Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Skinny privellege

758 replies

Annabella91 · 20/02/2023 08:40

Why is there shops full of clothes for women who are skinnt but nothing bigger i hate going clothes literally can never find anything in a size 16 it's all size 6 and 8 is the fat back in the 90s discrimination trend coming in again?? Shouldn't need to skinny to look nice??

OP posts:
OopsAnotherOne · 21/02/2023 16:48

Also OP I would just add that it sounds like you're struggling with your body image so you're dismissing your weightloss as "only 2 stone" but please just realise - that's actually a really significant amount of weight to lose and you should be really proud of yourself if you've been working towards losing weight.

2 stone is 28lbs - the average 2 year old toddler is 25lbs (give or take) and you've lost more than that! That's 28 packs of bacon, which when you imagine that many packs of bacon, is a hell of a lot! You really should be proud of yourself for losing 2 stone, especially while postpartum and parenting a newborn. Little steps OP!

clairelouwho · 21/02/2023 16:45

I don’t hold any resentment over other people choosing not to lose weight or not making the restrictive choices I’ve made. Or anything like that.

I am, however, irritated by people who are obese who complain perpetually that society is just not accommodating enough for their size and how they are inconvenienced by society refusing to bend to them. Rather than realising that it is their size that is inconveniencing them and to do something about it.

I get irritated when people want to pretend that obesity isn’t largely a result of over indulgence, poor diet and greed when we know that largely it is. None of those are moral failings. I’ve been obese for my height so I know how easy it is to overeat and make excuses etc. There is an element of greed and to deny that is to deny reality.

Life is easier when you’re slimmer. You have more energy, you feel better in yourself and you run the risk of less health problems. Clothes look better too. That is just the truth and it’s not said to make anyone feel bad but it’s not a privilege. Many work hard to gain and maintain their weight. That isn’t something that has just been handed to anyone.

This us versus them mentality helps no one.

Annabella91 · 21/02/2023 16:44

I'm very emotional at the moment i could sob for hours sometimes.

OP posts:
OopsAnotherOne · 21/02/2023 16:29

YABU to use the term "skinny" to describe people who, more often than not, are perfectly healthy. "Skinny" is described as "unattractively or unusually thin", which is not correct to describe someone who is a size 6 or a size 8.

Comedycook · 21/02/2023 16:18

@chaosmaker so you think it's terrible that some people struggle to put weight on? Well in all honesty, these people are few and far between. Yet people who may struggle to lose weight are just greedy. You really need to stop looking a food as an issue of morality. It's not a failing of these people. We live in a society with plentiful food options yet are still biologically programmed to believe food may be scarce at some point therefore we should eat as much as we can when it's available. However, it's always available. We really need to stop looking at individuals as terrible, moral failures.

chaosmaker · 21/02/2023 16:01

Comedycook · 21/02/2023 07:41

No anger and I'm not directing my posts at thin people. What I find irritating is thin people who play the victim and make out that being thin is just as difficult as being fat in this society. It's like someone with lots of money trying to persuade someone skint that they're struggling too. It's absolute nonsense.

Being fat has definitely gained in popularity and being thin and not being able to put on weight is terrible. I have friends with this problem and while there are conditions and meds that make losing weight hard. Honestly most of it is greed and the awful food that is advertised continually along with 'snack culture' pushed down our throats. Yes, some are obsessed with their size but I would say that is probably more linked with body dismorphia. I think fashion obsession is also unhealthy as there are actual things to worry about in this world.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 21/02/2023 15:55

Annabella91 · 21/02/2023 15:20

I'm wearing jeans and stuff now I stopped wearing pregnancy stuff like 3 weeks ago. I have couple of size 18 jeans and a few tops that fit me I don't like baggy clothes I never have it just depressing when i see other who had babies at the same time that look great but I don't iv only lost 2 stone after birth that's it I'm stuck 3 stone heavier I just need some clothes that look decent until I lose the weight needs to by gone by summer so I can go out on family days out without feeling like a frumpy I hate the way I look at the moment I just want to be slim like I was before.

You haven't only lost 2 stone. That's bloody good going, well done!

Clothes shopping is miserable generally. I placed a huge ASOS order recently and sent all but one thing back because they all looked shit. I'm probably what you'd call skinny but they forget that even if you're slimmer, you still have boobs!

Clothes just aren't the quality they used to be. Regardless of the size.

Don't put yourself down like this. You don't need to.

Swiftbushome · 21/02/2023 15:53

Yep while I massively disagree with the "skinny privilege" there is NO WAY I'd have fitted in my pre-pregnancy clothes at 6 weeks. In fact I'm laughing even thinking about it. I lived in maternity clothes or onesies for a long time.
In fact I went to a wedding 3 months after the birth where someone asked me when I was due! Honestly. I wasn't actually that bothered though. I mean I'd just grown a human. Who cares?? The lady who asked me was more embarrassed than I was. Seriously I think at 6 weeks PP I was still a sweaty, flabby, tearful mess!

Smoothlines · 21/02/2023 15:45

Surely losing two stone since the birth -only six weeks ago! - is great going. Why compare yourself to others? Other people’s weight makes no difference to you. Only you are on your journey. I really think going shopping for new clothes just after you have given birth is a bit crazy. If it makes you feel bad, don’t do it. No one needs new clothes. Surely most women who have just had a baby aren’t actually giving any time to how they look at this stage -they’re too busy. Wait till spring/summer. Or as other have said, there are plenty of shops selling clothes in all sizes if you can’t wait. Or can you do your hair or nails instead if you want to feel you look better -just as a temporary measure?

Everanewbie · 21/02/2023 15:43

Op. Chin up. Some people, me included have disputed your statements about privilege etc. But please don’t beat yourself up. You’ve done something wonderful in bringing a new life into this world and no one feels great after that. I hope you can find some clothes that tide you over. Your weight can be addressed in the coming months. What seems impossible now will be achievable, with, excuse the pun, baby steps. Best wishes x

Annabella91 · 21/02/2023 15:33

I'm jealous that I don't look good at the moment I cry when going shopping makes me feel worthless

OP posts:
Annabella91 · 21/02/2023 15:20

I'm wearing jeans and stuff now I stopped wearing pregnancy stuff like 3 weeks ago. I have couple of size 18 jeans and a few tops that fit me I don't like baggy clothes I never have it just depressing when i see other who had babies at the same time that look great but I don't iv only lost 2 stone after birth that's it I'm stuck 3 stone heavier I just need some clothes that look decent until I lose the weight needs to by gone by summer so I can go out on family days out without feeling like a frumpy I hate the way I look at the moment I just want to be slim like I was before.

OP posts:
Swiftbushome · 21/02/2023 15:19

Oakbeam · Today 15:11

while other people hear “breakfast is the most important meal of the day”

”Breakfast is the most important meal of the day” was a Kellogg’s marketing slogan dating from the 19th century.

Obviously a very effective one.

mind blown

Oakbeam · 21/02/2023 15:11

while other people hear “breakfast is the most important meal of the day”

”Breakfast is the most important meal of the day” was a Kellogg’s marketing slogan dating from the 19th century.

Obviously a very effective one.

Smoothlines · 21/02/2023 14:54

Annabella91 · 21/02/2023 10:35

My thin and uncle and nan bullied me for years about my weight but that's OK because I'm fat I'm not a bad person for saying shops don't cater for above a size 14!

Obviously, being bullied about your weight is dreadful and shouldn’t have happened. But it’s not true to say that shops don’t cater over a size 14. Whether you think saying this untrue thing makes you bad or mentally ill is the point. Most women are not skipping around the shops looking for new clothes in their pre-pregnancy size or thereabouts just six weeks after giving birth. And it’s winter. Everyone’s in baggy jumpers and loose trousers as far as I can see, not denim shorts and vest tops.

Comedycook · 21/02/2023 14:48

I know someone, daughter of a friend who as an adult is 5ft tall and weighs 5 stone

She eats every 2 hours a huge meal. Her life revolves around food

Surely a medical problem?

Kennykenkencat · 21/02/2023 14:39

collosalbrainbearer · 21/02/2023 14:14

I'm pre-disposed to bring skinny/slim/thin and have to make sure I eat extra food so I don't look too underweight

I know someone, daughter of a friend who as an adult is 5ft tall and weighs 5 stone

She eats every 2 hours a huge meal. Her life revolves around food.

People think she has bulimia but she doesn’t. It is a genetic thing as she has relatives on her dads side who have the same thing

Given what I have seen this now woman go through her whole life, whilst people might love the idea of eating anything they want
and still being slim this woman’s life is ruled by food. It costs her not only money but time out of her life.

DiddyHeck · 21/02/2023 14:22

Annabella91 · 21/02/2023 10:35

My thin and uncle and nan bullied me for years about my weight but that's OK because I'm fat I'm not a bad person for saying shops don't cater for above a size 14!

You're not a bad person, but your statement is completely false.

The average size of a UK woman is size 16.

Of course shops cater for them, it's their actual business to make clothes and money.

collosalbrainbearer · 21/02/2023 14:14

PrincessPeach92 · 21/02/2023 13:09

I find that to maintain a slim physique I have to deny myself a lot of things I want to eat. So if I have skinny privilege then fat people have eating privilege where they can really enjoy their food.

I'm pre-disposed to bring skinny/slim/thin and have to make sure I eat extra food so I don't look too underweight

MavisMcMinty · 21/02/2023 13:53

I know of people who eat takeaways never diet abs drink a lot of alcohol but still remain slim also they never exercise they drive everywhere lol slim people don't always work hard to be that way.

I’ll be 60 this year and am still much the same size and weight as 40 years ago. If you saw me eating - lots of lovely crisps and burgers - you’d think I was very lucky to be slim, but the thing is I only eat when I actually feel hungry. I eat what I want when I want, but only when I’m hungry. Don’t feel hungry until I’ve been up for 5 hours, so never eat breakfast, while other people hear “breakfast is the most important meal of the day” so eat it whether or not they’re hungry. Went through a phase of believing it myself, and had a bowl of porridge every morning when I got to work - it just kick-started my appetite and made me eat much more during the day.

Eat when you’re hungry
Drink when you’re dry
If the moonshine don’t get you
You’ll live till you die

5128gap · 21/02/2023 13:51

Seasonofthewitch83 · 21/02/2023 13:33

Just changing the topic slightly here but it seems to be coming up a lot with posters saying 'But I work REALLY hard to stay slim. I deny myself foods. I have to be really disciplined.'

I think people get angry that because THEY have done it, they do not see why allowances should be made for other people to have to navigate life with the same level of respect they receive, or comfort.

Because we are told that 'If you lose weight, you will be more attractive, you will have better luck with finding a partner, you will be more popular.' So the idea of sharing that with someone who hasnt given up what you have, worked as hard as you have, is jarring.

Its one of the reasons there can be such vitriol towards the plus size movement. Because it rejects the idea that you need to be slim to be happy. And that stings to those who feel like they EARNED it.

Yes, I think there's a lot of truth in this. I think there's definitely an element of wanting sacrifice recognised.
However I also think there's some justification when people get irritated at the belief that being slim is a 'privilege'. Couched in such terms it suggests something people should be grateful for and that they should have special empathy and consideration for those less lucky. That they should allow people without that 'privilege' to comment on their bodies using whatever term the non slim person sees fit.
The reality is few of us are fat or thin as a fixed characteristic, as in we were born that way and will die that way. Many of us move from one to the other and maybe back again, with age and life stages. To suggest a woman is privileged because at a certain point in her life she happens to be a size 8 and not a 16, whether through effort or (rarer) 'natural' disposition, is an irritating misuse of the term.

Comedycook · 21/02/2023 13:36

@Seasonofthewitch83 your posts are spot on.

Threads about weight tend to bring up the same opinions. My own view from what I've seen on the threads about weight is that a lot of women are massively proud of being thin/slim. They secretly hate the fact that there are overweight women who don't hate themselves for being overweight.

5128gap · 21/02/2023 13:35

Annabella91 · 21/02/2023 11:42

Thats a lot of crap jeez lol I know of people who eat takeaways never diet abs drink a lot of alcohol but still remain slim also they never exercise they drive everywhere lol slim people don't always work hard to be that way.

I find this very surprising. To know the occasional person maybe. But loads? Pretty much everyone I know who is slim, well, it's fairly obvious why. They may eat takeaways and drink, but they're reducing their overall intake in other ways that may be less apparent, or are very active. Obviously there are variations down to age, sex and frame with bigger younger men able to eat a lot more than smaller older women. But if you compare a bunch of women of the same age, apart from rare exceptions (which these threads attract) the slim ones will take in fewer, or burn more, calories than the heavier ones.
Not eating a lot doesn't make people superior but it does usually make them thinner.

Seasonofthewitch83 · 21/02/2023 13:33

Just changing the topic slightly here but it seems to be coming up a lot with posters saying 'But I work REALLY hard to stay slim. I deny myself foods. I have to be really disciplined.'

I think people get angry that because THEY have done it, they do not see why allowances should be made for other people to have to navigate life with the same level of respect they receive, or comfort.

Because we are told that 'If you lose weight, you will be more attractive, you will have better luck with finding a partner, you will be more popular.' So the idea of sharing that with someone who hasnt given up what you have, worked as hard as you have, is jarring.

Its one of the reasons there can be such vitriol towards the plus size movement. Because it rejects the idea that you need to be slim to be happy. And that stings to those who feel like they EARNED it.

LolaSmiles · 21/02/2023 13:25

PatientlyWaiting21
Agreed!

It's quickly becoming a thread of people with their own weight issues and hangups getting annoyed and viewing everything through that lens. Whilst it might make some posters feel better in the moment it's not terribly healthy.

If anyone, OP or other posters, are so hung up on perpetuating their victim status, they're better off speaking to someone properly to get support with their weight issues. No amount of people objectively unwanted comments about anyone's body are crappy and shops cater to their business model not individual people's preferences and personal build/weight distribution is going to help the people who are wedded to the idea of a conspiracy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread