Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Skinny privellege

758 replies

Annabella91 · 20/02/2023 08:40

Why is there shops full of clothes for women who are skinnt but nothing bigger i hate going clothes literally can never find anything in a size 16 it's all size 6 and 8 is the fat back in the 90s discrimination trend coming in again?? Shouldn't need to skinny to look nice??

OP posts:
Annabella91 · 20/02/2023 15:23

Excuse me don't tell me what to do I feel shit about not being able to get anything nice to wear 6 weeks after giving birth Don't need to be told to diet starve etc.

OP posts:
ElliF · 20/02/2023 15:23

Mitfordian · 20/02/2023 15:17

'Being overweight is not a health risk'. Are you serious?! I get the point that some body fat can have protective effects but being overweight is a compounding factor in all sorts of health issues.

I think what PP was pointing out is that there is a fundamental difference between BMI and ‘body weight’. Muscle is substantially denser than body fat, and two 16st girls can be the exact same weight but be substantially different shapes and in very different states of health. She’s talking about muscle mass not the volume of fat being carried by a person.

Mitfordian · 20/02/2023 15:22

bellac11 · 20/02/2023 15:20

BMI should be split into different ethnicities really because while the average White northern European people might not (might not) suffer too much risk at overweight levels, there is a problem for people from the Indian subcontinent and African Caribbean ethnicities where only being a small amount overweight significantly increases their risk of diabetes and heart disease.

If you look at the NHS website, it is different by race.

bellac11 · 20/02/2023 15:20

BMI should be split into different ethnicities really because while the average White northern European people might not (might not) suffer too much risk at overweight levels, there is a problem for people from the Indian subcontinent and African Caribbean ethnicities where only being a small amount overweight significantly increases their risk of diabetes and heart disease.

Kennykenkencat · 20/02/2023 15:20

GarlicGrace · 20/02/2023 15:14

Old sizes in inches:
10: 32-24-34
12: 34-26-36
14: 36-28-38
16: 38-30-40

So, yes, a 38 inch waist would have been a 24.

Size 10 was always 32” bust, 22” waist and 34” hips

10” difference between bust and waist and 12” difference between waist and hips.

ElliF · 20/02/2023 15:17

@YourApplePie The 'obesity crisis' isn't a simple fix of eat less, move more.

Yes it is.
It’s very basic maths.
And I am most definitely not a thin girl.

No-one is eating cream buns thinking this is good for them. No-on is on their second Zinger burger thinking they are eating a normal portion. No one buys their lunch by the bucket.

No one thinks driving their car to the corner shop is healthier than walking it.

But we are all willing to lie and justify what we do and pretend that ‘society’ or ‘modern living’ or ‘my genetics’ did it.

The food industry spend billions a year on studies to prove that crap food doesn’t make people fat, simple so that they can create confusion and doubt about very basic cause and effect that we have known since the Middle Ages.

40% of the research budge comes from big pharma precisely because if we don’t create enough I’ll people they don’t have customers for their products.

Yes, if calories going in are greater than calories expended you absolutely do get fat. If calories going in are less that calories expended, you absolutely do lose weight. That is why starvation is the rarest cause of death among fat people.

Let’s stop gaslighting about the causes of obesity. Be honest with people and tell the truth. It might help save lives.

Mitfordian · 20/02/2023 15:17

GarlicGrace · 20/02/2023 15:11

Is this the 'you can be fat and healthy' debate?

Blimey, not this now 😬 You can be fat & healthy. In women especially, body fat has quite a few health benefits. Being significantly obese threatens health.

Since I'm one of those (ex) fitness freaks who was labelled obese despite relatively low body fat, I'm aware BMI is an imperfect measure but, if you're one of the exceptions, you'll know. For the rest of us, the overweight section of the chart is not a health risk.

'Being overweight is not a health risk'. Are you serious?! I get the point that some body fat can have protective effects but being overweight is a compounding factor in all sorts of health issues.

YourApplePie · 20/02/2023 15:16

Mitfordian · 20/02/2023 15:05

It's an arbitrary measure and has its limitations, of course. It's not a measure of health generally, it's a weight benchmark and therefore still deemed to be useful in the round.

How does it hinder people? They feel so stigmatised by their high BMI that they can't lose weight? Is this the 'you can be fat and healthy' debate?

I was considering that it hinders people who can't access the medical care they need due to their BMI, even if their weight isn't an issue. Not to mention all of those people trying to fit a scale that was never meant to apply to them anyway.

The key thing is that it's not a measure of health, especially in isolation.

Yarrawonga · 20/02/2023 15:16

It is the size you are.

Exactly!

ImprobablePuffin · 20/02/2023 15:16

TheOrigRights · 20/02/2023 11:07

Staying slim is not some you are born with, except in some rare cases. It’s something you work on.

Don't be ridiculous. Many zillions of people don't actively work on being slim, unless you have an odd definition of slim and work.

Many zillions? Gosh that's more than I realised

bellac11 · 20/02/2023 15:16

GarlicGrace · 20/02/2023 15:14

Old sizes in inches:
10: 32-24-34
12: 34-26-36
14: 36-28-38
16: 38-30-40

So, yes, a 38 inch waist would have been a 24.

Thats interesting

And that chart is from the 80s, was it even smaller in the 50s and 60s?

Yarrawonga · 20/02/2023 15:15

Does anyone know what a size 10 was in 2010's and what that size is today?

I don’t think it has changed. I’m not a 10 but I have clothes from back then that still fit, and the labels say the same size I am now.

GarlicGrace · 20/02/2023 15:15

TrainedObserver · 20/02/2023 15:13

From reading the thread it’s clear which size is discriminated against and is never in stock.

It is the size you are.

😂

GarlicGrace · 20/02/2023 15:14

bellac11 · 20/02/2023 15:07

So a size 20 on that chart has a waist of 39 inches

Do you mean that a waist of 39 inches would originally have been a size 24?

Old sizes in inches:
10: 32-24-34
12: 34-26-36
14: 36-28-38
16: 38-30-40

So, yes, a 38 inch waist would have been a 24.

tirednewmumm · 20/02/2023 15:14

Erm I'm your age and shop in M and S for basics and workwear!

Carlycat · 20/02/2023 15:13

' Skinny Privilege ' 🙄
Get a grip

TrainedObserver · 20/02/2023 15:13

From reading the thread it’s clear which size is discriminated against and is never in stock.

It is the size you are.

Seasonofthewitch83 · 20/02/2023 15:12

Everanewbie · 20/02/2023 15:06

I don't think shouting energy in v energy out is the message key to solving the obesity crisis, but it is how weightloss is ultimately achieved.

The problem is that we as a nation underestimate how much we are consuming due to the unfulfilling calorie dense foods that are cheap and easy. Starbucks is a great example. We go for a coffee and think nothing of it, but a pumpkin spiced mocha chocca whatever can have the same calorie content as a full meal. If you have a slice of millionaire shortbread with it, you're pretty much halfway through that days calorie allowance without really being full. Likewise, an americano served black is zero, thats the sort of choice slimmer people tend to make.

I'm not saying that making that choice every time is how people should live their lives, but just have that knowledge of a rough calorie budget and try to live within that. If you struggle to make those choices subconsciously and are not prepared to give your consumption a second thought, well you wont lose weight.

I don't want to see those who wont make that commitment bullied and given a hard time, but to to call those who take the hard decisions and use their will power privileged is insulting.

There is a great Instagram account aimed at helping people with this, especially those who suffer with binge eating. It shows you just how many calories/fat/protein are in your so called 'healthy choice' and gives you a more filling alternative that you are more likely to stick with long term, or better options if you are going to binge to try and keep a lid on it.
Diets like Slimming World completely distort peoples ideas of what a healthy balanced diet looks like.

GarlicGrace · 20/02/2023 15:11

Is this the 'you can be fat and healthy' debate?

Blimey, not this now 😬 You can be fat & healthy. In women especially, body fat has quite a few health benefits. Being significantly obese threatens health.

Since I'm one of those (ex) fitness freaks who was labelled obese despite relatively low body fat, I'm aware BMI is an imperfect measure but, if you're one of the exceptions, you'll know. For the rest of us, the overweight section of the chart is not a health risk.

Everanewbie · 20/02/2023 15:08

BMI is a good starting point. If you are particularly muscly as in a rugby player or body builder BMI might not be good for you. But its small adjustments. You're not a healthy weight at BMI of 30 because you are big boned.

bellac11 · 20/02/2023 15:07

GarlicGrace · 20/02/2023 14:50

They've gone up by two sizes since the 1980s. Chart in inches.

So a size 20 on that chart has a waist of 39 inches

Do you mean that a waist of 39 inches would originally have been a size 24?

Okunevo · 20/02/2023 15:06

Okunevo · 20/02/2023 15:02

I'd say most underweight adults are underweight because they are unwell. Some, just slightly underweight it may be their build.

In the UK in 2023 I mean

Everanewbie · 20/02/2023 15:06

I don't think shouting energy in v energy out is the message key to solving the obesity crisis, but it is how weightloss is ultimately achieved.

The problem is that we as a nation underestimate how much we are consuming due to the unfulfilling calorie dense foods that are cheap and easy. Starbucks is a great example. We go for a coffee and think nothing of it, but a pumpkin spiced mocha chocca whatever can have the same calorie content as a full meal. If you have a slice of millionaire shortbread with it, you're pretty much halfway through that days calorie allowance without really being full. Likewise, an americano served black is zero, thats the sort of choice slimmer people tend to make.

I'm not saying that making that choice every time is how people should live their lives, but just have that knowledge of a rough calorie budget and try to live within that. If you struggle to make those choices subconsciously and are not prepared to give your consumption a second thought, well you wont lose weight.

I don't want to see those who wont make that commitment bullied and given a hard time, but to to call those who take the hard decisions and use their will power privileged is insulting.

Mitfordian · 20/02/2023 15:05

YourApplePie · 20/02/2023 14:54

I'm not an expert on it, it doesn't keep me awake at night. But a quick Google suggests it was only ever 50% accurate, doesn't account for all the changes in lifestyle in the last 200 years (can't get middle-aged spread if you die in your mid 30s) and never accounted for women and non-white people.

It seems to hinder more people than it helps.

It's an arbitrary measure and has its limitations, of course. It's not a measure of health generally, it's a weight benchmark and therefore still deemed to be useful in the round.

How does it hinder people? They feel so stigmatised by their high BMI that they can't lose weight? Is this the 'you can be fat and healthy' debate?

Okunevo · 20/02/2023 15:02

collosalbrainbearer · 20/02/2023 14:59

So you were unwell- how does that magically become 'most people'Confused

I'd say most underweight adults are underweight because they are unwell. Some, just slightly underweight it may be their build.