Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About not moving on the train?

358 replies

TrainSitu · 19/02/2023 16:13

I’ve recently had shoulder surgery but I am now out of a sling so I guess I don’t look injured. I’m sat at a table seat on the train to get back to my work area after visiting my dad.

I’ve got my backpack on the table and my big bag was put up on the top by a lovely man who offered to put it up. We get to the next station and it’s absolutely heaving and a mother with 3 kids gets on. Everyone files into seats and someone sits opposite me. She then approaches and asks if the other 2 seats are reserved. I said no and she could have them and sat the kids down. She then looks and me and say says “I’ve got 3 children who need a seat please can they have yours” I said no I’ve recently had shoulder surgery and still recovering so standing on a packed train would be too painful. She then continually said “ I have 3 kids though”

At this point I said “I’m not particularly bothered by the amount of kids you have but I will be staying in this seat as I need it too if you have any issues please go speak to the train conductor” The look she gave me could kill!

So AIBU for not moving? The original guy who put my bag in the overhead rack ended up telling her to leave me alone as she kept repeating about her 3 kids. I feel like a cow bag but a justified one!

NC for this so it can’t be linked to any previous threads.

OP posts:
ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 20/02/2023 15:31

YANBU!

and I say that as a mother of 7.
it's ok to ask people if they'd mind moving - done that, been asked that. no issues.
but to insist after you gave them a very valid reason?
that's just rude and selfish.

please don't feel bad.

Fuckthatguy · 20/02/2023 15:28

Haven’t RTFT but having multiple children myself, she should have given them the seats and stood herself.

I also make the smaller ones share a seat and if they don’t like it they can stand.

@SlaveToTheVibe I once knew a woman who spoke like @ShakespearesBlister , she really was a bitter old thing.

We sometimes felt sorry for her as she had few friends, and was very unpopular in the office. Mostly we avoided her as she was too unpleasant to engage with.

SlaveToTheVibe · 20/02/2023 15:14

ShakespearesBlister · 19/02/2023 16:24

If she kept repeating that to me my response would be along the lines of 'so what do you want, a medal for opening your legs?

How disgusting of you to even consider saying such a thing.

Fink · 20/02/2023 15:11

I was standing on a packed tube a few days ago seething at a couple of families - 1 had a toddler in a separate seat who could easily have sat on one of the parent's lap, another had older children fighting over which of them got seats, the parent already had one. I wouldn't have taken their seats anyway because I had a child in a pushchair so could only have taken a corner seat, but there were plenty of other people who could have used one and looked in more need.

IMO, if there are no spare seats then a child small enough to sit on an adult's lap should do so (or stand if they don't want to) and a child too big for that is old enough to stand. Obviously some kids have invisible disabilites too, but in general that would be my rule. I did break it twice recently: once we'd had a really long journey and I'd had a seat when teenage DD stood, so on the next train I let her have the only spare seat and I stood; and when taking my toddler niece I let her have a seat and I stood because she was overtired and under the weather and I wanted to avoid disturbing everyone with a tantrum (there were actually a few spare seats that time but not two together and I obviously couldn't leave her). But in both cases we only took up one seat between us. What bothers me is a family insisting on taking up multiple seats so that all the adults and children can sit even though other people have to stand.

SleepingStandingUp · 20/02/2023 14:50

Tricky34 · 20/02/2023 14:37

I wouldn’t have asked, I would have sat one of my kids on my knee if they were small enough or gave them my seat & stood. Some people are just rude! Good for you for standing your ground x

They're was as moment when I thought you were going to put one of your kids in OPs knee then...

SleepingStandingUp · 20/02/2023 14:48

BungleandGeorge · 19/02/2023 18:16

I’m confused about whether she asked you to give up your seat (and have to stand) or whether she asked you to move position because you were sitting as a lone person in a position Designed for groups? If there are limited groups of 4 I wouldn’t take one as a single person.

So with a poorly shoulder, you'd stand up and risk injury rather than sit in a 4 person table seat even though you'd be quite happy to let someone past you to sit down? Why?

Livpool · 20/02/2023 14:39

YANBU

She was being cheeky and obviously thought you were a soft touch. I've got a sciatica flare up at the moment and if I was sitting I wouldn't get up either

Tricky34 · 20/02/2023 14:37

I wouldn’t have asked, I would have sat one of my kids on my knee if they were small enough or gave them my seat & stood. Some people are just rude! Good for you for standing your ground x

AnnieSaxophone · 20/02/2023 14:34

I don’t understand why you should stand and she should sit. Why can’t she stand? Why does having 3 children give her the auto right to sit down - at all in anyone’s seat?

JoeMaplin · 20/02/2023 14:22

I’ve taught my children to stand if someone needs a seat! In face whilst out with my 23 year old son, the other day, he asked a lady in Specsavers if she’d like to sit (clearly not prompted by me of course, as he’s an adult). I would have prompted my 12 year old son to do the same.

ALongHardWinter · 20/02/2023 14:17

Totally agree with you.

Rugbyballhead · 20/02/2023 14:15

You were right to look after yourself! There's no point in risking damaging your shoulder and you were sat there first, after all.

Shelefttheweb · 20/02/2023 14:14

ShakespearesBlister · 19/02/2023 16:24

If she kept repeating that to me my response would be along the lines of 'so what do you want, a medal for opening your legs?

Whilst I think a child over 10 is perfectly capable of standing, I find this sort of response disgusting. It suggests children have no rights or agency of their own. They might be her children but they are also individuals in their own right.

bathsh3ba · 20/02/2023 14:00

I've travelled on public transport as a single mum with 2 kids since they were 4 and 6, they're now teens. I've never once asked someone to move for them. I've had one or both on my lap, I've stood so they can sit, and I've stood so I can keep an eye on them both when they had to sit separately. And I've stood with them when there was nowhere to sit and made sure they could hold on to me if need be. It wouldn't occur to me to ask someone to move for them, very odd.

Tinkerbyebye · 20/02/2023 13:59

Wow she was entitled. I was always taught as a child to give my seat up. Why couldn’t all three share the two seats if she was that worried

whynotwhatknot · 20/02/2023 13:59

under 5's go free still dont they-so why shold they get their own seat-and dont say because they could fall over

we all coped as kids

FancyFran · 20/02/2023 13:57

I am having to use a walking stick at the moment whilst I wait for a new treatment.
It is obvious I am disabled. I got on a train last week for work and no one asked if I wanted a seat. It was full of healthy kids. My parents would have whooped my arse. I eventually found a seat hogger with a bag next to her. Prior to that the train manager advised me to ask able bodied people to vacate the disabled spaces and I would have done with no qualms. Bloody people.

amusedbush · 20/02/2023 13:56

YANBU. Like PPs, I was always made to sit on my mum's knee/stand on public transport when an adult needed a seat.

DH and I were on a local bus while abroad in 2019. I have mobility issues and a chronic pain condition so I was struggling to stand, and was relieved when someone vacated a seat next to me. To explain the logistics of the next part, the seats at the rear of the bus were on a platform. Just before that was a (vacant) wheelchair space, so the first two raised seats had nothing in front of them, just a horizontal rail at chest height.

I had my foot on the step when a woman said, "quick, go and get that seat!" to a child of about 7 or 8. The kid slipped under the railing at breakneck speed and practically shoved me over as I went to sit down. Her mum (who had a seat btw!) just stared at me, too Hmm

Blossomtoes · 20/02/2023 13:51

Hbh17 · 19/02/2023 16:17

YANBU. As children, our parents always made us stand on public transport if adults needed a seat. I don't see any reason why that should have changed.

This. I was made to get up so an adult could sit down numerous times as a child. Cheeky cow.

celticprincess · 20/02/2023 13:49

You did the right thing. Maybe you should get a sunflower lanyard to wear when travelling? Just an idea.

Im an adult with kids but also a long standing back issue meaning I can’t stand for more than about 20 minutes without being in agony. I dread busy trains as sometimes people look at me thinking I should give up my seat for either the elderly or the children!!

The lady should have booked her seats for herself and 3 children. When travelled recently we weren’t able to book but that’s just bad luck sometimes.

I’d have my kids sharing or taking turns to be honest. Mine are both older. One autistic but doesn’t look it. She gets stressed easily but would be more than capable of swapping with her sibling now and shin or finding a spot on the floor.

When did kids outrank adults in the seat situations these days? I was brought up as a child to always give up a seat to an adult - and not necessarily an elderly or disabled looking one. On a short journey I’d expect my kids to give up their seat. But on a long journey of several hours we would keep our seats should we have found them. But I wouldn’t be expecting an adult to give up their seat for my child. On a shorter journey I’d prompt my kid to let an adult sit down.

FictionalCharacter · 20/02/2023 13:46

Hbh17 · 19/02/2023 16:17

YANBU. As children, our parents always made us stand on public transport if adults needed a seat. I don't see any reason why that should have changed.

I agree. As a kid I was made to stand for older people, and generally be very polite and courteous to them. Now I’m an older person myself, kids barge in front of me and grab seats!

soboredoflooking · 20/02/2023 13:40

She was a cheeky git! She shouldn't have asked u to move and u shldnt have had to explain. The fact she still badgered u after that well she's nuts. Also as a few others have said she cld have sat her kids down and stuff instead. Or squeezed in. I could easily fit myself and 2 kids on 2 seats. Maybe not if they were older than 19 but still!

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/02/2023 13:36

Xol · 20/02/2023 07:58

All rather odd. The issue with pregnant women is not the safety of the baby, it's the fact that the mother may well be in considerable pain given the effect of pregnancy on the ligaments and the fact that, surprise surprise, they're carrying a baby plus a placenta and a load of fluid.

How do you know that the elderly have all day to wait? They may be going to urgent appointments, they may be going to work, and once they're on the train anyway that is it totally irrelevant.

On the other hand, the small child is there with an adult who can have them on their lap or keep them safe while standing.

This! 👆 @Grumpybutfunny

don’t know how you could argue with that.

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/02/2023 13:33

Scalottia · 20/02/2023 12:00

So essentially you are saying the elderly/people without young children should make all of their appointments at a time that suits those with young children. Right, got it.

Can you see how ridiculous you are being?

@Grumpybutfunny

you are being ridiculous

DanseAvecLesLoup · 20/02/2023 13:29

Many years ago I had to travel to attend my grandfathers funeral in Ireland. At the time I was working offshore in Angola. Irish funerals tend to take place very quickly after someone has passed away so it was a race against the clock to get back in time. I had to get a helicopter from the rig to Lunada, pick up some gear from my accommodation, very slow drive to the airport as Luanda traffic is famously gridlocked, flight to Lisbon, Lisbon to London and then London to Shannon, in all about 22 hours of travel. On the last leg I was shattered, I had a window seat and was out like a light the moment I sat down. I was then woken up by a woman actually poking me "can you move to that seat over there so my husband can sit here". I might have accommodated her request if I was asked politely rather then physically poked and instructed to move. "Sorry no, I have had a very long day". "But I would really like my husband to be sat next to me....please can you move?". I think it was one of the very few times I have just casually told someone to 'fuck off'