Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think a UK psychiatrist shouldn't think that magic spells cause mental illness?

38 replies

Februarystars23 · 20/02/2023 12:45

Colleague from Nigeria told me that he believes some mental illness is caused by spells and evil spirit possession and he's seen exorcism work.

He is also incredibly homophobic and thinks it should be illegal.

AIBU to have concerns that this man is working with very ill people who are detained under the mental health act?

Or am I just racist or culturally insensitive?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WanderingWitches · 13/11/2023 22:13

JLOU17 · 13/11/2023 20:41

It's a cultural thing it's still very much believed in many parts of Nigeria, my partner being one of them although I think he's listened to my reasoning and is on the fence now 😅 . I personally do not find it very much different from religious people being around the vulnerable also same laws apply in your reasoning - make believe/ fantasy ✌️.... However - if his job role involves diagnosing this is v concerning. Of it is a support work/Carer type job and he's adhering to guidelines shouldn't be an issue unless his work practice is out of line we cannot tell people what to believe and like I said it's cultural x

Why on earth did you resurrect this old post?

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 13/11/2023 21:06

ZOMBIE

JLOU17 · 13/11/2023 20:41

It's a cultural thing it's still very much believed in many parts of Nigeria, my partner being one of them although I think he's listened to my reasoning and is on the fence now 😅 . I personally do not find it very much different from religious people being around the vulnerable also same laws apply in your reasoning - make believe/ fantasy ✌️.... However - if his job role involves diagnosing this is v concerning. Of it is a support work/Carer type job and he's adhering to guidelines shouldn't be an issue unless his work practice is out of line we cannot tell people what to believe and like I said it's cultural x

secular39 · 20/02/2023 17:22

Not sure about the homophobia bit as that is wrong.

But his thinking is quite the norm in some circles. The only way it would be an issue is if his beliefs interfered with his work.

People in the pass have called me transphobic simply because I refuse to have she/her under my signature title. I mean why do I have to do that?! My name is unisex which goes in my favour.

Feefee00 · 20/02/2023 17:12

I'm actually a different poster the colleague I'm talking about wasn't a psychiatrist nor a registered professional. I'm actually shocked a very educated person believes wholeheartedly in JuJu and black magic . It doesn't bother me having personal beliefs it depends if they were talking about JuJu to patients who are already psychotic as some can already have delusional beliefs etc.

rexythedinosaur · 20/02/2023 14:51

Sorry ^ posted on the wrong thread!

rexythedinosaur · 20/02/2023 14:50

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

KattyKattyKatz · 20/02/2023 14:46

If he only voiced his beliefs in front of you in all he has to do is deny everything . I'm not saying you're in the wrong but I would tread carefully if I were you . This could turn ugly.

rexythedinosaur · 20/02/2023 14:43

FatOaf · 20/02/2023 14:19

Please, please report him.

To whom? For what?

To his manager, because his beliefs (which it sounds like he is very vocal about, at least to his colleages) are not compatible with his chosen profession, in which he is responsible for the care of a number of very vulnerable people.

He is working as a psychiatrist which, as a profession, is about using a medical/ social model of care to treat mental illness.

That profession is not compatible with a belief that mental illness is caused by witchcraft/ magic/ demons, so his manager needs to be aware and take any necessary action to ensure he is practising safely or make a decison about whether he should be practising psychiatry at all.

NotanotherboxofFrogs · 20/02/2023 14:26

Definitely report. I didn't feel I had a voice when I encountered someone who used their psychiatrist position as a power play.

The very first psychiatrist I ever met at 15, pointed out that I couldn't be depressed as what had I to be depressed about at 15 and ignored other major symptoms and that I just needed to go to mass and sit near the front. Wtf. The GP had tried their best to manage things without referring to Psych (turns out they knew how bad she was but were waiting for her to get enough complaints)

I should also go and volunteer on the missions to see people who really had something to be sad about. I have no interest in religion.

She was a white Irish woman who intended to save all the African babies This was in 1989.

There was no teenage services locally at the time so she put me on a geriatric ward and I was denied proper treatment. I still have nightmares about it over 30 years later. ECT should never be a threat for anyone especially not from a psychiatrist.

My mother moved house just so I could be in a different catchment area after those first encounters. I was treated a lot better after that but was still in adult services as an under 18.

Cue 3 years later me being diagnosed with Schizophrenia and major depressive disorder as soon as I hit adult services in age terms.

FatOaf · 20/02/2023 14:19

Please, please report him.

To whom? For what?

Madethisupjustnow · 20/02/2023 14:07

Please, please report him. I was given a horrible, misogynist lecture once by a similar sounding man at a CMHT when seeking help for my very, very unwell husband.

I wasn’t able to report him at the time. My husband also would not go back to the service. It’s incredibly abusive to unwell people and their families.

Its not enough to argue that this is his private belief. He won’t be able to properly diagnose or treat people with schizophrenia or dissociation etc if he thinks they are possessed by an evil spirit FFS.

It’s nothing like having an opinion on gay marriage, this man’s beliefs conflict with widely accepted definitions of mental illness.

rexythedinosaur · 20/02/2023 13:58

This is quite a common belief in some cultures.

Deliverance, exorcism, witchcraft, juju - these are things that come up in safeguarding work and professionals attend courses about how to address situations where these beliefs cause safeguarding issues.

The question is whether you think his beliefs are affecting his work and causing harm to people.

I can't see how being a psychiatrist is compatible with these kinds of beliefs really, so I think you should report any concerns that you might have.

Lunde · 20/02/2023 13:53

I would flag this up given that there was a case last week of someone working in the NHS for 20 years with faked credentials
www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/feb/15/fake-doctor-zholia-alemi-nhs-guilty-fraud

Brieandme · 20/02/2023 13:46

Just to add on the flip side also; black African heritage men are significantly more likely to be medicated and medicated against their will due to institutional racism in the mental health system - where they are most likely to be assessed by white men (re medication) white women (re MHA)
One accepted reason for this is a lack of cultural sensitivity around beliefs about god, ancestors and communicating with them.
Having a variety of views in a mental health service is better than only having that of white/western medicine. I mean, it was the latter that gave us the diagnosis of hysteria and wandering wombs....

Brieandme · 20/02/2023 13:41

I've known mental health professionals who personally hold similar views - it's their cultural belief and it is promoted within certain churches. However if they're not sharing their beliefs in work, not discussing them where they're linked to their role (eg sharing on social media while identifiable) and they're treating patients in line with NHS guidelines then there isn't any recourse.

People can believe whatever they want, whatever job they're in. If you're a colleague of them and they've had this conversation with you then you could raise it and they'd probably be told to keep their views to themselves, but they can't be made to change their mind on it.

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 20/02/2023 13:38

Does he share his personal beliefs with his patients or treat them in accordance with his beliefs ie casting spells and exorcisms?

If he is professional in his practice and keeps his beliefs to himself then I don't think you have any basis for complaint.

There are plenty of practicing Christian's who believe in God and who speak to him and believe he communicates back, who take communion and believe they are ingesting the body and blood of Christ. Who believe in devils and angels.

Do we say that they are incapable of practicing psychiatry?

Untitledsquatboulder · 20/02/2023 13:38

Belief in evil, possession and exorcism is widespread in a number of religions and occurs in just about all cultures, so its interesting you chose to share his with us. If you feel his beliefs are damaging his patients then surely you have professional routes for reporting him, so it's doubly strange you are posting about it on Mumsnet.

TheEponymousGrub · 20/02/2023 13:37

So, your colleague is a psychiatrist but you honestly don't know whether his holding/sharing these beliefs is acceptable? Aye right.

unclebuck · 20/02/2023 13:34

Would you mind if they were a Catholic and believed transubstantiation? This is a genuine question. I find both utterly unacceptable but I suspect I am in a small minority.

WhisperingAutistic · 20/02/2023 13:32

Are you the person who posted about a colleague who agrees with FGM too?
The writing styles are very similar, as are some of the details.

whatsup00 · 20/02/2023 13:31

I have witnessed a psychiatrist like this. A lot of patients walked out. Didn't get proper treatment. And because they were in such a bad place they felt unable to complain, it carried on. Please don't let the possibility of this carry on.

Newwardrobe · 20/02/2023 13:29

In what capacity is he working and have these beliefs had a detrimental affect on the patients?

Tat2too · 20/02/2023 13:29

Something to consider, professionals are as susceptible to mental illness as any other person in society. If they are seeing demons and goblins and similar perhaps they need assessing by their colleagues....

Seeing there are now 2 threads about similar issues posted on the same day it's a bit Sus.

Dogsitterwoes · 20/02/2023 13:27

I believe you, OP.

I used to be very involved with highly educated professionals from Nigeria, including GPS, and they all held very biblical Christian beliefs, which includes 100% certainty about the influence of the devil, demons, witches etc on people's health and behaviour.

They werent physchiatrists though. That would really concern me.