Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About not moving on the train?

358 replies

TrainSitu · 19/02/2023 16:13

I’ve recently had shoulder surgery but I am now out of a sling so I guess I don’t look injured. I’m sat at a table seat on the train to get back to my work area after visiting my dad.

I’ve got my backpack on the table and my big bag was put up on the top by a lovely man who offered to put it up. We get to the next station and it’s absolutely heaving and a mother with 3 kids gets on. Everyone files into seats and someone sits opposite me. She then approaches and asks if the other 2 seats are reserved. I said no and she could have them and sat the kids down. She then looks and me and say says “I’ve got 3 children who need a seat please can they have yours” I said no I’ve recently had shoulder surgery and still recovering so standing on a packed train would be too painful. She then continually said “ I have 3 kids though”

At this point I said “I’m not particularly bothered by the amount of kids you have but I will be staying in this seat as I need it too if you have any issues please go speak to the train conductor” The look she gave me could kill!

So AIBU for not moving? The original guy who put my bag in the overhead rack ended up telling her to leave me alone as she kept repeating about her 3 kids. I feel like a cow bag but a justified one!

NC for this so it can’t be linked to any previous threads.

OP posts:
Solonge · 20/02/2023 19:48

I had my grandson for half term and took him to a cinema one afternoon. A bunch of early twenties who reeked of weed were walking down the stairs from the cinema to the shopping centre...they were plonked centrally on the stair case and I had to negotiate moving across to the other bannister. One of the girls turned round and asked if I was ok...one of the blokes piped up 'Oh dont worry about her'. I have to admit I forgot I had my grandson with me and replied 'well you are a piece of shit your mother must be proud of'.... he actually apologised...twice.

Solonge · 20/02/2023 19:45

You could have legitimately said, if you want all three of your children to sit down, I suggest you stand.

TrashyPanda · 20/02/2023 19:20

Skodacool · 20/02/2023 19:17

This is now on Mailonline

Have you got a link?

TrashyPanda · 20/02/2023 19:19

Tbf I don't think the people saying a child would get hurt are talking about on comparison of to someone physically vulnerable but in regards to an able bodied, fit adult

the points made about a child being likely to suffer less injury than an adult are all valid for an able-bodied adult too.

My 7 yo is likely to be daydreaming and not holding on properly

i was using a bus independently from the age of 7. Along with my friends. We all gave up our seats willingly. As buses still had the open rear exit then, we also learned how to jump off before the bus came to a complete stop!

Skodacool · 20/02/2023 19:17

This is now on Mailonline

Skodacool · 20/02/2023 19:16

lieselotte · 20/02/2023 10:14

As for rearranging medical appointments, it's laughable to say you can just change them. Maybe if you go privately (which no doubt is a little detail you didn't give). If it's an NHS hospital appointment, you will be waiting another six months. At least.

Exactly!

Justalittlebitduckling · 20/02/2023 19:12

She should have moved on and targeted someone on a different table. You said no and explained your reason.

It might be worth continuing to wear the sling on public transport though if you are still
feeling vulnerable. Although I once got on a packed train when I was using crutches and no one gave up their seat for me, so…

fetchacloth · 20/02/2023 18:59

PriamFarrl · 19/02/2023 16:35

She wanted you to give up your seat so her kids could sit down? No.

Exactly.
The entitlement of some parents never ceases to amaze me.

DdraigGoch · 20/02/2023 18:57

SlaveToTheVibe · 20/02/2023 15:14

How disgusting of you to even consider saying such a thing.

Fight fire with fire

User8646382 · 20/02/2023 18:55

Stand for a child? You must be joking. My kids were taught to stand for others as soon as they were too big to sit on a knee.

Weren’t the kids of “10+” embarrassed by all this carry on? Mine would have disappeared to the other end of the carriage as soon as I opened my mouth. I somehow don’t think story adds up. I just can’t imagine three great hulking lads sitting there while some poor sod has to give up his seat.

Wafflington · 20/02/2023 18:52

SleepingStandingUp · 20/02/2023 18:46

Tbf I don't think the people saying a child would get hurt are talking about on comparison of to someone physically vulnerable but in regards to an able bodied, fit adult.
My 7 yo is likely to be daydreaming and not holding on properly and no idea how well my 3 yo twins could actually hold on. For a physically vulnerable person I'd leave twins in one seat, make 7 yo stand and I'd stand in front of twins. For a person as for and able as me I wouldn't unless they asked. If DS and I were standing and I'd got the twins pinned into one seat, I reckon there's someone else more able to give up a seat.

Although I appreciate your response and what you would personally do, which are totally responsible things that any sane and normal adult would do, a previous poster quoted me saying she would expect me to stand at 7 months pregnant with pgp so her DC could sit, because her DC are at greater risk of injury than I am. Which is totally batshit imo lol

DdraigGoch · 20/02/2023 18:51

Scalottia · 20/02/2023 12:00

So essentially you are saying the elderly/people without young children should make all of their appointments at a time that suits those with young children. Right, got it.

Can you see how ridiculous you are being?

Peak Mumsnet

Bookegg · 20/02/2023 18:50

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the user's request

SleepingStandingUp · 20/02/2023 18:46

Wafflington · 20/02/2023 18:20

Also think it's bizarre as hell some posters harping on about how badly injured a child might be if a bus/train suddenly brakes. Obviously everyone is at risk of being hurt in this scenario, but I would bet money that the people least likely to be seriously injured are a child, versus the elderly/frail or pregnant women. Not saying a child won't get hurt, but the risk of injury to the elderly will be much greater with things like hip fractures etc from falling, or for a pregnant woman to suffer a placental abruption from hitting her bump. Much less likely to cause serious damage to a child who might take a tumble (although still unpleasant for them naturally) 🙄

Tbf I don't think the people saying a child would get hurt are talking about on comparison of to someone physically vulnerable but in regards to an able bodied, fit adult.
My 7 yo is likely to be daydreaming and not holding on properly and no idea how well my 3 yo twins could actually hold on. For a physically vulnerable person I'd leave twins in one seat, make 7 yo stand and I'd stand in front of twins. For a person as for and able as me I wouldn't unless they asked. If DS and I were standing and I'd got the twins pinned into one seat, I reckon there's someone else more able to give up a seat.

Wafflington · 20/02/2023 18:39

The irony too that I have just gotten off the bus where a woman was giving me evil stares for daring to sit in the wheel chair user space - until my colleague loudly starting asking how I am feeling with my pregnancy and hips. I can just about still pass for being fat and not actually pregnant in some winter coats still. And yes, should a wheel chair user have gotten on, I would have moved as I am not a self absorbed twat - but thankfully, none did 😆 although I doubt this lady would have moved and offered her seat given her death stares, and she is probably on this thread tutting at people

Mumof2boys74 · 20/02/2023 18:38

I have kids and never would I ever expect someone to give up a seat for them . I would however expect certainly the older one to give up his seat for someone else. This woman was rude, entitled and completely wrong

DdraigGoch · 20/02/2023 18:37

ancientgran · 20/02/2023 09:12

If you are a healthy adult you will be more able to balance and hold on than a small 4 or 5 year old child.

Don't know who taught you to drive, my instructor taught me that you drive using your gears and should only need to break suddenly if someone runs out in front if you leave a proper gap between you and the car in front. I realise people don't seem to be taught this now as people have such trouble leaving gaps. My husband was on the motorway one day when there was a pile up in front and behind him. He didn't hit the car in front of him as he'd left the correct space between them, unfortunately the idiot behind him was to close and hit him, DH still didn't hit the car in front of him.

If you are breaking hard frequently you have a problem with your driving.

Yes, if someone runs out in front of you then you would have to stamp on the brakes. Which is why the occupants of a car are strapped in to prevent them face-planting the headrests of the seats in front.

Trains can't stop anything like as quickly as a car - they would go into a slide. Therefore even with emergency braking the deceleration is much less. If your grandchild is too small to hold on to a solid object themselves then you should either hold onto them or sit them on your lap.

Xol · 20/02/2023 18:24

as a daily bus user for over 50 years, I don’t reckon kids are more vulnerable. They have less far to fall than an adult, have a smaller body mass than an adult (less velocity) and their bones are less likely to break in an accident. Plus they will be with an adult, who can hold onto them.

And they have a lower centre of gravity and therefore will tend to be more stable.

Wafflington · 20/02/2023 18:20

Also think it's bizarre as hell some posters harping on about how badly injured a child might be if a bus/train suddenly brakes. Obviously everyone is at risk of being hurt in this scenario, but I would bet money that the people least likely to be seriously injured are a child, versus the elderly/frail or pregnant women. Not saying a child won't get hurt, but the risk of injury to the elderly will be much greater with things like hip fractures etc from falling, or for a pregnant woman to suffer a placental abruption from hitting her bump. Much less likely to cause serious damage to a child who might take a tumble (although still unpleasant for them naturally) 🙄

Scepticalwotsits · 20/02/2023 18:15

ProfessionalWeirdo · 20/02/2023 16:24

Don't know who taught you to drive, my instructor taught me that you drive using your gears and should only need to break suddenly if someone runs out in front if you leave a proper gap between you and the car in front.

If you slow down using your gears rather than your brakes, the driver behind you gets no warning. Brake lights are there for a reason.

this is going off on a tangent however it doesn't matter - the car behind should have enough space built in for reaction time, plus you should read the road. Red light ahead, car in front will be slowing down regardless of whether you see their brake lights or not.

Whammyyammy · 20/02/2023 17:51

Read so many post's like this on trains and planes recently. Have people become more entitled?
Boarded a flight last year, we booked row 1 seats and found someone sat in one of ours.

My husband informed them they were sat in one of our precooked extra legroom seats, the man of the couple started to say something, my husband just said ill stop you there, whatever it is I'm not interested , please move to your allocated seat.. he moved. End of.

TrashyPanda · 20/02/2023 17:38

You're right, for most medical appointments I'm asked if x time and date works and I very rarely have an appointment that can't be changed

lucky you.

I’ve been told I have a 40 week wait for an appointment. I ain’t gonna change it to some mythical time without kids on the bus just incase the bus is full. No way.

if I’m on a bus, I will gladly give my seat to an older person, a pregnant woman or anyone with a walking aid/visible disability.

as a daily bus user for over 50 years, I don’t reckon kids are more vulnerable. They have less far to fall than an adult, have a smaller body mass than an adult (less velocity) and their bones are less likely to break in an accident. Plus they will be with an adult, who can hold onto them.

ProfessionalWeirdo · 20/02/2023 16:24

Don't know who taught you to drive, my instructor taught me that you drive using your gears and should only need to break suddenly if someone runs out in front if you leave a proper gap between you and the car in front.

If you slow down using your gears rather than your brakes, the driver behind you gets no warning. Brake lights are there for a reason.

Bethany7 · 20/02/2023 16:01

Her three kids could have sat down and she could have stood!!!
You did nothing wrong! Well done for standing your ground.

BlueHeelers · 20/02/2023 15:48

IMO, if there are no spare seats then a child small enough to sit on an adult's lap should do so (or stand if they don't want to) and a child too big for that is old enough to stand.

This is a sensible & clear principle. Excellent!