Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About not moving on the train?

358 replies

TrainSitu · 19/02/2023 16:13

I’ve recently had shoulder surgery but I am now out of a sling so I guess I don’t look injured. I’m sat at a table seat on the train to get back to my work area after visiting my dad.

I’ve got my backpack on the table and my big bag was put up on the top by a lovely man who offered to put it up. We get to the next station and it’s absolutely heaving and a mother with 3 kids gets on. Everyone files into seats and someone sits opposite me. She then approaches and asks if the other 2 seats are reserved. I said no and she could have them and sat the kids down. She then looks and me and say says “I’ve got 3 children who need a seat please can they have yours” I said no I’ve recently had shoulder surgery and still recovering so standing on a packed train would be too painful. She then continually said “ I have 3 kids though”

At this point I said “I’m not particularly bothered by the amount of kids you have but I will be staying in this seat as I need it too if you have any issues please go speak to the train conductor” The look she gave me could kill!

So AIBU for not moving? The original guy who put my bag in the overhead rack ended up telling her to leave me alone as she kept repeating about her 3 kids. I feel like a cow bag but a justified one!

NC for this so it can’t be linked to any previous threads.

OP posts:
Xol · 20/02/2023 10:42

ancientgran · 20/02/2023 09:18

The mother might already have a 2 year old on her lap or like someone I know she might have 2 year old twins on her lap and a 3 year old wobbling about.

Honestly, how wobbly are these 3 year olds? My cousin has a similar situation, she'd just get the older child to hold on tight and maybe lean against her.

Xol · 20/02/2023 10:39

ancientgran · 20/02/2023 09:15

You're right, for most medical appointments I'm asked if x time and date works and I very rarely have an appointment that can't be changed. I avoid busy times although I am driving not getting buses, I live near a primary school and definitely avoid having to leave when we have the school run chaos.

How easy do you find it to change medical appointments at the last minute just because you couldn't get on the train to get yourself there because you deemed it more important for a child to do so? And how well does it go down with your local doctor or hospital that you have wasted an appointment that someone else could have used?

Catspyjamas17 · 20/02/2023 10:39

I thought this was going to be about not moving down a busy train because if you go any further there is nothing to hold onto (and you are pretty much in the middle of the carriage anyway).

Xol · 20/02/2023 10:37

Don't know who taught you to drive, my instructor taught me that you drive using your gears and should only need to break suddenly if someone runs out in front if you leave a proper gap between you and the car in front.

My instructor taught me that I might need to brake suddenly if, for example, a bike suddenly cuts in front of me or someone shoots out of a side turning without looking. It doesn't happen often, but it's much more of a risk than a train suddenly stopping. And if a train does have to do an emergency stop, the chances are that you will go flying even if you're sitting down.

Xol · 20/02/2023 10:34

Grumpybutfunny · 20/02/2023 08:50

@Wafflington it not about pain tho is it, it's about safety. I'm quite often in pain from old injuries or sports but I chose to do those sports which means I suffer in silence. DS was an emergency section that means my pelvis has never healed properly it doesn't give me a right to complain and demand a seat i just get on with it.

I've never had any problems rearranging appointments to a time that suits, so the elderly can do the same over risking a child getting hurt.

It's not a matter of demanding a seat, you were talking about a scenario where there is one seat available and who you would offer it to. You would rather a pregnant woman stand in agony than expect a parent to take their own steps to ensure the safety of their small child? It's not as if trains are that dangerous for small children - as has been pointed out, sudden stops are rare. For all you know, an elderly person may if anything be more unsteady on their feet than a child - doesn't their safety count?

As for "never had any problems rearranging appointments" - don't be silly. I've just had a medical appointment cancelled by our local large hospital, the first replacement they could offer me was in June. There is no way I would take all the trouble to go to the station to get the train for a similar appointment, buy a ticket, and then just decide I'd bin the appointment because the train looked a bit full and a child needed to get on.

BellatrixLestrangesHeatedCurlers · 20/02/2023 10:27

Oh I can almost hear her say it.. "I have free kids dough. I got free kids. Gimme yor seat I got free kids."

ToriLynn · 20/02/2023 10:17

I have 3 under 3 and wouldn't dream of getting on a train with them all without reserving at least 2 seats, if she chose to travel with 3 kids and no reserved seats then that's her problem! You were absolutely within your rights to stay in the seat as you were there first!

lieselotte · 20/02/2023 10:14

As for rearranging medical appointments, it's laughable to say you can just change them. Maybe if you go privately (which no doubt is a little detail you didn't give). If it's an NHS hospital appointment, you will be waiting another six months. At least.

lieselotte · 20/02/2023 10:12

The mother might already have a 2 year old on her lap or like someone I know she might have 2 year old twins on her lap and a 3 year old wobbling about

Not sure why someone else's decision to have lots of kids means a vulnerable adult (even temporarily vulnerable after an operation) should give up their seat.

lieselotte · 20/02/2023 10:10

the elderly have all day to wait for a quieter train who says? Just because you're not doing paid work doesn't mean you don't have other commitments!

lieselotte · 20/02/2023 10:10

I think children under six are very vulnerable on a crowded train. If it stops suddenly they would go flying

So could anyone who is standing. And children tend to bounce. Unlike more vulnerable adults.

Grumpybutfunny · 20/02/2023 09:25

BlueHeelers · 20/02/2023 09:19

the elderly have all day to wait for a quieter train

What do you mean by this @Grumpybutfunny ? "The elderly" may still be working, may have things to do on a timetable not of their choosing, may simply be PART OF SOCIETY

We're told All.The.Time that "children are part of society' - well so are "the elderly."

You wait - you'd better hope you become one of "the elderly" because the alternative is worse. Meanwhile, have some empathy for someone whose age means that they tire more easily and maybe less strong than you or a small child.

They maybe but they need to adapt and travel at times when it is safe for them. The only elderly I know still working are doing it for pocket money so happy to drive everywhere. Me and DH have a very tight held view that if we do get so old we can't function on our own I.e we would drive over getting the train or stand then we simply don't want to be here.

In my view standing in a train isn't safe for children and as the youngest in society they are our future so need protection no matter the cost to other adults. I would much rather see an adult get hurt than a kid get crushed. As for taking away pain by putting kids at risk nope should never ever happen in my book.

BlueHeelers · 20/02/2023 09:19

the elderly have all day to wait for a quieter train

What do you mean by this @Grumpybutfunny ? "The elderly" may still be working, may have things to do on a timetable not of their choosing, may simply be PART OF SOCIETY

We're told All.The.Time that "children are part of society' - well so are "the elderly."

You wait - you'd better hope you become one of "the elderly" because the alternative is worse. Meanwhile, have some empathy for someone whose age means that they tire more easily and maybe less strong than you or a small child.

ancientgran · 20/02/2023 09:18

BlueHeelers · 19/02/2023 21:34

But if you and your 4 year old were both seated and full-fare paying adults were standing you might well get your 4 year old onto your lap to allow an adult to sit down. That would be the mannerly thing to do, which would also help to raise your child to have awareness and consideration for those around him/her.

The mother might already have a 2 year old on her lap or like someone I know she might have 2 year old twins on her lap and a 3 year old wobbling about.

ancientgran · 20/02/2023 09:15

Grumpybutfunny · 20/02/2023 08:50

@Wafflington it not about pain tho is it, it's about safety. I'm quite often in pain from old injuries or sports but I chose to do those sports which means I suffer in silence. DS was an emergency section that means my pelvis has never healed properly it doesn't give me a right to complain and demand a seat i just get on with it.

I've never had any problems rearranging appointments to a time that suits, so the elderly can do the same over risking a child getting hurt.

You're right, for most medical appointments I'm asked if x time and date works and I very rarely have an appointment that can't be changed. I avoid busy times although I am driving not getting buses, I live near a primary school and definitely avoid having to leave when we have the school run chaos.

ancientgran · 20/02/2023 09:12

Againstmachine · 19/02/2023 21:09

So if it's that dangerous that kids will go flying why should I put myself in danger of going flying to protect someone I don't know kids.

Nah thanks to you are being redicolous as trains brake less than cars and if you have never braked suddenly in a car either you rarely drive or you are a liar.

If you are a healthy adult you will be more able to balance and hold on than a small 4 or 5 year old child.

Don't know who taught you to drive, my instructor taught me that you drive using your gears and should only need to break suddenly if someone runs out in front if you leave a proper gap between you and the car in front. I realise people don't seem to be taught this now as people have such trouble leaving gaps. My husband was on the motorway one day when there was a pile up in front and behind him. He didn't hit the car in front of him as he'd left the correct space between them, unfortunately the idiot behind him was to close and hit him, DH still didn't hit the car in front of him.

If you are breaking hard frequently you have a problem with your driving.

Wafflington · 20/02/2023 08:55

Grumpybutfunny · 20/02/2023 08:50

@Wafflington it not about pain tho is it, it's about safety. I'm quite often in pain from old injuries or sports but I chose to do those sports which means I suffer in silence. DS was an emergency section that means my pelvis has never healed properly it doesn't give me a right to complain and demand a seat i just get on with it.

I've never had any problems rearranging appointments to a time that suits, so the elderly can do the same over risking a child getting hurt.

I would love to see the look on my midwives face, or my grandads doctor, if I told them "sorry I can't make my next appointment at 9am, can you reschedule it for me so some woman's precious child can have a seat on the bus?"

Do jog on, you're being ridiculous

Grumpybutfunny · 20/02/2023 08:50

@Wafflington it not about pain tho is it, it's about safety. I'm quite often in pain from old injuries or sports but I chose to do those sports which means I suffer in silence. DS was an emergency section that means my pelvis has never healed properly it doesn't give me a right to complain and demand a seat i just get on with it.

I've never had any problems rearranging appointments to a time that suits, so the elderly can do the same over risking a child getting hurt.

Wafflington · 20/02/2023 08:40

UdoU · 19/02/2023 22:24

Is this always a no no? I occasionally ask the general carriage to get up for a pregnant woman. They always thank me, but maybe I’m overstepping? I am a woman.

Some people are absorbed in their phones etc and probably don't always notice if a pregnant woman/elderly/etc gets on - doesn't always mean they wouldn't give up their seat if asked, just they haven't realised. Tbh I don't think a polite prompt is rude in that situation, so long as if someone says "sorry I also cannot stand for XYZ" their wishes are respected...

Wafflington · 20/02/2023 08:35

Grumpybutfunny · 19/02/2023 19:54

Interesting I would give up my seat for all of the above but if only one seat was left I would give it to the child. The baby is safely in a bubble of water, the elderly have all day to wait for a quieter train where as the child is at greater risk of injury of the train breaks suddenly or people keep pushing. I would also be tempted to say to one of the kids sit on the end of the table and hold on as that seems safer than standing. The logistic of getting kids off a train mean you don't really want to split up a family

Then I, as a 7 month pregnant woman with pgp, would kindly have told you to bugger off - and probably resulted in a nearly identical thread to this being posted. I will give my seat up to someone who is disabled and in greater need than I, or very elderly, but I'm not standing up in agony for a child 🙄

Xol · 20/02/2023 07:58

Grumpybutfunny · 19/02/2023 19:54

Interesting I would give up my seat for all of the above but if only one seat was left I would give it to the child. The baby is safely in a bubble of water, the elderly have all day to wait for a quieter train where as the child is at greater risk of injury of the train breaks suddenly or people keep pushing. I would also be tempted to say to one of the kids sit on the end of the table and hold on as that seems safer than standing. The logistic of getting kids off a train mean you don't really want to split up a family

All rather odd. The issue with pregnant women is not the safety of the baby, it's the fact that the mother may well be in considerable pain given the effect of pregnancy on the ligaments and the fact that, surprise surprise, they're carrying a baby plus a placenta and a load of fluid.

How do you know that the elderly have all day to wait? They may be going to urgent appointments, they may be going to work, and once they're on the train anyway that is it totally irrelevant.

On the other hand, the small child is there with an adult who can have them on their lap or keep them safe while standing.

Datafan55 · 20/02/2023 07:27

UdoU · 19/02/2023 22:24

Is this always a no no? I occasionally ask the general carriage to get up for a pregnant woman. They always thank me, but maybe I’m overstepping? I am a woman.

I suppose it depends on yours or the sickly blokes motives, to be fair then :-)

Yes some people are oblivious and need a prompt. Someone could get on with blood dripping from them and some people still wouldn't notice.
But, as we know, men do like to try and be in charge.
Sickly bloke could have meant well (although the fact he was asking only a woman to move instead of a bloke influenced me to think 'managing').

UdoU · 19/02/2023 22:24

Datafan55 · 19/02/2023 17:58

What was the sickly bloke doing asking anyway....? I know some people are oblivious to those around them, but nor do we need to be needlessly managed by random men, thank you so much.

Is this always a no no? I occasionally ask the general carriage to get up for a pregnant woman. They always thank me, but maybe I’m overstepping? I am a woman.

DNBU · 19/02/2023 22:08

Of course YANBU
Can’t believe she asked more than once.

Cosyblankets · 19/02/2023 22:02

BlueHeelers · 19/02/2023 21:34

But if you and your 4 year old were both seated and full-fare paying adults were standing you might well get your 4 year old onto your lap to allow an adult to sit down. That would be the mannerly thing to do, which would also help to raise your child to have awareness and consideration for those around him/her.

This!
No wonder some youngsters are so entitled!