Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Skinny privellege

758 replies

Annabella91 · 20/02/2023 08:40

Why is there shops full of clothes for women who are skinnt but nothing bigger i hate going clothes literally can never find anything in a size 16 it's all size 6 and 8 is the fat back in the 90s discrimination trend coming in again?? Shouldn't need to skinny to look nice??

OP posts:
MarkWithaC · 21/02/2023 10:30

Comedycook · 21/02/2023 10:28

I'm going to assume you're a man going by your username?

My posts are very much based on the female experience. I think thinness is praised in women and seen as desirable in a way it isn't for men

Sorry to hear about your experiences. It does sound horrible.

No, I'm a woman.

Comedycook · 21/02/2023 10:28

MarkWithaC · 21/02/2023 10:21

I'm not going to argue that one lot of people get 'worse' abuse than another. But please do not minimise the insults/criticism/abuse thin people get just because fat people get them too.

Since adolescence I've had insults and abuse aplenty because I happen to be tall and lanky. At school people called me a Shire horse because of my height and long legs: shouting at at me, snorting like a horse etc. I've had the Addams Family theme sung and whistled at me and been told I'm Lurch the butler. I've had kids throwing things at me on the bus while shouting about how weird and lanky I look, 'like an alien'.

After I met my DP's parents for the first time, his mother asked him if I was anorexic. How insulting to me; and how much more insulting to people who are. She clearly had no idea what a person with anorexia actually looks like. The ignorance and presumption is astounding.

People sneer 'you're so skinny' at me; laugh in my face if I mention how hard it is to find clothes to fit and give me their own tales of woe about buying clothes while being fat (side note: often these people are not what I'd call 'fat' at all).
People tell me, if they see me eating an apple, 'No wonder you're so thin if that's all you eat', and in the next breath, if I'm eating a biscuit, 'It's so unfair you can eat like that and stay so thin.' Well, which is it? Plus, how fucking rude and how on earth do they think they know how I eat? I'd never say to a fat person eating a burger, 'No wonder you're so fat if that's all you eat'; it might be their first burger in a month (sometimes the apple is my first apple in a month).

I do not accept that there is no 'venom and spite' directed at thin people.

I'm going to assume you're a man going by your username?

My posts are very much based on the female experience. I think thinness is praised in women and seen as desirable in a way it isn't for men

Sorry to hear about your experiences. It does sound horrible.

MarkWithaC · 21/02/2023 10:21

Comedycook · 21/02/2023 10:11

Nonsense. Fat people get way more abuse hurled at them than thin people. The odd comment a thin person might encounter usually come from a place or either jealousy/admiration/concern. The comments made to fat people are pure venom and spite.

I'm not going to argue that one lot of people get 'worse' abuse than another. But please do not minimise the insults/criticism/abuse thin people get just because fat people get them too.

Since adolescence I've had insults and abuse aplenty because I happen to be tall and lanky. At school people called me a Shire horse because of my height and long legs: shouting at at me, snorting like a horse etc. I've had the Addams Family theme sung and whistled at me and been told I'm Lurch the butler. I've had kids throwing things at me on the bus while shouting about how weird and lanky I look, 'like an alien'.

After I met my DP's parents for the first time, his mother asked him if I was anorexic. How insulting to me; and how much more insulting to people who are. She clearly had no idea what a person with anorexia actually looks like. The ignorance and presumption is astounding.

People sneer 'you're so skinny' at me; laugh in my face if I mention how hard it is to find clothes to fit and give me their own tales of woe about buying clothes while being fat (side note: often these people are not what I'd call 'fat' at all).
People tell me, if they see me eating an apple, 'No wonder you're so thin if that's all you eat', and in the next breath, if I'm eating a biscuit, 'It's so unfair you can eat like that and stay so thin.' Well, which is it? Plus, how fucking rude and how on earth do they think they know how I eat? I'd never say to a fat person eating a burger, 'No wonder you're so fat if that's all you eat'; it might be their first burger in a month (sometimes the apple is my first apple in a month).

I do not accept that there is no 'venom and spite' directed at thin people.

Comedycook · 21/02/2023 10:19

Yarrawonga · 21/02/2023 10:17

Nonsense. Fat people get way more abuse hurled at them than thin people.

I don’t think I have ever had any abuse for being slim. Quite the opposite. I have had the odd skinny reference which may or may not have been malicious but, like a previous poster, have always said thank you.

Well exactly... which is why I find it very tedious to be told by thin people how absolutely awful it is and how they are constantly being targeted with unkind comments

Yarrawonga · 21/02/2023 10:17

Nonsense. Fat people get way more abuse hurled at them than thin people.

I don’t think I have ever had any abuse for being slim. Quite the opposite. I have had the odd skinny reference which may or may not have been malicious but, like a previous poster, have always said thank you.

Stravaig · 21/02/2023 10:15

bellac11 · 21/02/2023 09:55

So what have I gleaned from this thread

That no matter what size you are, shops never really have enough of your size on the shelves and in any case the cut and tailoring (what tailoring!) in the UK is awful

That if you are fat you have full control to lose the weight and not be fat any more

Slim people are only slim through discipline and not eating as much as fatties, theres no such thing as 'naturally slim' people

But equally people who are underweight/slim just cant put weight on even if they want to, they dont have any control over this

Being a little bit overweight can protect you, but equally kill you.

People still define themselves via their size or weight and are surprised when others dont.

🤣👏😍

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 10:14

Wanderingowl · 21/02/2023 10:02

Having above average levels of muscle mass is most likely far more effective than having excess body fat as a protective factor in the majority of diseases. It certainly appears to slow down both ageing and the effects of ageing. It significantly decreases both the chances of falling and the very significant risk to mortality that a fall entails in the elderly.

Anyone who wants to live a long healthy life should be aiming to maintain body fat levels that are ideally on the lower side of healthy while exercising to increase, then maintain, very healthy levels of muscle, while also working towards functional flexibility and healthy joints. The best way to maintain joints is to ensure balance in muscle building so joints are used evenly.

Yes so these slightly overweight elderly people I'm talking about still have full mobility low falls risk even with very severe dementia. I think good muscle mass is the key.

Comedycook · 21/02/2023 10:11

Smoothlines · 21/02/2023 10:06

But it’s the “skinny” who are suffering the rather nasty, judgmental, sneery comments -so perhaps it’s true that those who make such comments are failing in their morals.

Nonsense. Fat people get way more abuse hurled at them than thin people. The odd comment a thin person might encounter usually come from a place or either jealousy/admiration/concern. The comments made to fat people are pure venom and spite.

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 10:11

I think a normal BMI is optimum unless you have large amounts of muscle mass. Either underweight/overweight isn't healthy really. The NHS spends a fortune on both obesity and underweight.

Smoothlines · 21/02/2023 10:06

Comedycook · 21/02/2023 10:00

The problem is being overweight is seen in our society as being a moral failing. Therefore those who aren't often view themselves as morally superior.

But it’s the “skinny” who are suffering the rather nasty, judgmental, sneery comments -so perhaps it’s true that those who make such comments are failing in their morals.

TheOrigRights · 21/02/2023 10:06

Yarrawonga · 21/02/2023 09:49

I get an 8 (or even a 6..daft) from Next and again, it's fine.

Don’t you think that as an average person it’s a bit silly that a Next size 6 will fit you. It’s the smallest size they sell.

I’m smaller than average but by no means “skinny” or “tiny” and have had to give up shopping in Next and M&S unless I want a scarf or something similar because none of their clothes fit me.

I was responding to a PP who suggested clothes were made for the average person, and said that I think I am that 'average' person, except I am not average in height (taller) or weight (slimmer), so yes, I agree with you entirely.

Wanderingowl · 21/02/2023 10:02

Having above average levels of muscle mass is most likely far more effective than having excess body fat as a protective factor in the majority of diseases. It certainly appears to slow down both ageing and the effects of ageing. It significantly decreases both the chances of falling and the very significant risk to mortality that a fall entails in the elderly.

Anyone who wants to live a long healthy life should be aiming to maintain body fat levels that are ideally on the lower side of healthy while exercising to increase, then maintain, very healthy levels of muscle, while also working towards functional flexibility and healthy joints. The best way to maintain joints is to ensure balance in muscle building so joints are used evenly.

Comedycook · 21/02/2023 10:00

The problem is being overweight is seen in our society as being a moral failing. Therefore those who aren't often view themselves as morally superior.

Wanderingowl · 21/02/2023 09:57

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 09:49

I was talking about the very elderly and not obese but overweight so BMI between 25-29. The healthiest is a healthy BMI of course neither extreme is healthy.

The Chinese study doesn't stand up to scrutiny either. It has a mean grouping of age 93 for people at the beginning of the study and doesn't control for how many overweight and obese people actually make it into their 80s. Taking people who have reached that age as a starting point, again makes it ridiculous in determining the healthiest weight for longevity.

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 09:56

KirstenBlest · 21/02/2023 09:53

@Feefee00 , not many very elderly people are obese.

I didn't say obese did I ? Yes there are overweight elderly people I work in that sector. We are more concerned with those who stop eating and need top up nutrition Vs those who are a bit overweight.

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 09:55

www.uea.ac.uk/news/-/article/how-the-body-uses-fat-to-fight-infection

Fighting off infection uses large amounts of energy to power the immune system. Your appetite also further reduces when ill. Neither extremes are beneficial for good health.

bellac11 · 21/02/2023 09:55

So what have I gleaned from this thread

That no matter what size you are, shops never really have enough of your size on the shelves and in any case the cut and tailoring (what tailoring!) in the UK is awful

That if you are fat you have full control to lose the weight and not be fat any more

Slim people are only slim through discipline and not eating as much as fatties, theres no such thing as 'naturally slim' people

But equally people who are underweight/slim just cant put weight on even if they want to, they dont have any control over this

Being a little bit overweight can protect you, but equally kill you.

People still define themselves via their size or weight and are surprised when others dont.

KirstenBlest · 21/02/2023 09:53

@Feefee00 , not many very elderly people are obese.

kittycreative · 21/02/2023 09:52

This is absolutely true!

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 09:49

Wanderingowl · 21/02/2023 09:40

Excess weight was a significant risk factor in Covid mortality as the virus was able to evade the immune system by hiding in adipose tissue, where it multiplied more rapidly. Anecdotes are not science.

I was talking about the very elderly and not obese but overweight so BMI between 25-29. The healthiest is a healthy BMI of course neither extreme is healthy.

KirstenBlest · 21/02/2023 09:49

Oh, sorry, it might not have been you.
Search engines will show all sorts of results, and not necessarily scientific proof of what someone said that fat reserves were beneficial to fighting infection.

Yarrawonga · 21/02/2023 09:49

I get an 8 (or even a 6..daft) from Next and again, it's fine.

Don’t you think that as an average person it’s a bit silly that a Next size 6 will fit you. It’s the smallest size they sell.

I’m smaller than average but by no means “skinny” or “tiny” and have had to give up shopping in Next and M&S unless I want a scarf or something similar because none of their clothes fit me.

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 09:47

www.newscientist.com/article/2317296-people-over-80-with-overweight-bmi-may-have-lower-mortality-rates/

Being underweight or overweight obese is never healthy especially when younger. Peddling that underweight is also healthy is wrong , your immune system becomes less able to fight off infections.

Wanderingowl · 21/02/2023 09:41

Comedycook · 21/02/2023 09:39

The search result will show you the research that has been done....

I never mentioned any thin models or actresses so I have no idea why you're specifically asking me to name some.

Read the post above yours, any study on over all mortality that excludes cancer deaths is worthless.

Wanderingowl · 21/02/2023 09:40

Feefee00 · 21/02/2023 09:38

Yes I've read it I've also seen it in practice. My long stay hospital during covid we lost many to COVID. A gentleman caught it three times he was a bit overweight in his late 80s still didn't pass away. I really think the weight was a protective factor.

Excess weight was a significant risk factor in Covid mortality as the virus was able to evade the immune system by hiding in adipose tissue, where it multiplied more rapidly. Anecdotes are not science.

Swipe left for the next trending thread