Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm the only one financially helping mum

60 replies

Sh82 · 20/02/2023 10:36

My mum has cancer, diagnosed in December and awaiting treatment. She lives alone, and usually works a minimum wage job, but has been on statutory sick leave. With the cost of living, like many, she's been struggling with bills and food, and I've had to lend her money so she can make ends meet. She gets benefits, but there's still a shortfall each month.

I have a sister who lives in Dubai, who is getting decent money (she's just back from a 3 week luxury holiday and has booked another). Despite me being a full-time student with my own children, my sister offers nothing. My mum approached her for financial help (a loan), and my sister she says she can't afford to help...

At the end of the day, she's my mum and she's struggling, so I'll do all I can to help her. But the amount is creeping up (currently over £500, so not an insubstantial sum). I'm feeling so resentful of my sister offering nothing, and if I receive one more holiday photo from her - I may scream!!

Am I being unreasonable to want to distance myself from my sister, given how she's behaving?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JudgeRudy · 23/06/2023 21:57

Does your mum have a mortgage? It might be possible to get a short term payment 'holiday'. If she's paying rent there should be a housing element attached to her universal credit. If she's too sick to work and the incapacity goes on for a while she'll get a higher rate of UC. Its not a huge amount, but it wouldn't be that dissimilar to a minimum wage job so she shouldn't be that much worse off. Are you sure this is all down to her being unable to work? Could it be that she's got behind with her bills in general before she got sick?

alittlequinnie · 20/02/2023 20:36

Hi OP.

You could apply for PIP for your mum - if she is under 65 - but it's tricky to get it for cancer - unless she's terminal..

Government website states...

Eligibility

You can get Personal Independence Payment (PIP) if all of the following apply to you:

you’re 16 or over

you have a long-term physical or mental health condition or disability

you have difficulty doing certain everyday tasks or getting around

you expect the difficulties to last for at least 12 months from when they started

You must also be under State Pension age if you’ve not received PIP before.

So you'd have to argue that she is likely to be in this state for at least 12 months.

With UC - she needs to try to get a health assessment to see if she can go into hte "limited capability for work group" - again I'm not sure if they will do this short term... but worth a try...

I'm not 100% sure she could claim UC straight away though because UC is an "income" benefit and usually you would apply for a contribution based benefit like ESA - I know that ESA is being phased out - but there is something called "new style ESA"

www.gov.uk/guidance/new-style-employment-and-support-allowance

Overview

If you are ill or have a health condition or disability that limits your ability to work you may be able to get New Style Employment and Support Allowance (ESA).

New Style ESA is a fortnightly payment that can be claimed on its own or at the same time as Universal Credit (UC). If you get both benefits, your Universal Credit payment is reduced by the amount you get for New Style ESA.

New Style ESA is a contributory benefit. Normally, this means you may be able to get it if you’ve paid or been credited with enough National Insurance contributions in the 2 full tax years before the year you’re claiming in.

Hopefully some of the above will be useful!

Sh82 · 20/02/2023 19:27

Thanks to all your advice, I got mum to call Macmillan again. Turns out she is eligible for a £350 grant, and is entitled to more universal credit than she's receiving - so she's going to follow this up. Great advice to always check and check again for sources of support - its amazing the work Macmillan do

OP posts:
Hont1986 · 20/02/2023 19:11

OP, I would take any benefits advice from Mumsnet with a huge grain of salt, most people haven't a clue what they are talking about.

Your mum is under pension age and on a low income, so the main benefit available to her would be Universal Credit. You don't mention if she is renting or not, so I will assume she isn't.

If her only income is SSP, then she should get £98/m in UC. This would rise to £689/m once the DWP find her unfit for work, although that can take 3-4 months so likely won't have happened yet. She should also get help towards her Council Tax bill but that varies by area, so I can't give an exact figure.

There is the possibility of PIP, but even with cancer, it's far from a sure thing and if she is living by herself without a carer, it doesn't surprise me that she has been turned down. It is still worth having CAB/Macmillan double-check if there is a good chance at appeal but don't count on it.

AlwaysAuntie · 20/02/2023 18:10

Hi, I am sorry to hear about your mum. When my dad had cancer he had support from Age Concern (apologies if mum isn'told enough to use their sevices), a lovely gentleman visited him and home and discussed all the benefits he was entitled to.

I would be tempted to put in an appeal with Pip, I don't know if you have a DIAL in your area - they're a charity that helps people with disabilities and long term illnesses. My local branch helps people fill in forms for Pip and helps people win appeals.

Unfortunately I don't have any advice on speaking with your sister about the situation. But I completely understand your frustrations, none of my brother's were much help when it came to caring for my dad.

Sh82 · 20/02/2023 18:07

That is absolutely how I feel, I'm sorry you had to go through a similar thing.

OP posts:
newyearsresolurion · 20/02/2023 18:05

What if the sister doesn't really have the money? Not all that glitters is gold

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 20/02/2023 17:58

I have been there. What I was frank about with my sister was that her lack of help was her business but it absolutely effects my relationship with her as a sister.

Sh82 · 20/02/2023 17:57

I take what you're saying on board, and agree - definitely no-one should be pressured into giving anyone money regardless of the situation. But if I didn't help mum, I don't know what she'd do, she has nowhere else to turn.

My frustration really is that my sister doesn't seem particularly bothered about the situation. She works full time, on a decent salary (60k plus apparently, and no tax - as does her husband), yet it appears its only me stepping in to help mum. I hear through mum that my sisters had her teeth done, botox, boozy brunches, booked another holiday, paying for people to fly there for visits- yet its me who is shouldering the responsibility of keeping mum financially afloat. It may be that she's sticking it all on credit cards, goodness knows, but it's the lack of consideration that blows me away. She hasn't asked once how mum's doing, or how things are going financially. We get sent plenty of photos from my sisters adventures. I've stopped replying to these (and actually left the watsapp group today, seeing these images I find it distasteful).

I'm going to take your suggestions, and make sure that mum is getting the right financial advice around benefits, etc. There could be more support out there for her. But sadly, I think I may have seen my sister's true colours. I think family should be more important than botox and beach breaks

OP posts:
HamBone · 20/02/2023 17:55

@Donkeyotey i agree with you in theory, I have no intention of letting my children support me either.

But life can be difficult with unexpected twists and turns. I know someone irl who’s been left homeless due to her late husband’s poorly written will. It was totally unintentional, but these things can happen. Only one if her adult children has stepped in to help her, and I can’t help judging the others.

I just couldn’t let my parent stress about bills when they’re battling cancer. I’m lucky in that my Dad’s financially self-sufficient, but I’ve chosen to pay for some extra help around the house to save him the effort and prevent falls. Plus he hates housework. 😂

bonzaitree · 20/02/2023 17:50

I would be direct with your sister. Polite but firm. « Sister, our mum is I’ll and cannot pay her bills. I have lent her £500 and she is seeking other financial help. I understand you’ve said no. In the circs I don’t want to see any more holiday pictures. »

ChangesUsername · 20/02/2023 17:40

Tinkerbyebye · 20/02/2023 14:03

As I get older I get less tolerant

next time she posts a picture I would comment, how nice you are enjoying yourself when you said you couldn’t help mum financially when she is I’ll and unable t9 pay her bills. Read the room

and would post each and everytime

i would also be sending her an email telling her in no uncertain words how horrible she is being to your mother

That's a horrible thing to do, do you think that she'd suddenly change her mind or would it make you feel better?
She knows already but has chosen not to help, that's her perogative
It's a lovely thing you are doing @Sh82

Donkeyotey · 20/02/2023 17:33

@HamBone I would never let myself get to a place where my children are having to support me - I simply wouldn’t accept any help from them, no matter what. I’m here to support them - not the other way around.

Financial support is provided to those who are unable to work both by the government and by charities (like MacMillan). And frankly a 60 year old woman should have savings of her own, or assets she can sell. That generation have had it a hell of a lot easier financially than their children. If she is having to take money from her children then something has gone seriously wrong.

Of course if my mother asked me for money I would give (and have previously given) it to her. But no way would I put my children in that position.

MelchiorsMistress · 20/02/2023 17:27

What’s your sister’s situation? Is she working while she lives in Dubai or is she only there because her husband is working or what? Do they have children or are they planning children? Are they saving in the hope of buying a home or anything else?

I don’t think it’s fair for either you or your Mum to expect financial help from your sister, despite your Mums situation being awful. You’re holding it against her for having holidays, but her husband has a say in those too, and in what happens to marital/family money even if your sister does earn herself. Maybe they booked the holiday a long time ago? She doesn’t have a responsibility to give your Mum money and neither of you should feel pressured into it. Especially as your mum is reluctant to find help she’s entitled to from elsewhere. She should be doing what she can for herself before expecting her children and their partners to provide for her.

Sh82 · 20/02/2023 17:18

Thanks all,

I've spoken to mum and told her she needs to get better advice around the benefits she may be entitled to, I've provided her with several support numbers, CAB, MacMillan. It looks like she may be eligible for a MacMillan grant. She takes no for an answer quite easily, but I've told her she needs to keep trying. This is frustrating in itself, she doesn't push for help.

If her treatment goes well, she's hoping to return to work at the end of April starting gradual. She's desperate to get back, and says she feels like a burden. It's hard isn't it, you want to support them - you only get one mum right? But agree, if things don't go to plan with her treatment we need to sit down and sort out a longer term strategy as this isn't sustainable.

OP posts:
HamBone · 20/02/2023 17:14

@Donkeyotey I agree that adult children shouldn’t HAVE to support their parents, but I think most people would consider helping with essential bills if their parent was on sick leave due to cancer, don’t you? I wouldn’t advocate giving money to fritter, but paying bills is something else entirely.

Anyway, the OP’s been given some good advice and I hope it works out.

Donkeyotey · 20/02/2023 16:45

mybunniesandme · 20/02/2023 11:26

Im going to go against the other replies here....

There could be a huge backstory we aren't aware of here about OPs mums financial history? Say for example she's frittered large sums away over the years, made reckless financial decisions in the past. What's the reason behind a minimum wage job and so on? The sister may feel like it's not her responsibility with reason? It isn't a child's** responsibility to help out financially in their parents old age?

Also depending on the visa your sister have many mean you have to leave the country every month or so - and it's cheap to fly to other countries - so what looks like a luxury holiday is far cheaper than you think and also a visa requirement....

Not defending the sister by the way just that bit everything is black and white

I agree. Children shouldn't have to support their parents financially.

kitcat15 · 20/02/2023 16:39

Sh82 · 20/02/2023 13:36

Really helpful suggestions, thanks so much everyone.

Yes I think the PIP was maybe declined because she is mobile and doesn't need support to dress/wash/cook etc? She's doing ok, but the cancer makes her very tired. I think the radiotherapy can make that worse too? (She starts that on Mon)

She's always been on a low wage, and was let go after 25years in a job where she'd worked up the ladder a bit paywise, but struggled aged 60 to find another job. She's usually in retail when not poorly.

I wish I could pick up the phone and call my sister, but apparently you can't watsapp call or facetime in the UAE (she said its banned?), and calling the mobile would cost a fortune. I messaged and she didn't reply, hopefully she'll not ignore it entirely. Interesting you mention her husband, he never been the friendliest character, so perhaps there's more going on than I realise behind the scenes. They do seem to spend a lot, so perhaps the credit card plays a part?

Thank you for taking the time to message back, I appreciate it

Your mum hasn't been declined pip...why do you keep saying that? .....she hasn't applied.....you are going off the say so of someone .....you would best be supporting her to claim benefits than giving her money....if she has chronic fatigue then it affects ts her ability to wash, dress, cook etc...she needs support from welfare benefit agency to complete the forms...its takes around 7 to 8 months to get an assessment but its all back dated....you have no exit plan...you can't keep giving your mum money....I can't blame your sister for not wanting to do this

soberfabulous · 20/02/2023 16:35

I live in the UAE and yes WhatsApp calls and FaceTime are banned.

Zoom and Skype work fine though.

How do you communicate if you didn't know about what works and doesn't, message only?

Quitelikeit · 20/02/2023 15:48

Your mother needs to make an appointment with the CAB to help her fill in her PIP forms.

They are absolutely brilliant at completing them and winning awards.

Your mum needs to appeal asap!

Im sorry about the diagnosis

CrinkleCutChips · 20/02/2023 15:43

Sounds just like my sister. We spent £100k to upgrade to a bigger house to my mum could live with us as she couldn’t afford to live alone. My sister never puts her hand in her pocket yet could easily afford it. Do what you can afford to do but don’t expect anything from your sister, it’ll only lead to heartache. That’s what I’ve had to accept.

radiatorflush · 20/02/2023 15:41

saltinesandcoffeecups · 20/02/2023 15:15

What is your mum’s long term plan?

If I’m honest I would be hesitant to start funding my parent in an open ended arrangement like this. How long have you been giving money? How long do you expect you (and your sister if she agrees) to give your mum money?

I feel the same as this

Minimalme · 20/02/2023 15:40

I'm not sure propping your dm up financially is the solution here.

She is in her 60s and won't be able to work to support herself forever.

It would be much better to look at what assets she has and her outgoings.

She needs a long term plan which isn't based on working.

mamabear715 · 20/02/2023 15:37

What @Tinkerbyebye said. :-(
I couldn't bring myself to carry on any kind of convo if my sis had done the same when our mum was so ill.

You've had some good advice financially, I'd just add, if no-one has said the same, that CAB etc will help you fill claim forms in. DWP look for specific things on the form, so even if you fill it in at great length, you might not be telling them the right things. Hugs..

HamBone · 20/02/2023 15:33

I agree with PP's that you need to be upfront with your sister about your Mum's financial situation and explain that you simply can't afford to keep subsidizing her to this extent.

Yes, there might be a backstory, but your Mum is older and ill, she really shouldn't just be left in financial penury. If your sister's concerned that your Mum might fritter away money, perhaps she could directly pay a couple of bills for her like council tax or electricity?

I'm helping my Dad out a bit financially now (he's 85) and alot in terms of my time. He hasn't always been the ideal parent and can be quite difficult, but he's still my Dad, so I'm prepared to make the effort. Perhaps your sister needs to be reminded that she's only got one Mum.