Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About not moving on the train?

358 replies

TrainSitu · 19/02/2023 16:13

I’ve recently had shoulder surgery but I am now out of a sling so I guess I don’t look injured. I’m sat at a table seat on the train to get back to my work area after visiting my dad.

I’ve got my backpack on the table and my big bag was put up on the top by a lovely man who offered to put it up. We get to the next station and it’s absolutely heaving and a mother with 3 kids gets on. Everyone files into seats and someone sits opposite me. She then approaches and asks if the other 2 seats are reserved. I said no and she could have them and sat the kids down. She then looks and me and say says “I’ve got 3 children who need a seat please can they have yours” I said no I’ve recently had shoulder surgery and still recovering so standing on a packed train would be too painful. She then continually said “ I have 3 kids though”

At this point I said “I’m not particularly bothered by the amount of kids you have but I will be staying in this seat as I need it too if you have any issues please go speak to the train conductor” The look she gave me could kill!

So AIBU for not moving? The original guy who put my bag in the overhead rack ended up telling her to leave me alone as she kept repeating about her 3 kids. I feel like a cow bag but a justified one!

NC for this so it can’t be linked to any previous threads.

OP posts:
dcthatsme · 21/02/2023 18:19

Even if you didn't have a shoulder injury why should you stand up as you were there first? If she/they were disabled, pregnant or very elderly then yes that would be a reasonable request. She can take one of the children on her lap/stand up herself. Like other posters, I was taught to stand up for adults on public transport when I was a child.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 21/02/2023 18:08

Whilst I do agree that op was right not to move. I would not tell my children to give their seat to an adult unless that adult was elderly/pregnant/disabled. Children are far more likely to be flung around with sudden jolts or stops than an able bodied adult. Whoever has the seat, keeps the seat unless a less able bodied person get on and they wish to give it up.
I wonder why op name changed though? Does this contradict previous encounters??

CM1897 · 21/02/2023 18:05

There would be no reason for you to move even if you hadn’t had surgery. They’re children, not elderly or disabled. Children can share a seat or sit on their parent’s lap surely

SinnerBoy · 21/02/2023 15:23

ancientgran · Yesterday 09:12

Don't know who taught you to drive, my instructor taught me that you drive using your gears and should only need to break suddenly if someone runs out in front if you leave a proper gap between you and the car in front.

You get marked down for short shifting, or engine braking, these days. This is because it uses the clutch as a braking point, increasing wear and because it sucks excess fuel through as you slow, which is ecologically unsound.

I got my single minor point for that, on my car test in 2008. 20 odd years on bikes before that and my car instructor never told me not to!

fancydressjess · 21/02/2023 14:58

Without getting into general priority or etiquette around seats, which is a subject subject to much debate...

What on earth does it teach her kids to see her treating someone (temporarily) disabled in that way?!?! Like, how self centred is she?!?!
There was no suggestion that any of her party would be in pain to stand and yet she thought you should be to make way for them?!? Wow, just wow....

katenutzs · 21/02/2023 14:36

I would tell her as I didnt make her pregnany 3 times I am not responsible for her children

NeoLinn · 21/02/2023 14:18

YANBU
I remember the days when we were younger travelling to Scotland with my mum (I have 2 bothers so mum and 3 kids!). We were often told to squeeze in one seat or would end up on mum's lap or even in the luggage cart when it got busy! Would never dream of kicking someone out of their pre,booked seat for my child to sit down!

Uberstar · 21/02/2023 12:21

Last year on a train from London back up to the north west, previous trains had been cancelled so it was severely overcrowded and our pre booked seats were no longer in use.
My 12 year old daughter is in end stage renal failure, she has dialysis each night for 10 hours, although she looks “normal” from the outside, she would not have have been able to stand for the whole journey home.
luckily a wonderful couple offered us seats but I never would have asked! I planned on alerting the staff on the train once we had got going and would never have asked people to give up seats!
having a child who has a “hidden” Illness proves how you just never know what someone is going through.

SleepingStandingUp · 21/02/2023 01:18

cherish123 · 20/02/2023 19:56

YADNBU
Cheeky entitled woman. No wonder kids are so badly behaved now.
Since when did adults give up seats to children? I thought it was the other way around.

Depending on the age of the child, only if you think a parent considers your safety to trump their child's.

My 7 yo if you look or state that you need it? Yes.
My 7 yo if you're fit and healthy? No. You've got more strength, height and focus to hold on safely.
No two 3 yos? Not unless it was desperate

WickedWitchOfTheEast87 · 21/02/2023 00:52

@TrainSitu You were mosy definitely not unreasonable what a cheeky fucker she had the hide of a rhino to keep harassing you after being told no! I would have told her to jog on.

Something similar happened to me, I have arthritis in both ankles I cannot stand on trains its too painful so I always reserve a seat and sometimes pay for it if I want one with a plug socket.

Well one journey I get on the train someone is sitting in my seat with his phone plugged into the socket I've paid for. I politely say to him its my seat I've reserved it. He replies back "that seat's free you can sit there" and points to the seat opposite that has no plug socket, at this point my cheeky fucker alarm bells start ringing so I firmly replied "excuse me I paid to reserve that seat and I will be sitting in it now either move or I'll get a member of staff to make you!" He tuts gets up moves his stuff and sits opposite but leaves his phone plugged in. At this point I'm now pissed off so I sat down got my laptop out and unplugged his phone and plugged my laptop in he then rudely says to me "I'm charging my phone!" I snapped and loudly said "well you should've fucking paid to reserve a seat and plug socket like I did then if you don't like it fuck off and sit somewhere else!!" He was silent for the rest of the journey but kept throwing me dirty looks.

Op cheeky fuckers like the woman on the train need telling they get away with it because they bank on people being far to polite to call them out for it.

TrashyPanda · 20/02/2023 23:48

Xol · 20/02/2023 23:13

A parent in that situation needs to take the trouble to reserve seats rather than leave it and then expect others to vacate a seat for them.

And pay for them too.

National Rail states
children under 5 who are travelling without a ticket may only occupy a seat that is not required by a fare-paying passenger. To have a reserved seat for a child under 5 you will need to purchase a child rate ticket

even the rail operators don’t expect fare paying passengers to give up their seats for a child travelling free. If the parent wants to ensure a seat for their child, they need to pay for one and reserve it.

TrashyPanda · 20/02/2023 23:43

Thank you, @Rummykitten

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 20/02/2023 23:40

She wanted you to give up your seat - as an adult woman - for kids aged 10+? That’s bonkers! Even if you didn’t have an injury. Kids of that age (unless they have a disability) are the most able to stand of anyone.

OK maybe kids under 5 need to sit down to stop them falling all about the place - and you could maybe stretch that to 6 ish at a push - but 10+ should be getting up for you if you’d come on later, if anything.

Rummykitten · 20/02/2023 23:31

TrashyPanda · 20/02/2023 19:20

Have you got a link?

@TrashyPanda

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-11772361/I-refused-train-seat-mother-three-kids.html

Xol · 20/02/2023 23:13

ancientgran · 20/02/2023 22:36

Presumably your husband only has one wife, a parent on a train might have 3 under 5 to hold onto so not quite the same.

A parent in that situation needs to take the trouble to reserve seats rather than leave it and then expect others to vacate a seat for them.

ancientgran · 20/02/2023 22:36

BoredZelda · 20/02/2023 22:09

No one is asking DC to hang from overhead straps. My DC would lean on me and I will keep them steady, just as my parents did when I was small.

As I do with my husband as I'm short and can't reach overhead straps either.

Presumably your husband only has one wife, a parent on a train might have 3 under 5 to hold onto so not quite the same.

BoredZelda · 20/02/2023 22:09

No one is asking DC to hang from overhead straps. My DC would lean on me and I will keep them steady, just as my parents did when I was small.

As I do with my husband as I'm short and can't reach overhead straps either.

crimsonpeak · 20/02/2023 20:35

You were totally in the right OP. Imagine if you had caved in and now had a set back with your shoulder?! Hope your recovery goes well.

Chocbuttonsandredwine · 20/02/2023 20:30

RosaBonheur · 20/02/2023 19:52

YANBU.

She could have sat next to you and her three kids could have shared two seats if they only have small bums.

Or if one of her three kids was little she could have held that one on her lap.

Or her three kids could have sat in the seats and she could have stood in the aisle.

Or she could have gone somewhere there were four seats together for her and her three kids.

The only times it's ever OK to ask someone else to let you have the seat they are sitting in is if you are elderly, disabled and pregnant and there are no free seats, or if it is a seat you have reserved.

This^

so many options. Entitled CF

DdraigGoch · 20/02/2023 20:20

NotQuiteHere · 20/02/2023 20:07

You did not have to be rude

If someone won't take 'no' for an answer then whatever works to get rid of them will have to do.

NotQuiteHere · 20/02/2023 20:07

You did not have to be rude

DotAndCarryOne2 · 20/02/2023 20:05

JudgeJ · 20/02/2023 12:54

Love how people feels that their ability to breed makes them special! Many years ago we went to the early evening showing of the new Harry Potter fim, we sat on the end of a row. As the cinema filled up and the lights started to dim a woman arrived with a caravan of children, about 6 of them. She put some of them into the same row but across the aisle that we were on, she then started to tell people in our row to move up, filling the odd gaps, Eventually she started on us, You need to move so I can be near the children! She seemed to be amazed that we didn't jump to her demands, she brought one of the staff to 'Tell them to move up'. We stuck to our guns and she was not a happy bunny, especially when she was told by me that anyone with intelligence wanting 7 seats together would have got there earlier.

I have a disabled blue badge and IME these are the same people who will also think nothing of taking up a disabled space if all the parent and child ones are taken. Not to mention parking a pram in the priority space on the bus and not moving for a wheelchair.

cherish123 · 20/02/2023 19:56

YADNBU
Cheeky entitled woman. No wonder kids are so badly behaved now.
Since when did adults give up seats to children? I thought it was the other way around.

RosaBonheur · 20/02/2023 19:52

YANBU.

She could have sat next to you and her three kids could have shared two seats if they only have small bums.

Or if one of her three kids was little she could have held that one on her lap.

Or her three kids could have sat in the seats and she could have stood in the aisle.

Or she could have gone somewhere there were four seats together for her and her three kids.

The only times it's ever OK to ask someone else to let you have the seat they are sitting in is if you are elderly, disabled and pregnant and there are no free seats, or if it is a seat you have reserved.

Swipe left for the next trending thread