Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you hate out adventure activities?

189 replies

user1496262496 · 19/02/2023 13:30

I run an outdoor centre which is primarily for young people. The sort of place schools book in to for a week and the young people do climbing, mountain walks, canoeing and bushcraft etc.

The culture of outdoor activities such as rock climbing, mountaineering and paddle sports has traditionally been male dominated. Participation has traditionally been male dominated. British Canoeing’s web site and Mountain Training’s website have loads of figures about this. There is research… but no one seems to ask the women who don’t engage, or who got put off for some reason at a young age.

I want the activities my centre runs to be as appealing as possible and for the young people to have the best time.

Where do outdoor centres etc go wrong?

I am interested to hear from women who don’t like outdoor adventure activities. What was it that put you off them? What is it that means they aren’t something you would do as an adult?

I don’t think I am unreasonable to think there is a problem in my industry.

If your DC didn’t like their school residential, why didn’t it work for them?

OP posts:
Lemons1571 · 19/02/2023 14:26

I’m in my late 40’s, fit and sporty. Can run 5k in the gym. I did a day at a well know activity centre provider last year with my son. Had no idea what to expect. It was a bit spit n sawdust, and quite frankly lots of it was physically uncomfortable. Leather straps and ropes that dig in. Cold. Bit damp. Hair over the place and face felt greasy. Activities that require you to have a flexible body, and at nearly 50 I’m a bit stiff jointed. It’s pretty knackering so you do have to be relatively fittish. Very weather dependent. Often food is canteen based with only one or two options. And you’re on a time budget with the instructors shouting “30 minutes for lunch then meet back at X”, so once you’ve queued and got some food it’s all a rush and faffy shovelling it down. No time for a nice coffee.

A day was ok. They were trying to sell short family breaks in half term. No chance. My BMI is around 20, if I’d gone along a few years ago at my previous bmi of 40 it would have been hell on earth. With the best intentions there really aren’t many women in their late 40’s who would enjoy hurtling down a zip wire designed primarily for children.

TommytheSquirrell · 19/02/2023 14:25

I absolutely love this kind of stuff. However pregnant at the moment so it’s kind of out. I do know a few women who enjoyed this kind of thing when they were younger but don’t enjoy it now or would like to but don’t as the feel self-conscious or unfit or overweight. I’m not sure how you would overcome this as a business.

deplorabelle · 19/02/2023 14:25

I think competitiveness is definitely the problem for me. I am completely scarred by school PE lessons and their overemphasis on team ball games which I'm completely and irrevocably put off by. (Imagine instead of a quick game of catch to break the ice I suggest a friendly oral spelling test. Against the clock and you're dyslexic. It's completely acceptable for other team members to yell "there's an e on the end you IDIOT" if you fuck up the spelling for your team. Now see if you fancy doing anything at all that might involve a spelling test at any point. Or be done by the kind of people who like spelling tests. That's the level of trauma I feel about any physical thing and it's shite because I'd have loved climbing etc before I got old and fat.)

I hate to think sessions have to be single sex to include women but they could be skewed to the feminine and reduce the element of physical competitiveness. I would love an outdoor weekend that had a non endurance purpose - go out on a kayak to do wildlife photography, hike to an out of the way spot and create a picnic, night hiking with an astronomy session in a dark park, rock climbing with geology or doing a nature survey. So there is a point to the activities that isn't go the furthest/fastest/highest/endure the most extreme conditions. The warmup activities should be yoga and health orientated not teambuilding competitions which always favour hearty pe types. If the centre could be a comfortable clubhouse rather than an austere correctional outbuilding that would be great too.

woodhill · 19/02/2023 14:24

@Fairy

Do they stay on ok?

I was thinking of the Kayak drill

Fidgety31 · 19/02/2023 14:21

Too expensive . Would do much more if was more affordable

FairyBatman · 19/02/2023 14:21

woodhill · 19/02/2023 14:19

The eyesight thing is a stumbling block though because even if you wear contacts you are not supposed to get water in your eye.

You can't kayak in glasses?

Do people wear prescription goggles

If you are really into watersports etc you can get prescription glasses for this. They are £££ though. My current pair were £400 and it took some perseverance to get them through an independent options as the high st chains don't cater for my prescription.

woodhill · 19/02/2023 14:19

The eyesight thing is a stumbling block though because even if you wear contacts you are not supposed to get water in your eye.

You can't kayak in glasses?

Do people wear prescription goggles

FairyBatman · 19/02/2023 14:16

I'm qualified in a number of outdoor disciplines but have never worked in the industry, only volunteered.

The barriers that I see are

  1. Centre kit is ALWAYS designed for boys / men. There are rarely if ever girls wetsuits / BAs / spare boots / waterproofs and as a consequence women and girls end up with kits that's too big and bulk and doesn't keep them warm properly.
  1. From experience women and girls have lower tolerance for the cold, when I run girls only activity sessions I keep them shorter and have more hot drinks breaks, this also accommodates more toilet breaks.
  1. Instructors are predominately male, this is uncomfortable and leads to situations where boys get more hands on teaching as male instructors are reluctant to get as close to girls, or the girls don't want to be as close to the instructors.
  1. Instructors are predominantly male so there's a lack or role models.
  1. Culture and 'banter' there's still quite a macho and drinking culture around a lot of outdoor stuff. Women don't joke with each other in the same way and it can be quite off putting. It's more a barrier to retention than entry, but still.
  1. A pp mentioned it already but the age that kids start getting into these things is also around the age they start getting periods. Having a period and doing activities where you might be away from a loo, get wet etc is quite daunting. Simple discussions around period pants and leaving out supplies incase people get caught out would help massively but no-one talks about it.
MelaniesFlowers · 19/02/2023 14:15

SweetSakura · 19/02/2023 14:11

I mean I assume you are just trolling. But I was 5 ft and very slim with long blonde hair and v pretty when I was doing these sports. And I quite often would hop out of the gear and into a mini dress/ballgown to go partying the same evening!

Nope not trolling. This is a very common view, people are just too afraid to admit it.

The women into these types of things always claim they’re feminine and not at all tomboy. It’s rarely true.

Scottishskifun · 19/02/2023 14:14

I'm outdoor sports based always have been, I've done it from a young age with outward bound courses and plas y Brenin courses.
But even my love of outdoor sports csn be dampened by competitive blokes! It becomes a pissing competition with the majority.

Things I have really enjoyed is things like women's paddle symposiums, women's climb days, rip curl girl surf days etc. Female instructor female group. The dynamic is completely changed and I learn how I can do it as a female as a lot of the time women have a more technical way rather then brute strength!

I think more options of girl focused groups would make a difference!

woodhill · 19/02/2023 14:13

Whyismycatanasshat · 19/02/2023 14:10

I’m writing this as a teacher who goes on residentials and enjoys them…

  • instructors who’s attitude is geared towards the capable, sporty participants. Excellent hard skills (Ho-yah Willy measuring is what my old headteacher used to say.) but no soft skills. And no ideas how to motivate anyone but the keen.
  • lack of decent/private bathrooms and dorms (and external changing facilities at destination activities) for everyone, not just females. Especially when you consider the average y5/y6 girl is heading into puberty.
  • crap drying facilities - who wants to have half dry kit to put back on, start the activity miserable!
  • similarly poorly maintained Centre Loan kit - no issue with the ppe ever but knackered, hokey wetsuits and waterproofs aren’t good.
  • activities which are geared to the sporty, capable children - the best residential I’ve been on in the last few years had an orienteering activity - not an evening or a filler, a whole afternoon or morning Session and children who’d struggled with climbing etc had an opportunity to achieve independently and some really shine.

I’m a well qualified former instructor. I left because I felt I had hit a glass ceiling as a female. I still freelance and don’t feel the industry has moved as far forward as it should have. I was working 2 weekends ago and was utterly patronised by a fairly new entrant who made a lot of assumptions.

Love it especially your ref to lack of soft skills

Cooking, dance and craft are much more my thing and I wouldn't have minded the orienteering or a quiz.

I don't like the team aspect of these sort of thing if you don't feel you are up to scratch

SweetSakura · 19/02/2023 14:11

MelaniesFlowers · 19/02/2023 13:51

It’s cold, it’s usually wet, it’s boring, the clothing and the gear is really ugly, and the types of girls/women that do these activities tend to be tomboy/masculine.

I would never take part myself and would discourage my daughters from doing so too.

I mean I assume you are just trolling. But I was 5 ft and very slim with long blonde hair and v pretty when I was doing these sports. And I quite often would hop out of the gear and into a mini dress/ballgown to go partying the same evening!

Whyismycatanasshat · 19/02/2023 14:10

I’m writing this as a teacher who goes on residentials and enjoys them…

  • instructors who’s attitude is geared towards the capable, sporty participants. Excellent hard skills (Ho-yah Willy measuring is what my old headteacher used to say.) but no soft skills. And no ideas how to motivate anyone but the keen.
  • lack of decent/private bathrooms and dorms (and external changing facilities at destination activities) for everyone, not just females. Especially when you consider the average y5/y6 girl is heading into puberty.
  • crap drying facilities - who wants to have half dry kit to put back on, start the activity miserable!
  • similarly poorly maintained Centre Loan kit - no issue with the ppe ever but knackered, hokey wetsuits and waterproofs aren’t good.
  • activities which are geared to the sporty, capable children - the best residential I’ve been on in the last few years had an orienteering activity - not an evening or a filler, a whole afternoon or morning Session and children who’d struggled with climbing etc had an opportunity to achieve independently and some really shine.

I’m a well qualified former instructor. I left because I felt I had hit a glass ceiling as a female. I still freelance and don’t feel the industry has moved as far forward as it should have. I was working 2 weekends ago and was utterly patronised by a fairly new entrant who made a lot of assumptions.

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/02/2023 14:09

MelaniesFlowers · 19/02/2023 13:51

It’s cold, it’s usually wet, it’s boring, the clothing and the gear is really ugly, and the types of girls/women that do these activities tend to be tomboy/masculine.

I would never take part myself and would discourage my daughters from doing so too.

Wow... like the last 50 years never happened....

SweetSakura · 19/02/2023 14:08

I love all outdoor adventure type activities.

I ended up doing a lot of water sports (windsurfing/sailing) and they have always felt reasonably balanced - we had a whole girls sailing team at university.

I think off putting things that deterred me from other sports i have enjoyed (kayaking,.climbing, potholing, abseiling)!include buoyancy aids etc not made for the big breasted. Horrible shower facilities etc
A bit of a "macho" culture so you could feel on the outside. The need to be good at the practical elements of setting up the kit/moving it around (I lack the strength), the sense that being "strong" was so important (whereas sailing /windsurfing you could counter this with technique),

And I guess the lack of opportunities too.

I've liked seeing the female paddle boarding community build up and can't wait to get back to that when I am better

PandasAreUseless · 19/02/2023 14:08

MelaniesFlowers · 19/02/2023 13:51

It’s cold, it’s usually wet, it’s boring, the clothing and the gear is really ugly, and the types of girls/women that do these activities tend to be tomboy/masculine.

I would never take part myself and would discourage my daughters from doing so too.

You would 'discourage' your daughters! Do you mean that? Like, you'd actually try to put them off taking part in outdoor pursuits? If so, that's such a shame.

MojoMoon · 19/02/2023 14:07

I still remember being mocked by the instructors at activity camp when I climbed to the top of a tree and then had to abseil down.

Went up confidently, then looked down (my first ever abseil) and froze with fear.

There was a very strong sense of militarism in all the outdoor camps we did as kids (and I did a fair number) - "you will suffer, you will be humiliated because you are not brave and strong enough so we will break you. "

A very crap version of the SAS challenge programme on channel 4 essentially. Usually run by sad men who thrived on making kids fear them.

So in my mind, outdoor adventures are entwined with humiliation and militarism!

That said as an adult I do outdoor swimming and have camped and even abseiled....but in female led groups only.
I've also done geo aching and navigation training trips and enjoyed them.

If the outdoor activities at kids camps had been more about the outdoor world - animal tracking, natural navigation, wildlife habitat building, I think a much wider range of kids could have engaged with the hiking and camping part of it as being a means to get to the activity.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 19/02/2023 14:07

I wear glasses and can't wear contacts or have laser eye surgery for various reasons - so all these activities are impossible for me. If I take my glasses off I can't see a thing so that's not an option either.

LadyOfTheCanyon · 19/02/2023 14:06

MelaniesFlowers · 19/02/2023 13:51

It’s cold, it’s usually wet, it’s boring, the clothing and the gear is really ugly, and the types of girls/women that do these activities tend to be tomboy/masculine.

I would never take part myself and would discourage my daughters from doing so too.

I mean, obviously this is a ridiculous stance to take, but I was just coming on to say that often by the time girls reach about 6 or 7, society has done a number on them by telling them that this sort of thing isn't for them, so it becomes a self fulfilling prophecy.

The periods/privacy/ presence of boys etc is also a very big part of it, once experienced.

I'd rather poke myself in the eyes with red hot pokers than go camping, personally.

PositiveLife · 19/02/2023 14:03

I love this stuff. One daughter also loves it, the other hates it.

I think for teenagers it can be awkward getting changed, knowing what to do about needing the loo and what to do about periods. My two have gone through phases of those things bothering them.

More generally, I agree that most kit is designed for men although I think it's improving. I wish manufacturers would stop assuming all women who like the outdoors are size 8 flat chested tall women. It's bloody hard to get stuff that fits as a short, busty size 14.

EssexCat · 19/02/2023 14:02

DisplayPurposesOnly · 19/02/2023 13:58

the types of girls/women that do these activities tend to be tomboy/masculine.

I would never take part myself and would discourage my daughters from doing so too.

That's a pretty crap attitude. Firstly, "tomboy/masculine" is a ridiculous characterisation and nonsense. Secondly, your daughters are not you, they may like different things from you; that's fine.

I’d agree. It’s fine not to like it yourself but perhaps your daughter might enjoy it?

Plus I LOVE this sort of thing and am quite a typically feminine woman. Love clothes, make up and have long blonde hair - so not v tomboy or masculine. Nor are my friends who like this sort of thing.

I

ThoseDamnCrows · 19/02/2023 14:02

If something was single-sex, and the instructors were female, I would be much more like to have a go.
When I've taken part in things in the past I've usually found that the males dominate and take over, or that the male instructors have no idea of the physical differences between the sexes.

I booked a paddle boarding lesson at a specific place because it was led by a female. When I had a further lesson in a different venue it was because I wanted to learn techniques for self-rescue. The male instructor seemed oblivious to the fact that as a woman I had a bust, and less upper-body strength, and couldn't just merrily swing myself onto the board.
The instructor had six of us in the group, the other five being male. My DH was spectating and at the end of the lesson commented on how little time the instructor had spent with me, literally minutes, compared to the men in the group. I've tried explaining it to him before but he never got it until then, how much men can dominate or change the dynamics of a group.

Having said that, now that I have really got into SUP it's definitely given me the confidence to try other outdoor activities. I used to think that they weren't for people like me, overweight and unfit, but now I'm keen to try other things. I do prefer the emphasis to be on fun and personal achievement not competition with others.

woodhill · 19/02/2023 14:01

I do hate dirty toilets and no privacy changing

woodhill · 19/02/2023 14:00

I think she is spot on

My dds were ok with it and liked doing that Mudda challenge thing

I did used to guide camp through

Swg · 19/02/2023 13:59

I love this kind of thing but I think the reason more guys get into it is that it's far easier for them to take off for a weekend - see the amount of people here who are left by husbands for cycling weekends.

Women have to juggle more in terms of childcare to get one single day away and then when they get there they're always the amateur abd always going to be because they'll never have as much time to do it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread