Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pregnant women are not respected the same anymore

435 replies

Grannypantsandtea · 20/02/2023 10:00

Is it just me or are people more inconsiderate to pregnant women (and new mums) than they used to be?
I remember being pregnant with my eldest 11 years ago, people would hold open doors, offer me seats etc. A lovely man helped me carry my buggy down stairs when the lift was broken. Older people would stop to fuss over the new baby.
Im now pregnant again with a very obvious bump and I’ve not come across one kind person yet.
Ive had people push into me, rush to get ahead in queues, run to take a bench I was clearly trying to sit at while feeling faint, not a single door held open, a woman pushing past to get into a lift so I couldn’t (spd so struggle with stairs).
Maybe it’s just me being old fashioned, I certainly don’t expect special treatment, but to lack consideration for a woman struggling seems to be a recent thing, I’m sure they wouldn’t do it to disabled people.
I have always been thoughtful to pregnant women, holding doors open for buggies etc, I thought it was just a general part of respect in this country but it’s sad how the world has changed in a decade.
Has anyone else experienced this complete lack of care towards others or is it just me? I’m prepared to be told I’m precious, but it only takes a few seconds out of your life to stop and let a pregnant lady walk past for example.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dillydallydilly · 22/02/2023 13:13

Katypp · 22/02/2023 07:45

Exactly. The kind of conversations I had with strangers when was eldest was born seem all to be off the table now - is he a good sleeper? Is he a good baby? How am I managing? would all be met with derision if MN is typical of society generally. I used to often offer to take a fractous baby in eg the hairdresser's or in a cafe to let its mother do what she has to do, but I would not dare now. I also would not dream of offering any advice about eg sleeping which was fairly commonplace 30 years ago. The current way to raise children is very insular - people have Google and think that replaces experience. It doesn't. The complete derision of anything other than the current guidelines (which seem to be accepted as the definitive set, nothing will ever change) and the inane Your Baby Your Rules mantra, no matter how ridiculous those rules are, make having a baby and being pregnant a lot different now, and old gits like me have no clue how to navigate this, so I don't and am probably accused of not caring. You can't win.

I don’t agree necessarily. I have on several occasions taken a small baby or watched one in a pram in public bathrooms so that the mum could go to the toilet with the door closed and both hands free. I think being a young(ish) woman probably helps - maybe I just look particularly unthreatening.

I am a fan of ‘baby on board’ badges. Yes they’re a bit twee but it really helps when knowing who to offer a seat to in a way that won’t cause offence. A young man stood up for me once on the tube when I was very much not pregnant. I didn’t wear that outfit again…

Katypp · 22/02/2023 09:08

I was on a thread a couple of days ago about kissing a baby which sort of illustrates what I am trying to say.
Page after page of - to me at least - hysteria about a risk so vanishingly small it was not worth worrying about. Of course, there's always someone who knew someone, so it's not risk free but is extremely low risk. Yet on and on it went, brushing aside any debate by quoting The Current Rules and sneering at anyone daring to question the sense and logic. A few even went of to say that babies do not need to get kissed! As I saus, I am an old git and have seen so many changes of advice I just go with the flow and use common sense but it's that that seems to be lacking in favour of slavishly following guidelines that will change in a year or two.
Usually I am asked rather patronisingly 'Do you have children?' as if it's impossible to hold my views and to have raised three kids my self. Sometimes when I am on a thread about baby routines, someone even says 'poor baby' because my children were not brought up to current guidelines, which we all kniw are both definitive, correct and will never change, ever🤔🙄

Katypp · 22/02/2023 07:45

butterfliedtwo · 21/02/2023 10:07

Agree with this. I wouldn't ever stop and fuss over a baby. There are enough threads on here about how we as extended family or friends need to leave the new family alone to make memories or for their routine not to be distupted. Why would anyone stop to coo in the street over a stranger's baby? I'd worry about being shouted at or thought to be weird.

Exactly. The kind of conversations I had with strangers when was eldest was born seem all to be off the table now - is he a good sleeper? Is he a good baby? How am I managing? would all be met with derision if MN is typical of society generally. I used to often offer to take a fractous baby in eg the hairdresser's or in a cafe to let its mother do what she has to do, but I would not dare now. I also would not dream of offering any advice about eg sleeping which was fairly commonplace 30 years ago. The current way to raise children is very insular - people have Google and think that replaces experience. It doesn't. The complete derision of anything other than the current guidelines (which seem to be accepted as the definitive set, nothing will ever change) and the inane Your Baby Your Rules mantra, no matter how ridiculous those rules are, make having a baby and being pregnant a lot different now, and old gits like me have no clue how to navigate this, so I don't and am probably accused of not caring. You can't win.

Idkrealorfake · 22/02/2023 01:14

There are priority seats reserved on trains and buses for disabled and pregnant people.

So clearly in some instances the two physical states are comparable.

Sorry to hear you've been treated badly op. Idk if it's a new thing but there are definitely lots of inconsiderate fuckers out there (hence seats having to be stated as prioritised for certain groups, because not everyone will bother to give up their seat to someone who needs it more).

WiIson · 22/02/2023 00:45

MorganKitten · 21/02/2023 20:58

My mum is in a wheelchair and cant do anything without any support, people will push into her chair, push us out the way, tut if they have to hold doors open, even ‘accessible’ places cant fit newer chairs, on the bus we’ve had someone try to sit on her chair because ‘she won’t mind’.
So no, pregnancy and disability are not the same.

Although clearly it is, if someone ends up in a wheelchair as a result of their pregnancy. It doesn't matter how it occured. The result is still the same.

WiIson · 22/02/2023 00:43

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 21/02/2023 21:04

Wow thank you, I had no idea that people included males and females. Your Nobel prize for contributions to scientific research is in the post 🏅

Glad it was of use to you.

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 21/02/2023 21:04

WiIson · 21/02/2023 19:56

People include males and females. It's only women that get pregnant. Pregnant people is a weird thing to say.

Wow thank you, I had no idea that people included males and females. Your Nobel prize for contributions to scientific research is in the post 🏅

MorganKitten · 21/02/2023 20:58

Grannypantsandtea · 20/02/2023 10:21

I haven’t labelled pregnancy as a disability at all, once again the comment is because people have a duty to prioritise disabled people, which they should, but this is a protected duty and I haven’t come across people being disrespectful to those with disabilities. So the comment is to highlight that people pick and chose who to be respectful to. I have severe spd and struggle to walk very far, my midwife has suggested I may even need a wheelchair or crutches in my final stages of pregnancy. I certainly wouldn’t expect people to pander to my needs anyway, particularly if I was having a straight forward pregnancy, the point of the thread is that people are disrespectful in general compared to the past.

Sorry to hear that others have experienced this, it is humiliating and I have begun avoiding going out in public without my husband.

My mum is in a wheelchair and cant do anything without any support, people will push into her chair, push us out the way, tut if they have to hold doors open, even ‘accessible’ places cant fit newer chairs, on the bus we’ve had someone try to sit on her chair because ‘she won’t mind’.
So no, pregnancy and disability are not the same.

WiIson · 21/02/2023 19:56

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 21/02/2023 17:39

Feel better now?

People include males and females. It's only women that get pregnant. Pregnant people is a weird thing to say.

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 21/02/2023 17:39

Jedsnewstar · 21/02/2023 16:56

Pregnant women

Feel better now?

Jedsnewstar · 21/02/2023 16:56

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 20/02/2023 10:07

Pregnant people aren’t necessarily all uncomfortable or needing special treatment though. I use public transport a lot and people often offer to help me on/off, but I don’t need any extra help. If you feel you do need help, then tell people.

Pregnant women

Tinkerloo · 21/02/2023 14:48

I wouldn’t say having a child is the most significant thing that a woman can do. Yes, having a child is significant but not the most significant 🤷🏼‍♀️

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 14:25

buttercupboots · 21/02/2023 12:39

@Feefee00 given your comments denigrating pregnancy and it's significance I'm interested. I understand you're very proud of your achievements. What is more significant for you, your daughter or your career? What is more meaningful and special to you?

Of course I'm happy I had my daughter she's lovely and amazing that's personal to me. I have have never really found parenting a burden or chore. I don't believe the world owes me worship because I had a child which I chose to do. I'm sure I could have also had a fulfilling life childfree. That being said if I saw a heavily pregnant woman I would open the door for them or offer them a seat same as the very elderly or disabled as that's good manners.

I don't think pregnancy childrearing is a miracle worthy of worship that's all I am saying.

ConfusedNT · 21/02/2023 13:17

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 12:21

This is a thread about pregnant women being respected. Why would an infertile person read it if it was going to cause them distress? It's evident by the thread title the topic it covers. Many people do not suffer from fertility issues so should be able.to express their views on a thread about pregnancy..

Well I read it as an infertile woman, I read lots of threads on here, whether they relate directly to me or not.

Only someone narrow-minded would stay just within their own circle of understanding.

In this case I came on the thread to understand why the OP felt she wasn't being respected as a pregnant woman because I thought I might learn something, or recognise something I hadn't done myself because I didn't know it was useful for pregnant women etc. I mean the OP isn't looking for pregnant women to change their behaviour after all

And reading a thread about how it's easier for pregnant women if you do certain things shouldn't be a trigger for me to not read it as it shouldn't end up in an argument about whether having a children is the greatest achievement a woman can have or not because quite frankly even if its the worst achievement a women can have people should still make sure she can sit on a train if she needs to etc. Why does achievement even need to come into it when it's a question of needs?

Wellthatwasweird · 21/02/2023 13:14

I am so glad that I rarely come into contact with a lot of these kinds of posters in real life. I would not have believed that such cynical bitterness could really be directed at pregnant women. I mean, most pregnant women don't expect to be treated as some kind of demi-god but it is nice when people make the effort to be helpful and kind at what can be a very psychically and emotionally tough time. This thread reveals a real coldness towards pregnant women. Why is that? I was pregnant, found it pretty tough at points and like to be helpful to other pregnant women in case I can make their day a little but easier. Seriously, who on earth has a problem with this? Do you all teach your children these virtuous values?

Wellthatwasweird · 21/02/2023 13:03

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 11:18

Sorry but to get pregnant you just have to spread your legs and a man ejaculates. Your body automatically does it for you it doesn't take immense study or concentration. It's not a talent to get pregnant, I have achieved much more difficult things in my life Vs reproducing. Childrearing is the more difficult part but still not as hard as professional and personal achievements. Millions of women shag and give birth it's not a miracle the earth isn't short of humans !!

What an utterly vulgar way to speak about women.

buttercupboots · 21/02/2023 12:39

@Feefee00 given your comments denigrating pregnancy and it's significance I'm interested. I understand you're very proud of your achievements. What is more significant for you, your daughter or your career? What is more meaningful and special to you?

WiIson · 21/02/2023 12:37

HistoryFanatic · 21/02/2023 12:28

You don't even have to have had problems conceiving to have winced at the wording of your post.

I agree.

HistoryFanatic · 21/02/2023 12:28

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 12:21

This is a thread about pregnant women being respected. Why would an infertile person read it if it was going to cause them distress? It's evident by the thread title the topic it covers. Many people do not suffer from fertility issues so should be able.to express their views on a thread about pregnancy..

You don't even have to have had problems conceiving to have winced at the wording of your post.

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 12:21

fitzwilliamdarcy · 21/02/2023 12:18

Is there a particular threshold of infertile women that needs to be hit before you think you should stop saying hurtful things, or?

This is a thread about pregnant women being respected. Why would an infertile person read it if it was going to cause them distress? It's evident by the thread title the topic it covers. Many people do not suffer from fertility issues so should be able.to express their views on a thread about pregnancy..

fitzwilliamdarcy · 21/02/2023 12:18

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 11:43

Most women do not have fertility issues though. I've gotten pregnant and given birth done child rearing. It's not as hard personally as my professional and personal achievements. I had my DD because well I got pregnant because of contraception failure I then decided to have the baby because I wanted too. I love her and I'm fiercely proud but it's not been an ordeal becoming a parent has been fulfilling for me not grueling.

Is there a particular threshold of infertile women that needs to be hit before you think you should stop saying hurtful things, or?

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 12:16

HistoryFanatic · 21/02/2023 12:01

Actually any pregnancy resulting in a healthy baby is a miracle given the odds against it.

Again why do you talk about women in such a crude way?

Not it's not for a young healthy woman a healthy baby is the usual outcome not a rarity or why is the birthrate so high in the world? Obstetrics has massively improved maternal outcomes. I'm a woman I have given birth , I had sex got pregnant and gave birth. I don't feel it was a miracle really but I'm very very happy I became a mother I don't think the world owes me very special treatment for what is a natural phenomenon for many people.

DilemmaADay · 21/02/2023 12:05

It's difficult when you read Mumsnet and see some of the aggressive responses people have received from pregnant women/new mums. Woman snatching their baby away when a stranger tries to coo over them, suspicious if someone bumps into them in the street and coos over baby. Comments saying how they hate being stopped and just want to get on with their day and how annoying it is. Then comments from a PP who said they were out carrying shopping bags at 36 weeks and didn't want to be treated like glass. Previous threads where people have snapped "I'm fine!" "I'm pregnant not disabled" and eyerolls from pregnant woman when people have offered seats/to carry something because they don't want to be patronised. And this is before the minefield of accidently assuming someone is pregnant when they're not.

Sometimes people can't win, whilst I don't think anyone should be rude, I can see why people just don't bother anymore.

HistoryFanatic · 21/02/2023 12:04

WiIson · 21/02/2023 11:38

It's a bit crass. I did wonder if it was a bloke speaking. Sadly probably not though.

I agree.

HistoryFanatic · 21/02/2023 12:01

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 11:46

I'm sorry for your fertility struggles but for many the majority have sex and get pregnant. It's not a miracle for most people.

Actually any pregnancy resulting in a healthy baby is a miracle given the odds against it.

Again why do you talk about women in such a crude way?

Swipe left for the next trending thread