Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pregnant women are not respected the same anymore

435 replies

Grannypantsandtea · 20/02/2023 10:00

Is it just me or are people more inconsiderate to pregnant women (and new mums) than they used to be?
I remember being pregnant with my eldest 11 years ago, people would hold open doors, offer me seats etc. A lovely man helped me carry my buggy down stairs when the lift was broken. Older people would stop to fuss over the new baby.
Im now pregnant again with a very obvious bump and I’ve not come across one kind person yet.
Ive had people push into me, rush to get ahead in queues, run to take a bench I was clearly trying to sit at while feeling faint, not a single door held open, a woman pushing past to get into a lift so I couldn’t (spd so struggle with stairs).
Maybe it’s just me being old fashioned, I certainly don’t expect special treatment, but to lack consideration for a woman struggling seems to be a recent thing, I’m sure they wouldn’t do it to disabled people.
I have always been thoughtful to pregnant women, holding doors open for buggies etc, I thought it was just a general part of respect in this country but it’s sad how the world has changed in a decade.
Has anyone else experienced this complete lack of care towards others or is it just me? I’m prepared to be told I’m precious, but it only takes a few seconds out of your life to stop and let a pregnant lady walk past for example.

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 20/02/2023 13:41

29052022J · 20/02/2023 13:32

No these lifts were only for the shops, different lifts for the car parks. If it was for the car parks I would understand, it seems like strange behaviour to take a lift if you are able bodied before some one in a wheelchair/physically impaired.

Very strange. There are notices by the lifts in my shopping centre asking for priority to be given at busy times to the disabled and families with young children and pushchairs. OTOH not everyone’s disability is visible but it might still mean they need to to use the lift rather than the escalator or stairs.

WiIson · 20/02/2023 13:39

ilovesooty · 20/02/2023 13:32

Asking if someone can offer you a seat because you're struggling is basic assertiveness. It's not about how people perceive that request.

Well it depends how much someone needing the seat, and likely in pain or unwell, is up for confrontation, particularly under those circumstances. Weighed against the probability of the seated person not moving anyway. And sometimes it's not worth the hassle considering the chances of encountering an arsehole seem to be pretty high, judging by the responses on this thread.

BadNomad · 20/02/2023 13:37

sanabria · 20/02/2023 13:34

I think people saying that pregnancy isn't a disability are missing the point a bit. No, pregnancy isn't a disability but generally speaking it's harder being pregnant than not pregnant. And people being completely inconsiderate to a pregnant woman are also likely to be inconsiderate to disabled people too. It just boils down to people being thoughtless, selfish, or disinterested in the needs/experiences of others.

I doubt someone who is considerate of the needs of a disabled person would be inconsiderate to a pregnant woman or vice versa. The two behaviours are likely to go hand in hand.

I'd say though that I had the opposite experience to OP. I was really touched how helpful people were towards me when I was pregnant. I didn't need the help in most cases, but it was really really nice to be offered. Especially as I had a bloody awful pregnancy.

That's the opposite of what the OP said though. She implied disabled people get treated better than pregnant women. People corrected her on that and that it isn't even a comparison that should be made.

JamToasties · 20/02/2023 13:36

@IsThereAnEchoInHere is probably the one pushing into you OP

sanabria · 20/02/2023 13:34

I think people saying that pregnancy isn't a disability are missing the point a bit. No, pregnancy isn't a disability but generally speaking it's harder being pregnant than not pregnant. And people being completely inconsiderate to a pregnant woman are also likely to be inconsiderate to disabled people too. It just boils down to people being thoughtless, selfish, or disinterested in the needs/experiences of others.

I doubt someone who is considerate of the needs of a disabled person would be inconsiderate to a pregnant woman or vice versa. The two behaviours are likely to go hand in hand.

I'd say though that I had the opposite experience to OP. I was really touched how helpful people were towards me when I was pregnant. I didn't need the help in most cases, but it was really really nice to be offered. Especially as I had a bloody awful pregnancy.

ilovesooty · 20/02/2023 13:32

WiIson · 20/02/2023 13:09

Well that's understandable. People are clearly so rude and dismissive about pregnancy that the chances of a polite request appearing confrontational are high. I wouldn't ask either. Imagine the response from some of the people on this thread.

Asking if someone can offer you a seat because you're struggling is basic assertiveness. It's not about how people perceive that request.

29052022J · 20/02/2023 13:32

KimberleyClark · 20/02/2023 12:01

Perhaps they were going to the car park levels? In my local big shopping centre the escalators only go to the second shopping level. There are 5 car park levels above that.

No these lifts were only for the shops, different lifts for the car parks. If it was for the car parks I would understand, it seems like strange behaviour to take a lift if you are able bodied before some one in a wheelchair/physically impaired.

Grannypantsandtea · 20/02/2023 13:31

Thanks again for the kind comments, it’s shocking to hear of some awful accounts some of you have had. I agree with many of the posters who say everyone should be equal and there shouldn’t be a competition over who has it worse. Everyone’s situation is different, comparing pregnancy vs disability is childish and brings nothing to the thread as that isn’t what it was about. I’m not sure what some of you hope to gain with your ridiculous comments, does it make you feel more superior or something? As it just makes you look discriminatory yourself.
I did have to laugh that I single handedley have over populated the planet with my second and last baby! I presume to the poster you are child free and never experienced pregnancy or disabilities, so your input is irrelevant here.
Im also fairly certain people can see my huge bump is not fat considering I don’t wear a coat and fit size 8-10 clothing, but nothing like women being bitchy hey!
I also do not use public transport so I’ve never been in a situation to need to ask for a seat.

OP posts:
Arguelikeagrownup · 20/02/2023 13:27

What I don't get about this thread is how many posters are competing over who has it harder; pregnant women or people with non-pregnancy related disabilities.

That's not what's happening. People are just pointing out that the OP is wrong for thinking that disabled people get treated any better.

Guis · 20/02/2023 13:26

I don't recognise the lack of regard you mention. It depends on your expectations of how you should be treated due to your pregnancy or have a small child in a buggy.

I expect people to get up and offer a seat on public transport. And opening a door is courteous to anybody.
I think it is fair to point out that people may have experienced poor manners from mums when out and about. I was once on a bus when a mum got on with her buggy which she proceeded to row with the driver over as there was a wheelchair user in situ. It was toe curling. And I remember being irritated seeing a mum with two strapping and mobile teenagers get out of a mum and baby car parking slot but also spied a very elderly and not very mobile couple walking slowly across the car park. Manners cost nothing but go a long way. But there is a difference between good manners and common courtesies and being overly attentive. To mention too some people might also be worried these days that being overly helpful might not be welcomed and they will get their head bitten off.

Jumbojade · 20/02/2023 13:26

BeetleyCarapace · 20/02/2023 10:02

I’m sure they wouldn’t do it to disabled people

<hollow, cynical laugh>

Oh they would. Take it from me.

And from me!

Wellthatwasweird · 20/02/2023 13:21

CAJIE · 20/02/2023 13:12

You are over populating the planet.do u want a reward? Lets have kindness towarda everyone.

Why not practise what you preach?

SmudgeButt · 20/02/2023 13:21

Maybe they don't notice you're pregnant or assume you're fat and are being polite by not mentioning it?

EmmaDilemma5 · 20/02/2023 13:20

HalftermHell2 · 20/02/2023 12:43

You are pregnant, not disabled, why on earth would you mention those 2 things together? I've been pregnant 3 times, I wasn't disabled for 9 months at a time, it was my choice to be pregnant, I didn't expect anything special. I was very lucky/unlucky in that I never really looked massively pregnant (I felt it believe me!!) so I wasn't offered seats on trains even at nearly 9 months pregnant. I actually gave my seat up on the train for an elderly person right before I went on mat leave, it wasn't comfortable but I couldn't let a very old person struggle, my condition was my choice and no one else was budging from their precious seat besides.

I will add I am kind to other women who are pregnant, I'd always help or give up my seat (you have to be careful these days though, some people are fat not pregnant 😬). I was in the airport last week and couldn't decide if a woman was pregnant or fat, thankfully there was a couple of seats left and she took 1 so I didn't have the dilemma of asking her.

You clearly had pregnancies that didn't impact you much then. Some of us have been bed bound or hospitalised for pregnancy complications. It disabled me for weeks, some women are disabled for their whole pregnancy.

Also, you didn't have to ask the woman if she wanted your seat. You could have got up and made your seat available. Whether she was pregnant or just overweight, it wouldn't kill to take a risk and offer it up subtly just in case.

What I don't get about this thread is how many posters are competing over who has it harder; pregnant women or people with non-pregnancy related disabilities.

Why?! Sure everyone is pain, or uncomfortable, or with vulnerabilities should be looked after and care for by others? Of course people should hold doors for pregnant women, as they should disabled people, the elderly and actually, any other person!

There's enough manners to go around, how about, rather than fight on a random website about how much worse it is for disabled people, and how pregnant women dare not consider themselves disabled, you just promote better manners and consideration for ALL people who need it.

Sillybanana · 20/02/2023 13:18

Yanbu op. I have a ten year gap between kids, and definitely noticed a difference in the second pregnancy..in terms of people offering a seat on the tube/bus and so on..

CAJIE · 20/02/2023 13:12

You are over populating the planet.do u want a reward? Lets have kindness towarda everyone.

BellatrixLestrangesHeatedCurlers · 20/02/2023 13:10

We're taught not to infer pregnancy unless the woman tells us she's pregnant. It's rude otherwise. Did you ask for a seat/help?

WiIson · 20/02/2023 13:09

ilovesooty · 20/02/2023 13:06

It seems a reasonable course of action to me but the OP apparently doesn't want to ask for what she needs because she doesn't like confrontation.

Well that's understandable. People are clearly so rude and dismissive about pregnancy that the chances of a polite request appearing confrontational are high. I wouldn't ask either. Imagine the response from some of the people on this thread.

CountZacular · 20/02/2023 13:08

HalftermHell2 · 20/02/2023 12:55

It doesn't make you disabled!! I felt faint lots, struggled to walk, peed myself at times. I didn't consider myself disabled or comparing myself to someone who can't walk through disability or who is actually incontinent permanently. The 2 aren't comparable.

Yes, it can make you temporarily disabled. Disabilities are conditions that limit day-to-day activities. Why is that so difficult to understand? If someone broke their leg would you just not consider that a disability because it’s temporary?

If you can’t walk, you can’t walk. Whether it’s pregnancy related, a sporting accident or a symptom of a long term condition, all people still deserve consideration.

whycantwegoonasthree · 20/02/2023 13:08

It's not a recent thing - when I was 8 months pregnant with DD2 13 years ago, I found myself at the bottom of a long flight of stairs at a tube station with a heavy stroller and a two year old in tow. One other person had gotten off the train at the same time, and I asked him if he'd mind giving me a hand up the stairs with the stroller. His response?

"Nah, might break a sweat."

Then ran up the stairs two at a time.

There was also the half a carriage of commuters who literally stepped over a passed out pregnant me a couple of years prior to that - although I'll be forever grateful to the older lady who helped me whilst swearing loudly and profusely at everyone else.

That said, someone did once offer their seat to me on the tube - and was very insistent about it. Sadly my youngest was 18mo at the time, but I hadn't lost the baby weight. It did at least motivate me to get my fat arse to the gym.

Wellthatwasweird · 20/02/2023 13:07

Oh come on with the winter coat rubbish!
I was heavily pregnant last January and couldn't zip my coat up over my massive bump which stuck out a mile from my open coat. I don't like in the UK and every time I was on public transport, somebody managed so see my bump under all these so called swathes and swathes of winter material, and off me a seat.

Surely as humans, its natural to look out for the more vulnerable, whoever that may be. I couldn't imagine looking at a pregnant woman on a bus and not at least asking her if she wants my seat. Or anyone older, someone with a disability, a frazzled looking mum of a young child, just anyone who looks like they could do with a seat. I just wasn't raised with this 'I'm alright, Jack' attitude.

As I said on the other thread, my first 2 pregnancies were easy peasy but in my 3rd I was practically immobile by the end. Its not a disability but it certainly can make you feel very incapacitated. People's kindness really can make a difference to how you get through your day. How has society got to this point?

As for the argument that pregnant women made that choice and need to suck it up...this 'choice' is actually creating the society of the future. All of the doctors, nurses, scientists, engineers, teachers, cleaners, plumbers, activists, therapsists, builders, town planners, refuse workers etc etc etc will be contributions to the world when you are old and need their services. These babies that pregnant women carry actually grow up to be the next generation. No, pregnant women aren't sacred but when did we just become so ungracious?

ilovesooty · 20/02/2023 13:06

WandaWonder · 20/02/2023 11:21

Do people not ask for a seat if they want one?

It seems a reasonable course of action to me but the OP apparently doesn't want to ask for what she needs because she doesn't like confrontation.

Invisibleeye · 20/02/2023 13:06

As a disabled person, I personally found that people were much more accommodating when I was pregnant than they are when I’m not.

hamstersarse · 20/02/2023 13:05

Quite, there is a phrase 'permanent disability' for a reason - not all disabilities are equal and not all are permanent.

There's a strange disablist vibe to the vitriol that is apparent when comparing pregnancy to a disability - like it's an insult to be disabled.

WiIson · 20/02/2023 13:03

I'm amazed this discussion even has to happen - any society not markedly looking after pregnant women is one that is on a bad path

Yes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread