkleCutChips · 20/02/2023 16:45

I don’t actually think this comes down to the dogs. I think this comes down to you having anxiety about whether this move is really the right thing for you and that’s totally understandable. I have several takes on this:

  1. You’re making the move and giving up your life. If he was that serious about you, wouldn’t he give up the dog to prove how serious he is?
  2. The dog is violent when provoked. What if that Yorkie had been a baby? I certainly wouldn’t want to be around a dangerous dog so don’t downplay it.
  3. Why can’t he move to be with you?
  4. Could you compromise and give up both dogs?
  5. If you can’t agree on something as simple as a dog, how is this going to work in the long run?

Sorry to bombard you and don’t feel you have to answer. It’s more food for thought really. His attitude towards this issue doesn’t sound fantastic if I’m honest.

Probablymagrat · 20/02/2023 16:44

sunflowerdaisyrose · 20/02/2023 16:26

I would no way take my dogs to a dog who has bitten and killed another dog, or have babies in the house with a pit bull x

I can see why he won't give up his dog though too.

This. I can't see this working tbh. I wouldn't have a baby in a house with a dog that had killed another dog whatever the circumstances.

Also a dog left in a crate all day is likely to have a few mental health issues, and might be jealous of you and your dogs which might make him more reacitve.

And I don't think I could fancy a man that thinks its fine to keep a dog in a crate all day.

Quartz2208 · 20/02/2023 16:42

Can I sk a honest question if he did agree to lose the dog would you be ok with that because it is clear his relationship with the dog is not the same as yours and doesn’t look after him properly

Zanatdy · 20/02/2023 16:42

I wouldn’t move my dog in with a pit bull who are a banned breed in the U.K. The dog isn’t exercised enough either. But no I wouldn’t expect him to give up his dog either

Butchyrestingface · 20/02/2023 16:42

The dog actually doesnt have much of a life - it is usually in a crate all day while he is at work - then at night just sleeps on the sofa with him and in bed

How old is his dog, @Uktousa2022 ?

ItchyBillco · 20/02/2023 16:41

Uktousa2022 · 20/02/2023 16:31

Potentially, but even he admits in the UK people treat dogs like children, whereas in the US they just have a dog to have a dog in the home. My life does sort of revolve around my dogs, and if anything happend, knowing i put them in that stiatuion, i would feel terrible. They have a good life here. Crazy I know

How well do you know this guy? Seems a big move into a situation that makes you very uncomfortable, with plans to have kids ‘very soon’.

FrictionDiction · 20/02/2023 16:41

I honestly feel if you take your dogs there to live with him you will be in effect 'giving up' your dogs, as his will very lucky kill or injure them. If his does hurt them out there and he still refuses to give his up, you'd have to either leave him or rehome your dogs in a country where you don't have people you can trust.

I would absolutely, definitely, not take them. Leave them with friends or family here. If you can't go without them, then don't go.

Even if this yorkie did 'provoke' his dog, it delivered a killing bite to a breed that can't possibly have made it feel physically threatened. This is not normal behaviour for most breeds.

Check out the blog 'dogs bite' - pitbulls do not behave like other dogs, and being neglected is doing nothing to make this dog safer for dogs or children (or you, frankly).

Jaxhog · 20/02/2023 16:41

You are NOT being unreasonable. At least not in the sense that you don't want to put your dogs in danger. I'd be concerned too about you each having a very different attitude toward pets. What's his view about kids?

I would be thinking very seriously about moving so far to be with someone who has such a different outlook on life.

Higgeldypiggeldy35 · 20/02/2023 16:40

If you're wanting to start a family with this man whilst he has a pit bull in your house then your dogs are the least of your worries. It would be hugely irresponsible to have a baby in a house where there are aggressive dogs, I include your snappy dog in that.

Floomobal · 20/02/2023 16:39

Uktousa2022 · 20/02/2023 16:12

I am a dog lover - which is why I don't want to put my dogs in a situation where they could potentially die like the other one.

You’re a dog lover, which is why you want your boyfriend’s dog ripped away from his home and given to someone else, so that you can move into it’s home? Okaaaaaaaaaaayyyyyy

Radiohat · 20/02/2023 16:38

How long have you known your man and have you spent much time together? You sound very different to each other. Your dogs have a nice life I think that might change.....

sunshinesupermum · 20/02/2023 16:37

he admits in the UK people treat dogs like children, whereas in the US they just have a dog to have a dog in the home.

Abundantly untrue Uktoussa2022 This is how he feels but it is not true of any American I know who owns a dog! They are members of the family just as your two are.

Your American sounds awful. Can't believe you are giving up everything here to live with him.

daffodilday · 20/02/2023 16:37

It’s a Pitbull. YANBU. However I’d rather give up my dogs before moving there than live with the anxiety of when it would kill another dog (your own )